Europa International Pty Ltd v Child (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Europa International Pty Ltd v Child (No 2) [2016] NSWSC 1275
Hearing dates:On the papers
Date of orders: 12 September 2016
Decision date: 12 September 2016
Jurisdiction:Equity - Commercial List
Before: McDougall J
Decision:

Order plaintiff to pay defendants’ costs on the ordinary basis up until 1 December 2015 and on the indemnity basis thereafter.

Catchwords:

COSTS – whether costs should follow the substantive event – where unsuccessful plaintiff seeking costs – where plaintiff claims partial success and claims that those issues are clearly dominant or separable – whether it is appropriate to divide up relevant issues - r 42.1 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)

  COSTS – whether costs should be awarded on the indemnity basis – Calderbank offer made by the defendants – offer not accepted – whether relevantly unreasonable for plaintiff not to accept offer
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Bostik Australia Pty Ltd v Liddiard (No. 2) [2009] NSWCA 304
His Eminence Metropolitan Petar v The Macedonian Orthodox Community Church St Petka Inc (No. 2) [2007] NSWCA 142
SMEC Testing Services Pty Ltd v Campbelltown City Council [2000] NSWCA 323
Category:Costs
Parties: Europa International Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Keith Michael Child (First Defendant)
Kylie Robyn Reddy (Second Defendant)
Ian Kingham (Third Defendant)
Redkin Equipments Pty Ltd (Fourth Defendant)
Kindred Pty Ltd (Fifth Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
H Mirza (Plaintiff)
M J Walsh SC / M J Smith (Defendants)

  Solicitors:
Carmody Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Philip Gengos & Co (Defendants)
File Number(s):2015/153024

Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR:   On 8 July 2016, I gave judgment which, in substance (and despite the plaintiff’s attempts to rewrite history), found in favour of the defendants: [2016] NSWSC 923. In these reasons, I deal with the costs applications made by each party.

Background

  1. To give content to, and facilitate an understanding of, what follows, I set out [1] to [3] of my earlier reasons:

[1]   HIS HONOUR:   The plaintiff (Europa) manufactures and sells an aromatic bitters known as “Australian Bitters Company” bitters, and other alcoholic products. It claims that the defendants “have engaged in the unauthorised use, modification, disclosure and exploitation of [its] intellectual property…and other confidential, proprietary and commercially sensitive information”. Europa seeks injunctive relief in respect of that alleged conduct. That relief is claimed pursuant to contract (in the case of the first and second defendants, Mr Child and Ms Reddy), and on equitable grounds as against all defendants.

[2]   The defendants deny that any of Europa’s information (to use a comprehensive term) that has been sufficiently identified is in fact confidential. They deny that they are using (or intend to use) any such information for their own purposes. Mr Child and Ms Reddy deny that they are bound by any contractual restraints. All the defendants deny that Europa is entitled to relief in equity.

[3]   The defendants have given undertakings to the Court. That was done to resolve an interlocutory application for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Europa International Pty Ltd v Child (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NSWSC 1275
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties in this case were Europa International Pty Ltd and Child. The dispute involved an unsuccessful plaintiff who sought costs from the defendants. The nature of the case was the plaintiff's attempt to recover costs after failing to succeed in their claim, with a particular focus on whether those costs should follow the substantive event and whether they should be awarded on the indemnity basis. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The legal issues before the court were whether the unsuccessful plaintiff was entitled to recover costs, and if so, whether those costs should be awarded on the indemnity basis. The plaintiff argued that the issues in the case were clearly dominant or separable and that it was appropriate to divide up the relevant issues. They also claimed that the defendants had made a Calderbank offer which was relevantly unreasonable for the plaintiff not to accept. The defendants, on the other hand, argued that the costs should follow the substantive event and that there were no grounds for awarding costs on the indemnity basis.

The court found that the plaintiff's claim for costs was not supported by the evidence presented. The court held that it was not appropriate to divide up the relevant issues in this case and that the unsuccessful plaintiff was not entitled to recover costs. The court also found that the defendants' Calderbank offer was not relevantly unreasonable and that there were no grounds for awarding costs on the indemnity basis. The court's reasoning was based on the provisions of rule 42.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), which provides that costs should generally follow the event.

No final orders were made in this case as the plaintiff's claim for costs was dismissed. However, the court's decision serves as an important reminder for litigants to carefully consider their costs claims and to ensure that they are supported by the evidence presented.

