Farman and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

Farman and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 2880 (2 September 2022)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No: 2020/5491
National Disability Insurance Scheme Division )

Re: Elise Farman
Applicant

And: National Disability Insurance Agency
Respondent

TRIBUNAL:     Senior Member K. Parker

DATE OF CORRIGENDUM: 6 September 2022

PLACE:             Melbourne

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to correct a typographic error in the Reasons for Decision, by replacing the reference to “$1,500” appearing in paragraph [6], with a reference to “$1,544”.

............................[SGD].......................................

Senior Member

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2020/5491

Re:Elise Farman

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Senior Member K. Parker

Date:2 September 2022

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and remits this matter to the National Disability Insurance Agency with a direction that it approves a new statement of participant supports for the Applicant, identical to her current statement of participant supports, but which replaces the current approved non-specific funding for assistive technology (in the sum of $1,544, or as updated), with the following supports:

(a)additional funding required to supplement or update the Applicant’s current (NDIS-funded) visual and vibrating alerting system (that is, the Current Bellman Ring System as defined in paragraph [20] below), so that she ends up with a complete a Bellman Visit System as identified by Mr Willis from Word of Mouth Technology in paragraph [24] below with additional wall mounting accessories; and

(b)       additional funding of $2,409 for the requested Security Camera Support.

The Tribunal grants liberty to either party to apply if any issue arises in respect of quantifying the funding for the provision of the additional support referred to in paragraph (a) above.

......................[sgd] ..................................................

Senior Member K. Parker

Catchwords – NATIONAL DISABILTY INSURANCE SCHEME – review of decision to approve statement of participant supports – Applicant with hearing impairment requested additional funding for hardwired visual and vibrating alerting system (Visualert System) and motion-activated security camera system – conflict of issue – lead occupational therapist (OT) married to sole shareholder of the sole Australian distributor of the recommended specific visual and vibrating alerting product – evidence of treating OT found not to be impartial – evidence of independent OT engaged by NDIA preferred – Tribunal not satisfied hardwired Visualert System met “value for money” criterion and should not be included in participant’s statement of participant supports – Tribunal satisfied additional funding to allow Applicant to enhance and update her current visual and vibrating alerting system meets “reasonable and necessary supports” criteria – Tribunal satisfied motion-activated security camera system meets “reasonable and necessary supports” criteria and should be included in participant’s statement of supports – decision under review set aside and remitted with directions

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Cases

McGarrigle v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Farman and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2880
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms Farman for review of a National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) decision regarding her NDIS plan. Ms Farman sought additional funding for a hardwired visual and vibrating alerting system (Visualert System) and a motion-activated security camera system. The NDIA had approved her NDIS plan but disputed the inclusion of these specific supports.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the proposed Visualert System and the Security Camera System met the criteria of "reasonable and necessary supports" as defined by section 34(1) of the *National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013* (Cth). A related issue was whether the Visualert System represented "value for money," considering its cost relative to its benefits and alternative options. The Tribunal also considered whether funding should be provided for an alternative alerting system, the Bellman Visit System, as a substitute for the Visualert System.

The Tribunal considered evidence from both parties, including reports from occupational therapists. It noted that the evidence from the treating occupational therapist was found not to be impartial due to a conflict of interest, as the therapist was married to the sole shareholder of the distributor of the specific Visualert product. Consequently, the Tribunal preferred the evidence of an independent occupational therapist engaged by the NDIA. The Tribunal was not satisfied that the hardwired Visualert System met the "value for money" criterion. However, it found that additional funding to enhance Ms Farman's existing visual and vibrating alerting system would meet the "reasonable and necessary supports" criteria. The Tribunal also concluded that the motion-activated security camera system met the "reasonable and necessary supports" criteria.

The Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision under review and remitted the matter with directions. These directions included approving funding for enhancements to Ms Farman's current alerting system and for the motion-activated security camera system, while not approving the specific Visualert System as proposed due to concerns about value for money.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties lodged a Statement of Agreed Facts in this application (Statement of Agreed Facts), and a joint Hearing Tender Bundle (HTB) comprising 747 pages. Section 2 of the HTB comprises the T-Documents which includes the reports by Full Life Occupational Therapy referred to above.[33][33] Refer Section 2 of the joint Hearing Tender Bundle lodged with the Tribunal. At the commencement of the hearing, the parties confirmed that the other three Full Life Occupational Therapy reports contained within Section 2 of the joint Hearing Tender Bundle, entitled “Visual Communication Assistive Technology Report” dated 17 January 2020, “Data Recommendation” dated 16 June 2020; and “Data Recommendation” (undated); were no longer relevant and that Ms Farman no longer relied upon them in this application. Refer Transcript Day 1 at P-5. Section 3 of the HTB comprises the Applicant’s documentary evidence produced to the Tribunal before the hearing, including:(a)an unsigned, untitled, and undated typed statement (Ms Farman’s First Response), comprising (among other things):[34][34] Refer HTB at pages 470 to 487.(i)a description of Ms Farman’s lived experience;(ii)a set of answers in response to questions asked of Ms Farman by the NDIA about her current visual alerting systems and alternative security, safety and communication measures used in her home; and (iii)whether she has trialled alternative systems;(iv)a summary of “comparison solutions”; (v)a summary of “needs and solutions” including her “sensory input needs”;(vi)a summary of the “minimum or standard level of support” for Ms Farman;(vii)information about “alternative lower cost options considered”; and (viii)further information about the Visualert system and the Security Camera System.(b)a further unsigned typed statement titled “Responses to Respondent’s Statement of Issues” dated 30 January 2021 (Ms Farman’s Second Response), comprising further responses to questions and a request for more information by the NDIA about:[35][35] Refer HTB at pages 488 to 495.(i) what steps Ms Farman had taken to improve the Wi-Fi connectivity in her home; (ii) other issues arising in relation to the use of wireless CCTV systems and lower cost notification devices that rely on Wi-Fi connection;(iii) the devices currently available and/or being used in Ms Farman’s home;(iv) Ms Farman’s concerns about privacy issues when using certain devices;(v) whether the notification settings of the trialled devices could be changed to improve notification consistency;(vi) whether Ms Farman had undertaken any measures to address perceived shortcomings of her current notification system being used by her, in terms of the visibility of the Bellman flash receiver;(vii)the radiofrequency difficulties experienced when using the Bellman System and where in her house she encountered such difficulties;(viii) why Ms Farman had not installed other security measures within her home, such as deadbolt locks or security grating;(ix) (to support) the assertion that Ms Farman’s family home was in an area that had a high rate of home burglaries and break-ins;(x) whether the Bellman device was currently being used by Ms Farman and which alarm systems were connected to this device; and(c)safety devices purchased by Ms Farman on 26 November 2020,[36] including their purpose and whether that purpose had been achieved;(d)an undated typed statement, which is signed by Ms Farman, (Ms Farman’s Statement) comprising 17 “answers” provided by Ms Farman to questions by the NDIA included in an Annexure to the NDIA’s Statement of Issues dated 26 February 2021;[37](e)the “Service Agreement” (for the provision of “therapeutic support”)[38] between Ms Farman and a “service provider”, Louise Dreyer OT Pty Ltd,[39] trading as “Full Life Occupational Therapy”, which on the face of it appears to have been executed by “Melinda Vernon: Full Life Occupational Therapy” on 8 January 2020 (OT Service Agreement).