EVANS and Shire Of Irwin

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   EVANS and SHIRE OF IRWIN [2006] WASAT 288

MEMBER:   MR D R PARRY (SENIOR MEMBER)

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   22 SEPTEMBER 2006

FILE NO/S:   DR 237 of 2006

BETWEEN:   DARREN EVANS

Applicant

AND

SHIRE OF IRWIN
Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Aged persons' housing - Density - Preliminary issue - Whether development is capable of approval - Determination of density coding applicable to site - Density coding for zone is R12.5 - Aged Persons Village is specific land use and subject to minimum area per dwelling development standard according to R30 - Whether discretion under Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002) to reduce minimum and average site areas by up to one-third for Aged Persons' dwelling is applicable to R12.5 or R30 density coding

Legislation:

Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002), cl 3.1.1 A1, cl 3.1.1 A3, cl 3.1.1 P1

Shire of Irwin Town Planning Scheme No 4, cl 1.10.3, cl 3.4.3, cl 3.4.4, cl 5.1.2, cl 5.1.3, cl 6.2

Result:

Development application is not capable of approval
Application for review dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     Self-represented

Respondent:     Mr SJ Bain (Acting as Agent)

Solicitors:

Applicant:     Self-represented

Respondent:     Shire of Irwin

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Nil

Case(s) also cited:

Forrest and Town of Cottesloe [2005] WASAT 311

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. The Shire of Irwin contended that a proposed aged persons' housing development was incapable of approval, because the minimum and average site areas were less than the minimum areas prescribed in the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002).

  2. The Tribunal determined that the relevant residential density coding of the land was R12.5, as argued by the Shire, not R30, as argued by the applicant.  Although a discretion to reduce the minimum and average site areas by up to one-third was available, even if the discretion were exercised, the minimum and average site areas proposed were less than those required by the Codes.  Furthermore, the development did not conform to the minimum area of lot per dwelling unit development standard prescribed in the local planning scheme.

  3. The development application was incapable of approval and the decision of the Shire to refuse development approval was affirmed.

Introduction

  1. The Shire of Irwin (Shire) has raised a preliminary issue for determination in planning review proceedings which are pending before the Tribunal.  The proceedings concern the Shire's refusal of a development application for approval to the construction of 40 aged persons' grouped dwellings and common facilities at Lot 15 Point Leander Drive, Port Denison (site) (DA).

  2. The preliminary issue is whether the DA is capable of approval.  This issue turns on the determination of the relevant density coding prescribed by the local planning scheme in relation to the site.

Relevant Scheme and Codes provisions

  1. The site is zoned "Residential R12.5" under the Shire of Irwin Town Planning Scheme…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EVANS and Shire Of Irwin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] WASAT 288
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Evans and Shire of Irwin, the applicant, Evans, sought approval for a development application concerning aged persons' housing. The Shire of Irwin, the respondent, refused the application, leading to Evans seeking judicial review of the decision in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The core dispute revolved around whether the proposed development was capable of approval under the relevant town planning laws, specifically focusing on the density coding and the standards applicable to the proposed aged persons' village.

The legal issues before the court included whether the development could be approved under the R12.5 density coding, whether the Aged Persons Village was a specific land use subject to the minimum area per dwelling development standard according to R30, and whether the discretion under the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002) to reduce minimum and average site areas by up to one-third for Aged Persons' dwellings was applicable to either R12.5 or R30 density coding. The court needed to determine if the development could comply with the relevant planning laws and standards.

The court examined the statutory provisions and planning regulations, concluding that the proposed development did not meet the required standards for either density coding. The court found that the Aged Persons Village was indeed a specific land use and subject to the minimum area per dwelling standard under R30. However, the court held that the discretion available under the Residential Design Codes to reduce minimum and average site areas did not apply to the R12.5 density coding. Consequently, the court affirmed the Shire of Irwin's decision to refuse development approval, holding that the proposed development was not capable of approval. The application for review was dismissed, and the Shire's decision was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proposed development is not capable of approval. 2. The application for review is dismissed. 3. The decision of the respondent to refuse development approval for an Aged Persons Village at Lot 15 Point Leander Drive, Port Denison is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The subject of the case involves a development application submitted by Evans for the establishment of an Aged Persons Village on Lot 15 Point Leander Drive in Port Denison. The application proposed a specific land use as an Aged Persons Village, which falls under the category of aged persons' housing. This type of development is governed by certain standards and regulations, including minimum area per dwelling, as stipulated in the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002). The site in question is zoned under the R12.5 density coding, while the specific land use for the Aged Persons Village adheres to the standards outlined in R30. The crux of the dispute revolves around whether the discretion available under the Residential Design Codes to reduce the minimum and average site areas by up to one-third is applicable to the R12.5 density coding or the R30 specific land use coding.

Evans argued that the development should be capable of approval under the discretion provided in the Residential Design Codes, which allows for a reduction in the required site areas for Aged Persons' dwellings. The Shire of Irwin, however, contested this argument, asserting that the proposed development did not meet the necessary standards and could not be approved as such. This disagreement led to the submission of a review application by Evans, which sought to overturn the Shire's decision to refuse development approval. The primary issue before the court was to determine whether the development proposed by Evans was capable of approval, considering the interplay between the R12.5 density coding and the R30 specific land use coding, and whether the discretion under the Residential Design Codes could be applied to the R12.5 density coding.

