Faulks and BIS Industries Limited (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

Faulks and BIS Industries Limited (Compensation) [2020] AATA 2951 (14 August 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2017/4493, 2017/6915, 2019/6495      

Re:John Faulks  

APPLICANT

BIS Industries LimitedAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Presiding Senior Member D O'Donovan,

Member Dr P Wilkins

Date:14 August 2020

Place:Canberra

The decision the subject of proceeding 2019/6495 is set aside and the Tribunal, in substitution, decides that, pursuant to section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act), the respondent is liable to pay compensation, in accordance with the SRC Act, in relation to the injury to the applicant’s lumbar spine at the L5/S1 level which is secondary to the accepted L4/L5 injury.

The decision the subject of proceeding 2017/4493 is set aside and the Tribunal, in substitution, decides that the respondent is liable to pay compensation for the “right L5-S1 microdiscectomy surgery” pursuant to section 16 of the SRC Act and to reimburse the applicant for attendances with Dr Jerry Day on 10 November 2016 and 31 May 2017, parking fees for 31 May 2017 and travel on 31 May 2017 and 15 June 2017.

The decision the subject of proceeding 2017/6915 is set aside and the Tribunal, in substitution, decides that the respondent is liable to pay compensation under section 16 of the SRC Act for the medical account provided by Dr Jamie McCarney for anaesthesia services provided during the right L5/S1 microdiscectomy surgery on 18 July 2017.

........................................................................

Presiding Senior Member D O'Donovan

Catchwords

WORKERS COMPENSATION –accepted injury to L4/5 in 2011 – ceased work – deterioration at L5/S1 requiring surgery – whether surgery is medical treatment obtained in relation to accepted injury – was L5/S1 condition a disease significantly contributed to by the applicant’s employment – significance of altered gait as a consequence of L4/L5 injury  -– section 14 liability for injury or disease at L5/S1 level – decisions under review set aside

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 14, 16, 19, 20, 24, 27

Cases

Abrahams v Comcare [2006] FCA 1829
Comcare Australia v Lees (1997) 151 ALR 647
EMI (Aust) Ltd v Bes [1970] 2 NSWR 238
Telstra v Hannaford (2006) 151 FCR 253

Secondary Materials

AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Disease and Injury Causation, Melhorn et al (2nd Edition), American Medical Association (2014)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Presiding Senior Member D O'Donovan,
Member Dr P Wilkins

14 August 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant undertook heavy work for the respondent (and its previous corporate incarnations) for more than 15 years. Back problems, which the respondent accepts are compensable, developed in 2009, re-occurred in 2011 and eventually resulted in the applicant’s employment with the respondent ceasing in 2014. The 2011 problems, which resulted in the applicant ceasing to be employed, were focused on the left side of the applicant’s spine at the L4/L5 level. After the applicant ceased employment, further back problems developed resulting in the need for surgery on the right side at the L5/S1 level. The applicant seeks compensation in relation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Faulks and BIS Industries Limited (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 2951
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr. Faulks, sought review of decisions that rejected his claim for compensation for surgery performed on his L5/S1 disc. The respondent was BIS Industries Limited. The dispute centred on whether the surgery, performed in November 2016, constituted medical treatment obtained in relation to an accepted injury sustained in 2011 at the L4/L5 level, or if the L5/S1 condition was a disease significantly contributed to by his employment. The matter was heard by Presiding D O'Donovan, SM.

The court was required to determine two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the surgery to the L5/S1 disc was undertaken "in relation to" the accepted L4/L5 injury, as required by section 16 of the SRC Act. This involved examining the purpose of the surgery and its connection to the applicant's prior accepted injury. Secondly, the court had to consider whether the L5/S1 condition was a disease significantly contributed to by the applicant's employment, potentially falling under section 14 of the SRC Act, particularly in light of an altered gait resulting from the earlier L4/L5 injury.

