Ex-Christmas Islanders Association Inc v Attorney-General

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ex-Christmas Islanders Association Inc v Attorney-General [2005] FCA 1867

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – decisions under administrative legal aid scheme relating to public interest and test cases – scheme non-statutory – decisions under the Scheme not decisions under any enactment – judicial review unavailable under ADJR Act – no public duty attracting the grant of mandamus - question of review of executive power not canvassed – application dismissed – poor quality of application and submissions – solicitor to show cause why costs should not be awarded personally against him.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 69
Appropriation Act (No 1) 2003-2004 (Cth)
Appropriation Act (No 1) 2004-2005 (Cth)
Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AB
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) s 6, s 7(1), s 3
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B

Federal Court of Australia Rules O 52 r 2(2), O 54 r 2A(1) and (2)

Combet v Commonwealth of Australia [2005] HCA 61 cited
Evans v Friemann (1981) 35 ALR 428 cited
Chittick v Ackland (1984) 53 ALR 143 cited
Thurgood v Director of Australian Legal Aid Office (1984) 56 ALR 565 cited
Barnett v Minister for Housing (1991) 31 FCR 400 cited

EX CHRISTMAS ISLANDERS ASSOCIATION INC,  THE ESTATE OF AIN BIN MARSAH, THE ESTATE OF BADRON BIN RIDWEE, NOOLIYAH BINTE SALLEH & MENG KOK HU v THE ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE COMMONWEALTH
WAD 36 OF 2005

FRENCH J
21 DECEMBER 2005
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD36 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

EX-CHRISTMAS ISLANDERS ASSOCIATION INC,
THE ESTATE OF AIN BIN MARSAH,
THE ESTATE OF BADRON BIN RIDWEE,
NOOLIYAH BINTE SALLEH & MENG KOK HU
APPLICANTS

AND:

ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S DEPARTMENT (COMMONWEALTH)
[LEGAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION]
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 DECEMBER 2005

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The second and third named ‘applicants’ not being legal persons, will be removed from the heading to these proceedings.

2.The Attorney-General for the Commonwealth is named as respondent in lieu of the Attorney-General’s Department.

3.        The application is dismissed.

4.The solicitors for the applicants are to show cause by written submissions filed on or before 28 February 2006 why they should not pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

5.The respondent may file written submissions on the question of costs by 28 March 2006.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD36 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

EX-CHRISTMAS ISLANDERS ASSOCIATION INC,
THE ESTATE OF AIN BIN MARSAH,
THE ESTATE OF BADRON BIN RIDWEE,
NOOLIYAH BINTE SALLEH & MENG KOK HU
APPLICANTS

AND:

ATTORNEY-GENERAL'S DEPARTMENT (COMMONWEALTH)
[LEGAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION]
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE:

21 DECEMBER 2005

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. Four former residents of Christmas Island commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of Western Australia in 1996 against the Commonwealth of Australia (the Commonwealth).  In those proceedings they alleged that the Commonwealth had engaged in unconscionable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ex-Christmas Islanders Association Inc v Attorney-General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] FCA 1867
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Ex-Christmas Islanders Association Inc initiated proceedings against the Attorney-General, seeking review of decisions related to the denial of legal aid and assistance in pursuing a claim against the Commonwealth. The Association, whose incorporation status is unclear, had previously brought a case in the Supreme Court of Western Australia by four members alleging the Commonwealth's control and exploitation of Christmas Island's phosphate resources. The current application aimed to review multiple decisions made by the Attorney-General regarding the provision of legal aid and assistance, as well as the conduct of the Attorney-General in handling these decisions.

The court was required to determine whether the decisions of the Attorney-General in denying and partially granting legal aid and assistance were lawful and if the conduct of the Attorney-General during the review process complied with the required legal standards, including procedural fairness and adherence to the Guidelines of the Scheme. Additionally, the court had to assess whether the decisions were unreasonable, made in bad faith, or constituted an abuse of power.

The court found that the Association's application was not substantiated and dismissed it. The court noted the procedural irregularities, including the failure to properly identify the legal representatives of the deceased plaintiffs and the removal of non-legal entities from the application's heading. Furthermore, the court held that the solicitors for the applicants must justify why they should not be held personally liable for the respondent's costs incurred during the application.

The court ordered that the second and third named applicants be removed from the heading of the proceedings, the Attorney-General for the Commonwealth be named as the respondent, and the application be dismissed. The solicitors for the applicants were required to submit written reasons by 28 February 2006 as to why they should not pay the respondent's costs, with the respondent having the opportunity to respond by 28 March 2006.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The second and third named ‘applicants’ not being legal persons, will be removed from the heading to these proceedings.

