EVV18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs
Link copied
CaseCopied
28 min read
Full text
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
EVV18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] FedCFamC2G 598
File number(s):
SYG 2644 of 2018
Judgment of:
JUDGE VASTA
Date of judgment:
10 JULY 2024
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection Visa – whether Immigration Assessment authority’s decision affected by jurisdictional error – where no error established in Immigration Assessment authority’s decision – application dismissed
To correct the name of Counsel for the applicant to Ms Poukchanski
Cover page
Amend the submitting appearance from the Applicant to the Second Respondent
ORDERS
SYG 2644 of 2018
FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)
BETWEEN:
EVV18
Applicant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
First Respondent
IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
Second Respondent
ORDER MADE BY:
JUDGE VASTA
DATE OF ORDER:
10 JULY 2024
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The name of the first respondent be amended to “MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS”.
2.The application filed on 19 September 2018 as amended on 25 July 2019 be dismissed.
3.The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application fixed in the sum of $8,371.30.
Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.
Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
JUDGE VASTA
INTRODUCTION
On 24 August 2018, the Immigration Assessment Authority (“the IAA”) affirmed a decision not to grant the Applicant, EVV18, a protection visa. On 19 September 2018, the Applicant asked this Court to review that decision.
The matter was mentioned by the Registrar on 11 October 2018, where orders for filing were made and the matter was stood over for call over by a Registrar on 22 October 2019. On 23 July 2019, amendments were made, in Chambers, by Her Honour Judge Baird, to the filing dates. On 21 October 2019, the matter was stood over for call over before a Registrar, or for final hearing before Judge Baird, on a date and place to be advised administratively and not before 1 September 2020.
The matter ended up…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read EVV18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:
The case of EVV18 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs involved an Iranian national who sought a protection visa in Australia based on his conversion to Christianity and fear of persecution if returned to Iran. The application was dismissed by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA), and the applicant sought judicial review of that decision. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether the IAA's decision was affected by jurisdictional error.
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the IAA erred in its assessment that the applicant's conversion to Christianity was not genuine and was merely a tactic to support his application for a protection visa. The court examined whether the IAA's decision was based on evidence and whether it had correctly applied the law in assessing the applicant's claims. The court also considered whether the IAA had properly evaluated the applicant's risk of persecution based on his conversion to Christianity.
The court found that the IAA had properly considered the evidence and applied the correct legal standards in reaching its decision. The court accepted the IAA's findings that the applicant's conversion appeared to be insincere and motivated by a desire to obtain a protection visa. The court noted that the applicant's understanding of Christianity was superficial, and he had not demonstrated a genuine commitment to the faith. The court also found that there was no credible evidence to suggest that the applicant would engage in Christian activities or proselytize if returned to Iran. As such, the court dismissed the application for judicial review and affirmed the IAA's decision.
The court's decision was based on a thorough analysis of the evidence and the IAA's reasoning. The court found that the IAA had properly evaluated the applicant's claims and had not erred in its assessment of the evidence. The court also noted that the applicant's psychological conditions and medication did not excuse his lack of knowledge or commitment to Christianity. The court concluded that the IAA's decision was not affected by jurisdictional error and was therefore valid. The application for judicial review was dismissed, and the decision of the IAA was affirmed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
I heard the matter on that day, but I noted that it had taken three months shy of six years for the Court to finally hear the application. This is a shocking delay, and, on behalf of the Court, I apologise to EVV18 for the delay. Notwithstanding that I had to reserve my decision on that day, I have striven to deliver this judgement as soon as possible.Background The Applicant is a citizen of Iran. He claimed that when he was wrestling at the state level, he was mistreated and punished by members of the Basij and the Sepah. He said that the manager of his team asked him to participate in the Evin Prison Wrestling team. When the Applicant refused, he said that the manager threatened him and sent men to his home to threaten him further. The Applicant said that he left Iran and came to Australia. He said that, after arriving in Australia, he wanted to speak out and