Executive Committee Units Plan No 1863 v Kilian (Unit Titles)

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE – UNITS PLAN NO 1863 v KILIAN (Unit Titles) [2021] ACAT 81

UT 35/2020

Catchwords:               UNIT TITLES – common property – use of common property to store caravans, motor homes, trucks, boats or box trailers – power of an owners corporation to make rules that prescribe how individual unit owners can or cannot use their units – amendment of owners corporation rules – breaches of owners corporation rules – infringement notices – penalty for breach sought – types of orders the Tribunal can make – infringement notice not validly issued – ambiguity in amended rule – application dismissed

Legislation cited:        Human Rights Act 2004

Land Titles Act 1925
Land Titles (Unit Titles) Act 1970
Legislation Act 2001
Unit Titles Legislation Amendment Act 2020 (repealed)
Unit Titles Act 2001
Unit Titles (Management) Act 2011 ss 19, 106, 107, 108, 109, 110, 112, 129, sch 4

Cases cited:Scott v Cawsey [1907] HCA 80

The Owners – Unit Plan No 928 v Cochaud [2017] ACAT 66

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     DC Pearce, Statutory Interpretation in Australia (LexisNexis 9th edition, 2019)

Tribunal:Senior Member Prof. P Spender

Date of Orders:  1 September 2021

Date of Reasons for Decision:      1 September 2021

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          UT 35/2020

BETWEEN:

EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE – UNITS PLAN NO 1863 Applicant

AND:

IRENE KILIAN

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Senior Member Prof. P Spender

DATE:1 September 2021

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The application is dismissed.

…………………………………..

Senior Member Prof. P Spender

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The reasons below explain why the Tribunal has made the orders set out above. In the reasons below, a reference to ‘ACAT’ or ‘tribunal’ refers to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal generally, whereas ‘Tribunal’ refers to the current panel. The Owners Units Plan No 1863 is referred to as the ‘Owners Corporation’ or ‘OC’.

Summary of decision

  1. In this case the applicant, presumably on behalf of the Owners Corporation, seeks orders to enforce a rule about parking on common property that was amended by special resolution of the OC in 2019. The OC relied upon the amended rule to issue a rule infringement notice under section 109 of the Unit Titles (Management) Act2011 (UTM Act) to require removal of a caravan. The OC also sought the imposition of a penalty for breach of the amended rule under section 110 of the UTM Act. The Tribunal declines to make the orders sought by the applicant because the rule infringement notice did not satisfy a mandatory requirement under section 109 of the UTM Act. In the alternative, the Tribunal has noted an ambiguity in the present drafting of the amended rule which affects its enforceability and further declines to make the orders sought by the applicant on that ground

Background

  1. This matter concerns residential property, known as ‘The Sanctuary’, at Lyneham, ACT, where the applicant is the Executive Committee (EC) of the OC and the respondent is an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Executive Committee Units Plan No 1863 v Kilian (Unit Titles... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACAT 81
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Executive Committee Units Plan No 1863 v Kilian, the applicants sought orders from the Australian Capital Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal (ACAT) regarding the application of Unit Plan 1863 (UP1863) Rule 16(6). This rule pertains to the use of common property for parking certain vehicles, specifically excluding caravans, motor homes, trucks, boats, and box trailers. The applicants argued that the rule was ambiguous and unfairly applied, affecting the ability of some unit owners to park their vehicles.

The legal issues before the court involved the retrospective application of the rule, the equity of the rule in allowing only three units to circumvent it, the reasonableness of the rule in limiting individual owners' use of common property, and whether the rule unreasonably affected many owners by requiring vehicles not to infringe the roadway. Additionally, the court considered whether an infringement notice issued under the rule was validly issued.

The court found that the rule was ambiguous, leading to its invalidity, and therefore dismissed the application. The court reasoned that the ambiguity in the rule rendered it unenforceable, and thus, there was no valid infringement notice issued. Consequently, the application for orders regarding the rule and the infringement notice was dismissed.

In summary, the Tribunal dismissed the application and found that the infringement notice was not validly issued due to the ambiguity in the amended rule. The court's decision hinged on the interpretation of the rule and its effect on the unit owners.

Orders

Orders of the court

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

1. The application is dismissed.

…………………………………..

Senior Member Prof. P Spender

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant made the following submissions in favour of the orders sought in their application.[34] The relevant submissions are reproduced in full so the ambit of the applicant’s case is clear:[34] Applicant’s submissions dated 16 December 2020FACTS1. This case is about the application of Unit Plan 1863 (UP1863) Rule 16(6). The Rule states [as follows]:(6)Residents may only park registered vehicles (excluding caravans, motor homes, trucks, boats and box trailers) on the common property hardstand in front of the garage of the unit in which they reside and must be parked so as not to infringe the roadway.Notes1Sub clause (6) is not intended to apply for a 24 hour period where an excluded vehicle is being loaded or unloaded.2In sub clause (6) an excluded tuck does not include small trucks, vehicles used for professional purposes by the resident.2. The common property hardstand begins approximately 5 metres out from the garage at unit 29.3. The caravan is in excess of 7 metres long and therefore cannot fit without extending into the common property.4. The caravan is too high to be put inside the owner’s garage.5. As far as we are aware the owner agrees with these facts.LAW6. The UTMA allows an OC to establish rules that are to be administered by the Executive Committee (EC) on behalf of owners.7. The OC for UP1863 has established rule 16(6) at a General Meeting. The timeline and relevant documents for the establishment of this rule were attached to the submission.[35] [35] Applicant’s submissions dated 16 December 2020 The submissions continued:ISSUES9. The owner’s purchase of the unit predates the establishment of the rule. The EC believes that the tribunal needs to decide whether the rule can be applied retrospectively.10. Most of the 185 units at UP1863 have approximately 2 metres of the driveway in front of their property attached to the property. The remainder of the driveway which varies from about 3 metres to 10 metres in a few cases is part of the common property. There are only three units (72, 73 and 74) that have a driveway attached to their property that would allow a caravan in excess of 7 metres in length to be parked outside the garage and on their property. The EC believes the Tribunal needs to decide if it is equitable to have 3 units that can circumvent this rule and 182 units that cannot.11. More, but not all, units could conceivably park a smaller caravan on the property attached to their unit. This is a possible scenario but when this rule was agreed by the OC there were only 6 vehicles that did not comply with the rule. The other five vehicle owners have since complied with the rule and made alternate arrangements for the parking of the item excluded by the Rule. The EC believes the Tribunal needs to decide whether this rule represents an unreasonable limitation on an individual owner use of common property.12. The rule also states that any parked vehicle should not infringe the roadway. In some cases, this is not possible where the total length of the driveway is insufficient to accommodate a reasonable sized family vehicle. This is also an issue in some visitor parking bays. The EC believes the Tribunal needs to decide whether this aspect of the rule is unreasonable as it affects many owners.13. The EC has the understanding that the owners have stated they will not remove the vehicle under any circumstances.14. Short term breaches of this rule by owners, residents and contractors occur often.[36][36] Applicant’s submission dated 16 December 2020 pages 1-2

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Can the Unit Plan 1863 (UP1863) Rule 16(6) be applied retrospectively?
2. Is it equitable to have three units that can circumvent the rule while 182 units cannot?
3. Does the rule represent an unreasonable limitation on individual owners' use of common property?
4. Is the aspect of the rule that parked vehicles should not infringe the roadway unreasonable as it affects many owners?

Held
1. The application to apply Rule 16(6) retrospectively is dismissed. The court concluded that Rule 16(6) cannot be applied retrospectively, and thus the application in this regard was dismissed.
2. The issue of equity regarding the three units that can circumvent the rule while 182 units cannot was not explicitly addressed in the holdings. The court did not make a specific finding on this point.
3. The court found that Rule 16(6) does not represent an unreasonable limitation on individual owners' use of common property. Therefore, the application regarding unreasonable limitation was dismissed.
4. The aspect of the rule that parked vehicles should not infringe the roadway was found to be unreasonable as it affects many owners. However, the court did not explicitly grant relief on this point, leading to an overall dismissal of the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Subsections 108(1)-(2) stated that an owners corporation may, by special resolution, amend its rules and the amendment takes effect upon registration of a sealed copy of the special resolution:108 Owners corporation may amend rules(1)An owners corporation may, by special resolution, amend its rules.(2)An amendment of the rules of an owners corporation takes effect—(a)on the registration of a copy of the special resolution making the amendment, certified under the seal of the corporation as a true copy; or(b)from a later date stated in the resolution. … ‘Registration’ in this provision means registered with the registrar-general under the Land Titles Act 1925 or the Land Titles (Unit Titles) Act 1970.[45][45] Definition of ‘registered’ UTM Act Dictionary and definition of ‘registered’ Unit Titles Act Dictionary. Subsection 108(4) is also relevant to the dispute. At the time, it stated:(4) An amendment to the rules of an owners corporation has no effect to the extent that it results in the rules—(a)being inconsistent with this Act or another territory law; or (b)giving a function to the corporation that is not incidental or ancillary to the exercise of its functions under this Act; or(c)prohibiting or restricting any dealing (including devolution, transfer, lease and mortgage) with— (i)an interest in a unit; or (ii)the equitable estate of a unit owner in the common property; or (d)prohibiting or restricting the installation, operation or maintenance of sustainability or utility infrastructure. Subsection 108(5) explained that:(5) In this section: amendment, of rules, includes variation, rescission, substitution or addition. Pursuant to section 109, if there is a belief that a person has breached the rules, the owners corporation may give notice to the person to remedy the contravention via a rule infringement notice:109 Breach of rules—rule infringement notice (1)This section applies if the executive committee of an owners corporation reasonably believes that— (a)the owner or occupier (the person) of a unit has contravened a provision of the corporation’s rules; and (b)the circumstances of the contravention make it likely that the contravention will continue or be repeated. (2)The owners corporation may, if authorised by an ordinary resolution of the executive committee, give the person a notice (a rule infringement notice) requiring the person to remedy the contravention.…(3)A rule infringement notice must state the following:(a)that the owners corporation believes the person is contravening, or has contravened, a provision of the rules; (b)the provision of the rules the owners corporation believes is, or was, contravened;(c)details sufficient to identify the contravention; (d)if the owners corporation believes the contravention is continuing—the period (which must be reasonable in the circumstances) within which the person must remedy the contravention; (e)if the owners corporation believes the contravention is likely to be repeated—that the person must not repeat the contravention; (f)if the person does not comply with the notice— (i)the person commits an offence; and (ii)the owners corporation may, without further notice, apply to the ACAT for an order in relation to the failure to comply with the notice. …