Fair Work Ombudsman v ANSA Finance Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v ANSA Finance Pty Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 833

File number: MLG 2773 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE FORBES
Date of judgment: 14 October 2022
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work Act – multiple Compliance Notices issued pursuant to s 716 - whether inspector had reasonable belief of contraventions – failure to comply with Compliance Notice – whether respondent had “reasonable excuse” for non-compliance – consideration of respondent’s reasons for non-compliance - whether respondent liable - whether manager of respondent involved in contraventions – accessorial liability under s 550
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 90, 117, 536, 550, 567, 568, 716, 717

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) s 141

Cases cited:

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Clarke (2007) 164 IR 299

Devonshire v Magellan Powertronics Pty Ltd [2013] FMCA 207

Fair Work Ombudsman v C & H Entertainment Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 1216

Fair Work Ombudsman v Gothic Downs Pty Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 21

Fair Work Ombudsman v Joys Child Care Limited & Anor [2019] FCCA 3356

Potter v Fair Work Ombudsman [2014] FCA 187

Qantas Airways Ltd v Transport Workers Union of Australia (2011) 280 ALR 503

Rural Press Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2002] FCAFC 213

Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 197
Date of hearing: 21 September 2022
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms Campbell of Counsel
Solicitor for the Applicant: HWL Ebsworth
First Respondent: Mr Fuoco with leave
Second Respondent: In person

ORDERS

MLG 2773 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

ANSA FINANCE PTY LTD

First Respondent

JOSHUA FUOCO

Second Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE FORBES

DATE OF ORDER:

14 OCTOBER 2022

NOTING THAT for the purposes of the following declarations and orders, the expressions “Chawla Compliance Notice”, “Mantzioukas Compliance Notice”, “White Compliance Notice” and “Jern Compliance Notice” shall each bear the meaning attributed to same in the statement of claim filed by the Applicant on 21 October 2021

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The First Respondent (Ansa Finance) contravened sub-sections:

(a)716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act), by failing to comply with the Chawla Compliance Notice, the Mantzioukas Compliance Notice, the White Compliance Notice and the Jern Compliance Notice; and

(b)536(1) of the FW Act, by failing to give pay slips to Mr Mantzioukas within one working day of payments being made to him in relation to the performance of work.

2.That the Second Respondent was involved, within the meaning of section 550(2) of the FW Act, in the contraventions by Ansa Finance of section 716(5) and section 536(1) of the FW Act referred to in declaration 1 above.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

3.Pursuant to section 545(1) of the FW Act, Ansa Finance take the steps that were required by the Chawla Compliance Notice, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v ANSA Finance Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 833
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Fair Work Ombudsman filed proceedings against ANSA Finance Pty Ltd and its director, Mr Fuoco, in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, alleging contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act). The primary dispute involves ANSA Finance's failure to comply with four separate compliance notices issued by Fair Work Inspectors. These notices pertained to underpayments of wages and entitlements to employees Ms Chawla, Mr Mantzioukas, Ms White, and Mr Jern. The central legal issues centred around whether ANSA Finance had a reasonable excuse for its non-compliance with the compliance notices and if Mr Fuoco was accessorily liable for the contraventions.

The Court found that the Fair Work Inspectors had formed reasonable beliefs that ANSA Finance had contravened the provisions of the Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2020 and the National Employment Standards (NES). This was based on the information available to the Inspectors at the time the reasonable beliefs were formed. ANSA Finance did not challenge the validity of the compliance notices or the reasonable belief held by the Inspectors. The Court held that ANSA Finance had not demonstrated a reasonable excuse for its failure to comply with the notices. The company's decision not to comply with the notices was a matter of choice, not capacity. The Court found that ANSA Finance had failed to provide payslips to Mr Mantzioukas within one working day of paying him for work performed, contravening section 536(1) of the FW Act. Furthermore, the Court found Mr Fuoco accessorily liable for ANSA Finance's contraventions under section 550(1) of the FW Act.

