Fair Work Ombudsman v Yeon Beauty Salon Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v Yeon Beauty Salon Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 258  

File number(s): SYG 830 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE CAMERON
Date of judgment: 5 April 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – breaches of civil remedy provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – declarations of breach – imposition of pecuniary penalties – relevant considerations.
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 14, 44, 45, 61, 87, 90, 96, 99, 116, 117, 325, 535, 536, 539, 546, 550, 556, 557, 687, 701, 793

Fair Work Amendment (Protecting Vulnerable Workers) Act 2017 (Cth) s 2, sch 1

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) s 4AA

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) regs 3.33, 3.34, 3.36, 3.40

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Kelly v Fitzpatrick (2007) 166 IR 14

Fair Work Ombudsman v Grouped Property Services Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 557

Division: Fair Work
Number of paragraphs: 80
Date of hearing: 10 May 2022
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms V. Bulut
For the Respondents: Ms Ha appeared in person

ORDERS

SYG 830 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

YEON BEAUTY SALON PTY LTD ACN 603 278 020

First Respondent

MIYEON HA

Second Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE CAMERON

DATE OF ORDER:

5 April 2023

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The first respondent contravened:

(a)section 325(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by unreasonably requiring its employee, Jahye Kim, to repay to it and/or the second respondent leave payments and therefore to spend or pay the whole or part of an amount payable to her in relation to the performance of work;

(b)section 325(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by unreasonably requiring its employee, Jahye Kim, to repay to it and/or the second respondent part of her wage to pay amounts for tax and superannuation and therefore spend or pay the whole or part of an amount payable to her in relation to the performance of work;

(c)section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay its employee, Jahye Kim, the minimum rate of pay for full time work as prescribed by clause 17 of the Hair and Beauty Industry Award 2010;

(d)section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay its employee, Jahye Kim, the minimum rate of pay for part-time work as prescribed by clauses 12.7 and 17 of the Hair and Beauty Industry Award 2010;

(e)section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay its employee, Jahye Kim, amounts sufficient to satisfy her entitlement to the Saturday loading prescribed by clauses 31.2(b) and 31.2(c) of the Hair and Beauty Industry Award 2010;

(f)section 45 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay its employee, Jahye Kim, amounts sufficient to satisfy her entitlement to the Sunday loading prescribed by clauses 31.2(c) and 31.2(d) of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Yeon Beauty Salon Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Yeon Beauty Salon Pty Ltd and its director Ms Ha were the defendants in this case brought by the Fair Work Ombudsman, who sought compensation and penalties for multiple contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) in relation to the underpayment of a former employee, Ms Kim. The contraventions included the underpayment of various award and national employment standard entitlements, as well as the repayment of amounts Ms Kim had previously been paid for leave and associated fees, which exceeded her actual entitlements. Additionally, the respondents failed to maintain proper records and provide accurate payslips. The court had to determine the appropriate compensation for Ms Kim and the penalties for the respondents' breaches.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Fair Work Ombudsman had established that the respondents had contravened the Fair Work Act and, if so, what compensation and penalties should be imposed. The court needed to consider the nature and extent of the contraventions, the respondents' conduct, and the appropriate penalties under the Fair Work Act.

The court found that the respondents had indeed contravened various provisions of the Fair Work Act, including underpaying Ms Kim, failing to provide accurate records and payslips, and making improper repayments. The court held that the total compensation for the underpayments and (re)payments was $103,036.25, with Yeon Beauty Salon Pty Ltd liable for $49,577.17 of this amount. The court also imposed pecuniary penalties on the respondents, totaling $139,091.50. The court considered the contraventions to be serious, given the extent of the underpayments and the failure to rectify the situation despite multiple warnings.

The Fair Work Ombudsman was awarded compensation of $103,036.25 for the underpayments and (re)payments, with Yeon Beauty Salon Pty Ltd liable for $49,577.17. The respondents were also ordered to pay interest on these amounts. Yeon Beauty Salon Pty Ltd and Ms Ha were required to pay pecuniary penalties of $100,000 and $39,091.50, respectively. These penalties and compensation amounts were to be paid within 28 days of the decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

