Excell, Valma Irene v Harris, Lyell James

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

Re: VALMA IRENE EXCELL
And: LYALL JAMES HARRIS, RONALD ALLAN PAGE AND SUSAN MARY HUDSON
And: JOHN FRANCIS MORROW, SUSAN RUSSELL AND JAMES AIKMAN STODDARD
And: GREGORY ARTHUR HANCOCK
And: AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY SCHOOLS AUTHORITY
And: MAX JOHN WOODWARD
And: ROSEMARY WALSH
No. ACT G28 of 1983
Administrative Law

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Neaves J.
CATCHWORDS

Administrative Law - Judicial Review - Commonwealth Teaching Service - Australian Capital Territory Schools component - Extension of time to institute proceedings - Recommendation by Advisory Selection Panel that officer perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification - Whether a decision subject of review - Instrument (including rules, regulation or by-laws) under an Act - Whether Personnel Policy and Procedures Manual such an instrument - Decision that officer perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification - Whether officer had power to make that decision - Relevant matters to be taken into consideration in selecting officer for temporary transfer - Whether a promotion or transfer within s. 27 of the Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972 - Whether appeal to Promotions Appeal Board open - Whether Promotions Appeal Board observed rules of natural justice - Dicretion whether to grant relief.

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977

Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972

Schools Authority Ordinance 1976

Commonwealth Functions (Statutes Review) Act 1981 Part VIII

HEARING

CANBERRA

#DATE 18:10:1983

ORDER

1. The time within which to institute these proceedings be extended up to and including 22 June 1983.

2. The application be dismissed.

3. The fourth respondent pay the costs of the applicant and of the sixth respondent of and incidental to this application.

JUDGE1

The applicant, Mrs. Valma Irene Excell, seeks orders of review under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 in relation to the selection of the sixth respondent, Mrs. Rosemary Walsh, to perform temporarily the duties of a position of Senior Teacher (Counselling) in the Guidance and Counselling Section of the Schools Branch of the Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority and the decision of a Promotions Appeal Board not to uphold the appeal lodged by Mrs. Excell against such selection.

The first respondents, Lyell James Harris, Ronald Allan Page and Susan Mary Hudson, are the members of the Advisory Selection Panel which recommended that Mrs. Walsh temporarily perform the duties of the position. The second respondents, John Francis Morrow, Susan Russell and James Aikman Stoddard, are the members of the Promotions Appeal Board. The third respondent, Gregory Arthur Hancock is the Chief Education Officer of the Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority which is the fourth respondent. The fifth respondent, Max John Woodward, is the officer of the Australian Capital Territory Schools Authority who signed the instrument directing Mrs. Walsh to perform the duties of the position.

The relevant legislative provisions.

The subject position is one within the Commonwealth Teaching Service. Section 19 of the Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972, a section which in its present form was enacted by the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Excell, Valma Irene v Harris, Lyell James and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1983] FCA 279
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Valma Irene Excell sought judicial review of decisions made in relation to her employment within the Australian Capital Territory Schools component of the Commonwealth Teaching Service. Excell argued that she had been passed over for a temporary transfer to a higher classification position. The court was tasked with determining the validity of the decisions made by the Advisory Selection Panel and the Promotions Appeal Board, as well as the scope of judicial review available in this context. Specifically, the court had to decide whether the decision to temporarily transfer another officer to a higher classification position was subject to review, whether the Personnel Policy and Procedures Manual was an instrument under an Act, and if the officer had the authority to make that decision. Furthermore, the court had to determine whether certain matters should have been considered in selecting the officer for the temporary transfer, if the decision constituted a promotion or transfer under the Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972, if an appeal to the Promotions Appeal Board was available, and if the Promotions Appeal Board adhered to the rules of natural justice. Additionally, the court had to decide whether to grant relief and, if so, to what extent.

The court found that the decision to temporarily transfer another officer to a higher classification position was not subject to review, as it was not a decision made under an Act. The Personnel Policy and Procedures Manual was also not considered an instrument under an Act. The officer did have the power to make the decision to temporarily transfer another officer to a higher classification position. However, the court found that certain matters should have been considered in selecting the officer for the temporary transfer. The decision did not constitute a promotion or transfer under the Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972, and therefore, an appeal to the Promotions Appeal Board was not available. The court found that the Promotions Appeal Board did not observe the rules of natural justice in its decision-making process. The court exercised its discretion not to grant relief to the applicant. The application for an extension of time to institute proceedings was granted, and the fourth respondent was ordered to pay the costs of the applicant and of the sixth respondent of and incidental to this application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The time within which to institute these proceedings be extended up to and including 22 June 1983.

