Eveready Australia Pty Ltd v Gillette Australia Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Eveready Australia Pty Ltd v Gillette Australia Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1824

TRADE PRACTICES – comparative advertising – advertisement that one brand of battery “lasts four times longer” or “lasts up to four times longer” – smaller print stating “than ordinary zinc carbon batteries” – whether advertisement misleading or deceptive – identification of subject of comparison – meaning of “up to”.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 52

EVEREADY AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED v GILLETTE AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED

NG 1205 of 1998

LINDGREN J
23 DECEMBER 1999
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 1205 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

EVEREADY AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 003 539 026)
Applicant

AND:

GILLETTE AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 000 011 914)
Respondent

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 DECEMBER 1999

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding be listed on 9 February 2000 at 9.30 for the making of orders including orders as to costs.

2.The parties provide to the Associate to Lindgren J by 2 February 2000 agreed short minutes of the orders to be made and if agreement has not by then been reached, the forms of short minutes of orders for which they will respectively contend and outlines of their submissions in support.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 1205 OF 1998

BETWEEN:

EVEREADY AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 003 539 026)
Applicant

AND:

GILLETTE AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 000 011 914)
Respondent

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE:

23 DECEMBER 1999

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The parties manufacture batteries.  The applicant (“Eveready”) complains about a comparative advertising campaign by the respondent which sells batteries under the brand name “Duracell” (I will use the word ‘Duracell’ to refer to the respondent itself as well as to its batteries).  Eveready’s complaint arises out of three television advertisements, a form of billboard advertisement, and stickers which were attached to Duracell battery packs.

  2. It will be necessary to discuss in detail the content of the advertising but for the purpose of this introduction it is adequate to think of it as an advertisement that “Duracell lasts four times longer” or “Duracell lasts up to 4 times longer”.  What is the meaning of “up to” four times longer in the present context?   The word “longer” indicates a comparison, but a comparison with what?  These two questions lie at the heart of the present case.

  3. Eveready submits that Duracell’s advertising would have led consumers to think that the comparison being made was between Duracell batteries and the batteries of each other manufacturer. Duracell submits that its advertising would have been understood by consumers as invoking a comparison between its batteries, which are all alkaline batteries, and zinc carbon batteries.  Eveready manufactures, relevantly, both alkaline batteries and zinc carbon batteries, the former under the name “Energiser”.

  4. It is not in dispute

    ·     that alkaline…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Eveready Australia Pty Ltd v Gillette Australia Pty Ltd (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] FCA 1824
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Eveready Australia Pty Ltd sought to have Gillette Australia Pty Ltd's advertisement, which claimed that Duracell batteries last up to four times longer than ordinary zinc carbon batteries, declared misleading or deceptive. The dispute was heard and determined by the Federal Court of Australia. The primary legal issue was whether Gillette's advertisement was misleading or deceptive under the Australian Consumer Law by comparing Duracell alkaline batteries with ordinary zinc carbon batteries. The court had to determine whether the advertisement was likely to mislead consumers about the actual performance of Duracell batteries compared to zinc carbon batteries.

The court found that the advertisement was misleading or deceptive because it did not clearly identify the specific type of zinc carbon batteries against which Duracell's longevity was being compared. The term "ordinary zinc carbon batteries" was not sufficiently defined, leading to confusion among consumers. The court also noted that the phrase "lasts up to four times longer" was not accurate, as tests showed that Duracell batteries did not last up to four times longer than any zinc carbon batteries in all categories tested. The court concluded that the advertisement was likely to mislead consumers into believing that Duracell batteries were superior to all other types of batteries, including alkaline batteries, which was not substantiated by the evidence.

The court ordered the proceeding to be stood over to a date for the making of orders consistent with its reasons. The parties were requested to provide agreed short minutes of the orders to be made or, if no agreement was reached, the forms of short minutes of orders for which they would contend, along with outlines of their submissions in support, by a specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be listed on 9 February 2000 at 9.30 for the making of orders including orders as to costs.

