Felix Taranto and John Holland Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

[2014] AATA 848  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Numbers

2012/5308, 2013/5669, 2013/5716, 2013/5732 and 2013/6514

Re

Felix Taranto

APPLICANT

And

John Holland Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member

Date 12 November 2014
Place Sydney

The decisions under review are affirmed.

........................[sgd]................................................

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS COMPENSATION – Whether condition is an injury – Prior injuries and conditions - Injuries not disclosed on pre-employment form - Whether wilful and false representation – Whether proposed surgery in relation to injury – Whether surgery was reasonable to obtain in the circumstances – Omission on pre-employment form does not constitute wilful and false representation – Decisions under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), ss 4, 7(7), 14, 16 and 19

CASES

Brown v Australian Postal Corporation [2014] AATA 261

Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439
Comcare v Porter (1996) 70 FCR 139
Commonwealth v Smith (1989) 18 ALD 224
Havnen v Comcare [2010] AATA 535
Health Insurance Commission v Van Reesch (1996) 45 ALD 302
Makin and Comcare [2010] AATA 432

Sheather-Smith and Australian Postal Corporation [2005] AATA 1001

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member

12 November 2014

SUMMARY

  1. Mr Felix Taranto, who is 49 years old, commenced fulltime employment with the John Holland Pty Ltd (John Holland), as a labourer on 12 March 2012. He had worked as a subcontractor for the Company since 2007. In his pre-employment medical history questionnaire completed in February 2012, he disclosed that he had been involved in a motor vehicle accident some months previously, in which he sustained no injuries, and had no time off work. He also disclosed a hernia two years prior, and an ankle injury


    15 years prior. He indicated that he had never experienced a back injury or back problem. Unfortunately he did not disclose all the events which have impacted on his health either to his employer or to his doctors. I have detailed those events in the paragraphs below. They impact upon Mr Taranto’s credit, and the opinions of the doctors who examined him.

  2. On 12 April 2012, Mr Taranto injured his back at work in the process of removing pegs from a silt fence. The forms he signed for the employer reporting the injury, which he says were filled in by his employer, indicated that the incident had occurred on


    16 April 2012. Mr Taranto said that he signed the forms with the incorrect date because he was afraid he might lose his job if he objected.  John Holland, the Respondent in these proceedings, accepted liability for aggravation of multilevel degenerative changes in the lumbar spine sustained on 16 April 2012, pursuant to section 14(1) of the


    Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

    (the Act).

  3. In matter 2013/5716, the Respondent, in a decision of 25 October 2013, ceased section 16 and section 19 entitlements for back injury as at 1 October 2013. In that reviewable decision, the Respondent held that as at 1 October…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Felix Taranto and John Holland Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 848
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Felix Taranto against John Holland Pty Ltd, the primary dispute involved whether Mr Taranto’s injuries, which he did not disclose during his pre-employment medical form, constituted an injury under the Workers Compensation Act. The case was heard by the Workers Compensation Regulator, which had earlier determined that Mr Taranto was not entitled to compensation as of 1 October 2013, as he did not suffer from a compensable injury. The decision was appealed and reviewed by the relevant tribunal, which was tasked with determining whether to affirm, vary, or set aside the Regulator’s decision.

The central legal issues before the tribunal included whether Mr Taranto's failure to disclose his prior medical conditions on the pre-employment form constituted a wilful and false representation, and whether the proposed surgery in relation to his injury was reasonable. Additionally, the tribunal had to decide if the omission on the pre-employment form constituted a wilful and false representation and whether the proposed surgery was reasonable under the circumstances.

The tribunal found that Mr Taranto’s omission of prior injuries and treatments on his pre-employment form did not constitute a wilful and false representation. The tribunal noted that the majority of medical evidence supported that Mr Taranto had aggravated his degenerative spine but did not suffer a specific injury to his lumbar discs. The tribunal also found that the proposed surgery was not reasonable given the transient benefits of the diagnostic injections. The tribunal affirmed the Regulator’s decision that Mr Taranto was not entitled to compensation as of 1 October 2013, as he did not suffer an incapacity for work or require medical treatment for his back injury.