[40] This OT Service Agreement estimates that the “service component of engagement” will include:[41] “Initial 2-3 hours; Travel 2 hours; Case coordination 1-2 hours; HM report 5-6; CCTV report 2-3 hours; and VC report 2 hours”. At the hearing, Ms Dreyer said she had a one-page document containing Ms Farman’s signature in execution of the OT Service Agreement. It was subsequently produced by Ms Dreyer. It was not dated by Ms Farman and was not produced at any earlier stage to the Tribunal. Ms Farman confirmed at the hearing she had signed this on 11 April 2020;[42] (f)a Full Life Occupational Therapy, “Consent to Collect and Share Your Information” form signed by Ms Farman on 3 September 2020;[43](g)statement issued by “TP Records” of expenditure of funding in Ms Farman’s NDIS plan commencing on 16 April 2020, which includes $2,273.52 spent on services provided by “Full Life OT” from 24 August 2020 to 10 January 2021;[44] and(h)a colour photograph of Ms Farman’s bathroom in her family home.[45][36] Refer HTB at page 504 under the heading ‘Assistive technology’.[37] Refer HTB at page 496.[38] Ibid at page 501.[39] The heading to this agreement above the preamble refers to the Service Provider being Louise Dreyer Pty Ltd, but in the body of the agreement refers to the Service Provider being Louise Dreyer OT Pty Ltd. [40] Refer HTB at page 497 to 501.[41] Ibid at page 501.[42] Refer Transcript Day 2 at P-152.[43] Refer HTB at page 502.[44] Ibid at page 503.[45] Ibid at page 504.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The NDIA contends that Mr Farman’s evidence about the Security Camera System does not establish that this is a “reasonable and necessary support”.[32][32] Refer NDIA’s Closing Submissions at paragraph [21].EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS The NDIA lodged a set of documents with the Tribunal in accordance with its obligations under s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (T-Documents). The parties lodged a Statement of Agreed Facts in this application (Statement of Agreed Facts), and a joint Hearing Tender Bundle (HTB) comprising 747 pages. Section 2 of the HTB comprises the T-Documents which includes the reports by Full Life Occupational Therapy referred to above.[33][33] Refer Section 2 of the joint Hearing Tender Bundle lodged with the Tribunal. At the commencement of the hearing, the parties confirmed that the other three Full Life Occupational Therapy reports contained within Section 2 of the joint Hearing Tender Bundle, entitled “Visual Communication Assistive Technology Report” dated 17 January 2020, “Data Recommendation” dated 16 June 2020; and “Data Recommendation” (undated); were no longer relevant and that Ms Farman no longer relied upon them in this application. Refer Transcript Day 1 at P-5. Section 3 of the HTB comprises the Applicant’s documentary evidence produced to the Tribunal before the hearing, including:(a)an unsigned, untitled, and undated typed statement (Ms Farman’s First Response), comprising (among other things):[34][34] Refer HTB at pages 470 to 487.(i)a description of Ms Farman’s lived experience;(ii)a set of answers in response to questions asked of Ms Farman by the NDIA about her current visual alerting systems and alternative security, safety and communication measures used in her home; and (iii)whether she has trialled alternative systems;(iv)a summary of “comparison solutions”; (v)a summary of “needs and solutions” including her “sensory input needs”;(vi)a summary of the “minimum or standard level of support” for Ms Farman;(vii)information about “alternative lower cost options considered”; and (viii)further information about the Visualert system and the Security Camera System.(b)a further unsigned typed statement titled “Responses to Respondent’s Statement of Issues” dated 30 January 2021 (Ms Farman’s Second Response), comprising further responses to questions and a request for more information by the NDIA about:[35][35] Refer HTB at pages 488 to 495.(i) what steps Ms Farman had taken to improve the Wi-Fi connectivity in her home; (ii) other issues arising in relation to the use of wireless CCTV systems and lower cost notification devices that rely on Wi-Fi connection;(iii) the devices currently available and/or being used in Ms Farman’s home;(iv) Ms Farman’s concerns about privacy issues when using certain devices;(v) whether the notification settings of the trialled devices could be changed to improve notification consistency;(vi) whether Ms Farman had undertaken any measures to address perceived shortcomings of her current notification system being used by her, in terms of the visibility of the Bellman flash receiver;(vii)the radiofrequency difficulties experienced when using the Bellman System and where in her house she encountered such difficulties;(viii) why Ms Farman had not