show his objections to the policies of the government of Iran. He said that he attended two protests relating to the treatment of political prisoners in Iran. The Applicant said he was not comfortable with the religion which was forced on him since birth. He said he decided to come to Australia to have a better opportunity to freely choose his religious belief. He said he was introduced to Christianity by a friend and attended St John’s church in Parramatta. He said that the lack of freedom in Islam on one hand, and the gratitude of Christians on the other hand, significantly attracted him to Christianity and led to his decision to convert to a new faith. The Applicant said that from late 2014, he attended services St John’s church and from mid-2016 decided to be a member of the Liberty Baptist Church in North Rocks. The Applicant said he was baptised and officially became a Christian on 4 December 2016. He said that he continues to attend Sunday services and Bible study at liberty Baptist Church. The Applicant claims that, if he returns to Iran, he will be arrested, interrogated, tortured, and may be executed. This will be because he has converted to Christianity.The IAA decision The IAA looked closely at the claims of the Applicant. Because the scope of this review is very narrow, I have no need to give a recitation of the reasons of the IAA. Suffice it to say, the IAA assessed whether the Applicant would be considered a Christian upon return to Iran. The IAA found that the Applicant had undertaken baptism and church attendance in Australia solely in furtherance of his protection claims. The IAA said that there was no credible evidence to indicate that the Applicant would participate, or have any interest in, participating in any activities in which he would be perceived to be Christian on return to Iran. There were other aspects to the claim that caused the IAA to affirm the decision of the delegate, however, this particular finding was pivotal to the decision of the IAA. The reasoning of the IAA is neatly contained in paragraphs 22, 23, 24 and 25 of the IAA decision. I have reproduced those paragraphs below:22.The delegate questioned the applicant in some detail on his knowledge of Christianity and what Christianity meant to him. The delegate concluded that his answers were not indicative of a person who is genuine or seriously committed to their religion. In the submissions to the IAA Ms Jafari contends that the applicant suffers from poor memory and concentration due to his psychological conditions as well as his current anti-depressant medication. This is supported by Dr Pishyar's report and I accept he suffers from poor memory and concentration. She further contended that "the delegate used a harsh tone in a superior way when questioning my client" which caused him added confusion. Even taking these factors into account, it did appear that the applicant's knowledge of any Christian concepts or core beliefs was very shallow. In terms of the applicant's beliefs, these appear from his evidence to be that he feels comforted in a church, that Christianity is about love, fellowship, friendship and believing in Jesus Christ. The applicant stated that he was cleansed of his sins but was unable to explain how this occurred or what he meant by the statement. He stated that he prayed and when asked why he did so he replied "because it makes us comforted".23.I accept that the applicant underwent baptism on 4 December 2016 and subsequently has attended, and continues to attend, the Liberty Baptist Church for services and bible studies. I do not accept that this is indicative of a genuine conversion to Christianity. I conclude that his baptism, his subsequent attendance at church and completion of various subjects in the Liberty Baptist Church Certificates were solely for the purpose of furthering his claims for protection.24.The delegate asked the applicant how the Iranian authorities would know that he had converted to Christianity. The applicant responded that they would know from his Facebook page, he posts things about Christianity on it. In her submissions to the IAA Ms Jafari contended that he did this from June 2016 onward. I note that the applicant was not attending church regularly at that time. The delegate did not accept the applicant's claim to have posted Christian material and Ms Jafari asserts that this was "incorrect as it could be checked in my client's Facebook account". It is not the delegate's role, nor is it that of the IAA, to hunt for evidence which supports a claim. The applicant provided no evidence of his Facebook page to the delegate nor, in the significant amounts of new information provided to the IAA, is there any indication of his on-line activities. Based on the available evidence, Ido not accept that the applicant posts Christian material on-line. Pastor Keith has claimed that the applicant "has told his family and friends in Iran that he is a Christian. Some of them are angry with him about this". The applicant has at no point made such a claim and I do not accept it.25.At the end of the PV interview the applicant added that it is his duty to evangelize and he would not be able to hide this in his home country. Due to my conclusion that he is not a genuine convert to Christianity I do not accept this claim. I am not satisfied that any one in Iran would be aware of the applicant's baptism or attendance at church or bible studies in Australia. I do not accept that the applicant would declare himself a Christian or would seek to practise or identify as a Christian on return to Iran. I do not accept that he would seek to convert others to Christianity. I do not consider that this would be because he would be afraid to do so because of a fear of persecution, but because he does not have a genuine and ongoing commitment to the Christian faith. I do not accept that the applicant would be perceived to be a Christian in Iran because he has attended church in Australia or been baptised.This review
