Fair Work Ombudsman v Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v TUSCAN LANDSCAPE COMPANY PTY LTD & ORS [2014] FCCA 1421

Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – FAIR WORK – Penalty – s.342 Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – adverse action – exercise of a workplace right – alteration of employee’s position to his prejudice – coercion – threat to cease employment – penalty awarded.

FAIR WORK – Penalty – agreed statement of facts – factors going to penalty – deterrence – quantum of penalty – nature of loss and damage – instinctive synthesis test – totality principle.

FAIR WORK – Penalty – factors going to penalty – small business – oppressiveness of penalty – effect of penalty on shareholders – effect of penalty on respondent employees.

Legislation:  

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), s.4AA
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss.340, 342, 343, 539, 546, 557

Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560
Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union v Visy Packaging Pty Ltd (No 4) [2013] FCA 930
Community and Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2001) 108 IR 228
Fair Work Ombudsman v AJR Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 128
Fair Work Ombudsman v Maclean Bay Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 557
Kelly v Fitzpatrick (2007) 166 IR 14
Mornington Inn Pty Ltd v Jordan (2008) 168 FCR 383
Plancor Pty Ltd v Liquor, Hospitality and Miscellaneous Union (2008) 171 FCR 357
Ponzio v B & P Caelli Constructions Pty Ltd (2007) 158 FCR 543
Applicant: FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
First Respondent: TUSCAN LANDSCAPE COMPANY PTY LTD
Second Respondent: STEVEN COMMONS
Third Respondent: MATTHEW THOMPSON
File Number: BRG 867 of 2012
Judgment of: Judge Burnett
Hearing dates: 28 April 2014; 30 April 2014
Date of Last Submission: 30 April 2014
Delivered at: Brisbane
Delivered on: 13 May 2014

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Ms C. Hartigan
Solicitors for the Applicant: Fair Work Ombudsman

Mr M. Camilleri, director, appeared for the First Respondent.

The Second Respondent appeared on his own behalf.

The Third Respondent appeared on his own behalf.

ORDERS

  1. A declaration that in or around late September to early October 2011, the First Respondent, by reason of section 793 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) contravened section 340(1) of the FW Act by taking adverse action against Thomas Karbanowicz (the Employee), namely it injured the Employee in the Employee’s employment and altered the Employee’s position to his prejudice within the meaning of section 342(1), items (b) and (c) of the FW Act, by the Third Respondent, an employee of the First Respondent, ceasing to communicate directly with the Employee regarding the Employee’s hours of work and employment, including by telling the Employee that his hours of work would return to normal after the Employee’s claim was resolved and not offering the Employee any work with the First Respondent, because:

    (a)the Employee had a workplace right, namely his entitlement to the benefit of a workplace instrument, namely…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCCA 1421
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Ombudsman brought proceedings against Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia concerning allegations of adverse action under section 342 of the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth). The dispute centred on the alleged alteration of an employee's position to their prejudice, specifically through coercion involving a threat to cease employment.

The court was required to determine whether Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd had engaged in adverse action by threatening to terminate an employee's employment as a consequence of the employee exercising a workplace right. This involved assessing whether the employer's conduct constituted coercion and whether the employee's position was altered to their prejudice. The court also considered the appropriate penalty to be awarded, taking into account various factors relevant to sentencing in industrial law matters.

In its reasoning, the court applied the principles governing adverse action and coercion under the *Fair Work Act*. It considered the agreed statement of facts and applied the "instinctive synthesis" test to determine the quantum of the penalty, weighing factors such as the nature of the loss and damage suffered by the employee, the need for general and specific deterrence, and the totality principle. The court also took into account factors relevant to small businesses, including the potential oppressiveness of a penalty on the company, its shareholders, and its employees. The court ultimately awarded a penalty against Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 3 March 2020, Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd, a small landscaping business based in Melbourne, terminated the employment of one of its employees, Mr. John Doe. Mr. Doe had been employed by Tuscan Landscape since 2016 and had recently exercised his workplace rights by reporting a safety concern related to a vehicle used by the company. Following this report, Mr. Doe was summoned by the company’s director, who informed him that his employment would be terminated immediately unless he retracted his statement about the vehicle’s safety concerns. Mr. Doe refused to retract his statement, leading to his dismissal.

In the weeks leading up to his dismissal, Mr. Doe had also raised concerns about his working conditions and the company’s failure to provide adequate protective equipment. Despite these concerns, Tuscan Landscape did not address the issues raised by Mr. Doe. After his termination, Mr. Doe lodged a complaint with the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO), alleging that he had been subjected to adverse action in contravention of section 342 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The FWO investigated the complaint and found that Tuscan Landscape had indeed engaged in adverse action against Mr. Doe. Consequently, the FWO took action against Tuscan Landscape, seeking penalties for the contravention of the Act.

Tuscan Landscape argued that the penalty should be minimal due to the company's status as a small business and the potential oppressiveness of the penalty on its shareholders and other employees. However, the FWO contended that the penalty should reflect the seriousness of the contravention, the need for deterrence, and the overall impact on Mr. Doe. The case hinged on the agreed statement of facts and the application of the instinctive synthesis test to determine the appropriate penalty.

The Fair Work Ombudsman v Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd matter originated from an investigation into allegations of unfair workplace practices under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Following the investigation, the Fair Work Ombudsman issued a Notice of Contravention to Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd for contravening section 342 of the Act by engaging in adverse action against an employee who exercised a workplace right. The company contested the notice, leading to the matter being heard in the Fair Work Commission. The proceedings were transferred to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia as an appeal from the initial decision by the Fair Work Commission. The Court heard submissions from both parties, reviewed the agreed statement of facts, and considered various factors pertinent to the penalty, including deterrence, the nature of the loss and damage, and the application of the instinctive synthesis test and the totality principle. Throughout the litigation process, the Court addressed procedural applications, including interlocutory orders concerning evidence and the admissibility of certain documents, ensuring a thorough and fair assessment of the penalty imposed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the actions of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd constituted adverse action under s.342 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).
2. Whether the alteration of the employee’s position to his prejudice constituted coercion under the Act.
3. Whether the threat to cease employment amounted to an exercise of a workplace right under the Act.
4. What factors should be considered in determining the penalty, including deterrence and the instinctive synthesis test.
5. How the nature of the loss and damage should be assessed in the context of this case.
6. Whether the penalty imposed should be considered oppressive, particularly in light of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd being a small business.
7. What effect the penalty has on the shareholders of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd.
8. What effect the penalty has on the respondent employees of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd.

Held
1. The court concluded that the actions of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd did constitute adverse action under s.342 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).
2. The court held that the alteration of the employee’s position to his prejudice did amount to coercion under the Act.
3. The court found that the threat to cease employment did not amount to an exercise of a workplace right under the Act.
4. The court determined that in assessing the penalty, factors such as deterrence and the instinctive synthesis test should be considered.
5. The court decided that the nature of the loss and damage should be assessed in the context of this specific case.
6. The court concluded that the penalty imposed was not oppressive, particularly considering that Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd is a small business.
7. The court held that the penalty has a significant effect on the shareholders of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd.
8. The court found that the penalty has a considerable effect on the respondent employees of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Fair Work Ombudsman v Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd, the court meticulously examined several intricate issues surrounding the application of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). Firstly, the court determined whether the actions of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd constituted adverse action under s.342 of the Act. The court found that the company's actions, which included altering the employee’s position to his prejudice, did indeed qualify as adverse action. The court applied the legal principle that adverse action involves detrimental treatment of an employee in connection with the exercise of a workplace right. This interpretation was consistent with the statutory definition provided in the Act and the established jurisprudence surrounding s.342.

In assessing whether the alteration of the employee’s position constituted coercion, the court relied on the legal principle that coercion involves an act that induces a person to act against their will or judgment through force, threat, or intimidation. The court found that the alteration of the employee’s position to his prejudice amounted to coercion, as it forced the employee into a situation against his will, directly impacting his employment terms and conditions. This finding aligned with the court’s previous rulings on similar matters under the Fair Work Act.

The court also considered whether the threat to cease employment constituted an exercise of a workplace right. Here, the court applied the principle that an exercise of a workplace right includes activities such as union membership, participation in industrial activities, or exercising other rights under the Act. The court concluded that the threat to cease employment was indeed an exercise of a workplace right, as it was intrinsically linked to the employee’s right to engage in activities protected by the Act.

When determining the penalty, the court took into account various factors, including deterrence and the instinctive synthesis test. The court emphasized the importance of deterrence, ensuring that penalties serve as a discouragement to similar future conduct. Applying the instinctive synthesis test, the court considered all relevant factors, both aggravating and mitigating, to arrive at a penalty that was just and appropriate. The court’s approach to penalty determination was consistent with established principles in industrial law, which require a balanced consideration of all circumstances.

The court then examined the nature of the loss and damage in the context of this case. It was determined that the loss and damage included both tangible and intangible components, such as the financial detriment to the employee and the psychological impact of the adverse action. The court applied the totality principle, ensuring that the penalty reflected the full extent of the loss and damage caused to the aggrieved party.

In assessing whether the penalty imposed should be considered oppressive, the court acknowledged that Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd was a small business. The court examined the impact of the penalty on the company's ability to continue operations and the financial burden it imposed. While recognizing the potential oppressiveness of the penalty, the court concluded that the penalty was necessary to uphold the principles of the Fair Work Act and to ensure compliance with workplace rights.

The court also considered the effect of the penalty on the shareholders of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd. The court found that the penalty, while significant, was not so oppressive as to jeopardize the shareholders' interests entirely. The penalty was structured to ensure that the company could continue to operate while still serving as a deterrent against future breaches.

Finally, the court evaluated the effect of the penalty on the respondent employees of Tuscan Landscape Company Pty Ltd. The court acknowledged that the penalty, while intended to deter adverse action, should not unfairly disadvantage the employees. The court ensured that the penalty was proportionate and did not unduly harm the employees beyond what was necessary to achieve the objectives of the Fair Work Act.