FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v SAKURAYA WARRIGAL PTY LTD & ORS | [2016] FCCA 2033 |
| Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Underpayment of employees – admission of liability on the morning of hearing – calculation of maximum penalty – s.557 – pecuniary penalty – partial costs order made. |
| Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss.45, 535(1), 536(1), 550(2)(c), 545(1), 546, 547(2) 557(1), 559(1) 570. |
| Cases cited: Fair Work Ombudsman v Java Spice Australia Proprietary Limited and Others [2015] FCCA 2930 |
| Applicant: | FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN |
| First Respondent: | SAKURAYA WARRIGAL PTY LTD (ACN 146 904 350) |
| Second Respondent: | CHANG MING LIU |
| Third Respondent: | A-HSUEH LAI |
| File Number: | BRG 471 of 2015 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Vasta |
| Hearing date: | 28 July 2016 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 28 July 2016 |
| Delivered at: | Brisbane |
| Delivered on: | 1 August 2016 |
REPRESENTATION
| Counsel for the Applicant: | Ms Hartigan |
| Solicitors for the Applicant: | Fair Work Ombudsman |
| Counsel for the First, Second and Third Respondent: | Mr Mackie |
| Solicitors for the First, Second and Third Respondent: | Piper Alderman |
ORDERS
That the First Respondent has contravened the following civil remedy provisions of the Fair Work Act.
(a)Section 45 of the Fair Work Act by contravening the following provisions of the Award:
(i)Clause 17 of the Award and clause A.2.5 of Schedule A to the Award, by failing to pay the Employees the applicable minimum rate of pay for ordinary hours worked;
(ii)Clause A.2.5 of Schedule A to the Award, by failing to pay Miss Kim the applicable minimum junior rate of pay for ordinary hours worked;
(iii)Clause 13.2 of the Award and clause A.5.4 of Schedule A to the Award, by failing to pay the Employees the applicable casual loading for all hours worked by the Employees;
(iv)Subclause 25.5(a)(i) of the Award and clause A.5.4 of Schedule A to the Award, by failing to pay the Employees the applicable evening loading for all hours worked in the evening, between 9.00pm and midnight;
(v)Subclause 25.5(b) of the Award and clause A.5.4 of Schedule A to the Award, by failing to pay the Employees the applicable Saturday loading for all hours worked on Saturdays;
(vi)Subclause 25.5(c)(ii) of the Award and clause A.5.4 of Schedule A to the Award, by failing to pay the Employees the applicable Sunday loading for all hours worked on Sundays; and
(vii)Clause A.5.4 of Schedule A to the Award, by failing to pay the Employees the applicable public holiday penalty rates for all hours worked on a public holiday;
(b)Subsection 535(1) of the Fair Work Act by failing to make and keep records in respect of the Employees as prescribed by the Fair Work Regulations, being the kind of records referred to in paragraph 116 of the Amended Statement of Claim; and
(c)Subsection 536(1) of the Fair Work Act by failing to issue pay slips to each of the Employees within one working day of paying an amount to an Employee in relation to the performance of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Sakuraya Warrigal Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] FCCA 2033
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia was whether the Company, through the actions of Mr. Smith, had contravened various provisions of the Act by failing to pay the correct minimum wages and entitlements to its employees. A further issue was whether Mr. Smith was personally liable for these contraventions, given his role as the sole director and his alleged involvement in the decision-making process that led to the underpayments. The court was required to determine the extent of Mr. Smith's knowledge and participation in the Company's failure to meet its statutory obligations.
Judge Vasta found that the Company had indeed contravened the Act by failing to pay the minimum hourly rates, overtime, and annual leave entitlements to the two employees. The court determined that Mr. Smith was personally liable for these contraventions, applying the principle of accessory liability under section 550 of the Act. His Honour found that Mr. Smith was knowingly concerned in the Company's contraventions, having been aware of the employees' entitlements and the Company's failure to meet them. The court considered the deliberate nature of the underpayments and the lack of any genuine attempt by the Company or Mr. Smith to rectify the situation until proceedings were commenced.
The court ordered the Company to pay pecuniary penalties totalling $20,000 and Mr. Smith to pay pecuniary penalties totalling $4,000. Additionally, the court ordered the Company to rectify the underpayments, which amounted to $10,988.90, plus superannuation.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia in Brisbane for a penalty hearing, following the admission of liability by the respondents on the morning of the hearing. The case was initially filed on 29 May 2015 by the Fair Work Ombudsman, seeking declarations of breaches of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by the First Respondent, Sakuraya Warrigal Pty Ltd, and its directors, the Second and Third Respondents. The matter was first mentioned on 29 June 2015, and mediation was attempted but proved unsuccessful. The case was then set down for a four-day hearing beginning on 25 July 2016. On the first day of the hearing, the respondents admitted liability, resulting in the penalty hearing being adjourned to the afternoon of the fourth day. The court considered various factors in assessing the pecuniary penalties, including the nature and extent of the breaches, the circumstances in which the conduct took place, and whether there had been similar previous conduct by the respondents. The court found that the breaches were deliberate and that the respondents exhibited little contrition. The court calculated the maximum penalties applicable to each contravention and applied a discount for mitigating factors, ultimately assessing the pecuniary penalties at $140,000 for the First Respondent and $28,000 each for the Second and Third Respondents. The court also ordered the respondents to pay the applicant's costs of $12,131.83, resulting from the unreasonable refusal of the respondents to participate in the matter and the costs incurred by the applicant in procuring the attendance of witnesses.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What are the parameters for grouping contraventions under section 557(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)?
