Fernando v Groves and Fernando v Kassman

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Fernando v Groves and Fernando v Kassman

[2015] NTSC 81

PARTIES:FERNANDO Kevin Nicholas

v

GROVES Joshua Ryan

FILE NO:JA 36 of 2015 (21531460)

FERNANDO Kevin Nicholas

v

KASSMAN Sean

FILE NO:  JA 37 of 2015 (21523765)

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY EXERCISING APPELLATE JURISDICTION

DELIVERED:  8 December 2015

HEARING DATES:  6 November 2015

JUDGMENT OF:  HILEY J

APPEAL FROM:  NEILL SM

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – Justices Appeal – appeal against sentence – breach of Alcohol Protection Order – offending at low level of seriousness – sentence disproportionate to offending – undue weight given to defendant’s prior offending – sentence manifestly excessive

APPEAL – Justices Appeal – appeal against sentence – breach of bail – no demonstrated error – sentence not manifestly excessive

Alcohol Protection Orders Act2013 (NT), s23(1)
Bail Act 1982 (NT), s37B

Wayne v Cornford [2013] NTSC 01, applied.

Hampton v The Queen [2008] NTCCA 5; R v Morse (1979) 23 SASR 98; R v Tait (1979) 46 FLR 386; Salmon and Chute (1994) 4 NTLR 1; Shannon v Cassidy [2012] 31 NTLR 188; Veen v R [No 2] (1988) 164 CLR 465; referred to.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:Mr O’Brien-Hartcher

Respondent:  Mr Wallace-Parnell

Solicitors:

Appellant:North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency

Respondent:  Office of Director of Public Prosecutions

Judgment category classification:    B

Judgment ID Number:  Hil1512

Number of pages:  14

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
OF AUSTRALIA
AT DARWIN

Fernando v Groves and Fernando v Kassman

[2015] NTSC 81

No. JA 36 of 2015 (21531460) and JA 37 of 2015 (21523765)

BETWEEN:

KEVIN NICHOLAS FERNANDO

Appellant

AND:

JOSHUA RYAN GROVES

First Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

KEVIN NICHOLAS FERNANDO

Appellant

AND:

SEAN KASSMAN

Second Respondent

CORAM:     HILEY J

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 8 December 2015)

Introduction

  1. The appellant has appealed against two sentences imposed by the Court of Summary Jurisdiction on 26 June 2015.

  2. The appellant was convicted of two offences:

    (a)breach an Alcohol Protection Order (APO)[1] on 25 May 2015, and

    (b)breach of bail by not attending court on 18 June 2015.[2]

  3. He was arrested for his breach of bail on 26 June and taken before the court later that day when he pleaded guilty and was convicted and sentenced to seven days imprisonment for each offence, to be served cumulatively. He served another four days in custody before he was released on appeal bail.

    Grounds of Appeal

  4. The amended notice of appeal contains the following grounds:

    Ground 1: that the learned magistrate erred in ordering that the two sentences imposed be served cumulatively;

    Ground 2: that the learned magistrate gave undue weight to the defendant’s record and prior offending;

    Ground 3: that the sentence was manifestly excessive.

    General principles concerning appeals against sentence

  5. The principles that apply to an appeal against sentence are well known and were conveniently summarised by the Full Court of the Federal Court in R v Tait (1979) 46 FLR 386 at 388. The Court…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fernando v Groves and Fernando v Kassman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NTSC 81
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns two separate sentences imposed by the Darwin Court of Summary Jurisdiction on the appellant, who was convicted of breaching an Alcohol Protection Order (APO) and breaching bail conditions. The appellant, Fernando, appealed against both sentences on the basis that they were excessive and disproportionate to the nature and circumstances of the offending. Groves was the police officer who issued the arrest warrant for the breach of the APO, and Kassman was the police officer who arrested the appellant for breaching his bail conditions. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of the Northern Territory, which exercised its appellate jurisdiction over the lower court's sentencing decisions.