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Applicant claims that, if he returns to Iran, he will be arrested, interrogated, tortured, and may be executed. This will be because he has converted to Christianity.The IAA decision The IAA looked closely at the claims of the Applicant. Because the scope of this review is very narrow, I have no need to give a recitation of the reasons of the IAA. Suffice it to say, the IAA assessed whether the Applicant would be considered a Christian upon return to Iran. The IAA found that the Applicant had undertaken baptism and church attendance in Australia solely in furtherance of his protection claims. The IAA said that there was no credible evidence to indicate that the Applicant would participate, or have any interest in, participating in any activities in which he would be perceived to be Christian on return to Iran. There were other aspects to the claim that caused the IAA to affirm the decision of the delegate, however, this particular finding was pivotal to the decision of the IAA. The reasoning of the IAA is neatly contained in paragraphs 22, 23, 24 and 25 of the IAA decision. I have reproduced those paragraphs below:22.The delegate questioned the applicant in some detail on his knowledge of Christianity and what Christianity meant to him. The delegate concluded that his answers were not indicative of a person who is genuine or seriously committed to their religion. In the submissions to the IAA Ms Jafari contends that the applicant suffers from poor memory and concentration due to his psychological conditions as well as his current anti-depressant medication. This is supported by Dr Pishyar's report and I accept he suffers from poor memory and concentration. She further contended that "the delegate used a harsh tone in a superior way when questioning my client" which caused him added confusion. Even taking these factors into account, it did appear that the applicant's knowledge of any Christian concepts or core beliefs was very shallow. In terms of the applicant's beliefs, these appear from his evidence to be that he feels comforted in a church, that Christianity is about love, fellowship, friendship and believing in Jesus Christ. The applicant stated that he was cleansed of his sins but was unable to explain how this occurred or what he meant by the statement. He stated that he prayed and when asked why he did so he replied "because it makes us comforted".23.I accept that the applicant underwent baptism on 4 December 2016 and subsequently has attended, and continues to attend, the Liberty Baptist Church for services and bible studies. I do not accept that this is indicative of a genuine conversion to Christianity. I conclude that his baptism, his subsequent attendance at church and completion of various subjects in the Liberty Baptist Church Certificates were solely for the purpose of furthering his claims for protection.24.The delegate asked the applicant how the Iranian authorities would know that he had converted to Christianity. The applicant responded that they would know from his Facebook page, he posts things about Christianity on it. In her submissions to the IAA Ms Jafari contended that he did this from June 2016 onward. I note that the applicant was not attending church regularly at that time. The delegate did not accept the applicant's claim to have posted Christian material and Ms Jafari asserts that this was "incorrect as it could be checked in my client's Facebook account". It is not the delegate's role, nor is it that of the IAA, to hunt for evidence which supports a claim. The applicant provided no evidence of his Facebook page to the delegate nor, in the significant amounts of new information provided to the IAA, is there any indication of his on-line activities. Based on the available evidence, Ido not accept that the applicant posts Christian material on-line. Pastor Keith has claimed that the applicant "has told his family and friends in Iran that he is a Christian. Some of them are angry with him about this". The applicant has at no point made such a claim and I do not accept it.25.At the end of the PV interview the applicant added that it is his duty to evangelize and he would not be able to hide this in his home country. Due to my conclusion that he is not a genuine convert to Christianity I do not accept this claim. I am not satisfied that any one in Iran would be aware of the applicant's baptism or attendance at church or bible studies in Australia. I do not accept that the applicant would declare himself a Christian or would seek to practise or identify as a Christian on return to Iran. I do not accept that he would seek to convert others to Christianity. I do not consider that this would be because he would be afraid to do so because of a fear of persecution, but because he does not have a genuine and ongoing commitment to the Christian faith. I do not accept that the applicant would be perceived to be a Christian in Iran because he has attended church in Australia or been baptised.This review