SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL Not Restricted No. 7906 of 1996 No. 7550 of 1996
F. & F. HOLDINGS PTY. LTD. (A.C.N. 004 555 239) Appellant v RIDGE LANE PTY. LTD. (ACN 005 626 960) First Respondent - and - ASPENDALE GARDENS SHOPPING CENTRE PTY. LTD. Second Respondent (A.C.N. 069 321 928) (RECEIVER AND MANAGER
APPOINTED)
---
JUDGES: ORMISTON, PHILLIPS and KENNY, JJ.A. WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE DATE OF HEARING: 19, 20 and 24 August 1998 DATE OF JUDGMENT: 14 October 1998 CASE MAY BE CITED AS: F. & F. Holdings Pty. Ltd. v. Ridge Lane Pty. Ltd. MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION: [1998] VSCA 72
---
PROPERTY LAW - Torrens system - Priorities - Whether first mortgagee entitled to priority over holder of charge pursuant to consultancy agreements between vendor of land and mortgagor - Land purportedly charged by purchaser in favour of vendor - Vendor induced to forego rights under first agreement in return for second agreement - Share security under second agreement made worthless by purchaser's subsequent acts - Whether mortgagee party to fraudulent scheme - Caveat lodged by vendor after registration of mortgage - Whether priority of first registered mortgage lost by reason of fraud - Transfer of Land Act 1958, ss.42, 43 and 44.
---
APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors For the Appellant Dr C.L. Pannam Q.C. and Jack Cohen, Serry & Co. Mr S.M. Anderson For the Respondents Mr D.R. Meagher Q.C. and Tasiopoulos, Lambros & Co. Mr N. Pane
ORMISTON, J. A.:
I have had the benefit of reading the judgment of Kenny, J.A. in draft form and, for the reasons she expresses, I agree that this appeal should be allowed.
PHILLIPS, J. A.:
I agree in the judgment of Kenny, J.A.
| KENNY, J. A.: |
On 6 October 1995 a company called Ridge Lane Pty. Ltd. ("Ridge Lane") brought an action against Daleford Glen Pty. Ltd. ("Daleford Glen") and Aspendale Gardens Shopping Centre Pty. Ltd. ("Aspendale Gardens"), claiming moneys due under two consultancy agreements with Daleford Glen dated 23 November 1994 and 5 April 1995 and declarations that land registered in the name of Aspendale Gardens (“the Aspendale land”) was charged with the payment of those moneys. On 21 June 1996 Hansen, J. by judgment ordered, amongst other things, that Daleford Glen pay Ridge Lane the sum of $480,885.92. His Honour also declared that Ridge Lane held a charge over the Aspendale land pursuant to the consultancy agreements and that Aspendale Gardens held its interest in the land subject to that charge. After judgment had been given, a priority dispute arose between Ridge Lane as chargee and F. & F. Holdings Pty. Ltd. ("F&F") as registered first mortgagee and it is that dispute which is now before us. (On 15 October 1996 Ridge Lane issued a summons against Daleford Glen and Aspendale Gardens seeking sale by public auction and payment of the proceeds into Court pending further orders. The hearing of that summons has been adjourned pending the determination of these appeals.)
The proceedings the subject…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read F & F Holdings Pty Ltd v Ridge Lane Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] VSCA 72
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included the interpretation of the consultancy agreements and whether the vendor's decision to forego rights under the first agreement was induced by fraud. Another key issue was whether the purchaser's subsequent actions rendered the charge under the second agreement worthless, and if so, whether this affected the priority of the first mortgage. The court also had to consider whether the mortgagee was party to a fraudulent scheme and if the lodgement of a caveat by the vendor after the registration of the mortgage affected the priority of the first registered mortgage.
The court examined the evidence and concluded that the vendor's decision to forego rights under the first agreement was indeed induced by fraud. The court found that the purchaser's subsequent actions rendered the charge under the second agreement worthless, but this did not affect the priority of the first mortgage. The court held that the mortgagee was not a party to a fraudulent scheme. The lodgement of a caveat by the vendor after the registration of the mortgage did not impact the priority of the first registered mortgage. Consequently, the court ruled in favor of the first mortgagee, F & F Holdings, granting them priority over the charge held by Ridge Lane.
The court ordered that F & F Holdings Pty Ltd, as the first mortgagee, is entitled to priority over Ridge Lane Pty Ltd, which holds a charge under the consultancy agreements. The court also determined that the fraudulent inducement of the vendor to forego rights under the first agreement did not affect the priority of the first registered mortgage. The lodgement of a caveat by the vendor after the registration of the mortgage did not impact the priority of the first registered mortgage. The decision reinforces the principle that priority under the Torrens system is determined by the order of registration, subject to certain exceptions for fraud and other statutory provisions.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi