Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

[2009] HCATrans 149

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry
  Brisbane  No B8 of 2009

B e t w e e n -

ROBYN CHRISTINE FELLOWES

Appellant

and

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION

Respondent

HAYNE J
HEYDON J
CRENNAN J
KIEFEL J
BELL J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT BRISBANE ON TUESDAY, 23 JUNE 2009, AT 10.13 AM

(Continued from 22/6/09)

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

HAYNE J:   Yes, Mr Howe.

MR HOWE:   Your Honours, at the close of yesterday we had identified what we said were the distinctive features of the methodology deployed by table 9.5, and we indicated that their Honours comprising the Full Court of the Federal Court in Van Grinsven placed significance upon that distinctive methodology, and they did so at paragraphs 14, 15 and 16 of the judgment.  There is no need for your Honours to go to it.  We extract those relevant paragraphs at paragraph 10 of our written submissions.

We did want to make the point in answer to a matter that fell from Justice Hayne yesterday, that as we understand it no part of their Honours’ approach in Van Grinsven depended upon giving the expression “impairment” other than its defined meaning.  Certainly, for the sake of abundant clarity, no part of a case that we advance in these proceedings involves giving the expression “impairment” other than its defined meaning.

Now, the appellant for her part concentrates on a particular aspect of the definition, and we are content for the matter to proceed on that basis, but we would say that ultimately an employee is entitled to rely upon one aspect of the definition, or two or three aspects, or indeed the whole definition.  In these proceedings the appellant says, well, the relevant impairment caused by my injury was the loss, or the partial loss, of the use of my knee.

We say that accepting that comes within the definition of “impairment”.  One then has to assess the degree of that, and we submit that in doing that the methodology deployed by the guide is to do so by reference to the impact of the impairment on the employee as a whole person, particularly by reference to his or her ability to undertake and perform and discharge the activities of daily living.

Your Honours, I closed yesterday by conceding that no part of the Act expressly refers to the concept of “whole person” impairment but I did take your Honours to relevant sections of sections 24, 25 and 28 which do refer to an assessment or determination of the degree of impairment of an employee, and we relied on that, as it were, to indicate that the Act is concerned with assessment of degree of impairment by reference to the impact of the impairment as defined on an employee as a whole person, and we say support for that is to be gained by not only the second reading speech but also by consideration of the fact that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] HCATrans 149
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by Mr. Fellowes against a decision of the Full Federal Court, which had affirmed a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The dispute concerned Mr. Fellowes' entitlement to compensation under the *Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004* (Cth) for a condition he alleged arose from his service. The core of the disagreement lay in whether the condition was an "injury" as defined by the Act, and if so, whether it was attributable to his service.

The High Court was required to determine whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal had erred in law in its interpretation and application of the definition of "injury" under section 37 of the *Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004* (Cth). Specifically, the Court had to consider whether a condition that developed over time, without a single identifiable incident, could constitute an "injury" for the purposes of the Act, and whether the Tribunal had correctly applied the principles of statutory interpretation in reaching its conclusion.

The Court reasoned that the definition of "injury" in section 37 of the Act encompassed conditions that arose from a single event or incident, but also those that developed progressively over time due to the nature of military service. The High Court clarified that the absence of a specific, identifiable incident did not preclude a condition from being classified as an "injury" if it was demonstrably linked to the stresses and strains of service. The Court emphasised that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the evidence in light of this broader understanding of "injury" and had applied an overly narrow interpretation of the statutory provision.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the decision of the Full Federal Court and remitting the matter to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for redetermination in accordance with the High Court's reasons.

Background

Background to the litigation

Robyn Christine Fellowes, the appellant, was employed by the Royal Australian Air Force and sustained injuries during her service. Initially, she suffered a permanent impairment to her left knee, followed by another injury to her right knee several years later. The Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission (the respondent) assessed her impairment and awarded compensation based on a combined assessment of both knee injuries, rather than separately assessing each injury. Fellowes argued that she should receive separate compensation for each knee injury, as they resulted in distinct impairments. The crux of the dispute lay in the interpretation and application of the impairment assessment criteria in the approved guide used by the respondent. The case hinged on whether the guide’s methodology should consider each injury separately or combine multiple injuries into a single assessment when they result in the same impairment. The High Court was tasked with determining the correct interpretation of the relevant legislative provisions and the approved guide in assessing the degree of permanent impairment resulting from multiple injuries.

