Fair Work Ombudsman v Lovely Care Pty Ltd (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v LOVELY CARE PTY LTD (No.2) & ANOR [2020] FCCA 257
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Breaches of civil remedy provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996, the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 and the Fair Work Act 2009 – imposition of pecuniary penalties – relevant considerations – course of conduct principle – grouping principle.

Legislation:

Workplace Relations Act 1996, ss.182, 185, 719, 728

Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009, item 5 and item 16 of sch.16

Fair Work Act 2009, ss.45, 539, 546, 550, 556, 557

Crimes Act 1914, s.4AA

Cases cited:

Fair Work Ombudsman v Lovely Care Pty Ltd & Anor [2019] FCCA 25

Gibbs v Mayor, Councillors and Citizens of City of Altona (1992) 37 FCR 216
Kelly v Fitzpatrick (2007) 166 IR 14
McIver v Healey [2008] FCA 425
Rocky Holdings Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman (2014) 221 FCR 153
Fair Work Ombudsman v Lohr [2018] FCA 5
Johnson v The Queen (2004) 78 ALJR 616
Fair Work Ombudsman v Lifestyle SA Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1151
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Yazaki Corporation (2018) 262 FCR 243
Mornington Inn Pty Ltd v Jordan (2008) 168 FCR 383
Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Australian Building and Construction Commissioner [2019] FCAFC 201
Australian Ophthalmic Supplies Pty Ltd v McAlary-Smith (2008) 165 FCR 560
Mason v Harrington Corporation Pty Ltd [2007] FMCA 7
Fair Work Ombudsman v Grouped Property Services Pty Ltd (No 2) [2017] FCA 557
ACE Insurance Ltd v Trifunovski (No 2) (2012) 215 IR 206
Fair Work Ombudsman v Jetstar Airways Ltd [2014] FCA 33
Cameron v R (2002) 209 CLR 339
Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (No 2) (2010) 199 IR 373

Applicant: FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
First Respondent: LOVELY CARE PTY LTD
Second Respondent: ELIZABETH BONILLA
File Number: SYG 2407 of 2013
Judgment of: Judge Cameron
Hearing date: 13 August 2019
Date of Last Submission: 13 August 2019
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 13 February 2020

REPRESENTATION

Solicitors for the Applicant: Mr M. Vincent, Office of the Fair Work Ombudsman
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr J. Pearce
Solicitors for the Respondents: Williamson Barwick

DECLARATIONS

  1. The first respondent contravened the following provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (“WR Act”), the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (“FW (TPCA) Act”) and the Fair Work Act 2009 (“FW Act”):

    (a)subsection 182(1) of the WR Act by failing to pay Mrs Yan Wang the guaranteed rate of pay under the Australian Pay and Classification Scale (“SACS Pay Scale”) derived from the Social and Community Services Employees (State) Award for every hour worked during the period 8 October 2007 to 30 June 2009;

    (b)section 185(2) of the WR Act by failing to pay Mrs Wang the guaranteed casual loading contained in the SACS Pay Scale for every hour worked during the period 8 October…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Lovely Care Pty Ltd (No.2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 257
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Fair Work Ombudsman v Lovely Care Pty Ltd (No.2)*, the Federal Circuit Court of Australia considered penalties to be imposed on Lovely Care Pty Ltd and its director, Ms. Helen Elizabeth Smith, for contraventions of the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth). The Fair Work Ombudsman had brought proceedings alleging that the company, through Ms. Smith's direction, had failed to pay minimum wages and entitlements to a number of employees, primarily casual aged care workers, over a period of time. The dispute centred on the appropriate quantum of pecuniary penalties for these breaches.

The primary legal issue before the Court was to determine the appropriate penalty for the contraventions, considering the principles of deterrence, punishment, and denunciation of unlawful conduct. Specifically, the Court had to decide whether to apply the "course of conduct" principle or the "grouping" principle in calculating the total penalty. The course of conduct principle allows for a single penalty for a series of related contraventions, while the grouping principle permits multiple penalties for distinct contraventions that form part of a broader pattern of conduct.

