Faulds v Police No. Scciv-02-174

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

FAULDS v POLICE

[2002] SASC 251

Magistrates Appeal

  1. WICKS J               This is an appeal against sentence.

  2. On 15 December 2001 the appellant was charged with common assault on a person other than a family member, contrary to s 39(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935. She was also charged with refusing without reasonable excuse to state to a member of the Police Force her full name and address, as required by s 74A(3)(a) of the Summary Offences Act 1953.

    Background

  3. The background to this matter is that the appellant had been drinking with her boyfriend at Mick O’Shea’s Irish Pub at South Road, Hackham on the evening of 14 December 2001.  During that evening they had an argument and that led her to drink too much so that she became very drunk. 

  4. The appellant and the security officer at the hotel had been friends, their relationship culminating in a sexual encounter one night.  After that incident, the security officer pursued the appellant to become his girlfriend.  She did not wish to pursue a long-term relationship with him.  This offended him and thereafter he treated her rudely by ignoring her when she spoke to him and by giving her “dirty looks” at a distance.  This state of affairs continued over a period of two years or so prior to the incident the subject of these proceedings.

  5. The appellant said that on the night the subject of these proceedings she had not done anything wrong before being removed from the premises.  No-one asked her to leave the premises.  If asked to leave, she would have done so without the embarrassment of a scene.

  6. The first she knew was that she was grasped by her left upper arm by the security officer and dragged violently to her left towards the outside door.  Throughout this incident she was saying :  “just let me get my shoes” because she had been “yanked” out of her shoes.  Outside, the security officer let her go.  She said that on the spur of the moment she punched him in the mouth.  The police were called.

  7. When the police attended the hotel the appellant refused to give her name and address, although subsequently she relented and gave that information claiming that her earlier refusal was a joke. 

  8. On 15 January 2002 the appellant pleaded guilty to both charges.  The learned Magistrate sentenced the appellant to 14 days imprisonment on the assault charge, and recorded a conviction, without further penalty on the charge of refusing to provide her name and address.  He declined to suspend the prison sentence.

  9. The appellant had a previous conviction.  She was convicted on 15 June 2000 of one count of common assault on a person other than a family member and one count of damaging property, for which the appellant was fined a total of $200.

    Grounds of Appeal

  10. There are three grounds of appeal in this matter.  The first is that the learned Magistrate, in circumstances where the appellant faced an immediate period…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Faulds v Police No. Scciv-02-174 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 251
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Faulds v Police No. Scciv-02-174 was a case where the appellant, who was charged with common assault and refusing to provide her name and address, appealed against the sentence imposed by the Magistrate. The appellant had pleaded guilty to the charges and was sentenced to 14 days imprisonment for the assault charge, with a conviction recorded but no penalty for the refusal to provide her name and address. The grounds of appeal included the Magistrate's failure to ensure the appellant appreciated the importance of legal representation, the lack of a referral to the duty solicitor, the absence of a pre-sentence report, inadequate inquiry into the appellant's personal circumstances, and the failure to suspend the sentence.

The court was required to determine whether the Magistrate had failed in his duty to ensure the appellant appreciated the importance of legal representation and other aspects of the sentencing process. The court also needed to decide if the sentence was appropriate given the circumstances of the offence and the appellant's background. The key issue was whether the sentencing process had miscarried due to the lack of a pre-sentence report or adequate inquiry into the appellant's personal circumstances, and whether the sentence was too severe considering the appellant's previous conviction and the nature of the offence.

The court found that the sentencing process had miscarried because the Magistrate failed to obtain a pre-sentence report or to examine the appellant about her personal circumstances. The court also found that the sentence was too severe and did not adequately take into account the appellant's personal circumstances and the fact that she was provoked into committing the assault. The court held that the sentence should be suspended and replaced with a bond for good behaviour. The appeal was allowed, the sentence of 14 days imprisonment was confirmed, but it was suspended upon the appellant entering a bond for $500 to be of good behaviour for a period of one year, subject to supervision by a community corrections officer. The appellant was directed to report to the Department for Correctional Services within two working days of entering into the bond.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 15 December 2001 the appellant was charged with common assault on a person other than a family member, contrary to s 39(1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935. She was also charged with refusing without reasonable excuse to state to a member of the Police Force her full name and address, as required by s 74A(3)(a) of the Summary Offences Act 1953.Background The background to this matter is that the appellant had been drinking with her boyfriend at Mick O’Shea’s Irish Pub at South Road, Hackham on the evening of 14 December 2001. During that evening they had an argument and that led her to drink too much so that she became very drunk. The appellant and the security officer at the hotel had been friends, their relationship culminating in a sexual encounter one night. After that incident, the security officer pursued the appellant to become his girlfriend. She did not wish to pursue a long-term relationship with him. This offended him and thereafter he treated her rudely by ignoring her when she spoke to him and by giving her “dirty looks” at a distance. This state of affairs continued over a period of two years or so prior to the incident the subject of these proceedings. The appellant said that on the night the subject of these proceedings she had not done anything wrong before being removed from the premises. No-one asked her to leave the premises. If asked to leave, she would have done so without the embarrassment of a scene. The first she knew was that she was grasped by her left upper arm by the security officer and dragged violently to her left towards the outside door. Throughout this incident she was saying : “just let me get my shoes” because she had been “yanked” out of her shoes. Outside, the security officer let her go. She said that on the spur of the moment she punched him in the mouth. The police were called. When the police attended the hotel the appellant refused to give her name and address, although subsequently she relented and gave that information claiming that her earlier refusal was a joke. On 15 January 2002 the appellant pleaded guilty to both charges. The learned Magistrate sentenced the appellant to 14 days imprisonment on the assault charge, and recorded a conviction, without further penalty on the charge of refusing to provide her name and address. He declined to suspend the prison sentence. The appellant had a previous conviction. She was convicted on 15 June 2000 of one count of common assault on a person other than a family member and one count of damaging property, for which the appellant was fined a total of $200.Grounds of Appeal There are three grounds of appeal in this matter. The first is that the learned Magistrate, in circumstances where the appellant faced an immediate period of imprisonment:(a)failed to ensure the appellant appreciated the fact and the desirability of legal representation,(b) failed to refer the appellant to the duty solicitor,(c) failed to order a pre-sentence report,(d)failed to inform himself adequately of the personal circumstances of the appellant,(e)failed to ensure that the appellant appreciated the importance of raising matters of mitigation as to the circumstances of the offence.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

WICKS J
In my opinion, the offending which is under consideration in the present case is not of sufficient gravity to require an outright sentence of imprisonment, particularly having regard to the fact that the appellant was provoked into committing the assault. Justice would require there to be a suspension of the sentence in this instance.Conclusion In sentencing, the importance of the appellant’s personal circumstances should be made known to the Court. In the present case, it would appear that those circumstances were not made known to the Magistrate. So far as this Court is concerned, the appellant made known her personal circumstances in an affidavit filed on 6 March 2002. A pre-sentence report could have been obtained to avoid having to sentence the appellant in a vacuum. Alternatively, the learned Magistrate could have asked questions of the appellant as to her physical and mental condition and also as to her personal circumstances and history. In the circumstances, I hold that the sentencing process in this matter has miscarried by a failure to obtain a pre-sentence report or to examine the appellant as to her personal circumstances and by the learned Magistrate’s failure to suspend the sentence in view of the fact the offence of assault charged and the prior conviction for assault were relatively minor offences and that I am entitled to re-sentence the appellant afresh. I propose to deal with the matter now rather than refer it back to the Magistrates Court for further consideration.Orders made For these reasons:(1) I allow the appeal;(2)I confirm the sentence of 14 days imprisonment imposed by the learned Magistrate;(3)The sentence will, however, be suspended upon the entry by the appellant into a bond for $500 to be of good behaviour for a period of one year subject to a condition requiring the appellant to be under the supervision of a community corrections officer for a period of one year;(4)I direct that the appellant report to the Department for Correctional Services, 181 Flinders Street, Adelaide not later than two working days after entering into the bond unless, within that period, she receives a notice from the Director of Chief Executive Officer of the Department to the contrary.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: WICKS J

Full text does not contain this section.