Fabcot Pty Ltd v Cairns Regional Council (No. 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Fabcot Pty Ltd v Cairns Regional Council & Ors (No. 3) [2022] QPEC 12

PARTIES:

FABCOT PTY LTD ACN 002 960 983

(Appellant)

v

CAIRNS REGIONAL COUNCIL

(Respondent)

AND

DEXUS FUNDS MANAGEMENT ACN 060 920 783

AND

CAIRNS COMBINED BEACHES COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION INC
(Second Co-Respondent by Election)

AND

INDIGENOUS BUSINESS ASUTRALIA AS TRUSTEE FOR THE IREIT SUB-TRUST

(Third Co-Respondent by Election)

AND

TRINITY PARK INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 123 732 525 ATF AND L’ARMONIA PTY LTD ACN 140 784 756

(Fourth Co-Respondent by Election)

FILE NO:

201 of 2018, 221 of 2018, 223 of 2018

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Appeals

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court, Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

3 May 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4 – 7 April 2022

JUDGE:

Everson DCJ

ORDER:

1.          Appeal 201 of 2018 will be allowed subject to the imposition of appropriate lawful conditions;

2.          Appeal 221 of 2018 is dismissed; and

3.          Appeal 223 of 2018 is dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – APPEALS – appeals against a preliminary approval for a Shopping Centre and Health Care Services and a development permit for a Child Care Centre, Service Station and Food and Drink Outlet and reconfiguring a lot and operational work in the Low-medium density residential zone

ASSESSMENT – LACK OF COMPLIANCE WITH THE PLANNING SCHEME – RELEVANT MATTERS – whether there are relevant matters which justify approval despite non-compliance with provisions of the Low-medium density residential zone

LEGISLATION:

Planning Act 2016 (Qld)

Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (Qld)

CASES:

Ashvan Investments Unit Trust v Brisbane City Council & Ors (2019) QPELR 793

Abeleda & Anor v Brisbane City Council & Anor [2020] QCA 257

COUNSEL:

BD Job QC and MJ Batty for the Appellant
RS Litster QC and K Buckley for the Respondent
DR Gore QC and JG Lyons for the First Co-Respondent by Election 
EJ Morzone QC and K W Wylie for the Fourth Co-Respondent by Election

SOLICITORS:

Keir Steele Lawyers for the Appellant
McCullough Robertson for the Respondent

Hopgood Ganim for the First Co-Respondent by Election Emanate Legal for the Fourth Co-Respondent by Election

Introduction

  1. This is a rehearing after a successful appeal to the Court of Appeal. It is limited in scope as the appeal succeeded on only one ground. I will now set out the relevant history of the matter.

  2. On 10 October 2018, the respondent (“the Council”) issued a preliminary approval for a Shopping Centre and Health Care Services and reconfiguration of a lot into 14 lots, together with a development permit for a Child Care Centre, Service Station, Food and Drink Outlet, operational work for an Advertising Device, and reconfiguring a lot into four lots and an access easement (“the proposed development”) on land situated at 171-173 and 175 Trinity Beach Road, Trinity Beach (“the site”).

  3. The decision of the respondent in the above terms resulted in four appeals to the Planning and Environment Court at Cairns. On 18 April 2019, the Court ordered that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fabcot Pty Ltd v Cairns Regional Council (No. 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QPEC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fabcot Pty Ltd initiated an appeal against Cairns Regional Council's decision to refuse a preliminary approval for a shopping centre and health care services, a development permit for a childcare centre, service station, and food and drink outlet, and to reconfigure a lot and undertake operational work in a Low-medium density residential (LMDR) zone. The matter was heard in the Queensland Planning and Environment Court. The central legal issues were whether there were relevant matters that justified the approval of the development despite non-compliance with the LMDR Zone Code and the appropriate weight to be given to subsequent amendments to the Planning Scheme.

The Court found that several relevant matters justified the approval of the proposed development. These included the need for the uses proposed, the co-location efficiencies, and the ideal location of the site to serve the growing community. The Court determined that the Planning Scheme amendments made after the development application was properly made should not be given weight because the development was impact assessable. The Court also considered the approval of a large residential development nearby, which increased the residential capacity of the area, as a relevant matter that supported the approval of the proposed development. The Court concluded that the factors favouring approval outweighed those against it, given the site's superior location and the pressing need for the proposed uses.

