Details
- Case
- [2023] FedCFamC2G 620
- Decision Date
-
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) filed a case against Carers Portland Inc and its director, principal, Chief Executive Officer, and owner, Ms Luong, seeking to enforce compliance with a Compliance Notice issued under section 716 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The dispute arose from allegations that Carers Portland Inc had failed to comply with provisions of the National Employment Standards and the relevant award, concerning the employment and payment of Ms Binh Tran. The case was heard by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.
The primary legal issues the Court had to decide included whether Ms Tran was an employee of Carers Portland Inc, whether the Compliance Notice was validly issued and served, whether the respondents failed to comply with the Compliance Notice, and whether there were any reasonable excuses for the non-compliance. Additionally, the Court had to determine whether Ms Luong, as the representative of the First Respondent, was involved in the contravention of the Fair Work Act.
The Court found that Ms Tran was indeed an employee of Carers Portland Inc, and the Compliance Notice was validly issued and served. Inspector Cox, who investigated the matter, had a reasonable belief that the First Respondent had contravened the Fair Work Act, which was substantiated by the evidence. The respondents did not comply with the Compliance Notice within the specified timeframe, and there were no reasonable excuses for their non-compliance. Furthermore, Ms Luong, as the representative of the First Respondent, was found to be involved in the contravention, given her control over the business and decisions related to Ms Tran's employment.
The Court ordered Carers Portland Inc to take specific steps to rectify the non-compliance, including paying Ms Tran the outstanding wages and superannuation contributions, and paying interest on the amounts owed. Additionally, both Carers Portland Inc and Ms Luong were ordered to pay pecuniary penalties to the Commonwealth for the contravention and involvement in the contravention, respectively.
This decision underscores the importance of compliance with the Fair Work Act and the consequences of failing to adhere to employment standards and award provisions.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Finally, section 717 of the Act sets out a mechanism in which a person who has been given a Compliance Notice may apply to the Court for a review of the Compliance Notice. No application to review the Compliance Notice was made in this case.EVIDENCE AND FINDINGSApplicant’s evidence The evidence leading to the issuing of the Compliance Notice, and the events relating to it, is set out in the affidavit of Inspector Cox. Ms Luong objected to the affidavit of Inspector Cox. The first objection was that Inspector Cox was based in Queensland, while the Respondents are in Victoria. That is not a basis to object to evidence, and I rejected it. The second objection was that the affidavit of Inspector Cox was witnessed by Sherilynn Ding (‘Ms Ding’). As I understood the objection, Ms Luong asserted that Ms Ding was not authorised or permitted to witness the affidavit of Inspector Cox, and the affidavit should have been witnessed by the Department of Justice. On this second objection, Inspector Cox’s affidavit was affirmed on 24 March 2023. Inspector Cox’s affidavit records Ms Ding as being an Australian Legal Practitioner. As it happens, Ms Ding has sworn various affidavits in this proceeding, the last of which was sworn on 24 November 2022. In that affidavit, Ms Ding deposes under oath that she is a solicitor in the sole employ of the law firm Maddocks. Accordingly, Ms Ding is a person properly authorised and capable of witnessing an affidavit. The second objection of Ms Luong was also, therefore, rejected. In her affidavit, Inspector Cox provides the following evidence:(a)She is an inspector with the office of the Applicant, properly appointed under section 700 of the Act;(b)On 30 July 2021 she received a request for assistance from Binh Tran (‘Ms Tran’) through Ms Tran’s sister;(c)In around September 2021, she commenced an investigation into the First Respondent in relation to Ms Tran’s complaint, and was assisted in that investigation by Fair Work Officer Madeleine Wainwright;(d)Ms Tran informed the officers of the Applicant that:(i)her employment with the First Respondent was facilitated through atWork Australia Pty Ltd (‘atWork’);(ii)she commenced work with the First Respondent on 4 January 2021;(iii)in the middle of May, she was told by a representative of the First Respondent to stay home;(iv)she was initially paid $20.00 per hour, then $20.06 per hour, then $20.21 per hour;(v)she was not paid for work performed from 3 to 6 May 2021, and 11 to 13 May 2021;(vi)she was employed as a kitchen hand, although she sometimes attended to customer service and cooking; (vii)food produced at the café of the First Respondent was usually placed in containers for customers to take away;(e)On 23 August 2021, the officers of the Applicant received an email containing a witness statement signed by Ms Tran on 22 August 2021, in which Ms Tran stated that:(i)she was employed as a kitchen hand at the café operated by the First Respondent from 4 January 2021 to 13 May 2021;(ii)her duties at the café included helping with preparing food, customer service and cleaning;(iii)she was paid $20.06 per hour;(iv)she was not provided with pay slips, and would be provided with a photo of a pay slip when she requested a payslip;(v)her employment had been facilitated via atWork and the First Respondent received a subsidy in exchange for employing Ms Tran;(vi)she worked 4 hours a day, 4 days a week and was paid fortnightly;(vii)she had worked 16 hours between 3 and 6 May 2021, and 12 hours between 11 and 13 May 2021, for which she had not been paid;(viii)she was not paid accrued but untaken annual leave at the end of her employment, and did not believe she was provided with notice of termination of her employment; (f)On 24 August 2021, officers of the Applicant received records of Ms Tran including text messages, payslips, handwritten notes of hours and shifts worked. Also received by officers of the Applicant on that day were other documents including a DES Wage Subsidy Agreement;(g)On 10 September 2021, officers of the Applicant received from Ms Tran bank statements for the period 3 May 2021 to 10 September 2021 showing payments apparently made by the Respondents as well as other records of hours worked; (h)On 8 November 2021, Ms Tran spoke to the Applicant and confirmed her employment commenced on 4 January 2021, that she was not paid for the first week of her employment, and that despite the DES Wage Subsidy Agreement containing a start date of 25 November 2020, she had not been allowed by the Respondents to commence work until January 2021;(i)On 8 November 2021, officers of the Applicant spoke to Nicole Stock from atWork by telephone. During that telephone call, Ms Stock said, among other things, that as far as she was aware, Ms Tran was a part-time kitchen hand, the First Respondent received a wage subsidy for employing Ms Tran, and the First Respondent only periodically provided payslips to atWork; and (j)On 10 November 2021, the Applicant received an email from Ms Tran attaching bank statements for the period 29 December 2020 to 29 June 2021 with various notations.
Decision
Reasons for decision
When these matters are considered, Ms Luong’s submission that Ms Tran was not an employee of the First Respondent is rejected. The evidence before the Court is, and I find, that Ms Tran was an employee of the First Respondent.CONCLUSIONS Having regard to all the evidence above, I find as follows:(a)Ms Tran was employed by the First Respondent;(b)Inspector Cox formed a reasonable belief that the First Respondent had contravened a provision of the National Employment Standards (‘NES’) (being sections 90 and 117 of the Act), and section 12.9 of the Award. The belief was reasonably held;(c)The Compliance Notice was issued to and received by the Respondents;(d)The Compliance Notice complied with the terms of subsections (2) and (3) of section 716 of the Act;(e)The Compliance Notice required the Respondents to take certain steps by 10 January 2022;(f)The Respondents did not take the steps required by the Compliance Notice within the relevant time frame; and(g)The Respondents do not have any reasonable excuse for failing to comply with the terms of the Compliance Notice as contemplated by section 716(6) of the Act. As a consequence of the findings I have made above, I am satisfied that the First Respondent has contravened section 716(5) of the Act. ACCESSORIAL LIABILITY OF MS LUONG Ms Luong is nominated as the representative of the First Respondent. During her evidence, Ms Luong confirmed that she was a director, principal, Chief Executive Officer and owner of the First Respondent, and that she owned the business. The evidence before me discloses that Ms Luong represented the First Respondent in all of its dealings with the Applicant. She also represented the First Respondent in this Court. It is clear from all the evidence that she made the decision to engage Ms Tran, and I infer given the apparent size of the business, made decisions in relation to what Ms Tran was to be paid, whether Ms Tran attended for work, and when she did not attend for work. There was a practical connection between her actions and the contravention. She knew the Compliance Notice was issued. She knew it had to be complied with. As the person with management control of the First Respondent she did not comply with the Compliance Notice. It is apparent from all of this, and I find, that she was involved in the contravention by the First Respondent within the meaning of section 550(2)(a) and (c) of the Act. THE ORDERS SOUGHT The Applicant sought orders and declarations as set out in its Outline of Submissions (which largely, but not identically, reflected the orders sought in the Statement of Claim). The orders sought as set out in the Outline of Submissions are as follows: The FWO seeks the following declarations.1.A declaration that the First Respondent contravened section 716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) by failing to comply with the compliance notice given to the First Respondent by Fair Work Inspector Cox (FWI Cox) on 3 December 2021 and pursuant to section 716 of the failing to comply with a compliance notice (Compliance Notice).2.A declaration that the Second Respondent was involved, within the meaning of section 550(2) of the FW Act, in the contravention by the First Respondent of section 716(5) of the FW Act in paragraph 1 above.The FWO seeks the following orders.3.Pursuant to section 545(2)(b) of the FW Act, the First Respondent take the steps that were required by the Compliance [Notice] within 28 days from the date of this order, by:(a) paying the amount of $1,881.05 to Ms Binh Tran;4.Pursuant to section 545(1) of the FW Act, the First Respondent take the steps that were required by the Compliance within 28 days from the date of this order, by:(a)calculating and paying into Ms Tran’s nominated superannuation fund any additional superannuation contributions required to be paid on the outstanding entitlements referred to in paragraph 3(a) above (as required by clause 21.2 of the Award); and (b)preparing and producing to the Applicant, a schedule outlining its calculations of the outstanding entitlements and additional superannuation contributions required to be paid to Ms Tran and providing proof that the outstanding entitlements and additional superannuation contributions were rectified as set out in paragraphs 3(a) and 4(a) above.5.Pursuant to section 547(2) of the FW Act, the First Respondent pay to Ms Tran interest on the amounts owed to her pursuant to paragraph 3(a) above within 28 days of the date of this order.6. Pursuant to section 546(1) of the FW Act:(a)the First Respondent pay a pecuniary penalty to the Commonwealth for the contravention set out in paragraph 1 above; and (b)the Second Respondent pay a pecuniary penalty to the Commonwealth for her involvement (within the meaning of section 550(2) of the FW Act) in the contravention pleaded in paragraph 2 above.7. Such further orders as the Court considers appropriate.