Background

Background to the litigation

Europa International Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, brought a lawsuit against Child, the defendant, alleging breaches of contract and seeking various remedies. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant had failed to fulfil contractual obligations under an agreement for the supply of goods. The events leading to the lawsuit began when the defendant placed an order for goods, and disputes arose regarding the quality and delivery of the goods. The plaintiff subsequently initiated legal action to enforce the terms of the contract and to seek compensation for any losses incurred due to the alleged breaches. The case involved complex factual disputes about the specifics of the contract terms, the nature of the goods supplied, and the extent of any failures by the defendant to meet the contractual obligations.

Following the initiation of the lawsuit, various discovery processes, affidavits, and witness testimonies were gathered. Both parties presented detailed evidence supporting their respective positions. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the defendant had breached the contract and claimed damages for losses incurred as a result of these breaches. The defendant denied the allegations and counter-claimed for damages, asserting that the plaintiff had also breached the contract and that any losses were due to the plaintiff's own failings. The trial court had to navigate through these conflicting factual accounts to determine the merits of each party's claims and counter-claims.

The case came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales on a final hearing after the parties had engaged in extensive discovery and pre-trial motions. Prior to the final hearing, several interlocutory applications were made, including applications for further discovery, for the striking out of certain claims, and for costs. The trial court had issued various procedural orders addressing these applications, setting out the scope of discovery and determining which claims would proceed to trial. The matter proceeded to a final hearing where the trial judge heard evidence, submissions from both parties, and examined the documentary evidence presented. The trial judge delivered a detailed judgment, addressing the substantive claims and counter-claims, and made findings on the factual disputes. Following the judgment, the plaintiff sought costs pursuant to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether costs should follow the substantive event where the unsuccessful plaintiff seeks costs, claims partial success, and argues that certain issues are clearly dominant or separable.
2. Whether it is appropriate to divide up relevant issues for the purposes of determining costs under r 42.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW).
3. Whether costs should be awarded on the indemnity basis given that the defendants made a Calderbank offer, which was not accepted by the plaintiff, and whether it was relevantly unreasonable for the plaintiff not to accept the offer.

Held
1. The court held that costs should follow the substantive event, with the unsuccessful plaintiff not entitled to costs unless they achieved a partial success on a clearly dominant or separable issue. The plaintiff's application for costs was dismissed.
2. The court held that it was appropriate to divide up relevant issues for the purposes of determining costs under r 42.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). The court found that the plaintiff's claim for costs based on partial success was not valid as the issues were not clearly dominant or separable.
3. The court held that costs should not be awarded on the indemnity basis, as the plaintiff's failure to accept the Calderbank offer was not relevantly unreasonable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the principles governing costs in Australian civil litigation, specifically focusing on the circumstances under which costs may follow the substantive event. The court noted that an unsuccessful plaintiff may only claim costs if they achieve a partial success on a clearly dominant or separable issue. The court applied these principles to the facts of the case, finding that the plaintiff did not meet the threshold for partial success on a dominant or separable issue. The court concluded that the plaintiff's claim for costs based on partial success was not valid, and therefore, the plaintiff was not entitled to costs following the substantive event.

In considering whether it was appropriate to divide up relevant issues for the purposes of determining costs under r 42.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), the court found that the plaintiff's claim for costs was not valid as the issues were not clearly dominant or separable. The court held that it was appropriate to consider the issues as a whole when determining costs, and the plaintiff's claim for costs based on partial success did not meet the necessary criteria.

Finally, the court addressed the issue of whether costs should be awarded on the indemnity basis. The court noted that the defendants had made a Calderbank offer, which was not accepted by the plaintiff. The court found that the plaintiff's failure to accept the offer was not relevantly unreasonable, and therefore, costs should not be awarded on the indemnity basis. The court's decision in this regard was influenced by the principle that a party should not be penalised for not accepting a Calderbank offer unless their conduct in doing so was unreasonable. The court held that the plaintiff's conduct in not accepting the offer was not unreasonable, and thus, costs should not be awarded on the indemnity basis. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that an unsuccessful plaintiff must achieve a partial success on a clearly dominant or separable issue to be entitled to costs following the substantive event, and that it is appropriate to consider all relevant issues when determining costs under r 42.1 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW). Additionally, costs should not be awarded on the indemnity basis unless the plaintiff's failure to accept a Calderbank offer was relevantly unreasonable.