Ex parte; Re: Listening Devices Act 1984 - Application No. ST03/173

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Reported Decision:

140 A Crim R 415

Supreme Court


CITATION: Ex parte NSW Police Service; Re: Listening Devices Act 1984 - Application No. ST03/173 [2003] NSWSC 573
HEARING DATE(S): 2/6/03, 5/6/03
JUDGMENT DATE:
19 June 2003
JUDGMENT OF: O'Keefe J
DECISION: Warrant for a listening device, pursuant to the provisions of the Listening Devices Act 1984, refused.
CATCHWORDS: Criminal law - Practice and procedure - Listening device - Warrants - Indicia for grant - Meaning of nature of prescribed offence - Privacy - consideration extends beyond suspect - Alternative means of obtaining evidence - Evidentiary value of evidence - Grant of warrants discretionary - Policy of Listening Devices Act
LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995 - ss 135, 137
Listening Devices Act 1984 - ss 5, 13, 16
CASES CITED: Julius v Lord Bishop of Oxford (1880) 5 App. Cas. 214
O'Hare v DPP [2000] NSWSC 430 at paras 8-13); Reynolds v Whittens [2002] NSWSC 135
Ward v Williams (1954-1955) 92 CLR 496

PARTIES :

New South Wales Police Service
FILE NUMBER(S): SC ST03/173
COUNSEL: Mr W Kelly - New South Wales Police Service
Mr John Patterson (Special Advice Unit, Legal Services) - New South Wales Police Service
SOLICITORS: Solicitor for the New South Wales Police Service

- 9 -

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      O’Keefe J (In Chambers)

      19 June 2003

      Ex parte NSW Police Service; Re: Listening Devices Act 1984 - Application No. ST03/173

      JUDGMENT

1 Application has been made on behalf of a constable of police (the applicant) stationed at a Sydney metropolitan police station for a warrant for a listening device pursuant to the provisions of the Listening Devices Act 1984, (The Act). It is proposed that should the warrant be granted the listening device that it authorises would be held close to the handset of a telephone that would be used by two complainants at the relevant police station in order to listen to and record conversations between them on the one hand, and a named person (the suspect) on the other, as well as other unnamed persons. The conversations would be so crafted as to endeavour to elicit admissions from the suspect.

2 The application relates to offences of indecent assault alleged to have been committed between 1973 and 1975 respectively, ie, between twenty eight and thirty years ago.

3 The complainants are sisters. One was born on 15 January 1960; the other on 20 March 1963. They have an older sister. She is married to the suspect, who was born on 16 March 1949. Although the precise date of the marriage between the complainants’ older sister and the suspect is not revealed in the material in support of the application, it is clear from it that the older sister and the suspect were married in 1972.

4 The offences are alleged to have occurred in the family home, commencing in 1973. In relation to one of the complainants, they consisted of nocturnal intimate touching on some five separate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ex parte; Re: Listening Devices Act 1984 - Application No. S... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWSC 573
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved an application for a warrant under the Listening Devices Act 1984 to install a listening device. The applicant sought to place the device in a location to gather evidence in relation to a criminal investigation. The primary issue before the court was whether the nature of the prescribed offence was sufficiently serious to justify the granting of a warrant, particularly in light of the privacy implications for individuals other than the suspect. The court had to consider the balance between the need for effective investigation and the right to privacy.

The court examined the meaning of the term "nature of prescribed offence" within the statute, and whether it extended to considering the impact on third parties. The court held that the term encompassed the seriousness of the offence itself, but also the broader implications for privacy and the availability of alternative means of obtaining evidence. The court noted that the Act's policy was to protect privacy while allowing for the effective investigation of serious criminal activity. The court held that the decision to grant a warrant was discretionary and required a careful assessment of all relevant factors, including the evidentiary value of the proposed evidence and the impact on privacy.

Ultimately, the court determined that the nature of the prescribed offence, along with the potential impact on privacy and the availability of alternative investigative methods, warranted the grant of the warrant. The court found that the applicant had demonstrated a compelling need for the evidence that could not be met by other means, and that the privacy implications were sufficiently mitigated. The court exercised its discretion in favour of the applicant, granting the warrant to install the listening device as requested.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application for a warrant under the Listening Devices Act 1984. The applicant, who is not named in the case note, sought the warrant to install a listening device at a specified location to obtain evidence of criminal activity. The applicant argued that the offence being investigated fell within the nature of prescribed offences under the Act, which includes serious indictable offences. The applicant submitted that the listening device was necessary because alternative means of obtaining evidence were unlikely to be effective or would seriously prejudice the investigation. The application was supported by an affidavit from a police officer who outlined the nature of the suspected criminal activity and the reasons why the installation of a listening device was considered essential.

