Fair Work Ombudsman v Crystal Carwash Café Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fair Work Ombudsman v Crystal Carwash Cafe Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 827

Citation: Fair Work Ombudsman v Crystal Carwash Cafe Pty Ltd (No 2) [2014] FCA 827
Parties: FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN v CRYSTAL CARWASH CAFE PTY LTD (ACN 060 916 770), ANTHONY SAHADE, PETER KHOURI, BADDINGTON PTY LTD (ACN 137 049 560), SEEKTON PTY LTD (ACN 137 049 579), OZREST PTY LTD (ACN 137 219 820), SCHATRY PTY LTD ACN (137 219 802), COOLJAM PTY LTD (ACN 141 762 352), OZRUN PTY LTD (ACN 141 762 389), TUSHAR INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 141 758 045), LUCKY HORIZONS PTY LTD (ACN 144 648 975), PEPPER STONE PTY LTD (ACN 144 649 427) and OAK MINK PTY LTD (ACN 145 471 941)
File number(s): NSD 1585 of 2012
Judge(s): BUCHANAN J
Date of judgment: 7 August 2014
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – civil penalty proceedings – contraventions of Vehicle Manufacturing, Repair, Services and Retail Award 2010 (“the Award”) – underpayment of minimum rates of pay under the Award – underpayment of overtime entitlements under the Award – contravention of requirement to keep adequate records – whether contraventions were serious and part of a pattern of conduct – whether high range penalty is justified in the circumstances  
Legislation: Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 135
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss 45, 535(2), 539(2), 539(2)(Item 2), 539(2)(Item 29), 546, 546(2), 546(3), 550, 550(1), 570, 687, 712
Vehicle Manufacturing, Repair, Services and Retail Award 2010
Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v EnergyAustralia Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 336
Fair Work Ombudsman v Crystal Carwash Cafe Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 1396
Fair Work Ombudsman v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 408
Tax Practitioners Board v Su [2014] FCA 731
Date of hearing: 4 July 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 54
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Y Shariff
Solicitor for the Applicant: Fair Work Ombudsman
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Sahade
Solicitor for the Respondents: Trinity Legal

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

NSD 1585 of 2012

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN
Applicant

AND:

CRYSTAL CARWASH CAFE PTY LTD (ACN 060 916 770)
First Respondent

ANTHONY SAHADE
Second Respondent

PETER KHOURI
Third Respondent

BADDINGTON PTY LTD (ACN 137 049 560)
Fourth Respondent

SEEKTON PTY LTD (ACN 137 049 579)
Fifth Respondent

OZREST PTY LTD (ACN 137 219 820)
Sixth Respondent

SCHATRY PTY LTD (ACN 137 219 802)
Seventh Respondent

COOLJAM PTY LTD (ACN 141 762 352)
Eighth Respondent

OZRUN PTY LTD (ACN 141 762 389)
Ninth Respondent

TUSHAR INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 141 758 045)
Tenth Respondent

LUCKY HORIZONS PTY LTD (ACN 144 648 975)
Eleventh Respondent

PEPPER STONE PTY LTD (ACN 144 649 427)
Twelfth Respondent

OAK MINK PTY LTD (ACN 145 471 941)
Thirteenth Respondent

JUDGE:

BUCHANAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 AUGUST 2014

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The first respondent, Crystal Carwash Cafe Pty Ltd (ACN…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Crystal Carwash Café Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 827
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) brought proceedings against Crystal Carwash Café Pty Ltd and related entities (collectively, the respondents) for underpayments of wages to carwash employees. The dispute centered on the respondents' use of purported labour hire arrangements to evade their obligations under the Vehicle Modern Award. The agreed facts revealed that the respondents established labour hire companies to employ carwash staff, paying them rates below the minimum required by the Award. The respondents claimed that these companies were the true employers, but later admitted that they were the actual employers of the staff. The primary issue before the court was the determination of an appropriate penalty for the respondents' contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009.