In response to the review application, the Shire of Irwin maintained its position that the development was not capable of approval, as it did not comply with the applicable standards and regulations. The court was tasked with evaluating the arguments presented by both parties and making a determination on the capability of the proposed development to be approved. This required an analysis of the relevant zoning and design codes, as well as an understanding of the specific circumstances and conduct that led to the legal dispute. Ultimately, the court's decision would affirm or overturn the Shire's initial refusal of development approval and provide guidance on the application of the Residential Design Codes to the R12.5 density coding and R30 specific land use coding.

The matter before the court involves a review of a decision by the Shire of Irwin to refuse development approval for an Aged Persons Village at Lot 15 Point Leander Drive, Port Denison. The applicant, Evans, filed an application for review of the Shire's decision, challenging the determination that the proposed development was not capable of approval. This application followed a prior decision by the Shire to refuse the development application on the grounds that it did not comply with the applicable density coding and minimum area per dwelling standards. The case has traversed through initial assessment and refusal by the local council, leading to the subsequent judicial review application by Evans. Key procedural steps include the filing of the review application and the consideration of preliminary issues regarding the applicability of discretion under the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002) to the specific land use and density coding in question. The court's role is to determine whether the development is capable of approval and to affirm or overturn the Shire's decision based on the procedural and statutory framework governing town planning and development applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the proposed development capable of approval under the relevant town planning regulations?
2. What is the applicable density coding for the site, specifically whether it is governed by R12.5 or R30?
3. Is there a minimum area per dwelling development standard applicable to the Aged Persons Village as a specific land use under R30?
4. Does the discretion under the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002) to reduce the minimum and average site areas by up to one-third apply to the R12.5 or R30 density coding for Aged Persons' dwellings?

Held
1. Is the proposed development capable of approval under the relevant town planning regulations?
The court concluded that the proposed development is not capable of approval under the relevant town planning regulations.

2. What is the applicable density coding for the site, specifically whether it is governed by R12.5 or R30?
The court concluded that the applicable density coding for the site is governed by R12.5.

3. Is there a minimum area per dwelling development standard applicable to the Aged Persons Village as a specific land use under R30?
The court concluded that there is a minimum area per dwelling development standard applicable to the Aged Persons Village as a specific land use under R30.

4. Does the discretion under the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002) to reduce the minimum and average site areas by up to one-third apply to the R12.5 or R30 density coding for Aged Persons' dwellings?
The court concluded that the discretion under the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002) to reduce the minimum and average site areas by up to one-third does not apply to the R12.5 or R30 density coding for Aged Persons' dwellings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the decision of Evans and Shire Of Irwin, the primary focus of the court was to determine whether the proposed development for an Aged Persons Village could be approved under the relevant town planning regulations. The court examined several key issues, including the capability of the development for approval, the applicable density coding, the minimum area per dwelling development standard, and the applicability of the discretion to reduce minimum and average site areas under the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002).

Firstly, the court assessed whether the proposed development was capable of approval. It determined that the proposed development did not meet the requirements set out in the town planning regulations. The court held that the development, as proposed, did not align with the zoning regulations and planning policies designed to protect the interests of the community and ensure sustainable development. Consequently, the court concluded that the proposed development was not capable of approval.

Secondly, the court addressed the issue of the applicable density coding for the site. The site in question was zoned under R12.5, which generally allows for a higher density of residential development compared to R30. However, the development proposed was for an Aged Persons Village, a specific land use governed by R30. The court noted that while the zoning code indicated R12.5, the specific nature of the development as an Aged Persons Village necessitated an examination under R30. The court found that the site was subject to the requirements of R30, which includes specific minimum area per dwelling standards.

The court then examined whether there was a minimum area per dwelling development standard applicable to the Aged Persons Village under R30. The court held that R30 does impose a minimum area per dwelling standard for Aged Persons' dwellings. The proposed development did not meet these minimum area requirements, which are essential to ensure the quality of life and safety of the residents. The court emphasised that these standards were not merely discretionary but mandatory, and compliance was necessary for the approval of the development.

Lastly, the court addressed the applicability of the discretion under the Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002) to reduce the minimum and average site areas by up to one-third for Aged Persons' dwellings. The court found that this discretion was applicable under R30, not R12.5. Given that the development was an Aged Persons Village, it fell under the specific provisions of R30. The court noted that while the discretion could be exercised under R30, the proposed development did not comply with the minimum area requirements even when applying this discretion. Therefore, the proposed development did not meet the necessary standards under R30.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a development for an Aged Persons Village, even if proposed in a zone with a higher density coding (R12.5), is subject to the specific land use provisions of R30, including the minimum area per dwelling standards. Additionally, any discretion to reduce these minimum areas applies only under R30, and the proposed development must still meet the mandatory standards even with the exercise of this discretion. The court's decision affirms the importance of adhering to specific land use regulations designed to protect the welfare of vulnerable populations.