In a statement of agreed of facts filed 8 December 2021, Yeon Beauty admitted 19 contraventions of the FW Act and Ms Ha admitted her involvement, within the meaning of s.550 of the FW Act, in 10 of those contraventions. Statement of agreed facts The terms of the statement of agreed facts are set out in attachment A to these reasons. In summary, it was agreed that:(a)pursuant to employment agreements dated 30 April 2015 and 23 March 2017, Ms Kim had been employed as a hairdresser by Yeon Beauty between 12 May 2015 and 9 October 2019 (“Employment Period”), had been classified under the Award as a level 5 employee and was permitted to work in Australia under a Temporary Work (Skilled) (Subclass 457) visa sponsored by Yeon Beauty (“457 visa”); (b)from 12 May 2015 to 21 June 2019 (“Full-Time Employment Period”) Ms Kim generally worked 8.5 hours per day, Tuesday to Sunday, totalling 51 hours per week while from 22 June 2019 to 9 October 2019 (“Part-Time Employment Period”) she generally worked 8.5 hours per day, totalling between 17 and 34 hours per week; (c)during the Full-Time Employment Period, although Ms Kim was paid a wage in accordance with the employment agreements, together with ad hoc additional payments, Yeon Beauty required her to repay:(i)$11,979.80 that had been paid to her for personal leave and annual leave, (“Leave Repayments”); and (ii)$93,629.23, an amount associated with her visa, with training fees, with accountants’ fees and with Yeon Beauty’s taxation and superannuation obligations related to her employment (“Cash Back Payments”); (d)Yeon Beauty underpaid Ms Kim the following amounts in relation to the following remuneration obligations it owed under the FW Act:(i)her Award entitlements to:(A)ordinary full-time hours ($485.52); (B)ordinary part time hours ($6,919.96); (C)Saturday loadings ($5,254.22); (D)Sunday loadings ($2,309.22); (E)public holiday penalty rates ($3,128.82); (F)overtime rates ($28,146.88); (G)tool allowance ($1,538.79); (H)annual leave loading ($1,793.76);(ii)her NES entitlements to:(A)paid annual leave ($5,339.60); (B)paid accrued annual leave and leave loading accruals commuted upon termination ($948.52); (C)paid personal leave ($580.96); (D)paid absences on public holidays ($729.17); and(E)notice of termination or payment in lieu ($1,808.77);(e)those underpayments included the value of the $11,979.80 Leave Repayments and totalled $58,984.19; (f)Yeon Beauty also owed Ms Kim compensation of $93,629.23 for the Cash Back Payments; (g)in addition to the underpayment and (re)payment contraventions, Yeon Beauty, also:(i)failed to keep records as required by the FW Act and the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth); (ii)failed to provide Ms Kim on all occasions with a payslip as required by the FW Act; (iii)provided Ms Kim with payslips that it knew were false and misleading; and (iv)entered into a part-time employment agreement with Ms Kim that was not in writing; (h)that conduct variously contravened ss.44(1) (i.e. the NES), 45 (i.e. the Award), 325(1), 535(1), 536(1) and 536(3) of the FW Act;(i)Ms Ha was involved in Yeon Beauty’s breaches of ss.325(1), 90(1), 90(2), 96(1), 116, 117(2), 535(1), 536(1) and 536(3) and, by virtue of s.550 of the FW Act, is to be treated as having contravened each of the applicable provisions herself; (j)the respondents were jointly and severally liable to compensate Ms Kim $103,036.25 for underpayments and (re)payments; and (k)Yeon Beauty was solely liable to compensate Ms Kim $49,577.17 for those contraventions for which Ms Ha was not also liable as accessory. RELIEF SOUGHT

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A penalty unit was worth: (a)$170 until 30 July 2015; (b)$180 on and from 31 July 2015 until 30 June 2017; and(c)$210 on and from 1 July 2017: s.4AA of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth).APPLICANT’S EVIDENCEMs Kim In her affidavit in chief affirmed 21 January 2022, Ms Kim deposed that she was born in the Republic of Korea (“South Korea”) and had worked there as a qualified hairdresser for about 5 years. She deposed that her native language is Korean and that she speaks and reads English at a moderate level. She deposed that she arrived in Australia in December 2008 and held a student visa until mid-2012 while she undertook English language and hairdressing courses. She deposed that on 13 June 2013 she was granted a Temporary Work (Skilled) (subclass 457) visa which was valid until 13 June 2017. This visa was sponsored by a company named Haircom where she worked from 2012 or 2013 until mid-April 2015. Employment arrangement with Yeon Beauty Ms Kim deposed that in early 2015 she decided to pursue permanent residency in Australia but Haircom could not assist her. In April 2015 she met with Ms Ha with whom she was already acquainted through a mutual friend, and Ms Ha said that she would employ Ms Kim on a full-time basis and would also sponsor her. Ms Kim deposed that Ms Ha said words to the effect of: “if you are working for me, I can support you” and “you will be responsible for your own expenses and I will be responsible for mine. So your expenses could include your income tax and your lawyers fee”. Ms Kim deposed she agreed with this proposal because she felt that she had to show Ms Ha her loyalty. Ms Kim deposed that she was given an employment contract on 30 April 2015 and then worked for Yeon Beauty Salon from 12 May 2015 until 9 October 2019. Ms Kim deposed that Yeon Beauty Salon took over the sponsorship of her first subclass 457 visa and later sponsored her second subclass 457 visa which was granted in March 2017. Ms Kim deposed that Ms Ha was her boss at the salon and that they communicated in Korean, in particular sending text messages on a mobile messaging application called Kakao. Her evidence was that her employment contract and the occasional pay slips she received showed that she was paid $1076.92 gross each week. Her evidence was that she received a (net) weekly wage of $855.70, deposited into her bank account.Leave repayments Ms Kim deposed that during her employment Ms Ha had said to her “If you take leave, I can’t pay you because no work, no money” and that on occasions when she did take leave, she was required to pay back her weekly wage of $855.70. She deposed that, for example, after a text exchange in Korean on the Kakao app on 2 January 2017 where she wrote to Ms Ha: “My Boss, what about the wages which have come in. I wonder whether we have to return it” and Ms Ha replied “yes”, Ms Kim then transferred the full amount of her wage to Ms Ha’s personal bank account. Translations of the Kakao messages regarding these leave repayments and records of leave repayments made by Ms Kim to Ms Ha on 2 January 2017, 21 August 2017, 28 August 2017, 4 September 2017, 11 September 2017, 18 September 2017, 1 January 2018, 10 July 2018, 10 September 2018 and 18 September 2018 were annexure JK-2 to Ms Kim’s affidavit in chief.Cash back payments

