| IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA | ) | ||
| NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY |
| ||
| GENERAL DIVISION | 1 |
| BETWEEN: | D | - ACN 057 389 769 |
First Applicant
ACACIA VIEW PTY LIMITED
ACN 007 274 642 tradino as
FASTWAY COURIERS GEELONG
Second Applicant
ADELAIDE COURIERS PTY LIMITED
ACN 065 962 398
Third Applicant
ASHMORE COURIERS PTY LIMITED
ACN 061 637 223 trading as
FASTWAY COURIERS GOLD COAST
B & J WEATHERLEY PTY LIMITED
ACN 061 701 353 tradina as
| FASTWAY COURIERS SUNSH~NE | COAST |
Fifth Applicant
| D | - | COFFS |
| ACN 066 000 235 trading as FASTWAY COURIERS COFFS HARBOUR |
Sixth ~ ~ ~ l i c a n t
DENBAR ENTERPRISES PTY LIMITED
ACN 060 552 249 trading as
FASTWAY COURIERS NEWCASTLE
Seventh Applicant
DETUMU PTY LIMITED
ACN 003 608 624 trading as
FASTWAY COURIERS TOOWOOMBA
Eighth ~i~licant
FASTWAY COURIERS (OLD) PTY LIMITED
ACN 057 811 211 tradina as
FASTWAY COURIERS BRISB~NE
Ninth Applicant
GOLDCARM PTY LIMITED
ACN 067 573 942 trading as
| FASTWAY COURIERS PORT MACOUARIE | - |
Tenth Applicant
ILLAW
ACN 064 481 974 tradina as
FASTWAY COURIERS WOLLONGONG Eleventh Applicant
MELBOURNE COURIERS PTY LIMITED
ACN 061 255 598 trading as
FASTWAY COURIERS MELBOURNE and
FASTWAY COURIERS BALLARAT
Twelfth Applicant
NATIONAL CAPITAL COURIERS PTY LIMITED
ACN 063 155 939 trading as
FASTWAY COURIERS CANBERRA
Thirteenth Applicant
NSW COURIERS PTY LIMITED
ACN 058 065 080 trading as
FASTWAY COURIERS SYDNEY
Fourteenth Applicant
W & J INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED
ACN 009 496 137 trading as
FASTWAY COURIERS TASMANIA
Fifteenth Applicant
| AND: | AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING CORPORATION |
First Respondent
STEVEN SHARP
Second Respondent
ROS THOMAS
Third Respondent
IAN BOTTCHER
Fourth Respondent
TREVOR DEWHURST
Fifth Respondent
WARREN GRIGGS
Sixth Respondent
MARK HANNS
Seventh Respondent
BOB SHAKESPEARE
Eighth Respondent
SAM TAYLOR
Ninth Respondent
HELEN WELLINGS
Tenth Respondent
| BEFORE: | GUMMOW | J. |
| PLACE : | SYDNEY |
| DATE : | 27 MARCH 1995 |
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT (EX TEMPORE)
HIS HONOUR: The first respondent, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation ("the Corporation") owes its present
- 3 -
constitution to the provisions of Part I1 of the Australian Broadcastina Corporation Act 1983. Section 25 provides, subject to a qualification not presently material, that the Corporation does not have the power to accept any payment or other consideration for the broadcasting or televising of any announcement, programme or other matter. Section 31 states that "the Corporation shall not broadcast or televise advertisements". This is subject to the qualification in sub- s. 31 (2) that the Corporation may, in certain circumstances, broadcast or televise announcements relating to proposed activities of the Corporation.
The second, third and tenth respondents are persons associated with the production of a programme scheduled to be televised by the Corporation on Tuesday 28 March 1995, entitled "The Investigators". This is one of a series of programmes. The particular controversy concerns a segment of the programme which, it is suggested, would be about six minutes in length. This segment focuses upon the activities of the Fastway Couriers Group in a way which has brought complaint. This is an application for a continuation of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fastway Couriers Aust Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Corp... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1995] FCA 512
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court examined the principles for granting interlocutory injunctions in defamation cases, concluding that the applicants had not established a sufficiently clear case to warrant such relief. The Court also considered the protection provided by Section 65A of the TP Act, which exempts certain publications by prescribed information providers from contraventions of Section 52 (misleading or deceptive conduct). The Court found that the telecast by the ABC qualified as a "prescribed publication" and that the exemption applied in this case.
Regarding the applicants' claim under the TP Act, the Court considered whether the telecast involved the supply or possible supply of "relevant goods or services." The Court concluded that the telecast was merely the provision of information and did not constitute the supply of goods or services. The Court also found insufficient evidence to support a claim under Section 75B of the TP Act, which pertains to aiding and abetting contraventions.
Ultimately, the Court decided not to grant the proposed interlocutory relief, allowing the existing injunction to expire. The Court emphasized the importance of balancing the interests of the parties and the need for a clear case before granting such relief. The Court also noted the potential for the facts to change at trial and the applicants' opportunity to present their case fully at that stage.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.