The Court ordered that ANSA Finance pay pecuniary penalties for each contravention and Mr Fuoco pay a penalty for his involvement in the contraventions. Additionally, the Court ordered ANSA Finance to rectify the underpayments to the affected employees and provide payslips to Mr Mantzioukas. The Court also made orders for costs in favour of the Fair Work Ombudsman.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In its written outline of submissions the Ombudsman conveniently and accurately describes the statutory scheme within which the FW Act compliance notice regime operates. Citing relevant and binding authority, the Ombudsman describes the intent and operation of the scheme as follows[2]:[2] Outline of Submissions at [10]-[18]10. Section 716 of the FW Act enables a Fair Work Inspector (FWI) to issue a compliance notice as a means to address identified non-compliance with certain obligations arising under the FW Act, including an employer’s obligations under a modern award and the National Employment Standards (NES).11. The ability for a FWI to issue a compliance notice is to provide a mechanism for the efficient and cost-effective rectification of identified contraventions of the FW Act, including underpayments, as an alternative to commencing litigation[3].[3] Fair Work Ombudsman v Baal Gammon Copper Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 348 at [9]; Fair Work Ombudsman v Anahata Naturals Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 2954 at [41]12.In order to issue a compliance notice to an employer in respect of a contravention of a term of a modern award or NES, the FWI must hold a reasonable belief that the employer has contravened that term. The test for the circumstances sufficient to constitute a reasonable belief were described by the High Court in George v Rockett[4]. As summarised by this Court, the test for a reasonable belief is more than a suspicion, there must be a rational basis for the belief, and it requires an assessment to be made based on the information available to the FWI at the time the reasonable belief was formed. It does not require proof on a balance of probabilities, nor is it to be based on information that might be known at a future point in time.[5] [4] (1990) 170 CLR 104, 116[5] Fair Work Ombudsman v Gothic Downs Pty Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 21 at [22] (Gothic Downs)13. The compliance notice may require the employer to do either or both of the following within such reasonable time as is specified in the notice:(a) take specified action to remedy the direct effects of the contravention; and(b) produce reasonable evidence of the person’s compliance with the notice.14. The compliance notice must contain the matters set out in section 716(3) of the FW Act.15.An employer that fails to comply with a compliance notice contravenes section 716(5) of the FW Act (which is a civil remedy provision), unless they have a “reasonable excuse”. An employer who seeks to rely on the exception of “reasonable excuse” bears the onus of proof[6]. In order to demonstrate a reasonable excuse, it must be an excuse that would be regarded as reasonable by a reasonable person in the relevant circumstances[7].16.A breach of section 716(5) is established by proving that the relevant notice was given and that there was subsequent non-compliance with the notice. Categorical proof of the underlying breaches of the modern award or NES is not required[8].17.Section 717 of the FW Act provides an employer with the ability to apply to the Court to challenge a compliance notice issued to it. This is on the ground that either or both:(a)the employer has not committed one or more of the contraventions set out in the compliance notice; and/or(b)the compliance notice does not comply with section 716(20 or (3) of the FW Act.18.Where an employer seeks to apply to challenge a compliance notice issued to it pursuant to section 717 of the FW Act, the Court may confirm, cancel or vary the notice as a result of that challenge. It is through this process that a person conventional late the question of whether the contraventions set out in the compliance notice occurred[9], or if the compliance notice did not comply with section 716(2) or (3) of the FW Act.[6] Potter v Fair Work Ombudsman [2014] FCA 187 at [72]; Fair Work Ombudsman v Joys Child Care Limited & Anor [2019] FCCA 3356 at [20][7] Fair Work Ombudsman v C&H Entertainment Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 1216[8] Gothic Downs at [13][9] Gothic Downs at [15]Brief procedural background