Decision

Reasons for decision

I believe that such a total is just and appropriate.CONCLUSION Within 28 days the respondents are to pay to the Ombudsman the amount of $103,036.25, being the compensation owing to Jahye Kim. Within 28 days the first respondent is to pay to the Ombudsman the amount of $49,577.17, being the compensation owing to Jahye Kim. Within 28 days the respondents also pay to the Ombudsman interest on the $103,306.25 compensation amount, calculated in accordance with paragraph 2.2 of the Federal Court of Australia practice note “Interest on Judgments Practice Note (GPN-INT)”. Within 28 days the respondents also pay to the Ombudsman interest on the $49,577.17 compensation amount, calculated in accordance with paragraph 2.2 of the Federal Court of Australia practice note "Interest on Judgments Practice Note (GPN-INT)". Yeon Beauty pay pecuniary penalties totalling $100,000. Ms Ha pay pecuniary penalties totalling $39,091.50. The pecuniary penalties are be paid to the Ombudsman within 28 days.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Ombudsman relied on the affidavits of Fair Work Inspector (“FWI”) Elizabeth McKendry affirmed 31 January 2022 and 7 April 2022.Respondent’s co-operation during the investigation In her first affidavit, FWI McKendry deposed that on 11 October 2019 Ms Kim complained to the Ombudsman about underpayment by Yeon Beauty and that the investigation of the complaint was assigned to her. In November 2019 she commenced an extended email correspondence with Ms Ha and Yeon Beauty’s then-legal representatives. She deposed in that regard that she telephoned or wrote by email to the respondents or their legal representatives on 8 November 2019, 6 December 2019, 18 December 2019, 19 December 2019, 30 January 2020, 24 February 2020, 25 February 2020 and 15 April 2020, variously seeking responses to the allegations that Ms Kim had made to the Ombudsman, documents and records relevant to the inquiry into Ms Kim’s allegations and documents and records relevant to Yeon Beauty’s financial status. The respondents provided documents and attended an interview with FWI McKendry on 20 April 2020. On 23 July 2020, FWI McKendry emailed the respondents’ legal representatives a Contravention Letter of the same date which required Yeon Beauty to pay by 7 August 2020 amounts totalling $161,996.94 found to be owing to Ms Kim and to advise FWI McKendry of the steps taken to do so. Further correspondence then ensured and a revised contravention letter issued on 11 August 2020 citing an adjusted total amount owed of $160,396.94. The letter warned that the Ombudsman might take enforcement action and that:Efforts by Yeon Beauty to correct the contraventions set out above will be considered in deciding whether or not to start enforcement action. FWI McKendry’s evidence was that Ms Ha had not rectified the amounts owing, either by 7 August 2020 or by the time of the first of her affidavits. In her second affidavit, FWI Ms McKendry deposed that on 24 March 2022 she conducted a company name search for Yeon Beauty, at which time Ms Ha remained the sole director of Yeon Beauty. She also deposed that on 6 April 2022 she received a copy of a contract for sale by Yeon Beauty of the business “Yeon Art Hair” dated 2 March 2021 specifying a sale price of $30,000. RESPONDENTS’ EVIDENCE Ms Ha filed an affidavit dated 14 March 2022 in which she deposed that she started her own hair salon business in June 2010 known as “Yeon Art Hair” and although she had worked in other salons from October 2007 to May 2009, that she had had no previous experience of managing a business. She deposed that in April 2014 she met Ms Kim, who was seeking a position where she could work on an employer-sponsored visa, and agreed to hire her on the basis that Ms Kim had offered to pay all of her own tax and superannuation. Her evidence was that as Ms Kim “would fully support Yeon Beauty Salon”, Ms Ha proceeded to set up the company “Yeon Beauty Salon Pty Ltd” as advised by Ms Kim’s migration agent who contacted her in December 2014. The company was necessary for Ms Kim to obtain a sponsored working visa. In 2017 she had planned to sell or discontinue the business but Ms Kim’s visa application had not been finalised and Ms Kim asked her to continue the business, stating that in order to keep it going she would meet all “required payments”, including her income (tax) and superannuation. Ms Ha’s evidence was that despite her limited understanding of the company’s legal obligations, that she had attempted to comply with her obligations in relation to Ms Kim by seeking advice from the latter’s migration agent.