SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Application)
EVAJADE PTY LTD & ORS v COCKATOO RIDGE WINES LIMITED
Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court
21 April 2005
PROCEDURE
Application to strike out summons insofar as it had been issued by three companies - summons issued by another natural plaintiff under alleged powers of attorney from the companies and without leave under R36.11(2) - held such issue of the summons by the companies was irregular and actions by them permanently stayed unless and until a solicitor represents them.
EVAJADE PTY LTD & ORS v COCKATOO RIDGE WINES LIMITED
[2005] SASC 152Reasons on Application by First Defendant to Strike Out the Action Against the Three Corporate Plaintiffs
Judge Lunn This action was instituted in the District Court on 8 February 2005. The plaintiffs were named as Evajade Pty Ltd as trustee for the Andrew Garrett Family Trust (“Evajade”), Andrew Garrett, Averil Garrett, International Vineyards Pty Ltd (“Vineyards”), International Vintners Australia Pty Ltd (“Vintners”), Nicholas Garrett and Tom Garrett. Averil Garrett is the wife of Andrew Garrett. Nicholas and Tom Garrett are children of Andrew Garrett. The defendants were named as Cockatoo Ridge Wines Ltd (“Cockatoo”), Brenton Atkinson, Edward Shipley and International Vintners Australia Pty Ltd.
The summons was signed by Andrew Garrett purportedly acting under powers of attorney for the other plaintiffs. There is no solicitor on the record for any plaintiff. Mr Garrett has sought to conduct the proceedings on behalf of all plaintiffs.
Annexed to the summons was a document entitled “Preliminary Statement of Claim”. It contained 145 paragraphs alleging fraud and misconduct by the other defendants in the affairs of Cockatoo. It then apparently claimed pre-action discovery, orders reversing various transactions and findings of fraud against Shipley and Atkinson. In the body of the summons it was stated:
“Summons issued pursuant to Rules 7.04, 9.01 (insofar as it relates to Pre-action discovery), 10.02, 10.03, 58 and 58A of the Supreme Court Rules”.
The summons does not expressly refer to Rule 60 which deals with pre-action discovery. Interestingly the fee paid on issue of the summons to the District Court was only $65 which indicates that it was proffered to the District Court as a summons for pre-action discovery under paragraph 1 of Schedule 1 of the District Court (Fees) Regulations 2004. If orders other than pre-action discovery were sought, an additional fee of $438 was payable under item 3 of that Schedule.
On 28 February 2005 a Master of the District Court transferred the action to this Court where it has since proceeded.
On 4 April 2005 Cockatoo took out an application seeking, inter alia, that the summons be struck out insofar as it was an action by Evajade, Vintners and Vineyard. The basis of the application was that was impermissible for Mr Garrett to have instituted the action on their behalf. I allowed Mr Garrett to speak on his own behalf and that of the three plaintiff companies in opposing the application.
Cockatoo also…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Evajade Pty Ltd v Cockatoo Ridge Wines Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] SASC 152
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether it was permissible for Andrew Garrett to institute the action on behalf of the other plaintiffs without the involvement of a solicitor and whether the summons should be struck out as it had been issued by the companies without the required leave under Rule 36.11(2) of the Supreme Court Rules. Additionally, the court needed to consider whether the action could proceed if a solicitor filed a notice of acting and took over the conduct of the action, or if it should be permanently stayed if that did not occur.
The court held that it was impermissible for Andrew Garrett to have instituted the action on behalf of the companies, and that the summons should not have been issued without the required leave under Rule 36.11(2). The court found that the summons should only be issued if leave was granted under Rule 36.11(1), and that such leave would not have been granted. The court also determined that the non-compliance with the Rules did not render the action void or make it a nullity. Instead, the appropriate course was to impose a permanent stay of proceedings unless and until a solicitor filed a notice of acting for the companies in accordance with Rule 11. The court further noted that the action as brought by Andrew Garrett and his family as personal plaintiffs against Cockatoo Ridge Wines Ltd remained in place, and that the question of costs would be left until the rest of the application had been dealt with.
The final orders of the court were that the action insofar as it had been brought by Evajade Pty Ltd, International Vineyards Pty Ltd, and International Vintners Australia Pty Ltd be permanently stayed unless and until a solicitor filed a notice of acting for those companies in accordance with Rule 11. The costs were reserved, and the matter was fit for counsel. The court also noted that similar applications were on file from the other defendants, and it would hear the parties on the listing of the outstanding applications for hearing.
Background
Background to the litigation
The fee paid on the issue of the summons to the District Court was $65, indicating it was presented as a summons for pre-action discovery under the District Court (Fees) Regulations 2004. If other orders were sought, an additional fee was payable. On 28 February 2005, the action was transferred to the Supreme Court of South Australia. On 4 April 2005, Cockatoo applied to strike out the summons insofar as it was brought by Evajade, Vintners, and Vineyard, arguing that it was impermissible for Mr. Garrett to have instituted the action on their behalf. Cockatoo also sought leave to bring the application against Vintners and Vineyard, which was granted as it did not contravene an injunction previously granted by Gray J. On 11 March, Mr. Garrett was directed to file any application concerning his representing other parties by 24 March, but no such application was filed. Consequently, Cockatoo's application was heard on the basis that no leave had been granted to Mr. Garrett to represent or appear for Evajade, Vintners, and Vineyard in this action.
