Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Barton

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read
96 CLR 359

FEDERAL COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION BARTON

RESPONDENT. Income Tax (Cth.)-Return of income-Lodgment within time-No assessment within

twelve months-Request for assessment-Failure to serve notice of assessment within three months thereafter-Assessment subsequently issued-Amended assessment-Whether assessment competent-Time limit for assessment-Income Tax Assessment Act 1936-1947 (No. 27 of 1936-No. 63 of 1947), ss. 170 (1) (2) (3)*, 171*.

A taxpayer who had made a return of income containing a full and correct disclosure received no notice of assessment within twelve months. The tax- payer in pursuance of S. 171 (1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936-1947 requested the commissioner to make an assessment but the commissioner did not make an assessment until after the expiry of the three months mentioned in sub-s. (2) of S. 171.

An objection to the assessment was made on the ground that, since under S. 171 (2) the assessment must be deemed an amended assessment, no such assessment could under S. 170 (3) be made in the circumstances except to

(b) in any other case -within six Assessment Act 1936-1947 provides :-

years from the date upon (1.) The Commissioner may, subject to this section, at any time amend any

payable under the assessment, assessment by making such alterations

amend the assessment by making such necessary, notwithstanding that tax

as he thinks necessary to correct an may have been paid in respect of the

or to prevent avoidance of tax as the (2.) Where a taxpayer has not made

(3.) Where a taxpayer has made to necessary for his assessment, and there has been an avoidance of tax, the

sary for his assessment, and an assess- Commissioner may-

ment is made after that disclosure, (a) where he is of opinion that the

increasing the liability of the taxpayer fraud or evasion-at any

in any particular shall be made except

96 CLR 360

Held that the objection was not well founded. Although the words of sub-s. (2) of S. 171 show that it does not express all the conditions that must be satisfied for the making of an amended assessment under that sub-section, yet no such assessment made after the expiry of the three months set going under S. 171 could be valid if it must satisfy in every respect all the requirements of sub-s. (2) or of sub-s. (3) of S. 170, and S. 171 clearly contemplates that an assessment may be made after the expiry of the three months. In its reference to a notional assessment sub-s. (2) of S. 171 provides no basis for any possible application of the conception of " an error in calculation or a mistake of fact ", although that forms the first restriction made by sub-s. (3) of S. 170 upon the power of amendment conferred by sub-s. (1) of that section. The reference to a notional assessment made by S. 171 (2) provides a completely adequate basis for applying the second restriction imposed upon the power by S. 170 (3) and it is that condition only of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Barton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1957] HCA 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Commissioner of Taxation appealed to the High Court against a decision of a Board of Review. The dispute concerned the validity of an income tax assessment issued to the taxpayer, Elsie Florence MacNeill Simpson, after a delay. The taxpayer had lodged a return with full disclosure, and after twelve months, requested the Commissioner to make an assessment under section 171 of the *Income Tax Assessment Act 1936-1947*. The Commissioner failed to issue the assessment within the subsequent three-month period stipulated by section 171(2). An assessment was eventually issued on 10 June 1948, which the taxpayer’s estate objected to on the grounds that the Commissioner was precluded from assessing after the three-month period had expired.

The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether the Commissioner was precluded by section 170(3) of the Act from making an assessment after the expiration of three months from the taxpayer's request under section 171(1), given that the taxpayer had made a full and true disclosure of all material facts. A secondary issue, which was subsequently abandoned by the Commissioner, concerned whether the taxpayer had a right of objection against the assessment.

The Court reasoned that section 171(2) contemplates that an assessment may be validly made after the expiry of the three-month period, deeming it an amended assessment for specific purposes. While this deeming provision gives the assessment a notional character, it does not require it to satisfy all conditions of section 170(2) or (3) in every respect. The Court held that the reference to a notional assessment in section 171(2) provides a sufficient basis for applying the time limitation imposed by section 170(3), which restricts amendments increasing liability except to correct an error in calculation or a mistake of fact. Crucially, the Court found that the notional assessment under section 171(2) does not preclude the application of the time bar in section 170(3), which allows for amendments within three years from the date tax became payable. As the assessment was issued within this time limit, it was competent.

The Court answered the first question in the case stated in the negative, finding that the Commissioner was not precluded from making the assessment. The second question was answered by noting that the right of objection was not contested by the Commissioner.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established