2. The parties provide to the Associate to Lindgren J by 2 February 2000 agreed short minutes of the orders to be made and if agreement has not by then been reached, the forms of short minutes of orders for which they will respectively contend and outlines of their submissions in support.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties are agreed that I should not make orders at this stage but should publish these Reasons then hear the parties on the orders to be made.FACTSThe Australian consumer battery market The issues in the present case arise in the context of the Australian dry cell battery market. According to the evidence, there are three segments to that market: a “primary” or “general purpose” segment; a “rechargeable” segment; and a “specialist” segment. The “specialist” segment embraces small disc batteries designed for use in such things as hearing aids and watches. The present case concerns only the first segment. The general purpose segment encompasses cylindrical batteries with terminals at both ends and oblong batteries with two terminals on the top. The cylindrical batteries come in “sizes” generally known as AAA, AA, C and D, D being the largest and heaviest, and AAA being the smallest and lightest. The oblong configuration comprises six volt (6V) and nine volt (9V) batteries. By far the largest selling battery is the AA. Marketing is largely by brand and the two main brands in the Australian market are those represented by the present parties. Another is Panasonic and there are house brands of which “Acme”, the Woolworths house brand, and “No Frills”, are referred to in the evidence. Batteries store energy. A way of describing and measuring a battery’s capacity to store energy is by reference to its life. Lithium batteries have a longer life than alkaline, and, as already noted, alkaline have a longer life than zinc carbon. While Duracell batteries are all sold under the “Duracell” brand, Eveready batteries are sold under different names. “Energiser” is the Eveready alkaline product. Eveready sells its zinc carbon batteries as “General Purpose”, “Heavy Duty” and “Super Heavy Duty”. The “General Purpose” Eveready battery is blue and is sometimes called the “Eveready Blue”; the “Heavy Duty” Eveready product is red and is sometimes called the “Eveready Red”; and the “Super Heavy Duty” Eveready product is black and is sometimes called the “Eveready Black”. Eveready’s Super Heavy Duty battery, the Eveready Black, is the largest selling zinc carbon battery. The main sales of the batteries of present concern occur in supermarkets and variety stores. In the marketing evidence, the supermarket outlets are called “grocery”, while the variety stores are such chains as “Target” and “Big W”. In total, the grocery and variety store outlets account for some 80 per cent of total sales. The energy storage capacity of batteries is reflected in their price. The Energiser and Duracell batteries, both being alkaline, occupy the “premium” segment of the primary battery market and are generally recognised by consumers as being long-lasting, multi-purpose and suitable for medium to high drain consumer devices. They sell for virtually the same price. The parties provided a statement of agreed facts in relation to “technical evidence” (“the Agreed Statement”). The Agreed Statement included a table headed, “Duracell Alkaline v ZnC Batteries – Average Duration Multiplier UNSW & Eveready Tests Combined”, a table of results of tests of the longevity of various kinds of batteries (“the Table”). The following is the text of the Agreed Statement (the Table is the first table annexed to these Reasons):“1.Eveready and Gillette both manufacture consumer batteries in range [sic] of standard sizes. There are three types of consumer battery relevant to the proceedings; zinc carbon, alkaline and lithium. The types differ in their chemical content and structure. Eveready sells batteries of all three types under the brand names Eveready, Energizer and Energizer Lithium respectively. Gillette only sells alkaline batteries. They are sold under the brand name Duracell and (since February 1990) Duracell Ultra.2.The oldest technology is zinc carbon. Alkaline is a more advanced technology. Alkaline batteries will outperform a zinc carbon battery for all consumer uses. The extent to which an alkaline battery lasts longer than a zinc carbon battery of the same size is not uniform but depends on the particular consumer use.3.A further more advanced type of battery technology is lithium. Lithium batteries possess some advantages over alkaline batteries; they are lighter, can run at higher voltages and can store even more energy than alkaline batteries.4.It is agreed that the claim ‘lasts up to four times longer’ could not accurately be made if the relevant comparison was Duracell alkaline batteries as against Energizer alkaline or Energizer Lithium batteries.5.Standards have been promulgated for testing of the performance of batteries. The standard used by battery manufacturers, including Eveready and Gillette, is the IEC (‘International Electrotechnical Commission’) standard IEC 86-1 and IEC 86-2. This standard has been adopted in Australia by Standards Australia where it is known as standard AS/NZ 2176/96. The testing undertaken by Eveready and Gillette was to this standard.6.The standards require certain testing conditions and tests that are designed to simulate generally consumers’ actual use of batteries in appliances. For each test appliance, for example ‘Radio’, the standard prescribes the test schedule that is to be followed, i.e. the periods for which the appliances is to be switched on. For example, the standard specified that the test schedule for the AAA size ‘Tape Recorder’ test is for the batteries to be run one hour per day. The standards also specify the test conditions, for example, the resistance and end voltages to be used.7.Testing is then done by placing the battery to be tested into a computer-controlled test apparatus, which is then used to apply the relevant test schedule. The test terminates when the battery has been run down to a pre-specified voltage. The time for this to occur (or the number of cycles, for example in a camera flash test) is a measure of the life of the battery under those test conditions. The test is done with a number of identical batteries and the results averaged.8.Annexed hereto is a table which summaries the results of the battery tests carried out by Eveready and Gillette. The table shows the factor by which the life of the standard Duracell alkaline battery exceeds that of the carious [sic – various] zinc carbon batteries. For example, the results show that AA Duracell alkaline battery lasts 3.33 times longer than the No Frills zinc carbon battery when tested using the ‘Tape Recorder’ test.9.The performance of the Duracell alkaline battery was compared with a range of zinc carbon batteries. Those zinc carbon batteries include No Frills, Eveready Red, Panasonic, Acme and Mallory Plus heavy duty batteries and the Eveready Black and Panasonic Extra/Super heavy duty batteries. In addition to the Eveready Red and Black batteries Eveready also sells a lower grade of General Purpose battery known as the Eveready Blue. This battery was not tested but it generally performs at a lower level than the Eveready Red battery.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

All of the Duracell battery packs are marked “Alkaline Batteries”. However, in most cases these words appear in relatively small and fine print on the bottom left hand corner of the battery pack.Survey evidence At the request of the solicitors for Eveready, Q2 Market Research (“Q2”) conducted what it described as “a communications test on a Duracell commercial”. The individual at Q2 responsible was Patrick Weissenberg. Mr Weissenberg apparently has a postgraduate Diploma in Market Research and Advertising from the University of South Africa and Master of Commerce degree based on a thesis, “The Assessment of Advertising Effectiveness”. Since 1980 he has been employed in the market research area. Mr Weissenberg devised a questionnaire intended to subject respondents to a memory test, a comprehension test and an interpretative test. The questionnaire was administered, not by Q2, but by NCS Australasia Pty Ltd (“NCS”), who trained and engaged interviewers for the purpose. Four hundred interviews were conducted; 200 in a shopping centre at Hurstville, Sydney and 200 in a shopping centre at Fountaingate, Melbourne. The survey was conducted from Thursday 1 to Saturday 3 July 1999. Respondents were to be over fourteen years but less than seventy years of age. A person was to be excluded if he or she worked for Duracell or a member of his or her family did so. The individuals were taken to an enclosed area and were twice shown a “clutter reel” of five commercials in sequence. The Duracell commercial was the third in the sequence. The questionnaire contained twenty questions. According to Mr Weissenberg, certain questions contained the memory test and were directed to assessing what respondents recalled after exposure to the commercial in the manner described. According to him, the comprehension test was directed to assessing what respondents understood by the terms “ordinary batteries”, “zinc carbon batteries” and “ordinary zinc carbon batteries”. The interpretative test was designed to assess how the message of the commercial was interpreted. The last question, question 20, was directed to this end. It read:“In the commercial they say ‘Duracell lasts up to four times longer than ordinary zinc carbon batteries’. What does this suggest to you about Duracell?”Suggestions for “probing” respondents were contained in the form of instructions to interviewers. The “probes” were of the form “What else? Anything else?” That is, in relation to appropriate questions, after giving his or her initial response, a respondent would be asked “What else?” and after responding, would be asked “Anything else?” Mr Weissenberg concluded:“Based on the communications test which was undertaken, I have made the following conclusions:·The brand name ‘Duracell’ is clearly recalled after two exposures to the commercial. ·The phrase ‘up to’ is only recalled by a very insignificant number of respondents.·Whilst the term ‘ordinary’ is used in the voice-over and is shown briefly on the screen in two key frames, it is not clearly recalled by the vast majority of respondents.·A very insignificant number of respondents recalled the term ‘zinc carbon’.·Whether or not the term ‘zinc carbon’ was recalled, it was not a term understood by the respondents.·The message ‘lasts up to 4 times longer than ordinary zinc carbon batteries’ is misunderstood by an overwhelming majority of respondents to the test.·The two message panels which were put to respondents in questions 12-17 containing the references to zinc carbon batteries, [these were taken from the Duracell advertisement in the “clutter reel”] are not recalled by the substantial majority of respondents.·Those respondents who recalled the references to the two message panels did not understand the meaning of those references. In my view, this is due to the following factors:-The poor contrast between the writing and the background on which they appear;-The short length of time in which the message is exposed;-The visual distraction which occurs at the time the message panels appear;-The strong emphasis in the final scene of the commercial on the words ‘lasts up to 4 times longer’.·Even if the commercial had properly conveyed a reference to zinc carbon batteries, there would still be confusion in the minds of the consumer or [sic – as] to the type of batteries referred to.My overall conclusion is that most respondents have been left with the understanding that Duracell is superior to all other batteries, including alkaline batteries.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
But again, as explained in para [53] above, the Duracell batteries do not attain the “four times longer” measure on any test as against zinc carbon batteries of the classes AAA or 9V, and as explained in para [54] above, the Duracell batteries do not attain the “four times longer” measure on any test as against the zinc carbon batteries of the classes of the manufacturers there mentioned.CONCLUSION As requested by the parties, the proceeding will be stood over to a date for the making of orders consistent with the above reasons.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J