The court reasoned that the applicant's submission that the surgery was to restore his gait to a previous baseline, thereby linking it to the accepted L4/L5 injury, was not supported by the full context of the medical evidence. It was found that the surgery was primarily aimed at addressing new symptoms and deterioration at the L5/S1 level, including nerve compression affecting the right leg, which evolved beyond the scope of the original L4/L5 injury. The court also considered the applicant's extensive history of heavy manual labour, which contributed to spinal degeneration. Ultimately, the Tribunal was satisfied that the applicant had a compensable injury at the L5/S1 level. The reviewable decisions were set aside, and the Tribunal found the applicant had a compensable injury at the L5/S1 level.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The third (2019/6495) seeks review of a reviewable decision made on 4 October 2019 rejecting liability under section 14 of the SRC Act to pay compensation in relation to a condition secondary to the accepted L4/L5 injury being an injury to L5/S1 sustained in 2017. In practical terms the challenge to each of the reviewable decisions is an attempt to identify a pathway to the payment of compensation in relation to the surgery performed on 10 November 2016.FACTS Our findings of fact are set out below. Where the findings are controversial, we have referenced the evidence on which they are based. The applicant has a long history of performing heavy manual tasks. In about 1995, the applicant started work with ‘Mquip,’ a forklift company, as a refueller. At some point he was subcontracted by Mquip to BIS Industries Limited (BIS) (at the time known as Brambles) and in 2004 he became a full-time employee of BIS.[1] BIS became a licensee under the SRC Act on 1 October 2008. [1] At the time it was still known as Brambles. When he worked for BIS, the applicant was responsible for refuelling vehicles which ran on liquid fuel and swapping over gas cylinders which powered forklifts. His work involved driving a truck, pulling fuel pump hoses, and carrying and manoeuvring heavy cylinders. Between 2004 and approximately 2008, the applicant’s work included manually lifting up, from the top of a flatbed truck, the large and heavy gas cylinders used to fuel forklifts. The applicant’s estimates of the weight of these cylinders when full was somewhere between 25kg and 45kg. The applicant was lifting cylinders more than 5 times a day and perhaps as much as 12 times per day. Precision on these matters is impossible given the passage of time, but we are satisfied that for a period of about 4 years when the applicant was employed by BIS, he was responsible for lifting and manoeuvring cylinders of at least 25kg more than 5 times a day, 6 days a week. Most of this work was undertaken prior to BIS becoming a licensee under the scheme in October 2008. Around 2009 modifications were made to the truck the applicant drove so that he was no longer required to lift the cylinders off the truck. A hoist was installed to facilitate the lifting and a cage was built which prevented the removal of the cylinders without using the hoist. The applicant gave evidence that these changes were made after he was injured for the first time. We are satisfied he genuinely believed this to be true. However, the Tribunal received a Task Analysis Report dated 23 December 2009 which indicates that the change occurred somewhat earlier, and we prefer that evidence to the recollection of the applicant.[2][2] ST105, folio 28. (refers to the use of a hoist in the applicant’s pre-injury duties) As part of his work, the applicant drove to a number of different sites. At the Port Kembla Steelworks he was required to drive over many speed bumps. In May 2009 the applicant suffered his first back injury. He has given a few accounts of what occurred which in broad detail are consistent.[3] The 2009 issues did not develop out of any specific traumatic incident but started to develop out of a pinching in his back and this came on while he was working. He put it down to getting in and out of a truck frequently. [3] See Exhibit A6 (while climbing in and out of truck); T19, folio 64; T64, folio 189; ST104, folio 22 (delivering gas bottles).