FAI Home Security Pty Ltd v Jay-N-Tee Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FAI Home Security Pty Ltd v Jay-N-Tee Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1408

FAI HOME SECURITY PTY LTD V JAY-N-TEE PTY LTD, ROBERT JAMES GILL, CRAIG MICHAEL BROWNE AND CRAIG BROWNE PTY LTD

S 74 OF 1999

JUDGE:         FINKELSTEIN J
DATE:           13 SEPTMEBER 1999
PLACE:         MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

S 74 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

FAI HOME SECURITY PTY LTD
Applicant

AND:

JAY-N-TEE PTY LTD, ROBERT JAMES GILL,
CRAIG MICHAEL BROWNE and
CRAIG BROWNE PTY LTD
Respondents

JUDGE:

FINKELSTEIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

13 SEPTEMBER 1999

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE (via video link to Adelaide)

UPON the Applicant by its counsel undertaking that it will pay to any party adversely affected by the interlocutory injunction such compensation (if any) as the Court thinks just, in such manner as the Court directs.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Order No 1 made by Finkelstein J on 1 September 1999 be continued up to and including 4.15 pm (Eastern Standard Time) on 5 October 1999.

2.The First and Second Respondent’s Notice of Motion dated 8 September 1999 be dismissed.

3.The Third and Fourth Respondent’s Notice of Motion dated 8 September 1999 be dismissed.

4.The First and Second Respondent’s pay 80% of the Applicant’s costs of the Notice of Motion referred to in paragraph 2 above.

5.The Third and Fourth Respondent’s pay 80% of the Applicant’s costs of the Notice of Motion referred to in paragraph 3 above.

6.Leave be granted to the Applicant to amend the Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Mr Peter Giannoss by deleting “9 September 1999” as the return date and inserting in its place “16 September 1999”.

7.The Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Jay-N-Tee Pty Limited be amended by:

(a)deleting the word “to” in the first line of paragraph 1 of the Schedule and inserting in its place the word “or”;

(b)deleting the words “or sales documents’ in the first line of paragraph 2 of the Schedule;

(c)deleting the word “to” in the first line of paragraph 2 of the Schedule and inserting in its place the word “or”; and

(d)deleting the words “evidencing or” in the first line of paragraph 3 of the Schedule;

8.The Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Peter Giannoss be amended by:

(a)deleting the words “or sales documents’ in the first line of paragraph 2 of the Schedule;

(b)deleting the words “evidencing or” in the first line of paragraph 4 of the Schedule;

9.The Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Craig Michael Browne, Craig Browne Pty Limited, Alex Kratz, Sam Bessell, Craig Haldane and Robert James Gill be amended by:

(a)deleting the words “or sales documents’ in the first line of paragraph 2 of the Schedule;

(b)deleting the words “evidencing or” in the first line of paragraph 3 of the Schedule;

10.The Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Jay-N-Tee Pty Limited, Peter Giannoss, Craig Michael Browne, Craig Browne Pty Limited, Alex Kratz, Sam Bessell, Craig Haldane…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FAI Home Security Pty Ltd v Jay-N-Tee Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1408
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

FAI Home Security Pty Ltd brought an application against Jay-N-Tee Pty Ltd, Craig Michael Browne, Craig Browne Pty Limited, Alex Kratz, Sam Bessell, Craig Haldane and Robert James Gill, for interlocutory injunctions and an extension of time to serve a subpoena to produce documents. The matter was heard by Finkelstein J of the Federal Court of Australia. The applicant sought an extension of time to serve a subpoena to produce documents on various respondents. The respondents opposed the extension of time and sought to set aside the subpoena on various grounds. The court was required to decide whether the applicant was entitled to an extension of time to serve the subpoena and, if so, on what terms. The court was also required to decide whether the subpoena was properly served and, if not, whether it could be amended to cure any defects.

The court found that the applicant had made a sufficient showing to justify the extension of time to serve the subpoena. The court found that the subpoena had not been properly served on some of the respondents and that the defects in the subpoena could be cured by amendment. The court dismissed the respondents' motions to set aside the subpoena and ordered that the subpoena be amended and served on the respondents. The court also granted leave to the applicant to amend the subpoena to produce documents to Mr Peter Giannoss by deleting the return date and inserting in its place a new date. The court adjourned the further hearing of the application for interlocutory injunctions and directed that the parties attend a mediation conference before the Registrar in Adelaide.

The court made orders extending the time for serving the subpoena, dismissing the respondents' motions to set aside the subpoena, granting leave to amend the subpoena to produce documents, and amending the subpoena to produce documents in various respects. The court also adjourned the further hearing of the application for interlocutory injunctions and directed that the parties attend a mediation conference. The court ordered that the First and Second Respondents pay 80% of the Applicant's costs of their Notice of Motion, and that the Third and Fourth Respondents pay 80% of the Applicant's costs of their Notice of Motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Order No 1 made by Finkelstein J on 1 September 1999 be continued up to and including 4.15 pm (Eastern Standard Time) on 5 October 1999.

2. The First and Second Respondent’s Notice of Motion dated 8 September 1999 be dismissed.

3. The Third and Fourth Respondent’s Notice of Motion dated 8 September 1999 be dismissed.

4. The First and Second Respondent’s pay 80% of the Applicant’s costs of the Notice of Motion referred to in paragraph 2 above.

5. The Third and Fourth Respondent’s pay 80% of the Applicant’s costs of the Notice of Motion referred to in paragraph 3 above.

6. Leave be granted to the Applicant to amend the Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Mr Peter Giannoss by deleting “9 September 1999” as the return date and inserting in its place “16 September 1999”.

7. The Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Jay-N-Tee Pty Limited be amended by:

(a) deleting the word “to” in the first line of paragraph 1 of the Schedule and inserting in its place the word “or”;

(b) deleting the words “or sales documents’ in the first line of paragraph 2 of the Schedule;

(c) deleting the word “to” in the first line of paragraph 2 of the Schedule and inserting in its place the word “or”; and

(d) deleting the words “evidencing or” in the first line of paragraph 3 of the Schedule;

8. The Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Peter Giannoss be amended by:

(a) deleting the words “or sales documents’ in the first line of paragraph 2 of the Schedule;

(b) deleting the words “evidencing or” in the first line of paragraph 4 of the Schedule;

9. The Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Craig Michael Browne, Craig Browne Pty Limited, Alex Kratz, Sam Bessell, Craig Haldane and Robert James Gill be amended by:

(a) deleting the words “or sales documents’ in the first line of paragraph 2 of the Schedule;

(b) deleting the words “evidencing or” in the first line of paragraph 3 of the Schedule;

10. The Subpoena to Produce dated 7 September 1999 to Jay-N-Tee Pty Limited, Peter Giannoss, Craig Michael Browne, Craig Browne Pty Limited, Alex Kratz, Sam Bessell, Craig Haldane and Robert James Gill be adjourned to 10.00 am (Central Standard Time) on Thursday 16 September 1999 before the Registrar in Adelaide.

11. The further hearing of the application for Interlocutory Injunctions is adjourned to 2.15 pm (Eastern Standard Time) on Tuesday 5 October 1999.

THE COURT DIRECTS THAT:

12. The parties attend a mediation conference before the Registrar in Adelaide at a time to be agreed upon by the parties.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established