Featherby v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

CITATION:    Featherby v Northern Territory of Australia [2013] NTMC 021

PARTIES:CLIVE FEATHERBY

v

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT:  LOCAL COURT

JURISDICTION:  Civil

FILE NO(s):21324665

DELIVERED ON:  29 July 2013

DELIVERED AT:  Darwin

HEARING DATE(s):  27 June 2013

JUDGMENT OF:  Dr John Lowndes

CATCHWORDS:

LOCAL COURT – APPEAL AGAINST REFUSAL OF COMMISSIONER OF POLICE TO GRANT A WHOLESALE FIREWORKS DEALER’S LICENCE – APPROPRIATE PERSON TEST – TREATMENT OF “CRIMINAL INTELLIGENCE” – RELIABILITY OF “CRIMINAL INTELLIGENCE” AND WEIGHT TO BE GIVEN TO IT – APPEAL DISMISSED

Regulations 5M (5), (7), (9) and (11) of the Dangerous Goods Regulations

K Generation v Liquor Licensing Court [2009] 237 CLR 501 applied

Henrie v Canada (Security Intelligence Review Committee) [1989] 2 FC 229 considered

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Appellant:Mr Stevenson

Respondent:  Mr Maurice QC

Solicitors:

Appellant:Ace Solicitors

Respondent:  Solicitor for the Northern Territory

Judgment category classification:        A

Judgment ID number:  [2013] NTMC 021

Number of paragraphs:  102

IN THE LOCAL COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21324665

BETWEEN:

CLIVE FEATHERBY

Appellant

AND:

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

Defendant

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 29 July 2013)

Dr John Allan Lowndes:

  1. On 27 June 2013 I confirmed the decision of the Commissioner of Police not to provide a certificate that Mr Clive Featherby is an appropriate person to whom a licence may be granted. I indicated that I would provide my reasons for decision at a later date. These are my reasons for decision.

    THE NATURE OF THE APPEAL

  2. This is an appeal brought by Mr Featherby (the appellant) pursuant to Regulation 5M(1) of the Dangerous Goods Regulations. The appellant is appealing a decision of the Commissioner of Police not to provide a certificate that he is an appropriate person to whom a licence may be granted. That decision was set out in a letter dated 5 June 2013 from the Commissioner to Ms Melissa Garde NT WorkSafe:

    I am advised there are sufficient grounds to object to the issuing of a licence pursuant to regulation 5H(4) of the Dangerous Goods Regulations:

    (4) A licence under this Division to sell shopgoods fireworks, other than by retail to the public during a retail purchase period, must not be granted unless the Competent Authority receives a certificate from the Commissioner of Police stating that, in the Commissioner’s opinion, the relevant person in relation to the application is an appropriate person to whom the licence may be granted.

    I hereby advise that Mr Featherby is not, in my opinion, an appropriate person to whom a licence may be granted.

  3. In appealing that decision, the appellant relies upon the following grounds:[1]

    1.The appellant is currently licensed to sell fireworks in every Australian State and was deemed to be a fit and proper person to hold a licence in each of those States.

    2.The appellant was deemed an appropriate person to hold an explosives licence in the 2012 season and was granted such a licence. No conditions of this licence were breached and there are no other facts…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Featherby v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NTMC 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Featherby v Northern Territory of Australia, the applicant, Mr Featherby, sought judicial review of a decision by the Commissioner of Police not to grant him a wholesale fireworks dealer's licence. The case was heard in the Local Court of the Northern Territory. The central issue before the court was whether the Commissioner's decision not to grant the applicant a licence was legally sound, particularly in light of the "criminal intelligence" that the Commissioner relied upon in making his decision.

The court was required to determine the appropriate standard of proof for assessing whether an applicant is an "appropriate person" to hold a fireworks dealer's licence. The court also needed to evaluate the reliability and weight of the "criminal intelligence" that the Commissioner had relied upon. Furthermore, the court had to decide whether the Commissioner's decision was consistent with the Dangerous Goods Regulations and whether the court itself should have considered the "criminal intelligence" in making its decision.

The court found that the Commissioner's decision was based on a sufficient body of "criminal intelligence" that was relevant and probative. The court held that the standard of proof for determining whether an applicant is an appropriate person is the civil standard – the balance of probabilities. The court determined that the "criminal intelligence" was sufficiently reliable and corroborated by multiple sources, thereby enhancing its credibility. The court concluded that Mr Featherby did not meet the high standards of probity and regard for the law required for holding a fireworks dealer's licence. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