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant medical evidence on which these conclusions are based is discussed below.THE MEDICAL EVIDENCE The Tribunal received written evidence from a number of doctors, and 5 doctors prepared reports for the proceedings and gave oral evidence in relation to their views.Dr Bentivoglio Dr Bentivoglio is a neurosurgeon. His view was that the heavy nature of the applicant’s work caused his spine to degenerate and that he has been the victim of that degeneration ever since. All the post-work degeneration which the applicant’s spine has demonstrated is not constitutional but the product of a process set in train by the heavy work which he undertook over many years, including from 2004-2011 working for the respondent. Dr Bentivoglio was an argumentative witness. His report shows little evidence of careful preparation in that the work history is extremely brief and there is little elaboration on questions of causation by reference to the literature. The absence of reference to the literature is important to his credibility because it is clear that it is now a contested question as to how significant heavy work is in causing or aggravating lumbar disc disease. Twin studies quoted in the AMA Guide to the Evaluation of Disease and Injury Causation[23] suggest that genetic factors are overwhelmingly important and for the lower lumbar spine manual labour is in most cases unimportant. However, a twin study in Croatia implicated intensity of physical labour at work in lumbar disc disease.[24] Dr Bentivoglio’s failure to engage with the complexity of the issue, take a careful work history or properly examine how much heavy work was done by the applicant with this employer, makes his report and opinions of limited assistance. [23] AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Disease and Injury Causation, Melhorn et al (2nd Edition), American Medical Association (2014), at 196-235.[24] Exhibit R4 (Saftic R et al. Case controlled study of risk factors for lumbar intervertebral disc herniation in Croatian Island populations. Croatian Medical Journal 2006; 47: 593-600); Exhibit A8, at 3.Mr Sergides The second doctor who gave evidence for the applicant was Mr Sergides. He is a practising neurosurgeon. He prepared a single medico-legal report which was decidedly vague and unpersuasive. He suggested that there was ‘potential injury’ at three levels in 2009 and if the respondent was liable for the L4/L5 damage it was reasonable to relate the L5/S1 injury to the same origin.[25] [25] Exhibit A2, at 4. When he gave his oral evidence Mr Sergides offered a more elaborate explanation of the relationship between the applicant’s earlier symptoms and his 2016 problems. He suggested for the first time that the altered gait (which he had not noted in his original report) was what caused the observed degeneration at L5/S1. He had not proffered such a view previously. He dismissed obesity as a possible cause of the degeneration (which is a view contested in the literature)[26] and proffered the view that the applicant’s pronounced Trendelenburg gait had the same effect as having one leg longer than the other and was relevant to the development of symptoms in 2017 because ‘walking like that is very likely to give you problems with your back’.[27] This analysis involves a significantly different analysis to his original views. [26] Transcript, at 124-5. [27] Transcript, at 126.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons which follow, the Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant has a compensable injury at the L5/S1 level on the right side.THE REVIEWABLE DECISIONS The Tribunal has before it three applications for review. The first (2017/4493) seeks review of a reviewable decision made on 28 July 2017 which rejected a claim for compensation under section 16 of the SRC Act for microdiscectomy surgery performed on the right side of the applicant’s spine at the L5/S1 level on 10 November 2016. As noted above, that decision was made in the context of the applicant having an accepted 2011 injury at the L4/L5 level on the left side of his spine. The second (2017/6915) seeks review of a reviewable decision made on 14 November 2017 rejecting a claim for compensation pursuant to section 16 of the SRC Act in relation to the costs of the anaesthetist who assisted in the microdiscectomy surgery. The third (2019/6495) seeks review of a reviewable decision made on 4 October 2019 rejecting liability under section 14 of the SRC Act to pay compensation in relation to a condition secondary to the accepted L4/L5 injury being an injury to L5/S1 sustained in 2017. In practical terms the challenge to each of the reviewable decisions is an attempt to identify a pathway to the payment of compensation in relation to the surgery performed on 10 November 2016.FACTS Our findings of fact are set out below. Where the findings are controversial, we have referenced the evidence on which they are based. The applicant has a long history of performing heavy manual tasks. In about 1995, the applicant started work with ‘Mquip,’ a forklift company, as a refueller. At some point he was subcontracted by Mquip to BIS Industries Limited (BIS) (at the time known as Brambles) and in 2004 he became a full-time employee of BIS.