The matter before the court arose from an action that was initially instituted in the District Court on 8 February 2005. The plaintiffs, which included Evajade Pty Ltd, Averil Garrett, Nicholas Garrett, and Tom Garrett, filed the summons against Cockatoo Ridge Wines Ltd and several other defendants. The summons was purportedly signed by Andrew Garrett, acting under powers of attorney for the other plaintiffs, but no solicitor was on record for any of the plaintiffs. Mr. Garrett sought to conduct the proceedings on behalf of all plaintiffs, including the three companies, despite the absence of a solicitor. On 28 February 2005, the District Court transferred the action to the Supreme Court. On 4 April 2005, Cockatoo took out an application seeking, inter alia, that the summons be struck out insofar as it was an action by Evajade, Vintners, and Vineyard. The basis of the application was that it was impermissible for Mr. Garrett to have instituted the action on behalf of the three plaintiff companies. The court allowed Mr. Garrett to speak on his own behalf and that of the three plaintiff companies in opposing the application. Cockatoo also sought leave to bring the application against Vintners and Vineyard, which the court did not consider contrary to the terms of an injunction granted by Gray J on 30 March 2005. The court held that the summons should not have been issued by the District Court and should have been conditional upon leave being granted to Mr. Garrett under Rule 36.11(1). As stated above, if that leave had been sought, it would have been refused. However, under Rule 3.05(1) this non-compliance with the Rules does not render the action void or make it a nullity. The situation here is not materially distinguishable from that in Hubbard Association of Scientologists International v Anderson (No 2) above. The court decided that if a solicitor filed a notice of acting and took over the conduct of the action, it could proceed, but it should not proceed if that did not occur. Hence it imposed a permanent stay of proceedings which was only to be lifted if and when a solicitor filed a notice of acting.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was it permissible for Andrew Garrett to issue the summons on behalf of Evajade, Vintners, and Vineyards without obtaining leave under Rule 36.11?
2. Should the summons be struck out as it was issued without compliance with Rule 36.11(2)?
3. If the summons was struck out, should it result in the proceedings being declared void or should they be stayed until proper representation is obtained?
4. Can Andrew Garrett represent the trust in which he claims to be a beneficiary, in place of the trustee Evajade?
5. Should the action brought by Andrew Garrett and his family as personal plaintiffs against Cockatoo be allowed to proceed?
Held
1. It was not permissible for Andrew Garrett to issue the summons on behalf of Evajade, Vintners, and Vineyards without obtaining leave under Rule 36.11. The court held that such issuance of the summons by the companies was irregular.
2. The summons should be struck out as it was issued without compliance with Rule 36.11(2). The court held that the summons should not have been issued by the District Court without leave being granted.
3. If the summons was struck out, the court held that the proceedings should be permanently stayed until a solicitor represents the companies, rather than declaring the proceedings void.
4. Andrew Garrett could not represent the trust in which he claims to be a beneficiary in place of the trustee Evajade. The court held that Rule 30.02(2) would only enable the beneficiary to be joined as an additional party, not in substitution for the trustee.
5. The court did not reach a conclusion on whether the action brought by Andrew Garrett and his family as personal plaintiffs against Cockatoo should be allowed to proceed, as this matter was reserved for later argument.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court first addressed the issue of whether it was permissible for Andrew Garrett to issue the summons on behalf of Evajade, Vintners, and Vineyards without obtaining leave under Rule 36.11. The Court noted that under Rule 36.11(2), any summons issued by a company must be accompanied by an application for leave and should only be issued if the Court grants leave under Rule 36.11(1). The summons in this case was issued without such leave, making its issuance irregular. This issue highlights the Court's adherence to procedural rules and its insistence that such rules be followed strictly, especially when they involve corporate plaintiffs. The Court relied on its inherent jurisdiction and the precedent set in Hubbard Association of Scientologists International v Anderson (No 2) to emphasize that while procedural non-compliance does not render an action void, it may warrant a stay of proceedings until proper compliance is achieved.
Next, the Court examined whether the summons should be struck out due to the non-compliance with Rule 36.11(2). The Court found that while the summons was irregular, it did not render the action void or a nullity. Instead, the Court imposed a permanent stay on the proceedings brought by Evajade, Vintners, and Vineyards until a solicitor was appointed to represent them. This decision aligns with the Court's obligation to uphold procedural integrity while also ensuring that justice is not unduly delayed. The Court referenced previous cases such as Crescent Oil and Shipping Services Ltd v Implrantang UEE and Eastern Metropolitan Regional Council v Four Seasons Construction Pty Ltd to support the idea that companies generally cannot initiate legal proceedings without a solicitor, and this principle is reinforced by the Rules.
The Court also considered whether striking out the summons should result in the proceedings being declared void or merely stayed. The Court ruled against declaring the proceedings void, choosing instead to impose a stay. This decision was based on the Court's inherent jurisdiction to manage its own proceedings and the precedent in Hubbard Association of Scientologists International v Anderson (No 2), where the Court similarly imposed a stay rather than declaring the proceedings void due to procedural irregularities. The Court's decision to stay rather than void the proceedings demonstrates a balanced approach that preserves the plaintiffs' rights while enforcing procedural compliance.
Another issue addressed by the Court was whether Andrew Garrett could represent the trust in which he claimed to be a beneficiary, in place of the trustee Evajade. The Court found that Rule 30.02(2) only allowed a beneficiary to be joined as an additional party and not to substitute the trustee. This interpretation is consistent with the principle that trustees are the legal representatives of the trust and should manage its legal affairs. The Court's reliance on this rule underscores the importance of adhering to the specific provisions governing the representation of trusts and the limitations on beneficiaries acting in place of trustees.
Finally, the Court considered whether the action brought by Andrew Garrett and his family as personal plaintiffs against Cockatoo should be allowed to proceed. The Court noted that this part of the action was separate from the issues concerning Evajade, Vintners, and Vineyards and would be addressed in subsequent proceedings. The Court's decision to reserve judgment on this issue reflects its approach to handling complex litigation by addressing each aspect of the case in a structured and methodical manner. This ensures that each party's rights and the procedural integrity of the case are carefully considered and managed.