Ferguson Corporation Pty Ltd ACN 008 943 646 v Kowalewski

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ferguson Corporation Pty Ltd ACN 008 943 646 v Kowalewski [2008] FCA 593

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – particular discovery – whether fishing expedition

Federal Court Rules O 15 r 2, O 15 r 2(3), O 15 r 8

Creative Brands Pty Ltd v Franklin [2001] VSC 338
Ferguson Corporation Pty Ltd v Kowalewski [2007] FCA 789
Independent Cement & Lime Pty Ltd v Australian Cement Ltd & Ors [1988] FCA 749
Liberty Financial Pty Ltd v Scott (No. 4) [2005] VSC 472
Seven Network Ltd v New Ltd (No 5) (2005) 216 ALR 147
Spyer v Cuddles ‘N’ Mum (Franchise) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2002] FCA 1563
Trade Practices Commission v CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (No 4) (1995) 58 FCR 426
WA Pines Pty Ltd v Bannerman (1980) 41 FLR 175

FERGUSON CORPORATION PTY LTD ACN 008 943 646 v HENDRYK KOWALEWSKI, JOPHIEL PTY LTD ACN 118 004 087 and ALFRESCO CONCEPTS PTY LTD ACN 122 503 020

WAD 360 OF 2006

MCKERRACHER J
2 MAY 2008
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 360 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

FERGUSON CORPORATION PTY LTD
ACN 008 943 646
Applicant

AND:

AND:

HENDRYK KOWALEWSKI
First Respondent

JOPHIEL PTY LTD
ACN 118 004 087
Second Respondent

ALFRESCO CONCEPTS PTY LTD
ACN 122 503 020
Third Respondent

HENDRYK KOWALEWSKI
Cross-Claimant

FERGUSON CORPORATION PTY LTD
ACN 008 943 646
Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 MAY 2008

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s motion of 20 February 2008 be allowed subject to the qualifications outlined in the reasons.

2.The cross-claimant’s motion brought by notice of motion filed on 21 February 2008 be allowed.

3.Particular discovery ordered.

4.Precise terms of the discovery and orders as to costs to be settled between the parties or re-listed for determination within 21 days.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD 360 OF 2006

BETWEEN:

FERGUSON CORPORATION PTY LTD
ACN 008 943 646
Applicant

AND:

AND:

HENDRYK KOWALEWSKI
First Respondent

JOPHIEL PTY LTD
ACN 118 004 087
Second Respondent

ALFRESCO CONCEPTS PTY LTD
ACN 122 503 020
Third Respondent

HENDRYK KOWALEWSKI
Cross-Claimant

FERGUSON CORPORATION PTY LTD
ACN 008 943 646
Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

MCKERRACHER J

DATE:

2 MAY 2008

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. There are two motions before the Court.  The applicant seeks from the respondents further particular discovery of certain documents which are described in the schedule to these reasons.  Similarly the cross-claimant, who claims monies due under a business purchase agreement, seeks against the applicant discovery orders as follows:

    1.The cross-respondent within 14 day (sic) of the date of this Order give discovery on oath of any taxation records and advice received by the cross-respondent relating to the sale agreement the subject of the cross-claim and defence to cross claim filed by the parties, and in particular but not limited to:

    1.1tax returns, including…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ferguson Corporation Pty Ltd ACN 008 943 646 v Kowalewski and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 593
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ferguson Corporation Pty Ltd ACN 008 943 646 v Kowalewski involves a dispute between the two parties regarding the acquisition of a business and the intellectual property associated with it. The matter was heard in an Australian court, where the primary issue was whether Ferguson Corporation had purchased the intellectual property from Kowalewski as part of the business acquisition. The court was also tasked with determining the validity of the claims made by both parties and whether further specific discovery was warranted.

The legal issues that the court needed to decide revolved around the interpretation of the purchase agreement between the parties, the validity of the claims made by both Ferguson Corporation and Kowalewski, and the admissibility of certain evidence. The court had to examine the affidavits filed by both parties and determine if there was sufficient evidence to support Ferguson Corporation's claim that Kowalewski had failed to disclose certain intellectual property and if Kowalewski had breached any non-disclosure or non-compete clauses in the agreement. Additionally, the court had to decide if the discovery sought by both parties was justified and whether it should be granted in its entirety or with certain qualifications.

The court found that while Kowalewski may have a valid explanation for his actions, Ferguson Corporation's claim was not speculative or insubstantial. The court held that there was enough evidence from both within Ferguson Corporation and externally that supported the claim. However, the court ruled that certain additional specific discovery should be granted but subject to some qualifications. The first qualification was that the discovery should not include any product that did not bear a close resemblance to a product sold by Ferguson Corporation. The second qualification was that terms needed to be reached between the parties regarding the confidentiality of the discovery, as there were obvious benefits for a competitor examining drawings, quotations, and financial records of products that were the same as those it sold.

The court ultimately ordered that the applicant's motion be allowed subject to the qualifications outlined in the reasons, that the cross-claimant's motion be allowed, and that particular discovery be ordered. The precise terms of the discovery and orders as to costs were to be settled between the parties or re-listed for determination within 21 days.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s motion of 20 February 2008 be allowed subject to the qualifications outlined in the reasons.

