Estate Agents Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ESTATE AGENTS PTY LTD v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2019] FCCA 3408
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Application for sponsorship of a nominee for the role of customer service manager – ANZSCO definitions – distinction drawn by Tribunal between management of employees as opposed to management of independent contractors independent contractors found to be illogical – application for review granted – decision of Tribunal quashed.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.140GB, 140GBA
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), r.2.72

Cases cited:

Cargo First Pty Limited v Minister for Immigration [2016] FCA 30
Cargo First Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration [2015] FCCA 2091
SZUXN v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2016) 69 AAR 210

Applicant: ESTATE AGENTS PTY LTD
(ACN 135 336 677)
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: BRG 116 of 2019
Judgment of: Judge Egan
Hearing date: 30 October 2019
Date of Last Submission: 30 October 2019
Delivered at: Brisbane
Delivered on: 27 November 2019

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr L. Karp
Solicitors for the Applicant: Fisher Dore
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms B. O'Brien
Solicitors for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

  1. That the name of the First Respondent be amended to read ‘Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs’.

  2. That the Further Amended Application for review filed on 30 October 2019 be granted.

  3. That the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 4 January 2019 be quashed.

  4. That a writ of mandamus issue directed to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal requiring it to determine according to law the applicant’s application for review of the second respondent's decision, and that the matter be remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for rehearing.

  5. That for the purpose of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal again determining the Applicants’ application, that it be constituted by a different member than the member who handed down the decision on 4 January 2019.

  6. That the First Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application for review fixed in the amount of $7,467.00.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT BRISBANE

BRG 116 of 2019

ESTATE AGENTS PTY LTD (ACN 135 336 677)

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTRUAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. The applicant operates a holiday accommodation business in and about Surfers Paradise on the Gold Coast. On 24 October 2016 the applicant applied to nominate one Rizan for a subclass 457 visa for the position of a customer service manager within its corporate structure. A letter from the applicant referred to in [14] of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal’s (The Tribunal) reasons recorded the duties of Rizan as follows:

    ·“Provide quality customer service and achieve revenue, cost saving and profit targets;

    ·Training the customer service team such as admin staff, housekeeping team and giving advice regarding customer complaints;

    ·Coaching and developing the Customer service teams to successfully deliver…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Estate Agents Pty Ltd v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 3408
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Estate Agents Pty Ltd sought judicial review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) which affirmed a delegate of the Minister's refusal to approve the company's nomination of a candidate for the role of customer service manager. The nomination was made under section 140GB of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) and Regulation 2.72 of the *Migration Regulations 1994* (Cth). The core of the dispute concerned whether the nominated position met the criteria for a "customer service manager" as defined by the Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO).

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Tribunal had erred in its interpretation of the ANZSCO definition of "customer service manager" and, consequently, in its assessment of whether the nominated position was genuine and involved a significant majority of the tasks associated with that occupation. Specifically, the court had to determine if the Tribunal's distinction between managing employees and managing independent contractors was a relevant or logical factor in assessing the genuineness of the managerial role. The applicant also argued that the Tribunal failed to properly consider evidence presented at the hearing regarding the tasks performed by the nominee.

Judge Egan found that the Tribunal's distinction between managing employees and managing independent contractors was illogical and not supported by the ANZSCO definition of a customer service manager. The court reasoned that the critical aspect of the role was the management of functions and responsibilities, regardless of whether those performing the tasks were employees or contractors. The Tribunal's focus on this distinction led it to misinterpret the requirements of the nominated occupation and to fail to properly consider the evidence of the nominee's actual duties.

The court granted the application for review and quashed the decision of the Tribunal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Estate Agents Pty Ltd (the Applicant) sought to nominate Ms Rizan, a Turkish national, for a Temporary Skill Shortage visa (Subclass 482) as a customer service manager. The nomination was lodged pursuant to the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). On 12 January 2017, a delegate of the Minister for Immigration refused to approve the nomination. The Applicant appealed this decision to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal), which affirmed the delegate’s decision on 4 January 2019. The Applicant then filed an amended application for review on 30 October 2019, seeking judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision.

Ms Rizan had worked for Estate Agents Pty Ltd for approximately two years in various roles, including as a customer service manager. The Applicant’s nomination for Ms Rizan was based on the role of customer service manager, which was to be filled by a skilled migrant under the Skilled Independent visa subclass 489. The nomination included a certification that the position was genuine and that Ms Rizan’s tasks matched the significant majority of the tasks of a customer service manager as defined in the Australian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO). The delegate and subsequently the Tribunal found that the nomination did not meet the criteria under Migration Regulation 2.72(10)(f), which requires the position associated with the nominated occupation to be genuine. The Tribunal’s decision hinged on its interpretation of the ANZSCO definition of "customer service manager" and its view that the managerial role did not include supervision of independent contractors.

The Applicant argued that the Tribunal erred in its interpretation of the ANZSCO definition and in failing to consider evidence that Ms Rizan’s tasks were consistent with those of a customer service manager. The Applicant contended that the ANZSCO definition does not require the staff or team members under the nominee’s supervision to be employees rather than independent contractors or subcontractors. Furthermore, the Applicant submitted that the Tribunal failed to properly consider evidence presented at the hearing, which detailed Ms Rizan’s tasks and responsibilities as being consistent with those of a customer service manager as set out in the ANZSCO dictionary. The Tribunal’s decision was thus challenged on the grounds that it was made in error and without proper consideration of relevant evidence.

