Eucalypt Group P/L v Robin

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Eucalypt Group P/L v Robin & Anor [2003] QSC 178

PARTIES:

EUCALYPT GROUP PTY LTD ACN 288 126 785
(applicant)
v
PHILIP DAVID ROBIN
SUSANNE PAULINE ROBIN

(respondents)

FILE NO:

SC 6087 of 2002

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Order for costs

DELIVERED ON:

12 June 2003

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

19 March 2003

JUDGE:

B W Ambrose J

ORDER:

I order that the applicant pay to the respondents their costs of and incidental to the application (including the application for costs) to be assessed on an indemnity basis

CATCHWORDS:

COSTS – indemnity costs – where respondents successfully opposed extinguishment of easement – where respondents had made clear their wish to retain easement – where applicant developer aware of this when it purchased the property – where existence of boulder sea wall principle issue in whether easement obsolete – where no evidence of sea wall construction tendered by applicant – whether Court should exercise discretion to order costs on indemnity basis

Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), s 181

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 704

Coles Myer NSW Ltd v Dymocks Book Arcade Ltd (1996) 7 BPR 14,638, considered
Colgate Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225, considered
In reJeffkin’s Indentures [1965] 1 WLR 375, considered
In re Wembley Park Estate Co Ltd’s Transfer [1968] 1 CH 491, considered
Tregoyd Gardens Pty Ltd v Jervis (1997) 8 BPR 15,845, considered

COUNSEL:

W Sofronoff QC with D J Campbell for the applicant

S L Doyle SC with B J Clarke for the respondents

SOLICITORS:

Hemming and Hart for the applicant
M F Lyons and Associates for the respondents

  1. AMBROSE J:   In this matter the respondents have successfully opposed the applicant’s effort to extinguish an easement the object of which I have found was to safeguard their access to their beachfront property in the event of cyclonic erosion of an Esplanade from which they have always obtained such access since they first acquired it. 

  1. I have no doubt upon the whole of the evidence – and in particular having regard to the content of letters written by the applicant to the respondents shortly after it purchased its allotments of land adjacent to that of the respondents that initially in any event it contemplated erecting a multi-unit apartment block upon those allotments which were subject to the respondents’ easement.  I infer that those allotments were purchased by another real estate development company for the purpose of demolishing the improvements on them and constructing in substitution a multi-storey apartment block.  The applicant then purchased them from that developer for the same purpose.

  1. The essence of the applicant’s claim was that the easement of which the respondents were the registered proprietors was obsolete.  Its contention which it supported by expert evidence was that the Esplanade by virtue of works effected to control erosion was no longer in danger of cyclonic storm surge erosion. 

  1. The applicant failed on this contention.

  1. A second…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Eucalypt Group P/L v Robin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] QSC 178
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved Eucalypt Group P/L, the applicant, and Robin, the respondent. The primary dispute centred around the extinguishment of an easement over a property that the applicant had purchased. The applicant sought to extinguish the easement, arguing it was obsolete due to the non-construction of a boulder sea wall, which was a key condition for its existence. The respondents opposed this application, asserting their intention to retain the easement and highlighting that the applicant was aware of this intention when purchasing the property. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

The central legal issue was whether the court should exercise its discretion to order costs on an indemnity basis. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the applicant should be required to pay the respondents' costs, given that the respondents had successfully opposed the extinguishment of the easement. The court needed to consider the respondents' clear stance on retaining the easement and the applicant's awareness of this position at the time of purchase. Furthermore, the court examined whether the applicant had presented sufficient evidence to substantiate the claim that the easement was obsolete due to the non-existence of the boulder sea wall.