Accordingly, the Court allowed Appeal 201 of 2018 subject to the imposition of appropriate lawful conditions, dismissed Appeal 221 of 2018, and dismissed Appeal 223 of 2018. The orders were that Appeal 201 of 2018 would be allowed subject to the imposition of appropriate lawful conditions, and Appeals 221 and 223 of 2018 were dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal 201 of 2018 will be allowed subject to the imposition of appropriate lawful conditions;

2. Appeal 221 of 2018 is dismissed; and

3. Appeal 223 of 2018 is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I also expressly found a number of relevant matters, other than the need for it, justified approval of the proposed development which I summarised as follows:“I accept that there will be efficiencies achieved by the co-location of the uses in the proposed development, all of which are well-located to serve the growing community identified in the PTA. The need for the uses in the proposed development coupled with the gap in the provision of a full-line supermarket to provide for the need, justifies the creation of a new centre on the site as contemplated in the Strategic framework of the Planning Scheme. The meeting of this need at a site which from the perspective of the planning evidence before me is ideally located to meet that need, is a powerful consideration. This consideration, together with the fact that it will provide the local community with the opportunity of shopping for the necessities of life and utilising the ancillary uses without having to journey along the at times congested Captain Cook Highway, clearly justify the proposed development despite the fact that it is not small-scale.”[26][26]Ibid at [59].The new evidence While I must assess the development application against or having regard to the version of the Planning Scheme in effect when the development application was properly made, I may give the weight I consider appropriate in the circumstances, to any amendments to it after the development application is properly made but before it is decided.[27][27]Planning Act 2016 s 45(7)-(8). Version 3.0 of the Planning Scheme commenced on 26 October 2021. It contains notes in various zone codes which are part of the Planning Scheme.[28] These notes have the effect of making code assessable development in the LMDR Zone subject to the centres strategy pursuant to the strategic framework which is described in s 3.3.2 of the Planning Scheme.[29] As the proposed development was impact assessable I have already assessed it having regard to these provisions and accordingly I am of the view that no weight should be given to the Planning Scheme amendments in Version 3.0.[28]Planning Scheme v3.0 s 1.3.2(3).[29]Ibid s 3.3.2. On 23 March 2022 the Council approved the construction of a new link road between Kewarra Beach and Trinity Beach providing increased access for certain residents of Kewarra Beach to the proposed development without having to travel along the Captain Cook Highway.[30][30]Exhibits R11, R12 and R13. By a judgment dated 21 July 2021, the P&E Court approved a large residential development called The Palms, within three kilometres to the north of the site.[31] Mr Norling, the economic consultant who gave further evidence on behalf of the Council, stated that this provides for additional residential capacity which he estimates at about 500 dwellings.[32] He asserts that the effect of the approval has been to increase the residential capacity of the adjoining suburb to the north, Kewarra Beach, by about 1,200 people and that this increase was not taken into account in the evidence presented to me at the first hearing.[33][31]Exhibit R19.[32]Exhibit R7, para 31.[33]Ibid, para 34.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The scale of the supermarket component of the proposed development makes it inevitable that it will not comply with the provisions of the LMDR Zone Code identified above, however this occurs in the context of the strategic framework allowing for the establishment of a new centre on the site. Even assuming a potential for eventual consolidation or co-location with similar complementary activities in Sub-precinct 3b, the TPI land is not as well located to serve the pressing need identified within the PTA.[52] The location of the site on a large roundabout on the Captain Cook Highway at the gateway to the significant dormitory suburb of Trinity Beach, is a far superior location for catering for the identified need than the TPI land. The locational attributes of the proposed development are only enhanced when one considers that the recent approval of The Palms development at Kewarra Beach is within 3 kilometres of the proposed development, to the north of the site. The TPI land is considerably south of it.[53] They are further enhanced when one considers the co-location of other uses, for which a need also currently exists, namely the Child Care Centre, the Medical Centre and the Service Station. The Planning Scheme contemplates the establishment of a new centre such as the proposed development when certain pre-conditions have been met. I have already concluded they have been met in the first P&E Court decision.[54] The factors which favour the approval of the proposed development far outweigh factors in favour of refusal of it, as a consequence of it not being small scale and it serving a larger catchment than what is contemplated in the relevant provisions of the LMDR Zone Code.[52]Exhibit R6, p 11, map 3.1.[53]Ibid.[54][2020] QPEC 17 at [53].Conclusion While the proposed development is at significant variance with identified provisions of the LMDR Zone Code, in that it is not small scale and will not only serve local residents or the local community, it is ideally located to serve the pressing need for it. While there will be a loss of some foot traffic at the Smithfield Shopping Centre and a code assessable proposal for a shopping centre incorporating a full-line supermarket on the TPI land is now ready for hearing, the locational attributes of the proposed development in meeting the pressing need for it far outweigh these factors. I therefore will allow Appeal 201 of 2018 subject to the imposition of appropriate lawful conditions. I therefore dismiss Appeals 221 and 223 of 2018.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.