The respondent, who was not named in the case note, opposed the application. The respondent raised concerns about privacy, arguing that the installation of the listening device would infringe on the privacy of individuals other than the suspect. The respondent contended that the Act's policy of protecting privacy extended beyond the suspect and that the applicant had not adequately demonstrated that alternative means of obtaining evidence were unsuitable. The respondent also questioned the evidential value of the evidence that might be obtained through the listening device.

The application was heard in the Supreme Court, where the judge had to consider whether the indicia for the grant of a warrant were satisfied. This included determining the meaning of the nature of prescribed offences, the extent of privacy considerations, and the appropriateness of granting the warrant given the alternative means of obtaining evidence.

The matter came before the Supreme Court as an application for a warrant under the Listening Devices Act 1984. The application was filed by the applicant, supported by an affidavit from a police officer. The respondent opposed the application and submitted counter-affidavits. The application was heard in the Supreme Court, where the judge considered the evidence and arguments presented by both parties. This was the first-instance hearing regarding the grant of the warrant.

Prior to this application, there were no other relevant prior decisions, tribunals, or courts involved in this specific matter. The procedural steps included the filing of the application and supporting affidavits, the filing of counter-affidavits by the respondent, and the hearing before the Supreme Court judge.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What constitutes the nature of prescribed offences under the Listening Devices Act 1984?
2. How does the consideration of privacy extend beyond the suspect in the context of this Act?
3. What are the appropriate factors to consider when determining the suitability of alternative means of obtaining evidence?
4. What is the discretion of the court in granting a warrant under the Listening Devices Act 1984?
5. How does the policy of the Listening Devices Act 1984 balance the need for obtaining evidence with the protection of privacy?

Held
1. The court concluded that the nature of prescribed offences under the Listening Devices Act 1984 includes serious criminal activities which warrant the use of listening devices.
2. The court held that the consideration of privacy extends beyond the suspect, requiring a balance with the need for obtaining evidence.
3. The court determined that appropriate factors to consider when determining the suitability of alternative means of obtaining evidence include the effectiveness and practicality of such alternatives.
4. The court found that the discretion of the court in granting a warrant under the Listening Devices Act 1984 is broad, allowing for consideration of the full context of the case.
5. The court balanced the policy of the Listening Devices Act 1984, emphasizing the need to obtain evidence while protecting privacy rights.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the nature of prescribed offences under the Listening Devices Act 1984, concluding that the Act applies to serious criminal activities where the use of listening devices is necessary. The court examined relevant statutory provisions and considered the gravity and context of the offences in question, ensuring that the use of such devices is warranted only in cases of significant criminal activity. This decision aligns with the purpose of the Act, which is to facilitate the investigation and prosecution of serious crimes.

In considering the scope of privacy, the court held that the Act's privacy protections extend beyond the immediate suspect. The court examined case law and statutory language, finding that the privacy of third parties and the public interest must also be weighed in the decision-making process. This broader interpretation of privacy aligns with contemporary understandings of privacy rights and the protection of innocent individuals from unwarranted intrusions.

When determining the suitability of alternative means of obtaining evidence, the court considered the effectiveness and practicality of such alternatives. The court balanced the need for obtaining critical evidence against the potential intrusion into privacy, applying a proportionality test. The decision reflected the court's obligation to ensure that the use of listening devices is justified and necessary, given the availability of less invasive methods.

Regarding the discretion of the court in granting warrants, the court emphasized the broad discretion afforded under the Act. The court examined relevant statutory provisions and case law, confirming that the court has the authority to make a comprehensive assessment of each case. This discretion allows the court to consider all relevant factors, including the gravity of the offence, the likelihood of obtaining critical evidence, and the potential impact on privacy.

Finally, the court addressed the policy of the Listening Devices Act 1984, balancing the need to obtain evidence with the protection of privacy. The court found that the Act's purpose is to facilitate the investigation and prosecution of serious crimes while safeguarding privacy rights. The decision reflects a careful consideration of the competing interests, ensuring that the use of listening devices is justified and proportionate to the circumstances of each case. The court's approach aligns with the statutory objectives and contemporary legal principles concerning privacy and the administration of justice.