The court considered several factors in determining the penalty, including the respondents' conduct in setting up the labour hire companies, which was deemed to be without legitimate purpose and thus an aggravating factor. The respondents' cooperation in the proceedings, while helpful in avoiding a trial, was not considered a mitigating factor as it was self-serving and not driven by a genuine desire to assist the administration of justice. Additionally, the deliberate nature of the underpayments, which involved setting flat rate wages regardless of Award entitlements, further aggravated the seriousness of the contraventions. The involvement of senior management, with Mr Sahade and Mr Khouri both having responsibility for setting employment terms, also contributed to the gravity of the situation.

Ultimately, the court found that the respondents' actions warranted a substantial penalty. The respondents were ordered to pay a total penalty of $1,157,000, reflecting the seriousness of the contraventions and the need for deterrence and retribution. This decision underscores the importance of compliance with employment laws and the consequences of attempts to circumvent them through illegitimate business practices.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties made short oral submissions but, with one minor exception, they were content for the issue of penalty to be determined principally on the papers. The one exception related to the weight to be given to parts of an affidavit relied upon by the applicant in the penalty proceedings. That affidavit addressed some matters not covered by agreed facts. Agreed facts in the penalty proceedings On the question of penalty, the parties provided agreed facts which included the following: PART A: CRYSTAL CARWASH… 2.Crystal Carwash conducts the business of operating eleven carwashes and cafes trading as “Crystal Carwash Cafe” (Carwash Business) at the eleven addresses listed below: (a)57 Curlewis Street, Bondi Beach, New South Wales (Bondi Beach Site); (b)460 Parramatta Road, Strathfield, New South Wales (Strathfield Site); (c)612 Military Road, Mosman, New South Wales (Mosman Site); (d)2 – 6 Bream Street, Coogee, New South Wales (Coogee Site); (e)559 Pittwater Road, Brookvale, New South Wales (Brookvale Site); (f)312 Victoria Road, Gladesville, New South Wales (Gladesville Site); (g)185 Pitt Street, Merrylands, New South Wales (Merrylands Site); (h)67 New South Head Road, Rushcutters Bay, New South Wales (Rushcutters Bay Site); (i)315 Victoria Avenue, Chatswood, New South Wales (Chatswood Site); (j)777 New South Head Road, Rose Bay, New South Wales (Rose Bay Site); and (k)75 Sailors Bay, Northbridge, New South Wales (Northbridge Site); (collectively, Carwash Sites). … PART B: THE CARWASH ENTITIES4.In the period from 1 January 2010 to 18 September 2010 (Underpayment Period), the 359 individuals listed in Annexure A performed car washing and detailing duties for the Carwash Business at the Carwash Sites on either a full time or a part time basis (Carwash Employees). … PART C: PURPORTED LABOUR HIRE ENTITIES6.In the period from approximately 1999 to approximately 2007, Crystal Carwash was directly employing individuals to work as car washers at some or all of the Carwash Sites. 7.In the period from 12 May 2009 to 28 July 2010, Crystal Carwash established the following ten labour hire companies to purport to directly employ individuals performing car washing work at the Carwash Sites: (a)Baddington Pty Ltd (ACN 137 049 560) (Baddington); (b)Seekton Pty Ltd (ACN 137 049 579) (Seekton); (c)Ozrest Pty Ltd (ACN 137 219 820) (Ozrest); (d)Schatry Pty Ltd (ACN 137 219 802) (Schatry); (e)Cooljam Pty Ltd (ACN 141 762 352) (Cooljam); (f)Ozrun Pty Ltd (ACN 141 762 389) (Ozrun); (g)Tushar Investments Pty Ltd (ACN 141 758 045) (Tushar Investments); (h)Lucky Horizons Pty Ltd (ACN 144 648 975) (Lucky Horizons); (i)Pepper Stone Pty Ltd (ACN 144 649 427) (in administration) (Pepper Stone); (j)Oak Mink Pty Ltd Pty Ltd [sic] (ACN 145 471 941) (Oak Mink); and (collectively, Labour Hire Entities). The names of the Labour Hire Entities, their dates of incorporation, and other relevant details are set out in Annexure B. 8.Throughout the Underpayment Period, Crystal Carwash claimed that the Labour Hire Entities, and not Crystal Carwash were the employers of the Carwash Employees. PART D:THE PURPORTED LABOUR HIRE ARRANGEMENTS9.Pursuant to the purported labour hire arrangements between Crystal Carwash and the Labour Hire Entities, the Labour Hire Entities contracted with Crystal Carwash to operate the Carwash Business at the Carwash Sites, including by employing employees to perform carwashing duties at the Carwash Sites. 10.On a weekly, fortnightly or monthly basis, a representative of Crystal Carwash prepared an invoice on behalf of each Labour Hire Entity in order for the invoice to be issued to Crystal Carwash. 11.Approximately one to two days after each Labour Hire Entity issued the invoices to Crystal Carwash, Crystal Carwash made a payment to each Labour Hire Entity which was approximately equal to the amount of total wages that each of the Labour Hire Entities paid to the Carwash Employees for that particular period. 12.Crystal Carwash received all of the profits and takings generated from the operation of the Carwash Business at each of the Carwash Sites. 13.On 22 July 2013, Crystal Carwash admitted, for the purposes of these proceedings only, that it was the true employer of the Carwash Employees. PART E: THE EMPLOYMENT ARRANGEMENTS 14.The majority of the Carwash Employees were from a non-English speaking background. 15.The wages of the Carwash Employees was paid by one or more of the Labour Hire Entities. 16.During the Underpayment Period, the Labour Hire Entities paid the Carwash Employees either $13, $14 or $15 per hour. … 17.The wage rates referred to in paragraph 16 above were determined by Mr Sahade, Mr Khouri and/or other persons acting on the instructions or directions that were ultimately given by Mr Sahade or Mr Khouri. PART F:CONTRAVENTIONS…20.Pursuant to subclause 33.4 and item A.2.5 of the Vehicle Modern Award, during the period from 1 January 2010 to 30 June 2010, the minimum rate of pay payable to the Carwash Employees was $14.31. 21.Pursuant to subclause 33.4 and item A.2.4 of the Vehicle Modern Award, during the period from 1 July 2010 to 18 September 2010, the minimum rate of pay payable to the Carwash Employees was $15.00. (Emphasis in original.)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