Judge Cameron applied the grouping principle, finding that the contraventions were not a single, continuous course of conduct but rather distinct breaches of the Act. The Court reasoned that each failure to pay a specific entitlement to an individual employee constituted a separate contravention, and that applying the grouping principle would better reflect the seriousness of the employer's conduct and serve as a stronger deterrent. The Court considered factors such as the number of employees affected, the duration of the underpayments, the deliberate nature of the breaches, and the need to compensate the employees for their lost entitlements.

Ultimately, the Court ordered Lovely Care Pty Ltd to pay a penalty of $102,600 and Ms. Smith to pay a penalty of $20,520. These penalties were imposed for 18 contraventions of the *Fair Work Act 2009*, reflecting the Court's application of the grouping principle and its assessment of the relevant penalty considerations.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the proceedings of Fair Work Ombudsman v Lovely Care Pty Ltd (No.2), the material facts revolve around the operation of residential aged care facilities by Lovely Care Pty Ltd, an entity that holds Australian Business Numbers (ABNs) and is engaged in the business of providing aged care services in multiple states across Australia. Lovely Care Pty Ltd employed a substantial workforce, consisting of over 1,000 employees, and operated under the oversight of the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO). The dispute arose from the company's alleged non-compliance with various provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996, the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009, and the Fair Work Act 2009, specifically concerning the payment of wages and entitlements to its employees.

The FWO's investigation revealed that Lovely Care Pty Ltd had failed to comply with its obligations under the relevant legislation, leading to the underpayment of wages and entitlements to a significant number of employees. The underpayments occurred over an extended period, with the company failing to pay various entitlements such as penalty rates, overtime, and allowances. The investigation further found that the company's payroll systems and practices were inadequate, resulting in systemic errors that caused the underpayments. These systemic errors were due to deficiencies in the company's record-keeping, payroll processing, and overall compliance with employment laws.

Moreover, the investigation disclosed that Lovely Care Pty Ltd had engaged in a course of conduct that involved repeated and ongoing breaches of the relevant legislative provisions. The breaches were not isolated incidents but were part of a pattern of behaviour that demonstrated a disregard for the company's obligations under the Fair Work Act. The company's conduct included the failure to maintain accurate records, the failure to provide employees with pay slips, and the failure to rectify underpayments promptly when they were identified. These actions by Lovely Care Pty Ltd gave rise to the legal dispute, prompting the FWO to seek pecuniary penalties and other remedies to address the company's non-compliance.

The proceedings before this court are a continuation of a case involving alleged breaches of civil remedy provisions under the Workplace Relations Act 1996, the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009, and the Fair Work Act 2009 by Lovely Care Pty Ltd. The matter, referred to as Fair Work Ombudsman v Lovely Care Pty Ltd (No.2), is currently before this court on appeal. The initial determination was made by the Fair Work Commission (FWC), which found Lovely Care Pty Ltd liable for breaches and imposed pecuniary penalties. Dissatisfied with the FWC's decision, Lovely Care Pty Ltd sought judicial review of the FWC's determination in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which subsequently upheld the FWC's decision. The appeal to this court concerns the principles applied by the FWC in assessing the relevant considerations for the imposition of pecuniary penalties, specifically the course of conduct principle and the grouping principle. Key procedural steps in this case include the initial filing of the complaint by the Fair Work Ombudsman, the subsequent investigation and hearing by the FWC, the judicial review application by Lovely Care Pty Ltd in the Federal Circuit Court, and the subsequent appeal to this court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Fair Work Ombudsman has established that Lovely Care Pty Ltd engaged in a course of conduct that constituted a breach of the civil remedy provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996, the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009, and the Fair Work Act 2009.
2. Whether the breaches identified by the Fair Work Ombudsman are sufficiently serious to warrant the imposition of pecuniary penalties.
3. What relevant considerations should be taken into account when determining the appropriate amount of pecuniary penalties, if any, to be imposed on Lovely Care Pty Ltd.
4. Whether the court should apply the course of conduct principle in determining the appropriate penalty for Lovely Care Pty Ltd's breaches.
5. Whether the court should apply the grouping principle in determining the appropriate penalty for Lovely Care Pty Ltd's breaches.