In conclusion, the tribunal upheld the Regulator’s decision, finding no basis to vary or set aside it. The tribunal affirmed that Mr Taranto was not entitled to workers compensation for the period in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In summary, Mr Taranto had medical treatment for his lower back, left knee, right knee, a hernia, and anxiety/stress before March 2012 when he commenced fulltime employment with John Holland. He did not disclose all of those conditions and the treatment he received in his pre-employment form in February 2012. In the paragraphs which follow, I deal with the medical evidence.Medical evidence Dr Tom Lieng, a general practitioner, saw Mr Taranto after his back and leg injuries on the 24 April and 4 and 9 May 2012. Following a review by Dr Machart, who recommended that a right L5 nerve root block was not a good idea because Mr Taranto’s pain was not typically radicular, Dr Lieng referred him to Professor James van Gelder (neurosurgery and spine surgery) for an opinion and management suggestions. Dr Lieng dealt with the Respondent in regard to rehabilitation. Dr Azmir, who has been Mr Taranto’s general practitioner for 20 years, gave oral evidence at the Tribunal. He told me that he had been treating Mr Taranto for chronic ongoing lower back pain, and pain in his testes. He also mentioned Mr Taranto’s left knee problem for which he had surgery in 2013, and his ongoing depression. Professor James van Gelder whose specialities are neurosurgery and spine surgery, reported on examining Mr Taranto on 25 July 2012. He noted that Mr Taranto had by then reported three months of continuous severe back pain. Professor van Gelder remarked that he did not obtain a clear history of sciatica, and did not identify any neurological signs in the legs. He noted further that symptoms and signs appeared severe and disproportionate to changes shown on the radiological studies and bone scan. He recommended Mr Taranto be treated with reassurance about the investigations, a trial of hydrotherapy, and a trial of alternative medication such as a short period on Diazepam. Dr Brian Hsu, a spine surgeon, provided a report dated 9 October 2012. In it, he opined that Mr Taranto demonstrated back and leg pain which could be related to lumbar disc pathology. He remarked however that the symptoms around his right groin and symptoms of giving way did not clearly fit with the radiographic findings. On 9 October 2012, and again in December 2012, he recommended a trial of diagnostic injections in the lower lumbar spine as both a diagnostic and therapeutic intervention. A report of Dr Hsu dated 13 February 2013 to Dr Lieng reported on his review of Mr Taranto following his L5/S1 right sided foraminal injection. He stated that the injection gave Mr Taranto a significant degree of relief and this has lasted him approximately two months. In a later report dated 5 March 2013, Dr Hsu stated that the injection gave Mr Taranto excellent relief for a short period. He recommended L5/S1 decompression or decompression and fusion surgery. However, I note that Mr Taranto told Dr Harvey that the effects of the injection provided short term relief only, perhaps 24 hours. In cross-examination he agreed he had told doctors that the beneficial effects of the injection were of short duration.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Drs Harvey and Machart recommended that Mr Taranto be assisted with a self-directed exercise program, noting that he would not be fit for heavy work involving lifting or bending. However, in his report, Dr Harvey opined that Mr Taranto would be able to do full time work of a suitable kind, with reassurance and encouragement to improve his state of physical fitness and return to normal activities.The Tribunal’s conclusions regarding the incident of 12 April 2012 In coming to a decision regarding whether to affirm, vary or set aside the decision of the Respondent dated 25 October 2013, which held that as at 1 October 2013 the Applicant no longer suffered the effects of his accepted injury incurred on April 2012, I have taken into account Mr Taranto’s evidence and that of the doctors who have treated and examined him. The determination decided that as at 1 October 2013 the Applicant was not entitled to compensation under section 16 of the Act on the basis that he did not reasonably require medical treatment in relation to his accepted back injury, and that he was not entitled to compensation under section 19 of the Act on the basis that he did not suffer an incapacity for work as a result of his accepted back injury. I am mindful of the Applicant’s evidence that he continues to suffer back pain. I am also mindful that the majority of the medical opinion (Drs Azmir, Lieng, Machart, Bodel Harvey), is in agreement that what occurred on 12 April 2012 when Mr Taranto was working on removing a silt fence, and pulling out a peg was that he aggravated his degenerative spine. Dr Bodel noted that an MRI taken of Mr Taranto’s lumbar spine on 9 May 2012 showed a central disc prolapse at the L4/5 level and a right sided and central disc prolapse at the L5/S1 level. He noted also that there was no definite nerve root compromise at any level, as agreed by Dr Harvey. Dr Bodel’s opinion was that Mr Taranto suffers mechanical back pain, whilst Dr Harvey’s opinion was he could have suffered a soft tissue injury on 12 April 2012, and that was that there is a very large non-organic component to his complaint. Drs Machart and Harvey opined that there may be non-organic factors contributing to the expression of the severity and discomfort Mr Taranto expressed. I have accepted that. The Respondent considered the effects of the injury were temporary and had resolved by 1 October 2013. I agree that this is supported by the fact that second to the MRI and the medical opinion, Mr Taranto did not suffer any specific injury to any of his lumbar discs which would have resulted in radicular symptoms in the lower limbs. The fact that the benefits of Dr Hsu’s injections in December 2012 were very transient, lasting only 24 hours according to Mr Taranto, supports the opinion that Mr Taranto did not suffer specific injury to any of his lumbar discs in the incident of 12 April 2012. I am mindful that because of industrial and rehabilitation issues Mr Taranto’s return to work after the April 2012 incident did not proceed smoothly, and that when he was to return to work he suffered the flu, followed by the fall on 26 August 2012 which involved his left knee. His back had improved and he was ready to return by then.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.