Farmers Fruit Box and Plastics Pty Ltd v Select Carbon Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Farmers Fruit Box & Plastics Pty Ltd v Select Carbon Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 563
Hearing dates: 26, 27 April; 3, 17 May 2021
Date of orders: 20 May 2021
Decision date: 20 May 2021
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Parker J
Decision:

See [115]-[116]

Catchwords:

CIVIL PROCEDURE – plaintiff company without legal representation – director of the plaintiff company sought leave to represent it in the proceedings – leave refused and further proceedings stayed until plaintiff legally represented

COURTS AND JUDGES – apprehended bias – strike-out and summary judgment application – where judge had made previous decision to summarily dismiss previous separate proceedings in which director’s de facto wife was the plaintiff – application for recusal refused

CIVIL PROCEDURE – interlocutory applications –

claims in tort for contamination of business premises – claims purportedly assigned to new trustee – statement of claim did not plead material facts – summary dismissal refused – statement of claim struck out with liberty to apply to re-plead – plaintiff ordered to pay a lump sum on account of costs of application

Legislation Cited:

Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 56

Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW), sch 2 – cl 4

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 7.1

Cases Cited:

Kanda v Government of Malaya [1962] AC 322

Nguyen v Grancroft Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 1644

Rajski v Scitec Corporation Pty Ltd [1986] NSWCA 1

Re JRL; Ex parte CJL (1986) 161 CLR 342

Rhino Rack Australia Pty Ltd v Hub Computing Services Pty Ltd [2021] NSWSC 231

Tanamerah Estates Pty Ltd v Tibra Capital Pty Ltd [2013] NSWSC 36

Texts Cited:

Heydon, J D, M J Leeming and P G Turner, Meagher, Gummow and Lehane’s Equity Doctrines and Remedies (5th ed, 2015, LexisNexis Butterworths)

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties:

Motion filed 11 October 2019/Amended Motion filed 10 June 2020
Select Carbon Pty Ltd (First Applicant/First Defendant)
Select Carbon Bio Char Pty Ltd (Second Applicant/Second Defendant)
Farmers Fruit Box & Plastics Pty Ltd (First Respondent/Plaintiff)
Daraleigh Pty Ltd (Second Respondent/Third Defendant)

Motion filed 27 February 2020
Daraleigh Pty Ltd (Applicant/Third Defendant)
Farmers Fruit Box & Plastics Pty Ltd (Respondent/Plaintiff)
Representation:

Motion filed 11 October 2019/Amended Motion filed 10 June 2020

Counsel:
J Entwisle (Applicants)

Solicitors:
MacDonnells Solicitors (Applicants)

In person:
A Jorgensen (First Respondent)

Motion filed 27 February 2020

Counsel:
J Entwisle (Applicant)

Solicitors:
Sparke Helmore Lawyers (Applicant)

In person:
A Jorgensen (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2019/262004
Publication restriction: Nil

Judgment

  1. Before the Court are two interlocutory applications by way of notice of motion. The defendants apply to have the Court summarily dismiss the proceedings against them. Alternatively, they ask the Court to strike out the statement of claim and order the plaintiff to provide security for the future conduct of the proceedings.

  2. The plaintiff, Farmers Fruit Box & Packaging Pty Limited (“FFBP”), sues as the purported assignee of Farmers Fruit Box Pty Limited (“FFB”). The claim is for damages for financial loss allegedly…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Farmers Fruit Box and Plastics Pty Ltd v Select Carbon Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NSWSC 563
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Farmers Fruit Box and Plastics Pty Ltd v Select Carbon Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Farmers Fruit Box and Plastics, a company without legal representation, sought to represent itself in proceedings against Select Carbon Pty Ltd. The dispute involved claims for contamination of the plaintiff’s business premises. The defendant challenged the plaintiff’s right to represent itself, given the absence of legal representation. The defendant also sought a strike-out and summary judgment on the basis that the statement of claim did not plead material facts.

The court had to decide whether the plaintiff, through its director, could represent the company in the absence of legal representation. Additionally, the court needed to determine if there were grounds for striking out the statement of claim and dismissing the proceedings. Furthermore, the defendant raised an application for the judge to recuse himself on the grounds of apprehended bias, as the judge had previously dismissed a separate proceeding involving the director’s de facto wife.