[1] BIS became a licensee under the SRC Act on 1 October 2008. [1] At the time it was still known as Brambles. When he worked for BIS, the applicant was responsible for refuelling vehicles which ran on liquid fuel and swapping over gas cylinders which powered forklifts. His work involved driving a truck, pulling fuel pump hoses, and carrying and manoeuvring heavy cylinders. Between 2004 and approximately 2008, the applicant’s work included manually lifting up, from the top of a flatbed truck, the large and heavy gas cylinders used to fuel forklifts. The applicant’s estimates of the weight of these cylinders when full was somewhere between 25kg and 45kg. The applicant was lifting cylinders more than 5 times a day and perhaps as much as 12 times per day. Precision on these matters is impossible given the passage of time, but we are satisfied that for a period of about 4 years when the applicant was employed by BIS, he was responsible for lifting and manoeuvring cylinders of at least 25kg more than 5 times a day, 6 days a week. Most of this work was undertaken prior to BIS becoming a licensee under the scheme in October 2008. Around 2009 modifications were made to the truck the applicant drove so that he was no longer required to lift the cylinders off the truck. A hoist was installed to facilitate the lifting and a cage was built which prevented the removal of the cylinders without using the hoist.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Khurana avoided the question of the contribution made by the applicant’s gait altogether.[37][37] Transcript, at 69CONSIDERATION Before dealing with the submissions of the applicant which the Tribunal accepts, it is necessary to deal briefly with the two bases on which he puts his case that the Tribunal has not accepted.First contention It is submitted by the applicant that the ‘in relation to’ test is satisfied because the purpose of the surgery was, as attested to by Dr Day, ‘to get [the applicant’s] gait back to his previous baseline so he could walk around without falling over’.[38] This evidence from Dr Day, the applicant submitted, meant there was ‘a direct correlation with the accepted and not disputed left leg radiculopathy and instability’[39] and the surgery undertaken.[38] Transcript, at 160[39]. Transcript, at 198. In essence this submission is based on the proposition that the 2017 surgery had the purpose of restoring left leg function which had been lost as a result of the 2011 injury and therefore the medical treatment was obtained in relation to the 2011 injury as required by section 16 of the SRC Act. With respect, this involves reading the relevant passage of the transcript without regard to context. The relevant passage is as follows:[40]…you…formed the opinion that he needed some urgent surgery?Well yes, I thought it was urgent because he was having even more trouble trying to walk around and I was concerned that if he did not have urgent treatment he would develop a permanent weakness problem in his right leg as well.And the object of the surgery was to – can you tell me what it was?Similar to what he’d had in his original procedure. This was another microdiscectomy, this time on the right side of the L5 disc to remove a piece of disc and pressing on the nerve.And so the object was to preserve or prevent any permanent right-sided weakness and was that one of the objects? Yes definitely.It was one of the other objects to address the pain he was experiencing in his lumbar spine? Yes.And were there any other objects of the surgery? Well, no, I mean those things on top of trying to get his gait back to his previous baseline, so he could walk around without falling over.[40] Transcript, at 160. Read in full context, it is clear that Dr Day is indicating that in undertaking the surgery he was trying to address the additional deterioration in the applicant’s condition over and above the impact of the 2011 injury and surgery. In particular the impact of the nerve compression at L5/S1 on the functioning of the applicant’s right leg. Accordingly, it is not true to say that the surgery was in relation to the already accepted injury at the L4/L5 level. The surgery involved treating the new symptoms that had evolved because of changes at L5/S1. Consequently, the applicant’s first proposed basis for the Tribunal accepting liability must be rejected.Second contention The applicant also submits that the Tribunal should be satisfied that the accepted 2009 and 2011 injuries include, amongst other things, an injury to the applicant’s L5/S1 disc and facet joint. If disc disease at that level is treated as part of the accepted claim then the cost of surgery is payable under the original claim. We note that in order to accept this submission it is necessary to characterise the applicant’s accepted claim as lumbar disc disease at multiple levels significantly contributed to by his employment rather than as discrete injuries or disease aggravations manifesting as ruptured discs and thickening of the vertebrae at the L3/L4 and L4/L5 levels.