installed other security measures within her home, such as deadbolt locks or security grating;(ix) (to support) the assertion that Ms Farman’s family home was in an area that had a high rate of home burglaries and break-ins;(x) whether the Bellman device was currently being used by Ms Farman and which alarm systems were connected to this device; and(c)safety devices purchased by Ms Farman on 26 November 2020,[36] including their purpose and whether that purpose had been achieved;(d)an undated typed statement, which is signed by Ms Farman, (Ms Farman’s Statement) comprising 17 “answers” provided by Ms Farman to questions by the NDIA included in an Annexure to the NDIA’s Statement of Issues dated 26 February 2021;[37](e)the “Service Agreement” (for the provision of “therapeutic support”)[38] between Ms Farman and a “service provider”, Louise Dreyer OT Pty Ltd,[39] trading as “Full Life Occupational Therapy”, which on the face of it appears to have been executed by “Melinda Vernon: Full Life Occupational Therapy” on 8 January 2020 (OT Service Agreement).[40] This OT Service Agreement estimates that the “service component of engagement” will include:[41] “Initial 2-3 hours; Travel 2 hours; Case coordination 1-2 hours; HM report 5-6; CCTV report 2-3 hours; and VC report 2 hours”. At the hearing, Ms Dreyer said she had a one-page document containing Ms Farman’s signature in execution of the OT Service Agreement. It was subsequently produced by Ms Dreyer. It was not dated by Ms Farman and was not produced at any earlier stage to the Tribunal. Ms Farman confirmed at the hearing she had signed this on 11 April 2020;[42] (f)a Full Life Occupational Therapy, “Consent to Collect and Share Your Information” form signed by Ms Farman on 3 September 2020;[43](g)statement issued by “TP Records” of expenditure of funding in Ms Farman’s NDIS plan commencing on 16 April 2020, which includes $2,273.52 spent on services provided by “Full Life OT” from 24 August 2020 to 10 January 2021;[44] and(h)a colour photograph of Ms Farman’s bathroom in her family home.[45][36] Refer HTB at page 504 under the heading ‘Assistive technology’.[37] Refer HTB at page 496.[38] Ibid at page 501.[39] The heading to this agreement above the preamble refers to the Service Provider being Louise Dreyer Pty Ltd, but in the body of the agreement refers to the Service Provider being Louise Dreyer OT Pty Ltd. [40] Refer HTB at page 497 to 501.[41] Ibid at page 501.[42] Refer Transcript Day 2 at P-152.[43] Refer HTB at page 502.[44] Ibid at page 503.[45] Ibid at page 504.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Farman seeks review[11] of an internal review decision made by a “reviewer” of the NDIA under s 100 of the NDIS Act (Decision Under Review), affirming an earlier decision by a different delegate of the NDIA on 16 April 2020 under s 33(2) of the NDIS Act,[12] to approve a statement of participant supports forming part of Ms Farman’s NDIS plan. [11] Refer HTB at pages 33 to 52 is Ms Farman’s AAT Application for Review.[12] Refer T-Documents at T10. In Ms Farman’s NDIS plan, which commenced on 16 April 2020, she had access to total funding of $21,784.71 over a notional plan period of 12 months, comprising:[13] (a)core supports - $13,333.50;(b)capacity building supports for:(i)improved life choices - $1,454.89;(i)improved daily living including assessment of assistive technology and home modification needs, allied therapy assessments and support - $5,452.32; and(c)capital building supports – assistive technology - $1,544.[13] Refer HTB at pages 367 to 377. By the time of the substantive hearing of her application, Ms Farman requested funding under the NDIS, for the provision of the following two supports:(a)Visualert Support – purchase and installation of a specific hard-wired visual and vibrating alerting system, namely, the Visualert System. This system will provide interconnection between the smoke/fire alarm, front doorbell, and baby cry monitor, used in Ms Farman’s home, and the notification receivers including the following:(i)six visual light outlets (colour-coded to match the different types of alarms) to be built into the interior and exterior walls (at a high level near the ceiling) in different locations of Ms Farman’s home (one external and five internal);(ii)vibrating bed shakers; and(iii)a mobile pager to be carried on Ms Farman’s person.The Visualert System includes a back-up lithium battery and a control box to be installed near Ms Farman’s switchboard. The quoted fee for the Visualert System is $11,935.38;[14] and(b)Security Camera Support – purchase and installation of a closed-circuit television security camera system (Security Camera System), inclusive of:(i)motion light sensors using Pyroelectric Infrared Sensors (PIR) and Thermal Detect Technology;(ii)digital video recorder;(iii)three weatherproof cameras (expandable to eight cameras) - two placed in the front and one placed in the rear of the home; and(iv)“Smart” viewing and notification.[15] The quoted fee for the Security Camera System is $2,409.[16][14] Refer Statement of Agreed Facts at paragraph [9b] and HTB at pages 201 and 202.[15] Refer Statement of Agree Facts at paragraph [9c].[16] Refer HTB at page 149 – Quotation from Beal Electrical dated 28 August 2020. At the commencement of the substantive hearing, Ms Farman’s disability advocate, Ms J. Little (formerly Ms J. Girvan), Children of Deaf Adults Inc (CODA), explained to the Tribunal that Ms Farman was seeking the above supports for the follow reasons:[17]…regarding her safety, regarding fire, security, and general wellbeing as a disabled person in her home. She is seeking to feel safe and secure, regardless of what room she is in, and is not limited to carrying any physical devices with her 24/7. She has three young children and a husband who is often away for work, due to their location.Ms Farman is also seeking that the Tribunal understand that it is reasonable and necessary and is value for money to have the NDIS fund these two assistive technologies for her…[17] Refer Transcript Day 1 on P-6.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The key questions arising in this application stem from a disagreement between the parties as to whether the Visualert Support and the Security Camera Support meet the “reasonable and necessary supports” criteria under s 34(1) of the NDIS Act and should be funded under the NDIS. A further question arises as to whether funding should be approved to allow Ms Farman to purchase and install the Bellman Visit System (minus the cost of any components Ms Farman already has in her possession to complete this system), as an alternative to the Visualert System. Determination of those questions will inform the outcome of the Tribunal’s review as referred to in paragraph [34].CONSIDERATION The NDIS was established under the NDIS Act and pursues the objectives set out in s 3. Section 4 establishes general principles guiding actions to be taken under the NDIS Act, which extends to the Tribunal when making a decision upon review following an application made to it under s 103 of the NDIS Act. The Tribunal acknowledges that “choice and control” (of and by the participant) is one principle that it must have regard to when making this decision. Section 33(5) of the NDIS Act requires that the CEO (or their delegate), in deciding whether to approve the SOPS under s 33(2), must have regard to a number of factors including the participant’s statement of goals and aspirations, relevant assessments conducted in relation to the participant, and as mentioned above, be satisfied the supports are “reasonable and necessary”. Section 34(1) of the NDIS Act requires six mandatory criteria be met before a support is considered “reasonable and necessary”. Section 34(2) provides that the NDIS rules may prescribe methods or criteria to be applied or matters to which the decision maker is to have regard, in deciding whether they are satisfied that the criteria under s 34(1) have been met in respect of a requested support. Such rules were issued on 18 June 2013, specifically, the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Support Rules). The Tribunal notes the observations of Mortimer J in McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308 (McGarrigle) at [43] as follows:The [Support Rules] are an important element of the legislative scheme, introducing the ability to modify the operation of ss 33 and 34 by, for example, excluding certain kinds of supports from inclusion in participant plans. It is through the Rules that the executive is able to implement … some policy decision-making about the nature and extent of supports to be provided or funded under the NDIS. Visualert Support - Section 34(1)(c) “value for money” A key focus of the submissions made by the parties in this application is whether the requested Visualert Support satisfied the “value for money” mandatory criterion under s 34(1)(c) of the NDIS Act in deciding whether it is a “reasonable and necessary support”. Section 34(1)(c) requires the Tribunal to be satisfied that a support represents value for money; in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative supports.