Fair Work Ombudsman v Domain Botanical Business Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fair Work Ombudsman v Domain Botanical Business Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 912

File number(s): MLG 2234 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE BURCHARDT
Date of judgment: 12 May 2021
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Application for declarations and penalties – statement of agreed facts but Court still required to determine discrete controversy going to the culpability of the second respondent – court not satisfied of second respondent’s denials – consideration of matters relevant to assessment of penalty – application of totality principle.   
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 44(1), 45, 90(2), 535(1), 546(1), 550, 557

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) cl 3.33(1)(b), 3.33(2), 3.34

Cases cited:

A & L Silvestri Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union [2008] FCA 466

Fair Work Ombudsman v Lindsay F.  Nelson Manufacturing Pty Ltd (No.2) [2020] FCCA 718

Fair Work Ombudsman v The Old Cop Shop Eatery Pty Ltd [2020] FCCA 1884

Rocky Holdings Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2014] FCAFC 62

Number of paragraphs: 95
Date of hearing: 29 March 2021
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Tracey
Solicitor for the Applicant: Fair Work Ombudsman
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr Tindley
Solicitor for the First Respondent: FCB Lawyers and Consultants
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr Tindley
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: FCB Lawyers and Consultants

ORDERS

MLG 2234 of 2020
BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

DOMAIN BOTANICAL BUSINESS PTY LTD ACN 611 578 459

First Respondent

JAMES MCBRIDE

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE BURCHARDT

DATE OF ORDER:

12 MAY 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The form of orders to reflect the judgment delivered on this day be reserved.

2.        The matter be adjourned to this Court on a date to be fixed.

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE BURCHARDT

  1. This is an application by the Fair Work Ombudsman for the imposition of civil penalties on respondents, together with declaratory relief.  There is a statement of agreed facts (“SOAF”) and accordingly, most of the aspects of this dispute are not contested, notwithstanding which a number of matters are quite strongly in issue.  The most significant factual dispute is the extent to which the second respondent, Mr McBride, should be permitted to deflect responsibility for the course of conduct which led to the numerous contraventions of the Fair Work Act2009 (Cth) (“FW Act”) and the relevant award that are admitted by placing the substantive blame on his former advisors whom I will refer to as Blue Rock. There is a further dispute about the grouping of the contraventions and, unsurprisingly, there is a dispute about the level at which penalties should be imposed. For the reasons that follow, I do not accept Mr McBride’s version of events, I accept the FWO’s submissions in relation to grouping and I fix penalties at the level indicated at the end of this judgment.

    AGREED MATTERS

  2. There is no dispute about what one might describe as formal matters.  There is no challenge to the applicant’s entitlement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Domain Botanical Business Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCCA 912
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Ombudsman brought proceedings against Domain Botanical Business Pty Ltd and Mr Randa Asi (referred to as Mr McBride in the judgment) for alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The dispute concerned the underpayment of employees, with a statement of agreed facts being presented to the court. However, a discrete controversy remained regarding the culpability of Mr McBride, and the court was required to determine this issue.

The court was tasked with determining the extent of Mr McBride's knowledge and responsibility concerning the underpayments, and whether his actions or omissions warranted penalties. Specifically, the court needed to assess the credibility of Mr McBride's denials and his attempts to attribute blame to a third-party payroll service, Blue Rock. The court also considered various factors relevant to the assessment of penalties, including the vulnerability of the affected employees, the respondents' cooperation and contrition, the need for specific and general deterrence, and the importance of compliance with minimum employment standards.

In its reasoning, the court found Mr McBride's explanations regarding his reliance on Blue Rock for advice on award rates and the Better Off Overall Test to be unpersuasive. The court noted that Mr McBride had been aware of the relevant award and potential underpayments from an early stage, evidenced by email communications. While acknowledging that the company had undertaken corrective action, the court observed a significant delay in this process. The court also considered the vulnerability of many of the underpaid employees, including visa holders and young workers, as a relevant factor in assessing the seriousness of the contraventions. The court ultimately was not satisfied with Mr McBride's denials and his attempts to shift responsibility.

The court reserved the form of its orders and adjourned the matter to a date to be fixed.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. The form of orders to reflect the judgment delivered on this day be reserved.

2. The matter be adjourned to this Court on a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Fair Work Ombudsman initiated proceedings against Domain Botanical Business Pty Ltd, trading as Gilson restaurant, and its manager, Mr. McBride, concerning alleged contraventions of minimum wage standards under the Hospitality Industry (General) Award 2010. The case involves the underpayment of wages to a significant number of employees, over half of whom were visa holders from non-English speaking backgrounds, and many of whom were casual workers or under 25 years of age. The dispute arose from the restaurant's practice of paying flat rates of pay rather than adhering to the award rates, despite being aware of the applicable award and receiving advice on the better off overall test from Blue Rock, a consultancy engaged for payroll and bookkeeping.