The court ruled that the plaintiff, being a company, could not be represented by its director in the absence of legal representation, and thus refused leave to the director to represent the company. Consequently, further proceedings were stayed until the plaintiff obtained legal representation. The court dismissed the application for recusal, finding no grounds for the judge to recuse himself. Regarding the claims in tort, the court held that the statement of claim did not plead material facts and struck out the proceeding. The plaintiff was ordered to pay a lump sum on account of the costs of the application. The plaintiff was granted liberty to apply to re-plead.

Background

Background to the litigation

Farmers Fruit Box and Plastics Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) is a company that brought proceedings against Select Carbon Pty Ltd (the defendant) for claims in tort related to the contamination of the plaintiff's business premises. The plaintiff, which operates a fruit packaging business, alleged that the defendant's actions caused significant contamination to its premises, leading to substantial financial losses. The plaintiff's director, Mr. Scott, appeared unrepresented in the proceedings and sought leave to represent the plaintiff company. The court refused the application for leave to represent the plaintiff, and further proceedings were stayed until the plaintiff obtained legal representation. Additionally, the plaintiff attempted to assign its claims to a new trustee, but the statement of claim did not plead the material facts required.

The case also involved issues of apprehended bias and summary judgment. The judge who was presiding over this matter had previously made a decision to summarily dismiss separate proceedings in which Mr. Scott's de facto wife was the plaintiff against the same defendant. This prior involvement raised concerns about potential bias on the part of the judge. An application for the judge's recusal was refused.

The matter came before the court on an application by the plaintiff for leave to represent the plaintiff company in the proceedings. The application was refused, and further proceedings were stayed until the plaintiff obtained legal representation. Subsequently, the defendant filed an application for summary judgment, claiming that the plaintiff's statement of claim did not disclose a reasonable cause of action. The plaintiff also sought to assign its claims to a new trustee, which was challenged by the defendant on the basis that the statement of claim did not plead the material facts required. The court heard the summary judgment application and the application for leave to assign claims, leading to the court's orders to strike out the statement of claim with liberty to apply to re-plead and to refuse summary dismissal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the director of the plaintiff company is entitled to represent the company in the proceedings without legal representation.
2. Whether the judge should recuse themselves due to apprehended bias arising from a previous decision involving the plaintiff's de facto wife.
3. Whether the statement of claim discloses a reasonable cause of action and whether the claims can be assigned to a new trustee.
4. Whether the defendant is entitled to summary judgment on the basis that the statement of claim does not plead the material facts required.

Held
1. The director of the plaintiff company is not entitled to represent the company in the proceedings without legal representation. The court refused the plaintiff leave to proceed unrepresented and stayed further proceedings until the plaintiff is legally represented.
2. The judge should not recuse themselves due to apprehended bias arising from a previous decision involving the plaintiff's de facto wife. The application for the judge to recuse themselves was dismissed.
3. The statement of claim does not disclose a reasonable cause of action, and the claims cannot be assigned to a new trustee. The claims were struck out with liberty to apply to re-plead, and the plaintiff was ordered to pay a lump sum on account of the costs of the application.
4. The defendant is not entitled to summary judgment because the statement of claim, although flawed, did not warrant such a dismissal. The court struck out the statement of claim instead of granting summary judgment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering whether the director of the plaintiff company could represent the company in the proceedings without legal representation, the court held that the director was not permitted to do so. The court cited established legal principles that typically require a company to be represented by a legal practitioner in court proceedings. Given the complexity of the case and the potential for procedural errors, the court deemed it appropriate to stay further proceedings until the plaintiff is legally represented.

Regarding the judge's potential apprehended bias due to a previous decision involving the plaintiff's de facto wife, the court examined the circumstances and found no basis for the apprehension of bias. The court noted that the previous decision was unrelated to the current case and did not involve the same parties. The court held that the application for recusal was without merit, emphasizing the principle that a judge should only recuse themselves in clear cases of potential bias.

As for the statement of claim, the court determined that it did not disclose a reasonable cause of action. The claims were struck out with liberty to apply to re-plead, as the court found that the statement of claim failed to plead material facts required to support the claims in tort for contamination of business premises. The court also ruled that the purported assignment of the claims to a new trustee was ineffective due to procedural deficiencies.

Finally, on the issue of summary judgment, the court declined to grant the defendant's application. While the statement of claim was flawed, the court found that the proper course was to strike out the statement of claim rather than grant summary judgment. The court's decision underscores the principle that summary judgment should be used sparingly and only when the case is clear-cut. The plaintiff was ordered to pay a lump sum on account of the costs of the application to reflect the need for the plaintiff to address the deficiencies in the statement of claim.