The court's final orders were that the appeal be dismissed, and the decision of the Commissioner not to grant Mr Featherby a wholesale fireworks dealer's licence was upheld. The court emphasised the importance of maintaining confidentiality of classified information while still providing adequate reasons for its decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, when giving its reasons in support of its decision, the Court should be careful when referring to the “criminal intelligence” before it to refer to that evidence in very general terms and to avoid inadvertently revealing information that has been found to amount to “criminal intelligence” as well as commenting directly on any particular document or piece of evidence. However, notwithstanding the difficulties occasioned by regulation 5M(8) of the Dangerous Goods Regulations, the Court must still give adequate reasons for its decision in order to avoid appellable error. CONSIDERATION OF THE WHOLE OF THE EVIDENCE AND DETERMINATION OF THE APPEAL The undeniably difficult task of the Court is to consider all of the evidence put before the Court, comprising the “criminal intelligence” relied upon by the respondent, the non classified material provided to the Court by the respondent and the evidence presented to the Court by the appellant. The Court’s job is to evaluate all the evidence in terms of its relevance or its rational probative value, reliability and weight. In undertaking this exercise, it is, in my opinion, inappropriate to approach the determination of the appeal from the perspective of one of the parties carrying a burden of proof. The question is purely and simply whether the Court is satisfied, on the whole of the evidence, that Mr Featherby is an appropriate person to hold the licence that he seeks. The standard of proof is the civil standard – the balance of probabilities. That standard requires the Court to be reasonably satisfied that it is more probable than not – or as sometimes expressed as more likely than not - that Mr Featherby is an appropriate person to hold the relevant licence. The obvious starting point is an evaluation of the “criminal intelligence” that was put before the Court. At the outset, I have been careful to ensure that all of the “criminal intelligence” relates to either Mr Featherby or his company KC’s Fireworks.[47] In my opinion, the “criminal intelligence” that was available to the Commissioner at the time of his decision was relevant or rationally probative. I have also formed the same opinion in relation to the subsequent “criminal intelligence” that was made available to the Court. In my opinion, annexures RB 2 – RB 15 to the affidavit of Richard Bryson (Exhibit 3) adversely reflect upon Mr Featherby’s probity and regard for the law, such as to seriously call into question his capacity to operate within and in accordance with the Northern Territory licensing regime, and to fully comply with the terms and conditions of a wholesaler’s licence in the event he was granted such a licence. In my opinion the information contained in the “criminal intelligence” is adequately sourced and not anonymous. Although specific pieces of “criminal intelligence” are not corroborated by more than one independent source, there is a body of “criminal intelligence” that comes from a number of different sources over a significant period of time that lends credence to each separate piece of “criminal intelligence”. In my opinion that enhances not only the reliability of each individual piece of information but also the totality of the “criminal intelligence”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In my opinion, there is nothing in Regulation 5M or any other regulation of the Dangerous Goods Regulations that has the effect of displacing the presumptive position.THE “APPROPRIATE PERSON” TEST AND RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS In forming the opinion that a person is an appropriate person to whom a licence may be granted the Court (standing in the shoes of the Commissioner) must have regard to the following matters:(a)whether a criminal history check discloses that the applicant for a licence has been found guilty of a disqualifying offence;(b)any other material available to the Commissioner (for example criminal intelligence about a person associated with the applicant or the fact that the applicant is on bail in relation to pending charges) that the Commissioner considers appropriate.[9] Regulation 5M(7) provides that if an appeal is against a decision by the Commissioner of Police not to provide a certificate that an applicant is an appropriate person to whom a licence may be granted, the Local Court must take steps to maintain the confidentiality of classified information provided to it by the Commissioner, including steps to receive evidence and hear argument about the information in the absence of the parties to the proceedings, their representatives and the public, if the Court considers the classifies information is criminal intelligence. Regulation 5M(9) provides that if the Local Court considers classified information is not criminal intelligence, the Court must allow the Commissioner of Police to withdraw the classified information from consideration. “Classified Information” is defined as meaning “information the Commissioner of Police classifies as criminal intelligence”.[10] “Criminal Intelligence” is defined to mean:(a)information relating to actual or suspected criminal activity (whether in the Territory or elsewhere) the disclosure of which could reasonably be expected to:(i) prejudice a criminal investigation; or(ii)enable the discovery of the existence or identity of a confidential source of information relevant to law enforcement; or(iii) endanger a person’s life or physical safety; or(b)information the disclosure of which could reasonably be expected to reveal, and prejudice the effectiveness of, any of the following:(i) police information- gathering or surveillance methods;(ii)police procedures for preventing, detecting, investigating or dealing with matters arising out of breaches or evasions of the law.[11] As pointed out by counsel for respondent, the preconditions for obtaining a licence – the licensing standards – are set very high:Essentially, only persons whose probity is beyond question, who are above suspicion so far as their regard for the law is concerned, are to be considered appropriate persons to hold a licence.[12] Whether or not a person is an appropriate person to hold a licence is inextricably linked to questions of probity and regard for the law. In determining the appropriateness of a person to hold a licence the relevant regulations give a mandate to the Commissioner (and the Local Court hearing an appeal), as counsel for the respondent put it, to have “regard to confidential criminal intelligence and unproven charges, and subordinating an applicants’ private commercial interests to the public interest in maintaining confidentiality in criminal intelligence”.[13]