Fairs and Anor and Pettit and Anor (No.3)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FAIRS & ANOR & PETTIT & ANOR (No.3) [2018] FCCA 1061

Catchwords:
FAMILY LAW – Contempt Application – the Respondents alleged to have acted in contempt of Court orders – whether the Court is satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that the Respondents acted in contempt – whether the Respondents communicated and/or had face-to-face contact with the eldest child of the First Applicant and the First Respondent in breach of Court orders – whether the Respondents conspired to procure the child away from the Applicants’ residence in breach of Court orders – whether the Respondents conspired to secrete the child interstate for the purpose of frustrating the execution of a recovery order – alternative application that the Respondents have contravened final orders in relation to the child.

HELD – The Respondents found beyond a reasonable doubt to have acted in contempt of Court in relation to charges 3, 5, 6 and 8 – charges 1, 2, 4 and 7 found not proven beyond a reasonable doubt – not necessary to consider the Applicants’ contravention application in the alternative.

Legislation:

Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), ss.112AP
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), r.19.02

Cases cited:

Ibbotsen & Wincen [1994] FamCA 103

Witham & Holloway (1995) 183 CLR 525

Medlow & Medlow [2017] FamCAFC 159

First Applicant: MS FAIRS
Second Applicant: MR FAIRS
First Respondent: MR PETTIT
Second Respondent: MS PETTIT
File Number: MLC 6856 of 2014
Judgment of: Judge Bender
Hearing date: 12 February 2018
Date of Last Submission: 16 February 2018
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 3 May 2018

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicants: Mr Testart
Solicitors for the Applicants: Pearce Webster Dugdales
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr Selimi
Solicitors for the Respondents: John Molnar
Counsel for the Independent Children's Lawyer: Mr Eidelson
Solicitors for the Independent Children's Lawyer: Schetzer Constantinou

ORDERS

  1. With respect to charge 1, being that between 20 October 2016 and 21 April 2017, the Respondent Mr Pettit (“Mr Pettit”) contrary to the terms of Order 4 did communicate with a child subject of this proceeding, namely X born (omitted) 2001 (“[X]”) by means of a software program enabling internet communication, “(omitted)”, that charge is found not proved.

  2. With respect to charge 2, being that between 20 October 2016 and 21 April 2017, the Respondent Ms Pettit (“Ms Pettit”) contrary to the terms of Order 4 did communicate with [X] by means of a software program enabling internet communication, “(omitted)”, that charge is found not proved.

  3. With respect to charge 3, being that between 20 October 2016 and 24 April 2017, Ms Pettit contrary to the terms of Order 4 did communicate with [X] by means of a telephone call or telephone calls, that charge is found proven.

  4. With respect to charge 4, being that between 20 October 2016 and 21 April 2017, Ms Pettit and Mr Pettit; alternatively, Ms Pettit; alternatively, Mr Pettit did, contrary to the terms of Order 4 conspire to procure [X] to breach the order by running away…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fairs and Anor and Pettit and Anor (No.3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCCA 1061
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for contempt of court brought by the Applicants, Fairs and Anor, against the Respondents, Pettit and Anor. The dispute centred on allegations that the Respondents had acted in contempt of court orders concerning the eldest child of the First Applicant and First Respondent. The proceedings were heard in the Family Court of Australia before Judge Bender.

The court was required to determine whether the Respondents had acted in contempt of court beyond a reasonable doubt. Specifically, the court considered whether the Respondents had communicated with the child via internet software, communicated with the child via telephone, conspired to procure the child to leave the Applicants' residence, conspired to secrete the child interstate to frustrate a recovery order, and had face-to-face contact with the child after a recovery order was made. The court also considered whether the Respondents had procured the child to travel interstate and whether their actions were taken with knowledge of and in disregard for court orders.

