FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| ESV17 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR | [2018] FCCA 2415 |
| Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial review – decision of Administrative Appeals Tribunal – whether Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s decision affected by jurisdictional error – Administrative Appeals Tribunal failed to consider close circuit television footage – whether failure to consider close circuit television footage ignoring relevant material – jurisdictional error – writs issued. |
| Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.36(2)(a), 36(2)(aa), 422B, 476 |
| Applicant: | ESV17 |
| First Respondent: | MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION |
| Second Respondent: | ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL |
| File Number: | PEG 566 of 2017 |
| Judgment of: | Judge Kendall |
| Hearing date: | 16 August 2018 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 16 August 2018 |
| Delivered at: | Perth |
| Delivered on: | 31 August 2018 |
REPRESENTATION
| Applicant: | In person with the assistance of an interpreter |
| Counsel for the First Respondent: | Mr P Corbould |
| Second Respondent: | Submitting appearance save as to costs |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Australian Government Solicitor |
ORDERS
A writ of certiorari issue quashing the decision of the second respondent dated 4 October 2017.
A writ of mandamus issue directed to the second respondent requiring it to determine the applicant’s application for review of the decision of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ESV17 v Minister for Immigration and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] FCCA 2415
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Minister's decision to refuse the protection visa was affected by jurisdictional error. This involved determining whether the delegate of the Minister, in assessing the applicant's claims, had failed to consider relevant considerations or had taken into account irrelevant considerations, thereby vitiating the decision-making process. Specifically, the Court was asked to consider if the delegate had failed to properly assess the risk of harm to the applicant in their country of origin, as required by the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) and relevant international conventions.
Judge Kendall found that the delegate had failed to adequately consider the applicant's specific circumstances and the evidence provided in support of their protection claims. The reasoning indicated that the delegate had applied a generalised assessment rather than a personalised one, which was a failure to consider relevant considerations. This failure constituted a jurisdictional error, rendering the decision to refuse the protection visa invalid.
Consequently, the Court made orders setting aside the decision of the Minister and remitting the application for a protection visa to the Minister for redetermination according to law.
Background
Background to the litigation
The Tribunal summarised the applicant’s claims for protection, which included that he had contracted business loans with loan sharks, was harassed to repay these loans, was falsely imprisoned, beaten, and tortured, and fled Malaysia, leaving his wife behind. The Tribunal did not accept the applicant’s claims as true, finding his evidence vague, lacking in detail, and illogical. The Tribunal also noted inconsistencies in the applicant’s evidence and found that he was unable to adequately explain the inconsistencies and vagueness of his claims. The Tribunal concluded that there was only a remote or far-fetched chance that the applicant would be harmed if he returned to Malaysia. The Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision, concluding that the applicant did not meet the refugee criteria under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth).
The applicant sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision in this Court, relying on three grounds of review: (1) the Tribunal failed to afford procedural fairness; (2) the Tribunal made a finding without supporting evidence; and (3) the Tribunal failed to consider the applicant’s claims but rather took into account irrelevant considerations. The applicant did not particularise the grounds in his application for judicial review, and he was unable to clarify his claims verbally to the Court. However, the Court determined that to the extent the applicant was asserting that the Tribunal failed to review CCTV footage that he says proved that he risked being harmed, it raised the possibility that the Tribunal failed to examine relevant evidence, which potentially could constitute jurisdictional error.
The Court reviewed the audio of the Tribunal hearing and noted that the Tribunal appeared to have received and reviewed the CCTV footage offered by the applicant. However, there was no explicit reference to the CCTV footage in the Tribunal’s decision, leading the Court to question whether the Tribunal had indeed reviewed the footage. The Court found that it was arguable on the evidence before it that the Tribunal failed to review the CCTV footage put to it by the applicant in circumstances where that footage might have assisted the applicant in proving his case. Consequently, the Tribunal’s decision should be set aside and the matter remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to law.
The matter before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia is an application for judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) that affirmed a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection not to grant the applicant a Protection (Class XA) visa. The applicant, a Malaysian citizen, had applied for the visa on 25 April 2016 and was refused by the delegate on 6 July 2016. The AAT reviewed the delegate's decision and, after two hearings on 31 August 2017 and 4 October 2017, affirmed the delegate's decision. The applicant then sought judicial review of the AAT's decision in the Federal Circuit Court, filing an application on 23 October 2017. The case was heard over two days, 13 June 2018 and 16 August 2018. The applicant, who was self-represented, sought to clarify and particularise his grounds of review during the hearing. The Court found that the AAT failed to review CCTV footage tendered by the applicant, which potentially constituted jurisdictional error. The Court decided to set aside the AAT's decision and remit the matter to the AAT for determination according to law.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) fall into jurisdictional error by failing to review all relevant evidence, specifically the CCTV footage provided by the applicant?