The evidence presented includes emails and affidavits from various individuals involved in the business operations. Ms. Donovan, who had been with Blue Rock, testified about her communications with Mr. Cash and Mr. McBride, expressing concerns about the payment practices and the impact of media reports and the Fair Work Ombudsman's crackdown on wage underpayments. Mr. McBride, on the other hand, adopted his affidavits as correct but denied several allegations, including that he was advised by Blue Rock on legal matters and that he knew about the award rates and the need for better off overall calculations. He claimed that his responsibility was to pay employees correctly but not to manage updates to pay rates, and he attempted to shift blame to Blue Rock for any difficulties.

Despite the parties' disagreement on the culpability of the second respondent, the Court was required to determine the discrete controversy concerning Mr. McBride's denials and his role in the underpayment of wages. The Court found Mr. McBride's evidence unconvincing and noted his attempts to place blame on Blue Rock, which did not result in any additional mitigation. Although Mr. McBride cooperated with the investigation and undertook corrective action, the Court observed a lengthy delay in addressing the underpayment issue. The vulnerability of the underpaid employees, the need for compliance with minimum wage standards, and the potential for specific and general deterrence were also considered in the context of the penalty assessment.

The matter of Fair Work Ombudsman v Domain Botanical Business Pty Ltd came before the court as an application for declarations and penalties following investigations into alleged underpayments of wages. The case involved multiple respondents, with Domain Botanical Business Pty Ltd being the primary respondent. The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) sought declarations and penalties against the respondents for contraventions of workplace laws. The case was advanced on a statement of agreed facts, which outlined the basic facts of the matter, but the court still needed to determine specific issues regarding the culpability of the second respondent. Prior to this hearing, the respondents had engaged in various discussions and negotiations with the FWO, but ultimately, the court found the second respondent's denials unsatisfactory. The court considered several procedural steps, including applications filed and interlocutory orders made in the context of the ongoing proceedings. The court's focus was on assessing the appropriate penalty, taking into account various factors such as cooperation, contrition, corrective action, involvement of senior management, and the need to ensure compliance with minimum standards. The final determination of penalties and orders was reserved pending further submissions and the court's judgment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Annexure “JM-5” to the same affidavit, is an email dated 28 November 2016 from Sarah Vincenzi to Randa, relevantly, saying:Gilson:Individual flexibility agreement (IFA) 1, I have now uploaded to the Gilson Dropbox Folder the IFA Cover Letter, Agreement and checklist. (checklist is for your assistance only, and does not need to be provided to employees) for Gilson restaurant. All new staff should receive and sign an employment agreement, as well as an IFA, which allows us to amend the award.THE ORAL EVIDENCE GIVEN AT COURT What follows is taken from my notes. Ms Donovan was called and adopted her affidavit as true and correct. Under cross-examination, she confirmed that she has sent the email ND1 – being part of exhibit ND1 at 11.41am to Mr Cash, with a copy to Mr McBride. She was then cross-examined about another email sent on 1 May 2018 at 11 hours, 40 minutes and 53 seconds in slightly different terms (which was tendered as exhibit R1). When asked how it was possible that there were two emails sent in such a short space of time in different terms, Ms Donovan said she could not be sure. They had a policy that emails were reviewed before being sent, so it was possible that the first was a draft. The second one seemed to have been reviewed. She could not say if she sent one or two emails. She might have sent the first one and tried to recall it. It was towards the end of her employment at Blue Rock. It might have been sent by her email address. Ms Donovan said that Blue Rock did not advise that flat rates of pay be paid and she said she had not told Mr McBride this. She was taken to exhibit “JM-5”, to Mr McBride’s second affidavit, being the email from Sarah Vincenzi. She said she was not involved with that. When questioned about exhibit “JM-4”, being the email to Mr McBride from Mr McKeon referring to a standard rate based on the better off overall test, Ms Donovan said she had very little interaction with the respondents. There had been meetings between the respondent and Employment Innovation, but she had never dealt with them herself. When cross-examined about paragraph 22 of her affidavit, Ms Donovan said it was an ongoing thing for herself. She wanted all clients to be doing the right thing. She had specific evidence about Gilson. She knew Blue Rock was not doing calculations of best off overall rates. She worked next to the accountants. That is where her concern came from. Her email of 30 April came after a conversation with Adam Cash. She told him about media reports about the industry and that the Fair Work Ombudsman was cracking down. It was Mr McBride who told her about legal advice. Mr McBride was called and adopted his affidavits as true and correct. He conceded that he is the manager of the Gilson Restaurant and has no other businesses at the moment. He dealt with Blue Rock in early mid-2016 and the business started in about December 2016. It was put that he had been told he needed to know the award, but said he did not recall such a meeting taking place. It was put that Blue Rock told him of the award rates and he denied this. When it was put that he was told about the existence of the café and restaurant being different awards, he said there was no such discussion. He had multiple meetings with Blue Rock.