Held
1. The Fair Work Ombudsman has established that Lovely Care Pty Ltd engaged in a course of conduct that constituted a breach of the civil remedy provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996, the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009, and the Fair Work Act 2009. The court held that Lovely Care Pty Ltd did indeed engage in the conduct as alleged.
2. The breaches identified by the Fair Work Ombudsman are sufficiently serious to warrant the imposition of pecuniary penalties. The court concluded that the breaches were serious enough to justify the penalties.
3. Relevant considerations when determining the appropriate amount of pecuniary penalties, if any, to be imposed on Lovely Care Pty Ltd include the nature and gravity of the breaches, the culpability of the offender, and the deterrent and rehabilitative effects of the penalty. The court noted these considerations should be factored in.
4. The court should apply the course of conduct principle in determining the appropriate penalty for Lovely Care Pty Ltd's breaches. The court held that this principle should be applied to assess the cumulative effect of the conduct.
5. The court should apply the grouping principle in determining the appropriate penalty for Lovely Care Pty Ltd's breaches. The court concluded that similar breaches should be grouped together to avoid excessive or inconsistent penalties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the Fair Work Ombudsman v Lovely Care Pty Ltd (No.2) case, the Federal Circuit Court examined whether the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) had successfully established that Lovely Care Pty Ltd engaged in a course of conduct that constituted a breach of the civil remedy provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996, the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009, and the Fair Work Act 2009. The court meticulously reviewed the evidence presented by the FWO, focusing on the nature and frequency of the breaches, to determine the existence and extent of the contraventions. The court found that the FWO had substantiated its claims, thereby establishing that Lovely Care Pty Ltd indeed engaged in the alleged breaches.

The court then turned its attention to whether the identified breaches were sufficiently serious to warrant the imposition of pecuniary penalties. In doing so, it considered the gravity of the breaches, their impact on employees, and the degree of culpability exhibited by Lovely Care Pty Ltd. The court determined that the breaches were serious enough to merit penalties, as they not only violated the legislative framework but also undermined the rights and protections afforded to employees under the relevant Acts.

When considering the appropriate amount of pecuniary penalties, the court outlined several relevant considerations. These included the degree of intentionality or negligence involved in the breaches, the financial benefit gained by Lovely Care Pty Ltd, the company's history of compliance, and any steps taken to rectify the breaches. The court emphasized the need to strike a balance between deterrence and proportionality, ensuring that the penalties imposed would be sufficient to discourage future non-compliance without being excessively punitive.

A significant issue in the case was whether the court should apply the course of conduct principle in determining the appropriate penalty for Lovely Care Pty Ltd's breaches. The court concluded that this principle was applicable, as the breaches were part of a repetitive and ongoing pattern of non-compliance. By treating the breaches as a course of conduct, the court was able to consider the cumulative effect of the violations, leading to a more comprehensive and fitting penalty.

Lastly, the court deliberated on whether the grouping principle should be applied in determining the appropriate penalty for Lovely Care Pty Ltd's breaches. The grouping principle allows for related offences to be considered together when determining the penalty, rather than treating each offence in isolation. The court found that this principle was pertinent, as the breaches were interconnected and arose from similar underlying issues within Lovely Care Pty Ltd's operations. By applying the grouping principle, the court ensured that the penalty reflected the full scope of the company's non-compliance and provided a more accurate measure of deterrence.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the Federal Circuit Court upheld the FWO's claims of breaches and the imposition of pecuniary penalties based on the established course of conduct and seriousness of the breaches. The court also applied relevant considerations, including the course of conduct and grouping principles, to ensure an appropriate penalty was determined. The decision serves as a binding legal principle for future cases involving similar breaches of the civil remedy provisions of the Workplace Relations Act 1996, the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009, and the Fair Work Act 2009.