In reaching its decision, the court noted that the existence of the boulder sea wall was a pivotal issue in determining whether the easement was obsolete. The court found that the applicant had not provided any evidence to support the claim that the sea wall had been constructed, which was necessary to establish the easement's obsolescence. Given that the respondents had effectively demonstrated their intention to retain the easement and the applicant's awareness of this intention, the court concluded that the applicant's application to extinguish the easement was unjustified. Consequently, the court exercised its discretion and ordered that the applicant pay the respondents' costs of and incidental to the application, including the application for costs, on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

I order that the applicant pay to the respondents their costs of and incidental to the application (including the application for costs) to be assessed on an indemnity basis

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Eucalypt Group P/L, the applicant and developer, and Robin, the respondent. Eucalypt Group P/L had purchased a property which was subject to an easement that allowed Robin to cross over for vehicular and pedestrian access. The easement was over a boulder sea wall which was a central issue in the dispute over whether the easement had become obsolete. Eucalypt Group P/L applied to extinguish the easement, arguing that the boulder sea wall no longer existed, making the easement obsolete. Robin opposed the application, asserting the continued existence of the easement. Robin had made it clear to Eucalypt Group P/L prior to the purchase that they intended to retain the easement. Eucalypt Group P/L was aware of this intention at the time of the purchase. The crux of the dispute hinged on the existence of the boulder sea wall and whether this was a determining factor in the obsolescence of the easement. Eucalypt Group P/L did not provide any evidence of the sea wall's construction or its absence.

The matter came before the court following an application by Eucalypt Group P/L to extinguish the easement. This was the first instance of the case being heard in court, not an appeal or a judicial review. Robin opposed the application, arguing for the continued existence of the easement. The court considered the submissions from both parties and the evidence provided, particularly focusing on the existence of the boulder sea wall. After evaluating the arguments and evidence, the court ruled in favour of Robin, successfully opposing the extinguishment of the easement. Subsequently, Robin applied for costs on an indemnity basis, which led to the current determination of costs by the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court should exercise its discretion to order costs on an indemnity basis in favour of the respondents.
2. Whether the existence of the boulder sea wall is a principle issue in determining the obsolescence of the easement.
3. Whether the applicant developer had sufficient evidence to support their claim that the boulder sea wall no longer exists.
4. Whether the applicant developer was aware of the respondents' intention to retain the easement at the time of the property purchase.

Held
1. The Court held that it should exercise its discretion to order costs on an indemnity basis in favour of the respondents.
2. The Court held that the existence of the boulder sea wall is a principle issue in determining the obsolescence of the easement.
3. The Court held that the applicant developer did not have sufficient evidence to support their claim that the boulder sea wall no longer exists.
4. The Court held that the applicant developer was aware of the respondents' intention to retain the easement at the time of the property purchase.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by considering whether it should exercise its discretion to order costs on an indemnity basis in favour of the respondents. The Court noted that the respondents had successfully opposed the extinguishment of the easement and had made clear their wish to retain the easement. Furthermore, the applicant developer was aware of this when it purchased the property. Given these circumstances, the Court found it appropriate to order costs on an indemnity basis to the respondents.

Next, the Court examined whether the existence of the boulder sea wall is a principle issue in determining the obsolescence of the easement. The Court concluded that the existence of the sea wall was indeed a principle issue, as it played a critical role in establishing whether the easement had become obsolete. The applicant developer had not provided any evidence to support their claim that the boulder sea wall no longer exists, which was crucial to their argument that the easement had become obsolete.

The Court also considered whether the applicant developer had sufficient evidence to support their claim that the boulder sea wall no longer exists. The Court found that the applicant developer had not tendered any evidence of the construction of the sea wall. Consequently, the Court held that the applicant developer had not provided sufficient evidence to support their claim.

Lastly, the Court addressed whether the applicant developer was aware of the respondents' intention to retain the easement at the time of the property purchase. The Court found that the applicant developer was indeed aware of this intention. This finding further supported the Court's decision to order costs on an indemnity basis in favour of the respondents, as the applicant developer had proceeded with the application despite being aware of the respondents' intention to retain the easement. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a party proceeds with a claim despite being aware of the opposing party's intention to retain a right, and the existence of a principle issue is central to the claim, the Court may exercise its discretion to order costs on an indemnity basis in favour of the opposing party.