The primary legal issues the court needed to address were whether the sentences imposed by the Darwin Court of Summary Jurisdiction were manifestly excessive and whether there was any demonstrated error in the trial judge's exercise of their sentencing discretion. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the trial judge had given undue weight to the appellant's prior offending history and whether the sentences were disproportionate to the relatively low-level seriousness of the current offending. The appellant argued that the sentences were manifestly excessive, given the low alcohol reading and the absence of any aggravating circumstances, such as disorderly behaviour, during the offending. The respondents, represented by Groves and Kassman, contended that the sentences were appropriate and reflected the need to enforce the conditions of the APO and bail.

The Supreme Court found that while the appellant's prior offending history was relevant, the trial judge had given undue weight to it in determining the sentences. The court considered that the current offending, although involving a breach of an APO and bail, was at a low level of seriousness and did not warrant such severe sentences. The appellant had not had any further contact with the police apart from the breach of bail and had shown an apparent change in behaviour since then. The Supreme Court concluded that the sentences were manifestly excessive and disproportionate to the nature and circumstances of the offending. As a result, the appeal against the sentence for the breach of the APO was allowed, and the sentence for the breach of bail was quashed. The matter was remitted to the Darwin Court of Summary Jurisdiction for re-sentencing.

In light of the findings, the Supreme Court ordered that the sentence imposed for the breach of the Alcohol Protection Order be set aside and the matter be remitted to the Darwin Court of Summary Jurisdiction for re-sentencing. The court did not consider it necessary to order a new sentence for the breach of bail, as it was already quashed and the matter would be dealt with upon re-sentencing for the APO breach.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

As a general rule there is a presumption that there is no error in a trial judge’s exercise of his or her sentencing discretion.[3] In order to interfere with the sentencing magistrate’s exercise of discretion, the court must be satisfied not just that the sentence was excessive but that it was manifestly excessive.[4] To determine whether a sentence is excessive, it is necessary to review it in the perspective of the maximum sentence prescribed by law for the crime, the standards of sentencing customarily observed with respect to the crime, the place which the criminal conduct occupies in the scale of seriousness of crimes of that type and the personal circumstances of the offender.[5]Background The appellant was issued with an APO on 8 January 2015 for 12 months. On 17 April 2015 he was convicted of 10 offences and sentenced to a total of one month imprisonment backdated to 5 April 2015. All of those offences were committed between 8 January and 16 April 2015. Six of the offences concerned breaches of an APO, presumably the APO issued on 8 January. Three of the offences concerned disorderly behaviour in a public place, offences committed at the same time as three of his breach of APO offences. The other conviction was for breaching a condition of bail on 17 February. I assume that he was released from prison on 4 May 2015. At 1.15pm on 25 May the appellant was observed seated at the barbecue area at East Point Reserve consuming a red coloured liquid. Two police officers approached the appellant and noticed that he smelt of intoxicating liquor. After they became aware that he was subject of an APO they arrested him and took him to the Darwin watch-house. He submitted to a breath analysis which showed a blood alcohol reading of 0.040% at 2.11 pm. When asked his reason for drinking the appellant said: “I just drank it because sorry business with my family.” The appellant was given bail later that day and required to appear at the Darwin Court of Summary Jurisdiction on 18 June. Conditions of his bail included prohibitions on him purchasing possessing or consuming alcohol and requirements for him to submit to breath testing and urine analysis if so requested by a police officer. He failed to attend court on 18 June and a warrant was issued for his arrest. At 11:15 am on 26 June he was located sitting in a park at Parap, and he was taken to the Darwin watch-house. When asked why he had breached his bail he said: “I was very sick on that day”. Counsel for the appellant told his Honour that the appellant was drinking with family members on 25 May and the reason for that was sorry business that was happening that day. While acknowledging the appellant’s numerous convictions on 17 April counsel pointed out that the present offending involved a low alcohol reading and was not accompanied by any aggravating circumstances, for example disorderly behaviour. He pointed out that the appellant had not had any further contact with police apart from his breach of bail, and appeared to have addressed his behaviour since then. He said the appellant now recognises that he needs to stay away from people who are bad influences on him.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.