EVISON & WILLIAMS v CONWAY, LILLY & ACTIVE PLACEMENTS PTY LTD
Civil
Judge Brebner
In this action the plaintiffs claimed damages from the defendants alleging breach of contract, misleading or deceptive conduct, misrepresentation, negligence and unconscionable conduct in connection with the sale of a business by the defendants to the plaintiffs.
The action proceeded to trial on the 11, 12 and 14 November 1997. As I said in the Reasons for Judgment which I published on 17 December1997:-
“Shortly before the action came on for trial, the defendants made a series of formal admissions. I need not now record them in detail. Suffice it to say that the defendants admitted that they had informed the plaintiffs that they wanted to recoup what they had paid for the business and a sum to cover ‘improvement expenses’, that, while negotiations were in progress, they had informed the plaintiffs that the ‘asking price’ for the business at the time when the defendants had purchased it had been $260,000 and that they had paid $220,000 for the business. They further admitted that the asking price for the business actually had been $200,000 and that the purchase price paid by the defendants for the business had been $130,000. It was also admitted that the defendants knew or ought to have known that the plaintiffs would rely on the representations made by the defendants and that the plaintiffs had in fact relied upon them. I shall, except where otherwise necessary, not distinguish between the defendants in this judgment. As I understand it, they admit joint and several liability for any moneys which may be found to be recoverable by the plaintiffs.”
I found that the true value of the subject business on the date of the sale by the defendants to the plaintiffs had been $140,000. That finding enabled the parties to agree upon the outcome of certain consequential claims that had been made by the plaintiffs. In the result, on the 18th December 1997, I entered judgment for the plaintiffs on their claim for the sum of $105,877. 06. That sum was inclusive of interest.
The defendants had filed a counterclaim about which there was no dispute. It raised but a minor matter, but it was agreed that there should be judgment for the defendants on the counterclaim for the sum of $3,392. 30. In essence, however, the plaintiffs succeeded in their action.
At the request of counsel, I reserved the question of costs. It was agreed at that time that counsel would provide me with written submissions on this aspect of the case. Both did so just prior to the commencement of the summer vacation on 24th December 1997.
In his submission, counsel for the plaintiffs argued that the plaintiffs should recover from the defendants costs on a solicitor and client basis in respect of the issue of the misrepresentations made by the defendants to the plaintiffs with reference to the sale of the business. I respect of the remainder of the plaintiffs’ costs,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Evison & Williams v Conway Lilly & Anor (No 2) No. DCCIV-96-... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] SADC 3955
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the defendants' late admissions and their maintenance of a defence that was groundless, knowing it to be false. The plaintiffs' counsel argued that the defendants' actions forced the plaintiffs to incur unnecessary costs in preparing for trial on issues that should not have been disputed. The court found merit in the plaintiffs' contentions and recognised that it was within its discretion to order costs on a basis other than the standard party and party basis. The court cited cases where solicitor and client costs were awarded due to groundless or knowingly false allegations, and noted that the defendants had no real chance of success.
The court exercised its discretion to order that the defendants pay the plaintiffs' costs on a solicitor and client basis for the misrepresentations and party and party basis for other issues. This decision recognised the defendants' conduct in maintaining a false defence until shortly before the trial, which prejudiced the plaintiffs by forcing them to incur unnecessary costs.
The final orders included the awarding of $105,877.06 plus interest to the plaintiffs, $3,392.30 to the defendants, and a specific order regarding the costs to be borne by the defendants based on the court's discretion.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi