Evans v Wakefield Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division)

EVANS v WAKEFIELD REGIONAL COUNCIL

[2009] SASC 238

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kourakis

13 August 2009

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - CONTROL OF PARTICULAR MATTERS - RURAL AND AGRICULTURAL - PARTICULAR CASES

The appellant sought approval for a development which involved the conversion of the existing residence on his farm to a manager’s residence and the construction of a new dwelling on the farm for his family – the Wakefield Regional Council refused the appellant’s application – the appellant appealed to the Environment, Resources and Development Court, where a Commissioner of that Court dismissed the appeal – the appellant appealed the Commissioner’s decision – whether the Commissioner erred in dismissing the appellant’s appeal.

Held:  The Commissioner erred in law by misconstruing individual provisions of the Wakefield Council Development Plan and the implications which arise from the combined effect of those provisions – in particular the Commissioner erred in proceeding on the basis that there is an implication in the Development Plan that approval should not ordinarily be given for the construction of new or additional dwellings in the Primary Industry Zone – appeal allowed – matter remitted to the Environment, Resources and Development Court.

Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993 s 30, referred to.
Evans v Wakefield Regional Council [2009] SAERDC 19, considered.

EVANS v WAKEFIELD REGIONAL COUNCIL
[2009] SASC 238

  1. KOURAKIS J:      The appellant is the owner of a 132 hectare allotment of land (the farm) near the intersection of the Balaclava/Mallala and Pinery/Owen roads, near Owen in the Mid North of South Australia.  The appellant and his family reside in an existing house on the farm.  Most of the land is used for cropping, however there is a sheep feedlot in the north-western corner of the farm.  Mr Evans proposes to increase the production and improve the efficiency of the feedlot by engaging a manager who will reside on the farm.  In March 2008 Mr Evans sought approval for a development which involved the conversion of the existing residence into a manager’s residence and the construction of a new dwelling for his family approximately 500 metres south of the existing residence.

  2. The Wakefield Regional Council (Wakefield) refused the application on 9 October 2008.  Mr Evans appealed the decision to the Environment, Resources and Development Court (the Environment Court).  A Commissioner of that Court dismissed the appeal on 20 April 2009.[1] On 8 May 2009 Mr Evans appealed to this Court. The appeal is brought pursuant to s 30 of the Environment, Resources and Development Court Act 1993.

  3. I have concluded that the Commissioner erred in law by misconstruing individual provisions of the Wakefield Regional Council Development Plan (Development Plan) and the implications which arise from the combined effect of those provisions.  In particular, the Commissioner was wrong to proceed on the basis that there is an implication in the Development…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Evans v Wakefield Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 238
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Evans v Wakefield Regional Council is a case concerning the approval of a development application by Mr Evans, who sought permission to convert an existing residence on his farm into a manager’s residence and build a new dwelling for his family. The Wakefield Regional Council rejected the application, and the subsequent appeal to the Environment, Resources and Development Court was dismissed by a Commissioner. Mr Evans then appealed the Commissioner’s decision to a higher court. The central issue was whether the Commissioner erred in law by misconstruing the Wakefield Regional Council Development Plan and the implications arising from the combined effect of its provisions, specifically regarding the approval of new or additional dwellings in the Primary Industry Zone.

The court found that the Commissioner did indeed err in law by misinterpreting certain provisions of the Development Plan. The Commissioner incorrectly assumed that the Development Plan implied that approval should not ordinarily be given for the construction of new or additional dwellings in the Primary Industry Zone. The court clarified that there is no general rule in the plan that restricts approval to only those developments that directly and substantially enhance the productive capacity of the land. Instead, the approval of such developments depends on a balanced consideration of all relevant planning factors. The court also noted that the plan does not require applicants to justify the construction of a dwelling as an exception to a general rule, as the Commissioner had suggested.

In light of these findings, the appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted to the Environment, Resources and Development Court for further consideration in line with the court’s determination. The court's reasoning emphasized the importance of correctly interpreting the Development Plan and its implications, ensuring that the balance of planning considerations is appropriately weighed in the approval process. The decision highlights the need for accurate legal interpretation of planning regulations to ensure fair and just outcomes in development applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

I have concluded that the Commissioner erred in law by misconstruing individual provisions of the Wakefield Regional Council Development Plan (Development Plan) and the implications which arise from the combined effect of those provisions. In particular, the Commissioner was wrong to proceed on the basis that there is an implication in the Development Plan that approval should not ordinarily be given for the construction of new or additional dwellings in the Primary Industry Zone. There is no implication in the plan that, generally, construction of a dwelling will only be approved if it directly and substantially enhances the productive capacity of the land within the Primary Industry Zone. In my view, approval of such a development in the Primary Industry Zone depends on a balancing of all of the relevant planning considerations. An applicant for development does not need to justify the construction of a dwelling as an exception to a general rule of the sort postulated by the Commissioner. My reasons for so concluding are given below.Background facts The farm has been in Mr Evans’ family’s hands for about three generations. His grandparents bought the farm shortly after World War II. Mr Evans was brought up on his parents’ property which was located near the farm. His parents later moved to Eyre Peninsular where they undertook broad acre farming and also maintained a feedlot operation. Mr Evans left his parents property to complete his tertiary education in Adelaide. Mr Evans has lived in the existing residence on the farm for about 11 years. Mr Evans still feels an affinity to the Owen community. He referred in his evidence to “some of the old families which I am part of there”. Mr Evans now works as an accountant in suburban Adelaide and commutes for that purpose during the working week. He also has a number of business interests. He is involved in a fertilizer importation, transport and spreading business which employs about 60 workers. Mr Evans also holds property near Broken Hill. His initial intention was to use the feedlot on the farm to prepare livestock from Broken Hill for market. However, Mr Evans has expanded the feedlot to take on lambs bought from other sources. In 2008 about 48,000 lambs were processed through the feedlot. There are very few sheep feedlots of that size in South Australia.The Development The farm is situated within the Primary Industry Zone of the Development Plan. By his application for development approval Mr Evans proposed to alter the existing residence into a manager’s residence. The existing home office would be converted into a dedicated office for the management of the feedlot. The manager’s residence would also provide for persons visiting the property to work (such as contract shearers) or on business. Shower and toilet facilities would be made available for those visitors. The floor area of the proposed new dwelling is 386 square metres with a verandah extending around its perimeter and a 67 square metre garage.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Moreover, many dwellings on farming properties were built in times of economic adversity and would now not be regarded as comfortable or desirable forms of accommodation. There is nothing in the plan which suggests that there is a general rule against constructing new dwellings in place of old. Nor is there anything in the plan which suggests that the construction of dwellings should only be approved for persons who are engaged on a full time basis, or at least on some substantial basis, in the day to day farming operations. On the contrary, in my view the efficiency of farming operations will often be improved by allowing a proprietor who undertakes some supervision of the farming operations to reside on the land. In those cases, investment in agricultural production will be encouraged if the proprietor of an agricultural operation is permitted to reside on site. Furthermore, where a farm proprietor seeks approval to replace an existing dwelling with a new one, the interest of the proprietor to continue to reside on his or her farm in appropriate accommodation is a relevant factor in assessing his or her application.Conclusion I have already explained my view that the Commissioner erred in finding that the development directly contravened Principle 169 and was, by implication, inconsistent with Principles 25 and 26 of the Primary Industry Zone. The primary finding of the Commissioner and the essential reasons for it are expressed in the following paragraphs:56On careful consideration of the evidence, what I observed on the view, my own assessment of the proposal against the Development Plan and weighing up both the pros and cons of the composite proposal (both change of use conversion of a dwelling to feedlot manager’s residence; and new large dwelling for the appellant and his family) I conclude that this proposal does not sufficiently meet the spirit or intent nor key strategy aims and objectives of the Development Plan and is thus not worthy of Development Plan Consent.57Whilst the Council did not detail the reasoning of its refusal, a number of the Development Plan clauses it referred to, particularly, Council Wide Strategic Aim (in my view para 2), Objectives 10, 18 and 20, and Principles 3, 168 and 169; and PIZ Strategic Aim (in my view para 6) and Objective 1 and Principle 2, are not sufficiently achieved by the development proposal and I find that the proposal is sufficiently at variance with the Development Plan as a whole to warrant that decision. I agree with and accept the conclusions of Ms Nolan, a most experienced urban, regional and environmental planner.[8][8] Evans v Wakefield Regional Council [2009] SAERDC 19 at [36]-[37]. The reference to Ms Nolan’s conclusion is most probably a reference to the following paragraph of her report dated 3 March 2009:8.1In my view, the construction of a new dwelling on the land is contrary to the overall intent of the development plan and to the specific intent of the primary industry zone to restrict dwellings on the land and to accommodate only activity/development which is directly associated with agricultural production.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established