The court found that the Respondents were not guilty of contempt in relation to charges 1, 2, 4, and 7. However, the court found beyond a reasonable doubt that Ms Pettit was in contempt for communicating with the child by telephone (charge 3). Furthermore, the court found both Ms Pettit and Mr Pettit to be in contempt for conspiring to secrete the child interstate (charge 5) and for having face-to-face contact with the child after a recovery order was made (charge 6). Charge 8, which alleged that the Respondents' actions were taken with knowledge of and in flagrant disregard for court orders, was also found proven against both Respondents.

Consequently, the court ordered that the Respondents were found to have acted in contempt of court in relation to charges 3, 5, 6, and 8. The alternative application by the Applicants that the Respondents had contravened final orders in relation to the child was not considered, as the contempt charges were proven.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

With respect to charge 1, being that between 20 October 2016 and 21 April 2017, the Respondent Mr Pettit (“Mr Pettit”) contrary to the terms of Order 4 did communicate with a child subject of this proceeding, namely X born (omitted) 2001 (“[X]”) by means of a software program enabling internet communication, “(omitted)”, that charge is found not proved.

2.

With respect to charge 2, being that between 20 October 2016 and 21 April 2017, the Respondent Ms Pettit (“Ms Pettit”) contrary to the terms of Order 4 did communicate with [X] by means of a software program enabling internet communication, “(omitted)”, that charge is found not proved.

3.

With respect to charge 3, being that between 20 October 2016 and 24 April 2017, Ms Pettit contrary to the terms of Order 4 did communicate with [X] by means of a telephone call or telephone calls, that charge is found proven.

4.

With respect to charge 4, being that between 20 October 2016 and 21 April 2017, Ms Pettit and Mr Pettit; alternatively, Ms Pettit; alternatively, Mr Pettit did, contrary to the terms of Order 4 conspire to procure [X] to breach the order by running away from the Applicants’ residence, and seeking harbour at the home of Ms Pettit’s mother, one Ms H, that charge is found not proved.

5.

With respect to charge 5, being that prior to, in 2017, and on or about 21 April 2017 Ms Pettit did conspire with, inter alia, Ms S, Ms K, Ms H, and Ms M to secrete [X] interstate out of Victoria for the purpose of frustrating the execution of the recovery order made that day by this Honourable Court, that charge is found proven.

6.

With respect to charge 6, being that on or about 21 April 2017 Ms Pettit and Mr Pettit; alternatively, Ms Pettit; alternatively, Mr Pettit did, contrary to the terms of Order 4, and after the making of the said recovery order by this Honourable Court as aforesaid, and with full knowledge of the making thereof, have face-to-face contact with [X], that charge is found proven as to both Ms Pettit and Mr Pettit.

7.

With respect to charge 7, being that on or about 21 and/or 22 and/or 23 April 2017, contrary to the terms of the said recovery order:

(a) Ms Pettit and/or Mr Pettit procured the said Mr D to drive [X] to a bus station where he there and then boarded a bus for Canberra;

(b) [X] was, as Ms Pettit and/or Mr Pettit well knew and had arranged, met by one Ms K in Canberra;

(c) from Canberra, [X] went by plane to Queensland, where he was met, as Ms Pettit and/or Mr Pettit well knew and had arranged, by Ms S, and given accommodation by her;

that charge is found not proved.

8.

With respect to charge 8, being that the actions taken, and the events set in train, by Ms Pettit and/or Mr Pettit referred to in paragraphs 1-7 inclusive above were:

(a) taken by them in the full knowledge of the existence of orders of this Honourable Court prohibiting such actions, alternatively in the full knowledge that such actions were at the least contrary to the intention of such orders;

(b) calculated by them or either of them to frustrate or defeat the operation of such orders;

(c) entered into by them or either of them deliberately, with a view that the natural consequences of their actions would follow;

(d) in flagrant disregard of the authority of this Honourable Court;

that charge is found proven as to both Ms Pettit and Mr Pettit.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established