2. Did the Tribunal fail to afford procedural fairness to the applicant by not reviewing the CCTV footage?
3. Did the Tribunal make a finding without supporting evidence, and if so, which specific finding was unsupported?
4. Did the Tribunal fail to consider the applicant’s claims but rather take into account irrelevant considerations, and if so, which claims and considerations were involved?
5. Was the Tribunal's decision illogical, irrational, or unreasonable given the evidence presented, particularly the CCTV footage?
6. Did the Tribunal show actual or apprehended bias in its handling of the applicant's case and evidence?
7. Did the Tribunal correctly interpret and apply the relevant provisions of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) in making its decision?
Held
1. Did the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) fall into jurisdictional error by failing to review all relevant evidence, specifically the CCTV footage provided by the applicant?
The court concluded that the Tribunal arguably fell into jurisdictional error by not reviewing the CCTV footage provided by the applicant. As a result, the Tribunal's decision should be set aside and the matter remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to law.
2. Did the Tribunal fail to afford procedural fairness to the applicant by not reviewing the CCTV footage?
The court concluded that the Tribunal's failure to review the CCTV footage could constitute a failure to examine relevant evidence, which could be seen as a breach of procedural fairness. This could amount to jurisdictional error.
3. Did the Tribunal make a finding without supporting evidence, and if so, which specific finding was unsupported?
The court concluded that Ground 2 was not made out as the Tribunal's findings were open to it on the evidence. The findings demonstrated an evident, transparent, and intelligible justification for the Tribunal's decision.
4. Did the Tribunal fail to consider the applicant’s claims but rather take into account irrelevant considerations, and if so, which claims and considerations were involved?
The court concluded that Ground 3 fails as the Tribunal's findings were open to it on the evidence that it did examine. The court noted that the Tribunal did not examine all the evidence it should have examined, but this was not relevant to Ground 3.
5. Was the Tribunal's decision illogical, irrational, or unreasonable given the evidence presented, particularly the CCTV footage?
The court did not explicitly conclude that the Tribunal's decision was illogical, irrational, or unreasonable. However, it did find that the Tribunal arguably fell into jurisdictional error by not reviewing the CCTV footage.
6. Did the Tribunal show actual or apprehended bias in its handling of the applicant's case and evidence?
The court did not make a conclusion on this issue as it was not explicitly addressed in the holdings.
7. Did the Tribunal correctly interpret and apply the relevant provisions of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) in making its decision?
The court did not make a conclusion on this issue as it was not explicitly addressed in the holdings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in ESV17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection addressed several issues raised by the applicant regarding the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal). The court found that the Tribunal fell into jurisdictional error by failing to review all relevant evidence, specifically the closed-circuit television (CCTV) footage provided by the applicant. This error, according to the Court, potentially impacted the applicant's case as the CCTV footage might have supported his claims. The court emphasised that procedural fairness requires the consideration of all relevant evidence, and the Tribunal's failure to review the CCTV footage, despite the applicant's request, was a significant oversight.
In terms of legal principles, the court relied on the concept of procedural fairness, which is rooted in the common law doctrine of natural justice, as articulated in Kioa v West and Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Miah. The court also referenced statutory obligations under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) that mandate the Tribunal to consider all relevant materials. The court distinguished between its role and that of the Tribunal, reaffirming that it cannot undertake a merits review but can only assess whether the Tribunal engaged in jurisdictional error.
The court found that the Tribunal did not make a finding without supporting evidence, as the Tribunal's reasons for its decision were transparent and justified based on the evidence available to it. However, it was noted that the Tribunal failed to consider the applicant's CCTV footage, which could have been a crucial piece of evidence.
The court also concluded that the Tribunal did not fail to consider the applicant's claims but rather rejected them based on the evidence. The court noted that the Tribunal was entitled to assess the credibility of the applicant's evidence and did not take into account irrelevant considerations.
Regarding the irrationality of the Tribunal's decision, the court found that while the Tribunal's decision was open to it based on the evidence it did consider, the failure to review the CCTV footage was problematic. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was not illogical or unreasonable in the broader sense, but the omission of the CCTV footage analysis constituted a jurisdictional error.
The court did not find evidence of actual or apprehended bias in the Tribunal's handling of the applicant's case. However, it did find that the Tribunal did not correctly interpret and apply the relevant provisions of the Migration Act by failing to review the CCTV footage.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a Tribunal must consider all relevant evidence provided by an applicant, and failure to do so, particularly when such evidence might significantly impact the applicant's case, constitutes jurisdictional error. The court's decision underscores the importance of procedural fairness and the necessity for administrative decision-makers to assess all pertinent materials before reaching a conclusion.