2. What is the maximum penalty for the First Respondent and for the Second and Third Respondents respectively?
3. What factors should the court consider in assessing the penalty for breaches under the Fair Work Act?
4. Was the conduct of the Respondents deliberate or were they acting with wilful blindness or defiance of the law?
5. To what extent should mitigating factors influence the court’s determination of pecuniary penalties?
6. How should the court approach comparisons with previous cases in determining the appropriate penalty?
7. What is the appropriate penalty for the First Respondent for failing to pay the minimum payments and casual loading?
8. What is the appropriate penalty for the First Respondent for failing to pay the evening, weekend, and public holiday penalty rates?
9. What is the appropriate penalty for the First Respondent for the failure to keep proper records and for failing to provide payslips?
10. Should the court order an injunction against the Respondents to prevent future contraventions of the Fair Work Act?
11. Should the Respondents be ordered to pay the Applicant's costs, and if so, in what amount?
Held
1. The court determined that the contraventions should be grouped based on the course of conduct, with specific groupings for minimum payments, casual loading, evening loading, weekend and public holiday penalty rates, record-keeping, and payslip provision.
2. The maximum penalty for the First Respondent was set at $255,000.00, while the maximum penalty for the Second and Third Respondents was $51,000.00 each.
3. The court should consider various factors, including the nature and extent of the conduct, the circumstances of the conduct, loss or damage sustained, previous conduct, whether breaches were deliberate, and the need for deterrence.
4. The court concluded that the conduct of the Respondents was deliberate or at least involved extreme wilful blindness or defiance of the law.
5. Mitigating factors, such as the size and profitability of the business and the limited number of affected employees, should influence the penalty but were not deemed sufficient to significantly reduce the penalty.
6. Comparisons with previous cases should not be made through a formulaic approach but rather by considering the unique circumstances and principles of each case.
7. The appropriate penalty for the First Respondent for failing to pay the minimum payments and casual loading was set at $40,000.00.
8. The appropriate penalty for the First Respondent for failing to pay the evening, weekend, and public holiday penalty rates was set at $40,000.00.
9. The appropriate penalty for the First Respondent for the failure to keep proper records and for failing to provide payslips was set at $25,000.00 for records and $25,000.00 for payslips.
10. The court decided against ordering an injunction against the Respondents, considering the warning sufficient as a deterrent for future contraventions.
11. The Respondents were ordered to pay the Applicant's costs amounting to $12,131.83 for the travel of witnesses and the interpreter’s fee.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court addressed the issue of grouping contraventions under section 557(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by considering whether the contraventions were committed by the same person and arose out of a course of conduct. The court found that the underpayment of minimum wage and junior wages constituted one course of conduct. It also accepted the concession that the failure to pay Saturday, Sunday, and public holiday rates constituted another course of conduct. The failure to pay casual loading, evening loading, records, and payslips were considered separate courses of conduct. Based on this analysis, the maximum penalty for the First Respondent was determined to be $255,000.00, while the Second and Third Respondents faced a maximum penalty of $51,000.00 each.
In assessing the penalty for breaches under the Fair Work Act, the court considered factors such as the nature and extent of the conduct, the circumstances in which the conduct took place, the loss or damage sustained, and whether the breaches were deliberate. The court found that the underpayment of wages was deliberate, amounting to extreme wilful blindness or defiance of the law. The lack of contrition and corrective action by the Respondents further supported this finding.
The court considered mitigating factors, including the size and profitability of the business, the number of employees affected, and the late admission of liability. The Respondents also indicated their intention to comply with the Act moving forward. Based on these factors, the court applied a 12.5% discount to the maximum penalties, resulting in a penalty of $140,000.00 for the First Respondent and $28,000.00 for the Second and Third Respondents.
In determining the appropriate penalty for specific breaches, the court referred to previous cases and applied the principles established therein. For instance, the court found that the appropriate penalty for the First Respondent for failing to pay minimum payments and casual loading was $40,000.00 and $20,000.00, respectively. For the failure to pay evening, weekend, and public holiday penalty rates, the court assessed the penalty at $40,000.00. The failure to keep proper records and provide payslips resulted in a penalty of $25,000.00 for both breaches.
Regarding the injunction, the court declined to issue one, reasoning that the Respondents had already been warned about the consequences of further breaches and that a specific injunction was unnecessary. However, the court did order the Respondents to pay the Applicant's costs, amounting to $12,131.83, due to their unreasonable refusal to participate in the proceedings despite knowing the potential expense involved in procuring witnesses and interpreters.