2. The application be dismissed.

3. The fourth respondent pay the costs of the applicant and of the sixth respondent of and incidental to this application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Valma Irene Excell brought an application seeking judicial review of decisions made by the Commonwealth Teaching Service (CTS) regarding her employment. Excell, a teacher employed under the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) Schools component of the CTS, sought to challenge a recommendation by the Advisory Selection Panel that she perform temporarily the duties of an office of higher classification. The events leading to this application involved Excell's application for a temporary transfer to a higher classification position and the subsequent recommendation by the Advisory Selection Panel. Excell was dissatisfied with the outcome and sought to challenge the decisions made by the CTS in this regard.

Excell also sought to challenge other decisions made by the CTS, including whether a decision to perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification was subject to review, whether the Personnel Policy and Procedures Manual was an instrument under an Act, and whether the officer had the power to make the decision. Further, Excell challenged whether the relevant matters were taken into consideration in selecting an officer for temporary transfer, and whether the decision was a promotion or transfer within section 27 of the Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972. Excell also questioned whether an appeal to the Promotions Appeal Board was open and whether the Promotions Appeal Board observed the rules of natural justice. The case primarily focused on these factual events and the decisions made by the CTS in relation to Excell's employment.

The case came before the court as an application for judicial review. Excell initially applied for an extension of time to institute proceedings, which was granted by the court. The matter then proceeded to the substantive application for judicial review. Prior to this court, there had been decisions made by the Advisory Selection Panel and the Promotions Appeal Board, both of which were part of the Commonwealth Teaching Service. Excell's application for judicial review was based on the decisions made by these bodies and the subsequent actions taken by the CTS. The court considered the procedural steps taken by Excell, including the application for an extension of time and the substantive application for judicial review.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the time within which to institute these proceedings should be extended up to and including 22 June 1983.
2. Whether the application for judicial review should be dismissed.
3. Whether the fourth respondent should pay the costs of the applicant and of the sixth respondent of and incidental to this application.
4. Whether a decision to perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification is subject to review.
5. Whether the Personnel Policy and Procedures Manual is an instrument under an Act.
6. Whether the officer had the power to make the decision to perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification.
7. Whether the relevant matters were taken into consideration in selecting an officer for temporary transfer.
8. Whether the decision to perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification is a promotion or transfer within section 27 of the Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972.
9. Whether an appeal to the Promotions Appeal Board is open in this case.
10. Whether the Promotions Appeal Board observed the rules of natural justice.

Held
1. The court held that the time within which to institute these proceedings should be extended up to and including 22 June 1983.
2. The court held that the application for judicial review should be dismissed.
3. The court held that the fourth respondent should pay the costs of the applicant and of the sixth respondent of and incidental to this application.
4. The court held that a decision to perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification is subject to review.
5. The court held that the Personnel Policy and Procedures Manual is not an instrument under an Act.
6. The court held that the officer had the power to make the decision to perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification.
7. The court held that the relevant matters were taken into consideration in selecting an officer for temporary transfer.
8. The court held that the decision to perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification is not a promotion or transfer within section 27 of the Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972.
9. The court held that an appeal to the Promotions Appeal Board is not open in this case.
10. The court held that the Promotions Appeal Board observed the rules of natural justice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the matter of extending the time for instituting proceedings, finding that due to exceptional circumstances, the extension was warranted. Regarding the application for judicial review, the court examined whether the decision to perform temporarily duties of an office of higher classification was subject to review and concluded that it was, as it affected the applicant's career prospects. The Personnel Policy and Procedures Manual was found not to be an instrument under an Act, yet the court held that the officer had the lawful authority to make the decision in question. The court further assessed whether the relevant matters were taken into consideration in selecting an officer for temporary transfer and found that they were. It was determined that the decision in question did not constitute a promotion or transfer within the scope of section 27 of the Commonwealth Teaching Service Act 1972, thus precluding an appeal to the Promotions Appeal Board. The court concluded that the Promotions Appeal Board had indeed observed the rules of natural justice in its proceedings. The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the clarification of the scope of judicial review in Commonwealth Teaching Service matters and the applicability of natural justice principles to decisions made by the Promotions Appeal Board.