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondents relied upon the affidavit and outline of submissions filed by Mr Fuoco on 7 September 2022. Mr Fuoco gave some oral evidence and was cross-examined. He also tendered a number of documents without objection.Evidence of the alleged contraventions The narrative set out below is derived from the affidavits and cross-examination referred to above. Unless otherwise stated the evidence was not challenged.The Chawla Compliance Notice Ms Chawla was employed by Ansa Finance on a full-time basis between 13 September 2020 and 27 November 2020. By virtue of the nature of her work (about which there is some minor but immaterial disagreement) she was covered by the Banking, Finance and Insurance Award 2020 (the Award) and was entitled to the minimum rates of pay and other entitlements prescribed by that instrument. From on or about 6 January 2021, following a complaint to the Ombudsman, FWIs Cox and Tran commenced an investigation into the circumstances of Ms Chawla’s employment. In the course of that investigation there were numerous communications between the inspectors and Mr Fuoco during which it is alleged that Mr Fuoco made admissions including that Ms Chawla was owed approximately $1,200.00. Ms Cox gave evidence that by 19 January 2021, based on information obtained during the course of that investigation, she formed a reasonable belief[14] pursuant to s 716(1) of the FW Act that:(a)Ms Chawla was employed by Ansa Finance on a full-time basis during the period 13 September 2020 until 27 November 2020;(b)Ms Chawla was covered by the Award and was classified as a Level 3 employee; and(c)Ansa Finance had contravened provisions of the Award and the National Employment Standards (NES) by not paying Ms Chawla the wages that were owed to her for work performed between 13 November 2020 and 27 November 2020 and payments in respect of accrued and untaken annual leave on termination of her employment, including annual leave loading.[14] Cox affidavit at [10], Annexure CMC-6 By reason of her reasonable belief that Ansa Finance had contravened the Award and NES, Ms Cox issued a compliance notice to Ansa Finance on 21 January 2021 (Chawla Compliance Notice) The Chawla Compliance Notice [15] required Ansa Finance to(a)calculate Ms Chawla's entitlements under the Award with respect to clauses 15.1 (minimum rates) and 22.3 (annual leave loading) of the Award, and the NES with respect to section 90(2) (annual leave on termination) of the FW Act;(b)rectify any underpayment of those entitlements by 24 February 2021; and(c)provide a schedule of Ansa Finance's calculations and proof of rectification of any underpayment by 3 March 2021. [15] Cox affidavit at [12], annexure CMC-8 The Chawla Compliance Notice contained an explanation regarding the consequences of any failure to comply, including that the recipient may contravene a civil remedy provision. The notice also informed Ansa Finance that it may apply for a review of the Compliance Notice on the grounds that the company had not committed a contravention as set out in the notice and/or that the notice did not comply with section 716 of the FW Act.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This submission appears to attack the underlying contravention rather than the compliance notice itself. As I have already discussed, disagreement with the notice does not constitute a reasonable excuse. If Ansa Finance was of the view that it had not committed one or more of the contraventions set out in the Compliance Notices, it could have made an application to seek review of the notice. It has not done so. Conclusion on reasonable excuse For the reasons set out above, the first respondent has not demonstrated a reasonable excuse for its failure to comply with each of the Chawla, Mantzioukas, White and Jern Compliance Notices. It seems to me on the evidence that the company and Mr Fuoco made choices about how the company’s resources, finances and his time were best allocated. I am not unsympathetic to the conundrum faced by small businesses in the midst of economic uncertainty, where no doubt difficult choices have to be made. However, implicit in the decision to get the company back on its feet before attending to outstanding statutory obligations is a value judgement about where employee entitlements sit in the hierarchy of corporate priorities. There can be few priorities more important than discharging the statutory obligation of calculating an employee’s entitlements in accordance with binding fair work instruments and paying employees what they are entitled to receive at the time they are entitled to receive it. The decision not to comply was a decision of choice, not capacity.Payslips - Contravention of section 536(1) Section 536(1) of the FW Act requires an employer to give an employee a payslip within one working day of paying the employee for the performance of work. The evidence satisfies me