Farrell v Chief Executive, Department of Lands

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[1995] QLC 101

 
  LAND COURT

BRISBANE

6 SEPTEMBER 1995

In the matter of an appeal against a valuation
Valuation of Land Act 1944
  Valuation Roll No.: 11815/00200
  Local Government:           Moreton (AV95-35)

James A Farrell
  v.
  Chief Executive, Department of Lands

(Hearing at Ipswich)

D E C I S I O N

In this matter the landholder appealed against the value of $46,000 placed on the subject land by the Chief Executive as at 30 June 1993 pursuant to the provisions of the Valuation of Land Act 1944. The appellant contends for a valuation of $35,000.
           The subject land comprises an area of 27.52 hectares situated at Cumner Road, Ripley, 14 kilometres south-east of the Ipswich Post Office.  Access is via Ripley Road into Barrams Road and then into Cumner Road.  Whilst Ripley Road is a two-lane bitumen roadway, Barrams Road is formed gravel, and Cumner Road is formed earth with some gravel.  Telephone is the only service available.  The land is zoned "Rural" under the Moreton Shire Council Town Planning Scheme which applied at the relevant date.  The property has a high-set timber dwelling on it which is occupied by the appellant, and has boundary fencing and fencing around the curtilage of the dwelling. 
           James Anthony Farrell gave evidence in support of his appeal, whilst Brian Joseph McDonald, registered valuer in the employ of the Department of Lands, gave evidence on behalf of the Chief Executive.
           Mr McDonald described the subject land as being an easy to moderate sandstone ridge with ironbark and spotted gum running down to easy sloping creek frontage.  Whilst Mr Farrell did not disagree with this description, his choice of words were somewhat more colourful, that is "mongrel country".  He said that the topsoil on the land, such as it was, would not sustain a garden and that the next strata in the soil was a hard sandstone material.  The country has about a 50% cover of blady grass, has no natural permanent water though a creek depression running through the land has holes in it which do hold water just after rain.  There is a 3 metre deep well on the subject land which is now dry but which has held water which Mr Farrell has pumped out by way of a solar-driven pump.  He has constructed a small dam on the property for a cost of about $600 and this still holds water.
The appellant's major contention is that the subject land ought to be treated as "farming" land pursuant to s.17 of the Valuation of Land Act. Section 17(1) of the Act provides:

"In making a valuation of the unimproved value of land exclusively used for purposes of a single dwelling house or for purposes of farming, any enhancement in that value for that the land has been subdivided by survey or has a potential use for industrial, subdivisional or any other purposes shall be disregarded irrespective of whether or not, in case of potential use as aforesaid, that potential use is lawful…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Farrell v Chief Executive, Department of Lands and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] QLC 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land Court of Brisbane, James A Farrell appealed against the Chief Executive, Department of Lands, regarding the valuation of land at Cumner Road, Ripley. The Chief Executive had assessed the land's value at $46,000 as of 30 June 1993, under the Valuation of Land Act 1944, while Farrell argued for a valuation of $35,000. The property, comprising 27.52 hectares, is zoned "Rural" and includes a high-set timber dwelling occupied by Farrell. Farrell claimed that the land should be treated as "farming" land under s.17 of the Valuation of Land Act, arguing that the lease income from grazing activities qualified as a business. However, the court found that the activities on the land did not constitute a business with a significant and substantial commercial purpose, and the dominant use of the land remained residential.

The court also considered Farrell's argument that his expenditure on constructing a road for vehicular access should be factored into the land's valuation. The court rejected this, citing the principle that unimproved value excludes all improvements made on the subject land, and that the cost of such improvements would be reflected in the purchase price. The court accepted the expert evidence provided by the Chief Executive's valuer, Brian Joseph McDonald, who valued the land as a "large rural homesite" and provided evidence of comparable sales in the area to support the valuation of $46,000.

Ultimately, the court dismissed Farrell's appeal and affirmed the Chief Executive's valuation of the subject land at $46,000.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established