Everingham & Anor v Mullins & Ors No. Scciv-01-714

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

EVERINGHAM & ANOR v MULLINS & ORS
[2001] SASC 415

Full Court:  Martin, Gray and Besanko JJ

  1. MARTIN J            The respondents (“the plaintiffs”) are a firm of solicitors practising as Stanley and Partners.  The appellants (“the defendants”) are former clients of the plaintiffs.  By summons filed in the Magistrates Court on 8 December 1997, the plaintiffs sought to recover from the defendants the sum of $6883.50 for professional services rendered.  The defendants filed a defence alleging that the services provided were not of a professional standard and that, as a consequence, the defendants had suffered damages.  After a trial a magistrate found in favour of the plaintiffs and gave judgment for the full amount of the claim.  Indemnity costs were awarded.  An appeal against that judgment to a single judge was dismissed.  The defendants appeal against the decision of the single judge.

  2. On 3 April 2000 the defendants filed a document headed “Particulars of Defence”.  The magistrate treated the document as including particulars of a counterclaim.  His Honour directed that the defendants should proceed as dux litis.  He expressed his reasons for that decision as follows:

    “9I directed that the defendants should proceed as dux litis. I did so primarily because there had never really been any issue of liability (or non-liability) in respect of the Stanley accounts. The principal quibble that the Everinghams had was that the bills may have been excessive, and to that end Stanleys prepared a Bill of Costs for taxation in the Supreme Court pursuant to s 42 of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981. It would appear that the Bill of Costs is still in that jurisdiction and that Judge Kelly declined to proceed with the taxation until the questions of liability raised by the Everinghams was (sic) resolved in the Magistrates Court civil division.

    10With that background in mind I made the order regarding dux litis and advised Mr Everingham as to the significance of it - with particular reference to the burden of proof and the standard of proof that would apply in these proceedings.”

  3. As the defendants complain that the magistrate erred in directing that they should proceed as dux litis, it is necessary to set out the particulars of the defence:

    “Particulars of Defence

    It is alleged that services provided by the plaintiff(s) were not of a professional standard and/or unnecessary costs were incurred as specified below, and should not be charged to the client:

    1.With respect to charges attributed to matters associated with Teachers Appeal Board Action No.4/1992 the plaintiff;

    a.      failed to inform the client of potential and/or actual conflicts of interest and/or to advise the client to seek independent advice with respect to:

    (i)the plaintiff filing the appeal application out of time.

    (ii)the plaintiff’s failure to advise client that a medical appointment had not been re-scheduled and/or take appropriate action.

    (iii)evidence and or testimony that could be provided by and/or adduced from the plaintiff which was relevant to the matter.

    b.     continued to advise the client in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Everingham & Anor v Mullins & Ors No. Scciv-01-714 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 415
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Everingham & Anor v Mullins & Ors No. Scciv-01-714 involved a dispute between the plaintiffs, Everingham and another, and the defendants, Mullins and others. The central issue was whether the plaintiffs, who were legal representatives for the defendants, had acted negligently in their professional capacity. The case was heard and decided by the Supreme Court. The defendants sought to appeal the decisions made by both the magistrate and the single judge, who had both found in favour of the plaintiffs. The defendants raised 30 grounds of appeal in total, which were narrowed down to ten substantive issues in the appeal to the Supreme Court.

The legal issues before the Supreme Court centered on whether the magistrate and the single judge had erred in their findings and conclusions regarding the plaintiffs' conduct. The defendants argued that the plaintiffs had failed to prosecute one of the actions efficiently, which led to unnecessary costs and jeopardized the success of the action. They also contended that the termination of the retainer was not by mutual consent and that this decision led to their need to change solicitors, thereby losing a chance of success in ongoing proceedings. Additionally, the defendants argued that the plaintiffs were not diligent in their representation and that they had breached their duty of care.

The Supreme Court reviewed the arguments presented and found no merit in the defendants' appeal. The court noted that the magistrate had found no evidence of negligence or impropriety on the part of the plaintiffs and that the single judge had agreed with this finding. The court found that the defendants' criticisms were largely based on nit-picking and did not demonstrate any professional negligence. The court also concluded that the magistrate and the single judge had correctly interpreted the evidence and applied the appropriate legal standards. The Supreme Court upheld the decisions of the lower courts and dismissed the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARTIN J GRAY J BESANKO J
“ConclusionsThere is not at any stage any evidence of want or lapse of care by Mr Bourne or indeed of any impropriety or lack of application of the appropriate professional standards. At all times he acted and made decisions with the best wishes of his clients uppermost in his mind.I must say that I have a considerable sympathy for the plight in which Mr Bourne found himself. It is clear that the Everinghams are a couple who seem to have developed what I would regard as an unwholesome liking for litigation. It is clear that they were very particular clients whose particularity at times bordered on outright difficulty. It may be that they are persons who adhere to counsel of perfection. Mr Bourne was not perfect. But I consider that his performance over the relevant period with which this action was concerned was nigh impeccable and nigh flawless. In my view he did all that a reasonable solicitor in his position could possibly do. It does not surprise me that he has been called to account in these proceedings, by the Everinghams, by virtue of their cavilling and nit-picking attitude.” Before the single judge, the defendants advanced 30 grounds of appeal. Each ground was addressed in turn during oral argument presented by Mr Everingham. The judge identified eight matters that he considered were “deserving of comment”. I can discern no error in the manner in which his Honour approached those eight identified matters. In concluding that no appealable error had been identified by Mr Everingham, his Honour said:“Most of Mr Everingham’s criticisms upon appeal appear to be based upon the “nitpicking” to which the magistrate referred.... The Magistrate did not find any professional negligence and I consider that the Magistrate’s decision was justified by the evidence. Therefore the grounds of appeal largely fall away.” Mr Everingham argued the appeal before this Court. Although there were 21 grounds of appeal, in his written outline of submissions Mr Everingham referred to “ten substantive issues”. Mr Everingham addressed each of those issues in his oral submissions. Having considered the grounds of appeal and the ten issues, in my opinion the defendants have failed to make out a case for intervention by this Court. The magistrate and the single judge were plainly correct. It is only necessary to deal briefly with each of the ten issues specifically addressed on the appeal. The first issue concerns the allegation that the plaintiffs failed to prosecute one of the actions instituted on behalf of the defendants efficiently and diligently. Mr Everingham argued that as a consequence the success of the action was jeopardised and unnecessary costs were incurred. The magistrate rejected the allegation and, on appeal, the judge was satisfied that the magistrate was correct. The defendants have failed to demonstrate that either erred in their conclusions. Secondly, the defendants complain that a finding that the retainer of the plaintiffs was terminated by “mutual consent” was contrary to the evidence given by Mr Everingham. The defendants also argued that as they were compelled to change solicitors, they lost a chance of succeeding in the particular proceedings that were being conducted by Mr Bourne at that time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARTIN J, GRAY J, BESANKO J

Full text does not contain this section.