SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Full Court: Civil)
EXCELSIOR LAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ORS v ALAN SHEPPARD CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD
[2012] SASCFC 119
Judgment of The Full Court
(The Honourable Justice Gray, The Honourable Justice David and The Honourable Justice Stanley)
29 October 2012
PROCEDURE - COSTS - GENERAL RULE - COSTS FOLLOW THE EVENT
PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - OTHER CASES - FAILURE IN PORTION OF A CASE
Parties unable to agree on appropriate order as to costs - matter came on appeal to the Full Court by permission from a single judge of the Supreme Court who heard an appeal from a judgment of the District Court - parties agreed that no order should be made as to costs of the appeal to the Full Court, the notice of alternative contentions and the interlocutory applications filed 30 May 2011 and 1 June 2011.
Consideration given to the basis upon which the trial and the appeal was decided - second respondent was not successful on primary submission but on alternate submission.
Held: Appellant to pay respondent 50 percent of its costs of and incidental to the District Court application - appellants are to pay respondent 50 percent of its costs of and incidental to the appeal to the single judge of the Supreme Court - general rule is that costs follow the event.
The respondent was successful on the basis set out in the notice of alternative contentions, and not on its primary submission - significant time and resources were devoted to pursuing the primary submission - justice is therefore served by the order made by this Court.
Steele Ford and Newton v Crown Prosecution Service (No. 2) [1994] 1 AC 22; Advance Resources Services v Charlton (2008) 100 SASR 388; In Re Elgindata Ltd (No. 2) [1993] 1 All ER 232; Myers v Defries (1888) 5 Ex D 180; Slatford v Erlebach [1912] 3 KB 155; Colbert v Beard [1992] 1 Qd R 26, considered.
EXCELSIOR LAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ORS v ALAN SHEPPARD CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LTD
[2012] SASCFC 119Full Court: Gray, David and Stanley JJ
THE COURT:
Introduction
On 13 July 2012, the Court published its reasons in this matter. On appeal the Court granted an extension of time to the respondent for the issue of enforcement proceedings, and granted permission for the lodging of a further notice of lien reflecting the monetary claim now pursued by the respondent in respect of the land over which the lien was claimed pursuant to s 191(k) of the Real Property Act 1886 (SA) (the Real Property Act). The Court indicated it would hear the parties as to costs and to the terms of the order that had been made.
The parties have been unable to agree the appropriate order in relation to costs.
While the parties agree that there be no order as to the costs of the appeal to the Full Court, the notice of alternative contentions,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Excelsior Land Holdings Pty Ltd v Alan Sheppard Construction... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] SASCFC 119
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Full Court involved the proper exercise of discretion regarding costs, particularly in circumstances where a party succeeds on an alternative argument after their primary submission fails. The court was required to determine whether the general rule that costs follow the event should be departed from, and if so, on what basis, given the complex procedural history and the partial success of the respondent. This involved considering the validity of a second lien lodged after the first had lapsed due to failure to commence enforcement proceedings within the prescribed time, and the respondent's alternative arguments for an extension of time and amendment of the first lien.
The Full Court reasoned that while the respondent's primary argument regarding the District Court's power to enforce the second lien ultimately failed, it succeeded on an alternative basis that had been consistently argued. The court acknowledged that multiple events can arise in litigation, allowing for discrete cost orders for each. Applying this principle, and considering the significant resources expended on the unsuccessful primary submission, the court determined that justice would be served by ordering the appellants to pay 50 percent of the respondent's costs of the trial and the appeal to the single judge.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In exercising the discretion as to costs, it is well recognised that there may be more than one event. Where there are separate issues the court can treat those issues as discrete events. Where this occurs, costs on each such issue will follow its event.[8] [8] Myers v Defries (1888) 5 Ex D 180; Slatford v Erlebach [1912] 3 KB 155; Colbert v Beard [1992] 2 Qd R 67; Interchase Corp Ltd (In Liq) v Grosvenor Hill (Queensland) Pty Ltd (No. 3) [2003] 1 Qd R 26. Consideration In order to determine the appropriate basis upon which to exercise the Court’s discretion in relation to the costs of the proceedings below, it is necessary to have regard to the basis upon which the trial and the appeal to the single judge of this Court was decided. The respondent building company brought proceedings in the District Court to enforce its lien in respect of unpaid invoices for work it had performed for the appellants. It had originally issued a lien for an incorrect amount, and over two titles, when the work had only related to one title. It issued a fresh lien and brought the proceedings in respect of that subsequent lien. The District Court held that a notice of lien is deemed to be a caveat and, accordingly, s 191(k) of the Real Property Act empowered the Court to authorise the lodgement of a second lien, and the justice of the case made it proper to exercise that power in the respondent’s favour. The appeal to a single judge of this Court was dismissed. The Court held that it was open to the District Court to authorise a person to lodge a second lien under the Workers’ Liens Act 1893 (SA) (the Workers’ Liens Act) when the first lapsed because of the lienee’s failure to commence enforcement proceedings within the 14-day period prescribed by the Workers’ Liens Act. The learned judge found that the first lien was invalid because the notice of demand on which it was founded had not been executed by the respondent personally. Accordingly, there was no impediment to the lodging of a further lien based on any argument that it was impermissible to lodge more than one lien in relation to the same matter. Importantly, at trial in the District Court[9] and on appeal to the single judge of this Court,[10] the respondent contended that it was also entitled to an extension of time in which to enforce the first lien, and to the amendment of that lien, which reflected the true position. The District Court Judge did not address this argument, presumably because he felt it unnecessary given the conclusion he reached. On appeal to the single judge of this Court, his Honour found it unnecessary to consider the issue given his conclusion that the decision of the District Court Judge was correct.[9] See affidavit of Alexander Charles Antic declared 22 April 2010 appeal case book p 38 – 39.[10] See notice of alternative contention appeal case book p 180 – 181. On appeal, the Full Court held that the original lien had ceased in accordance with the provisions of s 15 of the Workers’ Liens Act by reason of the failure to enforce it within the prescribed time and, accordingly, the District Court lacked power to enforce the second lien. The Court rejected the proposition that the first lien was invalid by reason of the failure of the respondent to sign the notice of demand personally. Nonetheless, the Full Court found in favour of the respondent on the basis set out in the notice of alternative contention. The Full Court granted an extension of time in which to issue proceedings in respect of the first lien pursuant to s 48 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1936 (SA) and granted permission pursuant to s 191(k) of the Real Property Act for the lodging of a further notice of lien.