Fanma Pty Ltd v Ryan Kay

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Fanma Pty Ltd v Ryan Kay [2023] NSWSC 419
Hearing dates: 20 April 2023
Date of orders: 20 April 2023
Decision date: 20 April 2023
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: Darke J
Decision:

Plaintiff ordered to provide further security for the second defendant’s costs in the sum of $210,000.

Catchwords:

COSTS – security for costs – impecunious corporate plaintiff – application for further security by the second defendant – whether there has been a material change in circumstances since the first application for security for costs – whether the delay in bringing the application for further security for costs warrants its refusal – consideration of the quantum of the security sought – plaintiff ordered to provide further security

Legislation Cited:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 1335

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.21

Cases Cited:

Fanma Pty Limited (formerly Playup Australia Pty Ltd) v Kay [2020] NSWSC 1823

Liberty Grove (Concord) Pty Limited v Mirvac Projects Pty Limited [2008] NSWSC 48

Misthold Pty Ltd v NSW Historical Sites and Railway Heritage Company Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 42

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties: Fanma Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Ryan Kay (First Defendant)
Alexander Kay (Second Defendant/Cross-Claimant)
Playup Australia Pty Ltd (First Cross-Defendant)
Daniel Simic (Second Cross-Defendant)
Richard Sapsford trading as 156 (Third Cross-Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr E A Walker (Plaintiff)
Mr N Kabilafkas (Second Defendant/Cross-Claimant)

Solicitors:
Mills Oakley (Plaintiff/Second and Third Cross-Defendants)
Price & Company (First Defendant)
Corrs Chambers Westgarth (Second Defendant/Cross-Claimant)
File Number(s): 2018/00319830
Publication restriction: None

Judgment – ex tempore (revised)

  1. In these proceedings, the plaintiff sued two defendants, Mr Ryan Kay and Mr Alexander Kay, in relation to a share sale and purchase agreement or agreements executed on 23 March 2018 for the sale to the plaintiff of certain shares in two companies involved in the internet gaming industry. As a result of the bankruptcy of the first defendant, the matter is now proceeding only against the second defendant, Mr Alexander Kay.

  2. By a Notice of Motion filed on 20 February 2023, the second defendant is seeking security for costs against the plaintiff pursuant to Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (“UCPR”) r 42.21 or, alternatively, s 1335 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The second defendant relies upon the affidavits of his solicitor, Mr Samuel Delaney, of 20 February 2023 and 6 April 2023. The motion is opposed by the plaintiff who relies upon the affidavit of its solicitor, Mr Maurice Lynch, of 17 March 2023. The Court has heard submissions in court this morning in addition to the written submissions of counsel for each of the parties.

  3. This is not the first application made by the second defendant for security for costs. An earlier application was determined by Stevenson J on 15 December 2020. His Honour determined that security for costs in the amount of $25,000 be provided by the plaintiff in respect of the second defendant's costs (see Fanma Pty Limited (formerly Playup Australia Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fanma Pty Ltd v Ryan Kay and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWSC 419
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fanma Pty Ltd sought to enforce a judgment debt against Ryan Kay, the first defendant. The second defendant, who had initially agreed to indemnify Fanma against costs up to a certain amount, applied for an order that Fanma provide further security for costs. The application was made after a delay of several months. The Federal Circuit Court was required to determine whether there had been a material change in circumstances since the first application for security for costs, and whether the delay warranted refusal of the application. The court considered the quantum of the security sought and the potential financial position of Fanma.

The court noted that the first application for security for costs was made shortly after the commencement of the proceeding. Since then, there had been a significant increase in the amount of costs incurred and anticipated. The second defendant had also provided evidence of Fanma's financial position, which indicated that it was experiencing financial difficulties. The court found that there had been a material change in circumstances since the first application for security for costs. The delay in bringing the application for further security for costs was not considered to be a bar to the application. The court held that the quantum of the security sought was reasonable and ordered Fanma to provide further security for costs.

The court further considered that Fanma had not provided any evidence to rebut the presumption that it was impecunious. The court held that Fanma was required to provide further security for costs in the amount sought by the second defendant. The court ordered Fanma to provide further security for costs within 14 days of the date of the judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

Fanma Pty Ltd, a corporate plaintiff, brought an action against multiple defendants for damages related to alleged breaches of contract and other related claims. The first defendant, Ryan Kay, was a shareholder and director of Fanma Pty Ltd, while the second defendant was a company involved in the contractual arrangements. Fanma Pty Ltd applied for security for costs, which was initially granted in a limited amount due to the plaintiff being an impecunious corporation. Subsequently, the second defendant applied for further security for costs, asserting that there had been a material change in circumstances since the initial application. The second defendant cited delays in the proceedings and additional potential liability as reasons for the application. Fanma Pty Ltd opposed the application, arguing that the delay in bringing the application for further security warranted its refusal. The court had to consider the quantum of the security sought by the second defendant and whether the circumstances had materially changed since the initial security for costs order.

The matter came before the court on an application by the second defendant for further security for costs. This application followed an earlier order for security for costs in favour of Fanma Pty Ltd, which had been granted on the basis of the plaintiff's impecunious status. The second defendant filed the application for further security, citing delays in the proceedings and additional potential liability as grounds. Fanma Pty Ltd opposed the application, arguing against the refusal based on the delay and the lack of material change in circumstances. The court heard arguments from both parties on the application and considered the relevant factors in determining whether further security for costs should be ordered.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there has been a material change in circumstances since the first application for security for costs.
2. Whether the delay in bringing the application for further security for costs warrants its refusal.
3. What is the appropriate quantum of the security for costs sought by the second defendant.

Held
1. The court concluded that there has been a material change in circumstances since the first application for security for costs.
2. The court held that the delay in bringing the application for further security for costs does not warrant its refusal.
3. The court determined that the appropriate quantum of the security for costs sought by the second defendant should be AUD 50,000.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether there has been a material change in circumstances since the first application for security for costs, the court noted that the plaintiff's financial position had deteriorated significantly, evidenced by its inability to meet previous obligations and the significant increase in debt. This deterioration was deemed sufficient to warrant a reconsideration of the security for costs originally granted. The court further assessed that the second defendant's application, while delayed, was not inordinately so and did not constitute an abuse of process. The court found that the delay did not prejudice the plaintiff's ability to defend the action, and therefore, the delay did not warrant refusal of the application.

In considering the quantum of the security for costs, the court examined the plaintiff's financial statements and the nature and complexity of the proceedings. The court determined that the plaintiff's financial vulnerability and the potential costs of the litigation justified a security amount of AUD 50,000. The court balanced the plaintiff's need to access justice against the second defendant's need to protect itself from undue financial risk. The ratio decidendi here is that a significant and verifiable change in a plaintiff's financial circumstances, coupled with the potential costs of the litigation, can justify an increase in the security for costs. The court also reaffirmed that while delays in applying for further security can be a factor, they do not automatically lead to the refusal of such applications if the delay does not prejudice the plaintiff's right to defend the action.