Fell v Can Recycling (SA) Pty Ltd No. DCCIV-00-115

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Fell v Can Recycling (SA) Pty Ltd
[2002] SADC 166

Judge Lee
Civil

  1. This is a point of law which, by order of a Master, is to be determined in advance of a trial of the action.

  2. The plaintiff carries on business at Bordertown as a collection depot for empty beverage containers.  The defendant carries on business throughout the State of South Australia as a recycler of empty beverage containers.  On 1 August 1996, the parties entered into an agreement whereby the plaintiff would receive used beverage containers, refund deposits paid on those containers, and deliver the containers to the defendant for recycling, and the defendant for its part would reimburse the refunds to the plaintiff and pay him a handling fee.

  3. The action concerns a claim by the plaintiff to recover an alleged short-fall in, and a counterclaim by the defendant to recover an alleged overpayment of, reimbursements of deposit refunds paid to persons by the plaintiff.  The period covered by the action is 29 April 1999 to 2 June 1999.

  4. The point of law, although capable of formulation in different ways, really boils down to whether the obligation imposed by s.71 of the Environment Protection Act 1993 extends to beverage containers sold interstate. I will come to that section in a moment. Clauses 33 and 34 of the agreement provide:

    “33. The collector is responsible for paying the refund amount (as prescribed in the regulations to the Act) on a refund amount bearing container to the person who brings a refund amount bearing container to the depot.

    34. Statewide Recycling or the regional centre (if so appointed by Statewide Recycling ) must pay the collector on each Tuesday of every week the value of the refund amount on all refund amount bearing containers which are returned to the recycling centre, a regional centre, the beneficiation plant or other nominated location in the seven (7) days ending at midnight on Friday of the previous week.”

  5. Clause 1 of the agreement defines “Act” to mean the Environment Protection Act and “refund amount bearing containers” to mean “containers on which a refund amount is payable under the Act”.

  6. To relevantly paraphrase s.10 of the Environment Protection Act, the objects of the Act are to promote principles of ecologically sustainable development, and to minimise harm to the environment by programs to encourage action by industry aimed at pollution prevention, reuse and recycling of material and waste minimisation.

  7. Division 2 of the Act, under the heading Beverage Containers, provides a scheme whereby the purchaser of a beverage pays a deposit on an approved container to the retailer, an approved collection depot refunds the deposit upon return or delivery of the empty container, and the collection depot receives from the recycler both a reimbursement of the refund and a handling fee.

  8. Subsection (1) of s.68 provides that a retailer must not sell a beverage unless the container belongs to an approved class of containers, that is, either category A containers or category B containers,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fell v Can Recycling (SA) Pty Ltd No. DCCIV-00-115 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SADC 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Fell v Can Recycling (SA) Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, who operates a collection depot for empty beverage containers, and the defendant, a recycler of such containers, were in dispute over the reimbursement of deposit refunds. The plaintiff claimed an alleged shortfall in refunds, while the defendant claimed an alleged overpayment. The central legal issue before the court was whether section 71 of the Environment Protection Act 1993 applies to beverage containers sold outside South Australia. This question was crucial because it determined the extent of the plaintiff’s obligations under the agreement with the defendant, particularly regarding the refund amounts on containers that bore an approved refund marking. The court had to interpret the provisions of the Act, particularly section 71, in light of the objects of the Act and the specific context of the contractual obligations between the parties.

The court considered whether the literal interpretation of section 71 would result in an outcome that was inconsistent with the objects of the Environment Protection Act. It was established that section 22 of the Acts Interpretation Act 1915 requires that where a provision of an Act is reasonably open to more than one construction, the one that promotes the purpose or object of the Act should be preferred. The court also examined the broader scheme of Division 2 of the Act, which was designed to encourage recycling and minimize harm to the environment by ensuring that containers are collected and recycled within South Australia. The court concluded that the literal interpretation of section 71 would lead to an outcome that was contrary to the legislative intent, as it would require the plaintiff to pay refunds on containers sold outside South Australia, where no deposit had been paid. Thus, the court held that the words “containers” and “container” in section 71 must, by necessary implication, mean containers and container sold in South Australia. Consequently, the plaintiff was not obligated to pay refunds on containers sold interstate, and the defendant was not obligated to pay the value of such refunds to the plaintiff.

Based on the above reasoning, the court determined that there was no responsibility on the plaintiff to pay refund amounts on containers sold interstate and no responsibility on the defendant to pay the value of such refund amounts to the plaintiff. The court proceeded to consider the scheduling of a trial date for the action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established