However, the business practice revealed directly in the present case of setting up supposed labour hire companies (to which the affidavit material gave additional colour, but not extra weight) deserves censure and reflection in the penalties I fix. It can have no legitimate purpose (at least none was suggested) and is an aggravating aspect for which each of the first, second and third respondents must bear responsibility. Submission 5(e) – Co-operation and contrition The respondents submitted that their co-operation in the proceedings has saved the Court time and resources, which should be taken into account to mitigate any penalty. I give little weight to this submission. The conduct of the respondents in agreeing facts in these proceedings and not requiring a trial was clearly also in their interest. It was not done purely for the purpose of facilitating the resolution of these proceedings or to rectify the contraventions but also to help the respondents avoid the risks and further costs associated with a trial. I note the parties’ explicit agreement that the respondents were unco-operative during the Fair Work Ombudsman investigation. According to the agreed statement of facts, the respondents denied access to premises and refused to produce certain records sought by Fair Work Inspectors pursuant to a Notice to Produce issued under s 712 of the FW Act. The second respondent also declined to participate in a Record of Interview with a Fair Work Inspector. I do not overlook the fact that the respondents have contributed to the avoidance of the public (as well as private) inconvenience of a potentially lengthy hearing. However, I see no basis upon which to discount from any penalty otherwise appropriate. In my view, the respondents have acted principally from self-interest rather than from any particular desire to assist the administration of justice. I see no evidence of contrition. Submission 5(f) – Deliberateness of the contraventions The applicant contends the underpayment contraventions were deliberate and should be considered more serious as a result. No answering submissions were made on this point by the respondents. On the basis of the agreed facts I am satisfied that the conduct of the first, second and third respondents to make payment of a flat rate amount to employees regardless of Award entitlements, particularly overtime entitlements, was deliberate and calculated. Submission 5(g) – Involvement of senior management Based on the statement of agreed facts the applicant made the following submissions in relation to the second and third respondents: 8.Mr Sahade is the sole director and secretary of Crystal Carwash. Mr Sahade is responsible for the overall operation, directions and control of Crystal Carwash. Mr Sahade was a person with responsibility for setting the terms and conditions of the employment of the Carwash Employees. 9.Mr Khouri was employed by Crystal Carwash as a manager and along with Mr Sahade, also had responsibility for setting the terms and conditions of employment of the Carwash Employees.