2. The Attorney-General for the Commonwealth is named as respondent in lieu of the Attorney-General’s Department.

3. The application is dismissed.

4. The solicitors for the applicants are to show cause by written submissions filed on or before 28 February 2006 why they should not pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

5. The respondent may file written submissions on the question of costs by 28 March 2006.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The application will be dismissed and the solicitors for the applicant required to show cause why they should not personally pay the respondent’s costs of the action. Factual and Procedural Background The Association is apparently incorporated under the Associations Incorporation Act1987 (WA) although there is no direct evidence of that fact before the Court. In 1996, four members of the Association commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of Western Australia in Action Number CIV 2057 of 1996 against the Commonwealth. They were Ain Bin Marsah, Badron Bin Ridwee, Nooliyah Binte Salleh and Meng Kok Hu. The first two are now deceased. The proceedings do not appear to have been brought in the name of their personal representatives. It is not clear therefore what, if any, authority the solicitor has to act on the behalf of those representatives. The ‘Estate of …’ is not a legal person. The second and third named ‘applicants’, not being legal persons, shall be removed from the heading of this proceeding. The nature of the proceedings in the Supreme Court was outlined by Master Sanderson in an interlocutory judgment delivered on 23 February 1999 in which he allowed an amended statement of claim to be filed. The statement of claim pleaded, uncontroversially, the existence of Christmas Island (the Island), which is an Australian external territory located in the Indian Ocean off the north-west coast of Western Australia. None of the four plaintiffs was born on the Island but all were permanent residents for various periods up to 1979. The Island became a Territory of the Commonwealth in 1958, having formerly been part of the British colony of Singapore. The plaintiffs alleged that at all material times the sole industry on the Island was the mining of phosphate for sale and export. Between December 1948 and July 1982 the Commonwealth and the Government of New Zealand controlled the mining and for that purpose engaged the British Phosphate Commissioners (the Commissioners). It was also alleged that at all material times the Commonwealth sought to obtain, accepted and retained sovereignty and control over the Island for the primary purpose of exploiting its phosphate resources so as to secure for Australian farmers a reliable supply of phosphate at the lowest possible cost. The Master’s decision identified paragraphs 16 to 23 of the statement of claim as crucial to the plaintiffs’ case. There was a reference in the pleading as set out to the ‘Agent’ which was not defined in the reasons. Presumably that was a reference to the Commissioners. The plaintiffs pleaded that the Commissioners and the Commonwealth were the only employers on the Island. Each of the plaintiffs was employed by them for different periods of some years between 1952 and 1979. They all had a reasonable expectation that they and their descendents would be entitled to reside permanently on the Island. That expectation was said to have been created and encouraged by the conduct of the Commonwealth.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
In a reply letter dated 13 July 2005 the solicitors asserted that their own opinion, namely that of Mr Mijatovic, had been provided on 30 November 2004 and that he was counsel for the purposes of satisfaction of the condition. Ms Buckley wrote back on 28 July 2005 reiterating the position that it was a condition of the completion of the internal review that an opinion be obtained from another counsel on the applicants’ prospects of success in the proceedings. The Decisions and Conduct for which Review is Sought The decisions and conduct for which a review order is sought are stated in the amended application as follows (in chronological order): 1.Decision of 28 August 2001 as to ‘the balance of the application for legal assistance’.2.Decision of 12 August 2003 to refuse legal aid/assistance.3.Decision of 2 December 2003 to partly grant legal aid/assistance. 4.Decision of 25 January 2005.The conduct relied upon is expressed partly in terms of failure, neglect or refusal to make decisions or provide legal assistance. The failures alleged are: 1.Failing, neglecting or refusing to make a decision on the balance of the application for legal assistance of the applicants. 2.Failing, neglecting or refusing to review the decision on the balance of the application for legal assistance of 2 December 2003.3.Failing to properly and sufficiently provide legal assistance to fund the conduct of the action by the applicants. 4.Failing to make any determination upon review or otherwise of the decision of 12 August 2003 as to the legal services and costs incurred by the applicants since 28 June 2001 or otherwise including the legal assistance for –(i)discovery of documents; (ii)inspections; (iii)pleadings; (iv)Chambers and court hearings;(v)applications and appearances before the Court; (vi)general conduct of the application to trial.5.Failing, neglecting or refusing to review the application for legal assistance for amounts other than those granted in the decision of the respondent dated 2 December 2003. An order of review is also sought for the respondent’s conduct constituted by various alleged failures which may be summarised as follows: (a)To provide natural justice.(b)To comply with procedures required by law. (c)To engage in conduct contrary to the Guidelines of the Scheme which the respondent is required by law to apply.(d)To properly exercise the power conferred by the Guidelines as to procedural fairness under cl 7.(e)To avoid an error of law. (f)To make a decision or making of the decision would be otherwise be contrary to law. (sic)(g)To take into account all relevant considerations in the exercise of the power and taking wrongly into account irrelevant considerations in the exercise of the power.(h)To exercise the power to grant legal assistance for a purpose other than a purpose to which the power is conferred and exercising a discretionary power in bad faith or in the interests of the parent body of the respondent, being the Commonwealth of Australia who is at risk with respect to the action. (i)To exercise a discretionary power in accordance with a rule or policy without regard for the merits of the case of the applicants. (j)To exercise a power which is so unreasonable that no reasonable person should have so exercised that power or exercised that discretion as the respondent has done so. (k)To exercise its power in a way that constitutes an abuse of power in that the respondent including creating obstacles to the applicants in their ability to conduct the action. (l)To make a decision on the ground and causing unreasonable delay in making that decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

Full text does not contain this section.