Ferdinands v Police No. Sccrm-02-136

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

FERDINANDS  v  POLICE
[2002] SASC 279

Full Court:  Doyle CJ, Wicks and Besanko JJ

  1. DOYLE CJ, WICKS AND BESANKO JJ:              Mr Ferdinands has applied for leave to appeal to the Full Court against a decision by a Judge of this Court.  The Judge dismissed an application for leave to appeal to the Full Court.  The application for leave to appeal is now made to the Full Court.

  2. Mr Ferdinands appealed to the District Court against a decision made by the Police Disciplinary Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), acting under the Police (Complaints and Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1985 (“the Police Act”). The appeal lay to the District Court by virtue of s 46(1) of the Police Act.

  3. By s 46(9) of the Police Act, the appeal lay to the District Court sitting in its Administrative and Disciplinary Division.

  4. The appeal to the District Court was dismissed by a Judge of that Court on 6 July 2001.

  5. Section 46(8) of the Police Act provides as follows:

    “(8)   No further appeal lies against a decision of the Court made on an appeal under this section.”

  6. That provision is a bar to an appeal to this Court against the decision of the District Court. Although s 43 of the District Court Act 1991 confers a right of appeal to this Court against a judgment of the District Court, s 43(3) of that Act provides:

    “(3)   In the case of a judgment of the Court in its Administrative and Disciplinary Division, an appeal lies as of right on a question of law and by leave of the Supreme Court on a question of fact (but this principle may be displaced or modified by the provisions of the special Act under which the jurisdiction is conferred).”

    Section 46(8) of the Police Act displaces the right of appeal that would otherwise be conferred by s 43 of the District Court Act.

  7. Accordingly, there was no right of appeal from the decision of the District Court to this Court.

  8. Nevertheless Mr Ferdinands filed a Summons in this Court, seeking an order that the decision of the District Court be set aside, and that his appeal be determined by the Supreme Court. If this is to be treated as an appeal against the District Court decision, s 46(8) of the Police Act is a bar to it being entertained by the Court.

  9. The submissions filed by Mr Ferdinands suggest that s 46(8) of the Police Act is invalid. In particular, Mr Ferdinands argues that the provision is discriminatory and is contrary to certain rights, not clearly identified, that are guaranteed to Mr Ferdinands. It suffices to say that there is no substance in these submissions, and there is no arguable prospect of them succeeding.

  10. It follows from this that the purported appeal to the Supreme Court against the decision of the District Court was incompetent.

  11. In another document that Mr Ferdinands was permitted to file, he seeks a “referral” of the District Court decision, on the grounds…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ferdinands v Police No. Sccrm-02-136 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Ferdinands v Police, the appellant, Mr. Ferdinands, sought leave to appeal to the Full Court against a decision of a Judge of the Supreme Court, which had dismissed an application for leave to appeal to the Full Court. The initial appeal was against a decision made by the Police Disciplinary Tribunal, acting under the Police (Complaints and Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1985. The appeal to the District Court was subsequently dismissed by a Judge of that Court. The legal issues at hand revolved around the validity of section 46(8) of the Police Act, which bars further appeal against a decision of the Court made on an appeal under this section. Mr. Ferdinands argued that this provision was discriminatory and contrary to certain rights, though these rights were not clearly identified. He further contended that there was no right of appeal from the decision of the District Court to the Supreme Court.

The court held that section 46(8) of the Police Act was valid and effective, thereby barring an appeal to the Supreme Court against the District Court decision. The submissions by Mr. Ferdinands did not present a valid basis for invalidating the section, and there was no arguable prospect of success. The court found that the purported appeal to the Supreme Court was incompetent and should have been struck out. The decision to strike out the application for "referral" was also deemed correct as there was no basis for such a referral. The Full Court concluded that the Judge was right in dismissing or striking out the purported appeal and that there was no need for the matter to be dealt with by the Full Court.

The application for leave to appeal to the Full Court was ultimately struck out as incompetent. The court found that the Judge had the inherent power to strike out the appeal on the grounds that it was plainly incompetent to invoke the jurisdiction of the Court. The Full Court considered that the Judge's decision was correct and that there was no need for further proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Ferdinands applied to the Police Disciplinary Tribunal for a review of a decision made by the Tribunal under the Police (Complaints and Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1985 (the Police Act). The Tribunal dismissed his application, and he appealed that decision to the District Court. The District Court dismissed his appeal, finding no grounds to overturn the Tribunal's decision. Under section 46(8) of the Police Act, no further appeal lies against a decision of the District Court made on an appeal under the Police Act. Mr Ferdinands then sought to appeal to the Supreme Court against the District Court's decision. However, section 46(8) of the Police Act bars any further appeal from the District Court to the Supreme Court. Despite this, Mr Ferdinands filed a summons in the Supreme Court seeking to set aside the District Court's decision and have his appeal determined by the Supreme Court. The submissions made by Mr Ferdinands argued that section 46(8) of the Police Act is invalid and discriminatory, but these arguments were found to be without substance. The Supreme Court Judge dismissed Mr Ferdinands' application as incompetent, finding there was no right of appeal from the District Court's decision to the Supreme Court. Mr Ferdinands also sought a "referral" of the District Court decision on the grounds that there is no right of appeal, but this application was also dismissed as there is no basis for such a referral. The Full Court found that the Judge was correct to strike out Mr Ferdinands' purported appeal to the Supreme Court as it was plainly incompetent.