2. The cross-claimant’s motion brought by notice of motion filed on 21 February 2008 be allowed.

3. Particular discovery ordered.

4. Precise terms of the discovery and orders as to costs to be settled between the parties or re-listed for determination within 21 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It is common ground that the claim for Ferguson Corporation is largely inferential. In the context of these applications for further specific discovery, it is essential to resolve the question of whether or not the primary claim is just based on a suspicion with little or no support - in which case further specific discovery may be an unjustifiably intrusive fishing expedition. Or does common sense suggest that there is enough on the face of matters in the material supporting the claim to entitle the orders sought? It is not possible to form a view on that topic unless the evidence in support of the claim as well as that in response is examined. While it is not appropriate to attempt to reach any clear view as to the ultimate quality of the evidence at this stage, it may be that if the claim is no more than speculation, so much would be clear. Each party has filed several affidavits. I will refer to some of the material without recording it all at this interlocutory stage.EVIDENCE FOR FERGUSON CORPORATION Ferguson Corporation relies on several affidavits as does Mr Kowalewski. Some of those affidavits had also been read in earlier interlocutory proceedings. Mr Ferguson swore an affidavit on 12 December 2006. He deposed to the fact that in or about May 2004, Ferguson Corporation purchased a business known as HA TEC – Aroma Catering Appliances from Mr Kowalewski. At the time it was acquired by Ferguson Corporation, it specialised in gas cooking equipment and, in particular, in barbeques and wok cookers. As part of the purchase of the business, Ferguson Corporation agreed to employ Mr Kowalewski. His employment with Ferguson Corporation commenced in May 2004 as a technical consultant. He was the most senior production sales employee involved with its range of outdoor kitchen products. His business was absorbed into the existing stainless steel division of Ferguson Corporation. That division manufactured exhaust hoods, refrigerators and other custom made architectural stainless steel products. The first twelve months or so after acquiring the business was spent streamlining the business product range to ensure that Ferguson Corporation capitalised on its competitive advantage in the market place. He described the extensive work involved in that activity. In the middle of 2005, Ferguson Corporation embarked on an extensive promotional campaign to expand the brand awareness of the outdoor kitchen barbeque equipment marketed under the name of Alfrescostyle. Ferguson Corporation did not in fact manufacture or sell outdoor kitchens or barbeque equipment until after it acquired Mr Kowalewski’s business. He gives details of the promotional campaign and the steps taken to market the products. Mr Kowalewski was intimately involved in that activity and directed subject to the supervision of Mr Ferguson the development of Ferguson Corporation’s Alfrescostyle range of products. He had a close involvement with Ferguson Corporation’s customers and a detailed knowledge of its selling prices because he personally handled 90% of the quotations provided by it. Ninety percent of Ferguson Corporation’s customers for the Alfrescostyle range are one-off retail customers and the other 10% come from sources such as builders and interior designers. In that source there is often a lead time of up to 18 months between a quote being provided and the order being confirmed. As at the date of swearing his affidavit there were approximately 35 quotations submitted to Ferguson Corporation customers for Alfrescostyle range of products between April and October 2006 that had not then resulted in orders. The quotations ranged in dollar value between $3,000 and $90,000 with an average value of $18,000. He describes the processes involved in developing and fabricating Alfrescostyle equipment including the concepts and configuration stage, the drawing, designing, prototyping and testing. The first stage takes some eight weeks and the second stage some 16 weeks.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MCKERRACHER J
There is a conflict between the parties as to what was purchased under the agreement on about 19 April 2004. The Ferguson Corporation defence to the cross-claim refers to an oral agreement reached on 19 April 2004 with Mr Kowalewski by which Ferguson Corporation agreed to buy on ongoing basis the business including the intellectual property and good will for an amount of $40,000. Ferguson Corporation alleged that it was an express term of the purchase agreement that the purchase consideration would be paid by offsetting the amount owed by Mr Kowalewski to Ferguson Corporation at the time of the formation of the purchase agreement. This was an amount equal to deposits collected by Mr Kowalewski prior to the formation of the purchase agreement and retained by him in relation to orders subsequently completed by Ferguson Corporation. Ferguson Corporation contends that the purchase price has been paid first by offsetting an amount of $10,222.69 owed by Mr Kowalewski to Ferguson Corporation at the time of the purchase agreement; secondly by offsetting the amount of $13,690 for deposits collected by Mr Kowalewski prior to the formation of the purchase agreement and retained by him in relation to orders subsequently completed by Ferguson Corporation; and thirdly by the payment of $20,000 made by Ferguson Corporation to Mr Kowalewski on or about 19 July 2005. CONCLUSION While Mr Kowalewski may have a perfectly sound explanation for all of the actions from which Ferguson Corporation contend that inferences should be drawn to support its claim, on the face of the matter, the claim is not fanciful, insubstantial or speculative. There is a deal of evidence from both within Ferguson Corporation itself and externally which is consistent with the claim. No conclusion can presently be reached as to whether or not the evidence will be accepted. The articulation of the claim in the pleading has been upheld in a previous strike out application and it follows, in my view, that certain additional specific discovery should be given but not in categories as broad as those which are sought by Ferguson Corporation. In my view Ferguson Corporation is entitled to discovery in all of the six categories in the attached schedule but subject to qualification. The first qualification is that the discovery should not include any product which does not bear a close resemblance to a product sold by Ferguson Corporation – the ‘kegerator’ is an obvious example but there may well be others. The second qualification is that as discussed in the course of the hearing, terms will have to be reached between counsel (and, if not, I will resolve them) as to confidentiality as there are obvious benefits for a competitor examining drawings, quotations and financial records of products which are the same as those which it sells. Equally, and for similar reasons, in my view, it is appropriate that Ferguson Corporation give discovery of those documents sought by Mr Kowalewski which go to the question of the manner in which Ferguson Corporation treated the payment of the consideration for the acquisition of Mr Kowalewski’s business. The four categories are qualified by the description of taxation records and advice received relating to the sale agreement, the subject of the cross-claim and defence and in particular, but not limited to, the various four items set out in the first paragraph of these reasons. As with discovery to be given by Mr Kowalewski, terms should be reached in relation to the confidentiality of that potentially highly sensitive discovery.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MCKERRACHER J