Essington Investments v Regency Property Group (Judgment on Costs)

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
CITATION: Essington Investments & Ors v Regency Property Group (Judgment on Costs) [2003] NSWSC 1057
HEARING DATE(S): 30 October 2003
JUDGMENT DATE:
30 October 2003
JUDGMENT OF: McDougall J at 1
DECISION: Paragraph 12 of judgment
CASES CITED: Gladstone Park Shopping Centre Pty Ltd v Wills (1984) 6 FCR 496
Sanderson v Blyth Theatre Company [1903] 2 KB 523

PARTIES :

Essington Investments Pty Ltd
Essington Group North Sydney Pty Ltd
Essington Asia Pacific Pty Ltd
Recency Property Group Pty Ltd
Richard Drummond
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 50058/03
COUNSEL: J Stoljar (Plaintiffs)
J Stephenson (Defendants)
R G Thomas (Cross-Defendant)
SOLICITORS: Gilbert & Tobin (Plaintiffs)
Watson Mangioni (Defendants)
Curwood & Partners/Trevor Barker & Associates
(Cross-Defendants)

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      EQUITY DIVISION

      McDOUGALL J

      30 October 2003 (Revised 6 November 2003)

      50058/03 ESSINGTON INVESTMENTS PTY LTD & ORS v REGENCY PROPERTY GROUP PTY LTD

      JUDGMENT ON COSTS

1 HIS HONOUR: In this matter I gave judgment on 10 October 2003 in which I answered certain preliminary questions as between the plaintiff and the defendant and as between the defendant (cross-claimant) and the cross-defendant. I indicated my view that the answers that I gave would lead to the conclusion that there should be judgment for the defendant on the claim and for the cross-defendant on the cross-claim. The parties today do not dispute that.

2 The substantial dispute is as to costs. It is not disputed that the defendant should have its costs of the claim against it by the plaintiff but there is a dispute as to the costs of the cross-defendant.

3 Since the position that will follow from the making of orders disposing of the claim and the cross-claim is that the defendant will succeed and the cross-defendant will succeed, the prima facie result is that each should have their costs.

4 For the defendant, Mr Stephenson submits that his client should not pay the cross-defendant's costs of the cross-claim because, having regard to my findings, the cross-defendant was in a substantial way the author of the proceedings or the person whose actions gave rise to the dispute. Alternatively, Mr Stephenson submits that if his client is ordered to pay the cross-defendant's costs, then the costs payable to it by the plaintiff should include the costs payable by it to the cross-defendant. There is no dispute but that under s 76 such an order would fall within the wide discretion as to costs that the Court has.

5 Mr Stoljar of Counsel for the plaintiff submits that I should not make an order of the alternative kind proposed by Mr Stephenson. He says in effect, as Mr Stephenson said, that the cross-defendant was the author of the proceedings and should not be rewarded with his costs. He points also to the circumstance that I made adverse findings as to the credit of the cross-defendant and that those findings, as he put it, occupied a considerable space in the judgment. I think it is fair to say…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Essington Investments v Regency Property Group (Judgment on... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] NSWSC 1057
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case Essington Investments & Ors v Regency Property Group (Judgment on Costs) was heard by McDougall J in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary dispute centered on the costs associated with the litigation, particularly whether the cross-defendant should bear the costs of the cross-claim. The plaintiffs, Essington Investments Pty Ltd, Essington Group North Sydney Pty Ltd, and Essington Asia Pacific Pty Ltd, had brought a claim against Regency Property Group Pty Ltd, and Regency Property Group had in turn cross-claimed against Richard Drummond. The matter involved complex issues of agency and authority, which McDougall J had addressed in an earlier judgment. The court was required to determine the appropriate allocation of costs among the parties, given the outcomes of the claim and cross-claim.

The legal issues before the court included whether the cross-defendant, Richard Drummond, should bear any costs associated with the cross-claim, and if so, in what form. Counsel for the defendant argued that Drummond should not be entitled to costs from the defendant since Drummond was considered the instigator of the proceedings. Conversely, counsel for the plaintiff argued that Drummond should not be rewarded with costs due to his actions and because McDougall J had made adverse findings about Drummond's credibility. The court needed to decide if Drummond's conduct warranted the defendant being ordered to pay Drummond's costs or if there was another equitable solution.

McDougall J concluded that while Drummond's conduct was problematic, it was appropriate for the defendant to join Drummond in the litigation to resolve all issues in one proceeding. Therefore, the court decided that the defendant should pay Drummond's costs of the cross-claim but that these costs should be incorporated into the costs payable by the plaintiffs to the defendant. McDougall J found precedent in Gladstone Park Shopping Centre Pty Ltd v Wills, where a similar order was made. The court also considered but ultimately rejected a "Sanderson approach," which would have involved direct payment of costs from the plaintiff to Drummond, as it saw no basis for such an order beyond mere convenience.

In conclusion, McDougall J made specific orders for the entry of judgment in favor of the defendant on the plaintiff's claim and in favor of Drummond on the defendant's cross-claim. The court ordered the plaintiffs to pay the defendant's costs of the claim and directed that these costs include the defendant's costs of Drummond's cross-claim. This ensured that Drummond would receive his costs but also maintained the overall fairness of the litigation outcome.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established