The matter before the Full Court in Ferdinands v Police is an application by Mr Ferdinands for leave to appeal against a decision of a single Judge of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The single Judge dismissed Mr Ferdinands' application for leave to appeal against a decision of the District Court, which in turn had dismissed an appeal by Mr Ferdinands against a decision of the Police Disciplinary Tribunal. Section 46(8) of the Police (Complaints and Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1985 prohibits further appeal against the District Court's decision, and Mr Ferdinands' appeal to the Supreme Court against the District Court's decision was dismissed as incompetent. Mr Ferdinands now seeks leave to appeal to the Full Court against the Supreme Court's decision dismissing his application for leave to appeal. The Full Court considers that the Supreme Court Judge was correct to dismiss the appeal as incompetent and that the application for leave to appeal to the Full Court should also be struck out as incompetent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Police (Complaints and Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1985 (SA) section 46(8) is a valid bar to an appeal from a decision of the District Court to the Supreme Court.
2. Whether section 46(8) of the Police Act is discriminatory or contrary to certain rights guaranteed to Mr Ferdinands.
3. Whether Mr Ferdinands' application for leave to appeal to the Full Court is competent and should be allowed.
4. Whether the Supreme Court has the inherent power to strike out an incompetent appeal to the Full Court.
5. Whether the purported appeal by Mr Ferdinands should have been brought before the Full Court at the outset.

Held
1. The court concluded that section 46(8) of the Police (Complaints and Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1985 (SA) is a valid bar to an appeal from a decision of the District Court to the Supreme Court. As a result, the purported appeal was incompetent.
2. The court found that section 46(8) of the Police Act is not discriminatory or contrary to any rights guaranteed to Mr Ferdinands. Therefore, the argument that the section is invalid on these grounds was dismissed.
3. The court determined that Mr Ferdinands' application for leave to appeal to the Full Court was not competent and should be dismissed. There was no arguable prospect of success for the appeal.
4. The court held that the Supreme Court has the inherent power to strike out an incompetent appeal to the Full Court. In this case, the court exercised this power to dismiss Mr Ferdinands' appeal.
5. The court did not find it necessary to address whether the purported appeal by Mr Ferdinands should have been brought before the Full Court at the outset, as the appeal was already deemed incompetent and struck out.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether section 46(8) of the Police (Complaints and Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1985 (SA) is a valid bar to an appeal from a decision of the District Court to the Supreme Court, the court held that section 46(8) effectively bars such an appeal. The court noted that while section 43 of the District Court Act 1991 generally provides for an appeal to the Supreme Court from a decision of the District Court, section 43(3) limits this right of appeal when it comes to judgments made in the Administrative and Disciplinary Division of the District Court. The court further found that section 46(8) of the Police Act specifically displaces this right of appeal, thereby barring any appeal from the District Court's decision to the Supreme Court. This interpretation was consistent with the legislative intent to limit further appeals in disciplinary proceedings involving police.

The court dismissed Mr Ferdinands' contention that section 46(8) of the Police Act is discriminatory or contrary to certain rights guaranteed to him. The court found Mr Ferdinands' submissions to be without merit, noting that there was no arguable basis for invalidating the section. The court held that the provision was neither discriminatory nor contrary to any rights that could be substantiated by Mr Ferdinands. Consequently, the court found that Mr Ferdinands' arguments lacked substance and did not present a viable legal challenge to the validity of section 46(8).

In addressing whether Mr Ferdinands' application for leave to appeal to the Full Court was competent and should be allowed, the court determined that the application was indeed incompetent. The court observed that Mr Ferdinands had filed a summons in the Supreme Court seeking to set aside the District Court's decision and have his appeal determined by the Supreme Court. The court recognized that section 46(8) of the Police Act barred such an appeal, making Mr Ferdinands' application incompetent. The court further held that even if an appeal did lie to the Supreme Court, it would only be under section 43(2)(c) of the District Court Act, and it would have to be brought before the Full Court of the Supreme Court.

The court then considered whether the Supreme Court has the inherent power to strike out an incompetent appeal to the Full Court. The court concluded that the Supreme Court does possess such inherent power and that the Judge was correct in striking out the purported appeal on the grounds of its incompetence. The court found no necessity for the matter to be dealt with by the Full Court, as the inherent power of the court allowed the Judge to dispose of the incompetent appeal directly.

Lastly, the court examined whether the purported appeal by Mr Ferdinands should have been brought before the Full Court at the outset. Although the court had not received submissions on this specific point, it opined that the Judge could indeed exercise the inherent power of the Court to strike out the appeal. The court determined that the Judge's decision to dispose of the appeal was correct and that the application for leave to appeal to the Full Court should be struck out as incompetent.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that section 46(8) of the Police (Complaints and Disciplinary Proceedings) Act 1985 (SA) effectively bars an appeal from the District Court to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court has the inherent power to strike out an incompetent appeal to the Full Court. The court did not depart from prior authority but rather followed established principles regarding statutory interpretation and the inherent jurisdiction of courts to manage their own processes.