The procedural history of this matter begins with the applicant, Estate Agents Pty Ltd, lodging an application for sponsorship of a nominee for the role of customer service manager. On 12 January 2017, a delegate of the Minister for Immigration refused the nomination under section 140GB of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and Regulation 2.72 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). Following this refusal, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) affirmed the delegate’s decision on 4 January 2019. Dissatisfied with the Tribunal’s decision, the applicant filed an amended application for review on 30 October 2019, which was granted leave. This review focused on the Tribunal's interpretation of the ANZSCO definitions, particularly regarding the distinction drawn between the management of employees and independent contractors. The key procedural steps included the Tribunal’s consideration of the applicant's evidence and the argument that the distinction made by the Tribunal was illogical and misapplied the relevant criteria.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Tribunal err in its consideration of whether Migration Regulation 2.72(10)(f) was met because it misinterpreted the definition of "customer service manager" in the ANZSCO dictionary?
2. Did the Tribunal err in finding that the cleaners under the nominee’s supervision were not relevant to her managerial role because they were contractors rather than employees?
3. Is it a necessary criterion of the supervisory role of a "customer service manager" that "staff" or "team members" be employees as opposed to contractors or subcontractors?
4. Did the Tribunal err in failing to lawfully consider and apply evidence given at hearing (at pp 30-32 of the hearing transcript) of the tasks undertaken by Ms Rizan which are consistent with those of a "customer service manager" as set out in the ANZSCO dictionary?

Held
1. Did the Tribunal err in its consideration of whether Migration Regulation 2.72(10)(f) was met because it misinterpreted the definition of "customer service manager" in the ANZSCO dictionary? The court concluded that the Tribunal misinterpreted the definition of "customer service manager" in the ANZSCO dictionary. Result: The application for review was granted, and the Tribunal's decision was quashed.
2. Did the Tribunal err in finding that the cleaners under the nominee’s supervision were not relevant to her managerial role because they were contractors rather than employees? The court concluded that the Tribunal's distinction between management of employees and management of independent contractors was illogical. Result: The application for review was granted, and the Tribunal's decision was quashed.
3. Is it a necessary criterion of the supervisory role of a "customer service manager" that "staff" or "team members" be employees as opposed to contractors or subcontractors? The court concluded that it was not a necessary criterion of the supervisory role of a "customer service manager" that "staff" or "team members" be employees as opposed to contractors or subcontractors. Result: The application for review was granted, and the Tribunal's decision was quashed.
4. Did the Tribunal err in failing to lawfully consider and apply evidence given at hearing (at pp 30-32 of the hearing transcript) of the tasks undertaken by Ms Rizan which are consistent with those of a "customer service manager" as set out in the ANZSCO dictionary? The court concluded that the Tribunal erred in failing to lawfully consider and apply the evidence given at the hearing. Result: The application for review was granted, and the Tribunal's decision was quashed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 12 January 2017 a delegate of the Minister refused to approve the applicant’s nomination made pursuant to the provisions of s.140GB of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act) and Regulation 2.72 of Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations). Those relevant provisions respectively provide as follows:SECTION 140GB MIGRATION ACT 1958 (Cth)Minister to approve nominations(1)A person who is, or who has applied to be, an approved work sponsor, or a person who is a party to negotiations for a work agreement, may nominate:(a)an applicant, or proposed applicant, for a visa of a prescribed kind (however described), in relation to:(i)the applicant or proposed applicant’s proposed occupation; or(ii)the program to be undertaken by the applicant or proposed applicant; or(iii)the activity to be carried out by the applicant or proposed applicant; or(b)a proposed occupation, program or activity.(2)The Minister must approve a person’s nomination if:(a)in a case to which section 140GBA applies, unless the person is exempt under section 140GBB or 140GBC – the labour market testing condition under section 140GBA is satisfied; and(aa)in a case in which the person is liable to pay nomination training contribution charge in relation to the nomination – the person has paid the charge; and (ab)in any case – the person is an approved work sponsor; and(b)in any case – the prescribed criteria are satisfied.Note 1: Section 140GBB provides an exemption from the labour market testing condition in the case of a major disaster. Section 140GBC provides for exemptions from the labour market testing condition to apply in relation to the required skill level and occupation for a nominated position.Note 2: See section 140ZM for when a person is liable to pay nomination training contribution charge.(3)The regulations may establish a process for the Minister to approve a person’s nomination.(4)Different criteria and different processes may be prescribed for:(a)Different kinds of visa (however described); and(b)Different classes in relation to which a person may be approved as a work sponsor.REGULATION 2.72(10)(e) and (f) OF THE MIGRATION REGULATIONS 1994 (Cth)Criteria for approval of nomination – Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) visa and Subclass 482 (Temporary Skill Shortage) visa…(10) If the person is a standard business sponsor – the Minister is satisfied that:…(e) if the nomination is made on or after 1 July 2010 – the person has certified as part of the nomination, in writing, that:(i) the tasks of the position include a significant majority of the tasks of:(A) the nomination occupation listed in the ANZSCO…(f) the position associated with the nominated occupation is genuine; and” The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) affirmed the decision of the delegate on 4 January 2019. The further amended application for review was filed by leave on 30 October 2019. It included the following grounds of review:“Grounds of application1. The Tribunal erred in its consideration of whether Migration Regulation 2.72(10)(f) was met because it misinterpreted the definition of “customer service manager” in the ANZSCO dictionary.Particulars(a) The Tribunal found that the cleaners under the nominee’s supervision were not relevant to her managerial role because they were contractors rather than employees.(b) It was not necessary criterion of the supervisory role of a “customer service manager” that “staff”, or “team members” be employees as opposed to contractors or sub contractors.2. …3. The Tribunal erred in failing to lawfully consider and apply evidence given at hearing (at pp 30-32 of the hearing transcript) of the tasks undertaken by Ms Rizan which are consistent with those of a “customer service manager” as set out in the ANZSCO dictionary.4. …5. …”