that Mr Mantzioukas was employed by Ansa Finance and performed work for the first respondent during the period 7 December 2020 until at least early February 2021. Although there is some dispute about his end date, it is not contested that he was employed for at least that period. Ansa Finance did not provide Mr Mantzioukas with payslips until May 2021[59]. Although the respondents deny that they contravened s 536(1), they admit having failed to provide Mr Mantzioukas payslips within one day of paying him an amount in relation to the performance of work. [59] Cox affidavit at [35], Annexure CMC-26 The elements of that contravention are made out. Accessorial Liability The Ombudsman seeks a declaration that Mr Fuoco was involved in each of Ansa Finance’s contraventions pursuant to section 550(1) of the FW Act. Section 550 has the effect of deeming a person involved in a contravention (often referred to as an accessory) to be a contravenor. That is, where a person has been “involved in” a contravention in the requisite sense, that person is taken to have contravened the civil remedy provision him or herself. Section 550 is not a civil remedy provision itself and it does not establish a separate contravention. Rather, it deems an accessory to a contravention to be a contravenor and operates to enable that person’s involvement in the contravention to be “treated in the same way as actual contravention”[60][60] see Heading to s 550; see also Devonshire v Magellan Powertronics Pty Ltd [2013] FMCA 207 at [81], [84]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, Mr Fuoco submitted that the Mantzoukis and White Compliance Notices were not valid because those employees had “failed to satisfy the performance of work defined by the FW Act”. The substance of this submission was somewhat vague and not properly developed, but I infer that Mr Fuoco believes that those employees either did not perform or adequately perform work during the alleged period of employment (White) or engaged in conduct which was not consistent with their employment contracts (Mantzoukis), such that they were not at law entitled to the underpayments alleged. Consideration It is to be recalled that the Ombudsman seeks declarations and orders against the respondents in relation to four alleged contraventions of s 716(5) of the FW Act. The facts that the Ombudsman must prove to establish those contraventions are that:(a)a Fair Work Inspector formed the reasonable belief that Ansa Finance had contravened one or more of the fair work instruments referred to in s 716(1);(b)the Fair Work Inspector issued Compliance Notices requiring Ansa Finance to do one or more things contemplated by section 716(2);(c)each Compliance Notice was given to Ansa Finance; and(d)Ansa Finance failed to comply with each of the Compliance Notices. To establish liability on the part of Mr Fuoco, the Ombudsman must also establish to the requisite level of proof that Mr Fuoco was “involved” in the company’s contraventions. The issue of accessorial liability is dealt with later in these reasons. The Ombudsman submits that it is not an element of the contraventions that Ansa Finance did not have a “reasonable excuse” – in other words it does not fall to the Ombudsman to prove the negative. The Ombudsman submits that it is for the respondent to raise “reasonable excuse” as a defence to an alleged contravention of s 716(5) and that it falls to the respondent to produce evidence and satisfy the Court that a reasonable excuse existed at the relevant time. An employer who seeks to rely on the exception of “reasonable excuse” bears the onus of proof[48].[48] Potter v Fair Work Ombudsman [2014] FCA 187 at [72]; Fair Work Ombudsman v Joys Child Care Limited & Anor [2019] FCCA 3356 at [20] The Ombudsman also submits that whether or not a reasonable excuse exists is an objective fact to be determined by the Court on all the evidence; it is not to be determined based on the respondent’s subjective belief. It must be an excuse that would be regarded as reasonable by a reasonable person in the relevant circumstances[49].[49] Fair Work Ombudsman v C&H Entertainment Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 1216 Turning then to each of the elements of the alleged contraventions.Inspector’s reasonable belief In relation to each Contravention Notice, the Ombudsman must prove that a Fair Work Inspector formed the reasonable belief that Ansa Finance had contravened one or more of the fair work instruments referred to in s 716(1) of the FW Act. In determining whether or not there was a reasonable belief, is not necessary for the Court to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the underlying contraventions of fair work instruments have in fact occurred. The proper test is whether there was a rational basis for the Inspector’s belief based on the information available to the Inspector at the time the reasonable belief was formed[50].[50] Gothic Downs at [22]