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It was put that he was responsible for the financial side of the business assisted by Blue Rock but Mr McBride did not answer directly. He then said it was his responsibility to pay employees correctly. He was taken to the agreement with Blue Rock being annexure “BM-2”, the Blue Rock agreement. It was put that there was no mention of Blue Rock managing updates to payrates. Mr McBride said this fell under bookkeeping and payroll processing. He was taxed with standard term and condition 16 which denied legal advice. He did not agree that Blue Rock was not providing legal advice. He then volunteered that he got legal advice from Blue Rock from Sarah Vincenzi. He was taken to paragraph 13 of his first affidavit in which he essentially blamed Blue Rock for any difficulties. He said it was his responsibility but not his job. He stood by the evidence in paragraph 18 of his first affidavit in which he denied unlawful conduct. That was what he thought. He was interviewed by the Fair Work Ombudsman in February 2019 and was aware that the Ombudsman was investigating and there was a risk of underpayments. He agreed that the FWO found a contravention in November 2019. When it was put that there were no repayments until July 2020 he agreed and said this was far too long. He was also cross-examined about his concession in his first affidavit that it was probable that there were underpayments from 2016 to 2018. He agreed he had not put on any evidence yet as to his investigations. He said his accountant was working on this. There have been underpayments. He ought to be aware of this. He had not rectified any earlier underpayments. It was put that he was not sorry for his contraventions and was only sorry for what had happened to him but he said this was not correct.CONCLUSION ON THIS ASPECT OF THE DISPUTE I have no doubt that Mr McBride knew from a very early stage of the existence of the award. The emails sent to him from time to time make this quite clear. If one goes to annexure “BM-14” to Mr McDonnell’s first affidavit, it being the record of interview on 19 February 2019, at page 154 Mr McBride relevantly said:Yeah, we paid yeah, flat rates, we’d say, you know, ah 25 bucks an hour, you know, whatever it might be and you’d pay that rate day in, day out… And that’s sort of the way that I’ve been – been taught, you know, in my family business, when I was a kid and that’s how I guess, the – like and I guess that’s where we want the industry to go away from, but ah, you know, it was a – it’s been a – it’s been a learning curve and a change in the industry. At page 216 to page 218 of the court book, Mr McBride traversed the commencement of the business and I note that Randa was Randa Asi, the respondent’s first general manager. He had already said earlier on the page that the flat rates came in from Blue Rock. On page 217, he repeated that the better off overall advice came from Blue Rock 100 per cent, although, he had known by May 2018 that penalty rates might apply.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I note that during the assessment period over half of the employees underpaid were visa holders and came from non-English speaking countries and 14 were 25 years or younger with the youngest being 19 years old. Many were casuals. Their vulnerability is in my view a relevant consideration. Cooperation, Contrition and Corrective Action Although the parties, as the respondents’ written submissions assert “fundamentally disagree” about this aspect of the matter, in my view the overall picture is reasonably clear. First, it should be noted that the applicant accepts that the first respondent cooperated in the investigation by providing various records in response to notice to produce and attending a voluntary recorded interview and by making full admissions, and entering into a statement of agreed facts. Unlike the respondents, I accept that Mr McBride’s attempts (ultimately unsuccessful) to place the blame, essentially, on Blue Rock counts as a countervailing factor. However, it should also be noted, and I bear in mind, that a party is not to be penalised for, as it were, pleading not guilty (to use an analogy from the criminal law sphere). The fact that Mr McBride has tried to blame Blue Rock and I do not accept his explanation does not mean that any greater penalty should be imposed. It is simply that Mr McBride does not get the additional mitigation, so to speak, that might have arisen, had I accepted that evidence. It is agreed that the company undertook corrective action, but I accept there was a lengthy period before this took place, and I note Mr McBride’s affidavit evidence, as to his delay and failure to address this issue.Involvement of Senior Management While, of course, Mr McBride was senior management for all relevant purposes, this needs to be seen in context. This was not some huge corporation, with multiple tentacles. It was a single restaurant in which Mr McBride was, effectively, the owner and manager. I bear in mind his seniority and responsibility, but in my opinion, in the particular circumstances of this case, it adds little.Similar Previous conduct There is none alleged.Need to Ensure Compliance with Minimum Standards It is sufficient to say that I accept the applicant’s submissions as to this important matter. The safety net is, as the written submissions assert, “of particular importance in a competitive service industry, such as the restaurant industry, where the underpayment of wages can provide a competitive advantage” (paragraph 50, written submissions). I also accept the submission that proper record keeping is the bedrock of compliance with workplace laws and this is a matter that I take into account. Specific Deterrence The applicant submits that Mr McBride’s lack of proper contrition points to a need for specific deterrence. I confess I found Mr McBride’s evidence unpersuasive, albeit that the questions put to him were closed questions which gave him little opportunity to expand more fully. I think it is more probable than otherwise that the outcome of this decision is likely to deter Mr McBride in the most potent way from any further repetition.General Deterrence