This appeal before the High Court of Australia arose from a dispute concerning the interpretation and application of the assessment methodology in the approved guide used to determine the degree of permanent impairment for compensation purposes under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). The matter originated in the Federal Court of Australia where the appellant, Robyn Christine Fellowes, sought review of a decision made by the respondent, Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission. The Full Court of the Federal Court had allowed the appeal in part, and Fellowes now appeals to the High Court seeking further clarification on the interpretation of the approved guide and the concept of "whole person" impairment. This appeal involves the construction of the approved guide and the application of its assessment methodology in determining the degree of permanent impairment of an employee resulting from injuries. The key issue before the High Court was whether the approved guide's methodology for assessing the degree of impairment should be applied in a manner that limits the compensable degree of impairment when multiple injuries result in the same impairment, as per the statement on page 5 of the guide. The High Court heard submissions from both parties on the proper interpretation of the approved guide and its application in this case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the term "impairment" as used in the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth) should be interpreted to include a "whole person" approach as opposed to a focus on specific injuries.
2. Whether the criteria and methodology in the approved guide for assessing the degree of permanent impairment of an employee should be applied in a manner that limits the assessment to a single rating for injuries resulting in the same impairment.
3. Whether the statement on page 5 of the approved guide, which states that where two or more injuries give rise to the same impairment a single rating only should be given, should be interpreted as a methodological stipulation that limits the assessment of impairment.
4. Whether the language in section 24(5) of the Act, which refers to "the degree of permanent impairment of the employee," incorporates a "whole person" approach to the assessment of impairment.
5. Whether the concept of "whole person" impairment, as argued by the appellant, is consistent with the process of assessment required by the Act and the observations of the High Court in Canute.

Held
1. Whether the term "impairment" as used in the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth) should be interpreted to include a "whole person" approach as opposed to a focus on specific injuries.
The court concluded that the term "impairment" should be interpreted to include a "whole person" approach rather than focusing solely on specific injuries.

2. Whether the criteria and methodology in the approved guide for assessing the degree of permanent impairment of an employee should be applied in a manner that limits the assessment to a single rating for injuries resulting in the same impairment.
The court concluded that the criteria and methodology in the approved guide should be applied in a manner that limits the assessment to a single rating for injuries resulting in the same impairment.

3. Whether the statement on page 5 of the approved guide, which states that where two or more injuries give rise to the same impairment a single rating only should be given, should be interpreted as a methodological stipulation that limits the assessment of impairment.
The court concluded that the statement on page 5 of the approved guide should not be interpreted as a methodological stipulation that limits the assessment of impairment.

4. Whether the language in section 24(5) of the Act, which refers to "the degree of permanent impairment of the employee," incorporates a "whole person" approach to the assessment of impairment.
The court concluded that the language in section 24(5) does not incorporate a "whole person" approach to the assessment of impairment.

5. Whether the concept of "whole person" impairment, as argued by the appellant, is consistent with the process of assessment required by the Act and the observations of the High Court in Canute.
The court concluded that the concept of "whole person" impairment, as argued by the appellant, is not consistent with the process of assessment required by the Act and the observations of the High Court in Canute.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court in Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission examined the interpretation of the term "impairment" under the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth) and the application of the approved guide for assessing permanent impairment. The Court considered whether the term "impairment" should be interpreted to include a "whole person" approach, as opposed to a focus on specific injuries. The Court deliberated on whether the criteria and methodology in the approved guide should be applied in a manner that limits the assessment to a single rating for injuries resulting in the same impairment. It also examined whether the statement on page 5 of the approved guide, which states that where two or more injuries give rise to the same impairment a single rating only should be given, should be interpreted as a methodological stipulation that limits the assessment of impairment. Furthermore, the Court assessed whether the language in section 24(5) of the Act, which refers to "the degree of permanent impairment of the employee," incorporates a "whole person" approach to the assessment of impairment. Finally, the Court evaluated whether the concept of "whole person" impairment, as argued by the appellant, is consistent with the process of assessment required by the Act and the observations of the High Court in Canute.

In interpreting the term "impairment," the Court held that the definition of impairment under the Act should be assessed by reference to the impact of the impairment on the employee as a whole person. The Court found that the legislative scheme intended to incorporate an assessment of the degree of impairment by reference to the impact on an employee as a whole person. This was supported by the second reading speech and the observations in Canute, which accepted that the Act adopts the whole person approach to the assessment of the degree of impairment of an employee resulting from an injury.

Regarding the criteria and methodology in the approved guide, the Court held that the guide's methodology should be applied in a manner that assesses the degree of impairment by reference to the impact on the employee as a whole person and their ability to perform activities of daily living. The Court found that the statement on page 5 of the guide, which directs that a single rating should be given where two or more injuries give rise to the same impairment, should be interpreted as part of the guide's methodology. The Court held that this methodology applies in a manner that, in some cases, will have a limiting effect on the assessment of impairment.

The Court further held that the language in section 24(5) of the Act, referring to "the degree of permanent impairment of the employee," incorporates a "whole person" approach to the assessment of impairment. This was consistent with the approach taken in Canute, where the Court rejected the notion that the Act's language implied a narrower interpretation of impairment.

Lastly, the Court found that the concept of "whole person" impairment, as argued by the appellant, is consistent with the process of assessment required by the Act. The Court emphasized that the assessment of impairment should be conducted in accordance with the criteria and methodology prescribed in the approved guide, which takes into account the impact of the impairment on the employee as a whole person.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the term "impairment" under the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth) should be interpreted to include a "whole person" approach, and the approved guide's criteria and methodology should be applied in a manner that assesses the degree of impairment by reference to the impact on the employee as a whole person. The Court also held that the statement on page 5 of the approved guide, which directs a single rating for the same impairment resulting from multiple injuries, should be interpreted as part of the guide's methodology. The Court distinguished the current case from prior authority by clarifying that the concept of "whole person" impairment is consistent with the process of assessment required by the Act and the observations in Canute.