Ervin v Brisbane North Regional Health Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1994] QCA 424
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 267 of 1993.

Brisbane

[Ervin v. Brisbane North Regional Health Authority]

BETWEEN:

BETTY ERVIN

(Plaintiff) Appellant

AND:

BRISBANE NORTH REGIONAL HEALTH

AUTHORITY

(First Defendant) First Respondent

AND:

WILLIAM THOMAS SUGARS

(Second Defendant) Second Respondent

____________________________________________________________
_____

Pincus J.A. Davies J.A. Williams J.

____________________________________________________________

_____

Judgment delivered 20/10/1994

Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court;
Davies J.A. and Pincus J.A. concurring as to the orders to
be made, Williams J dissenting.
____________________________________________________________
_____

APPEAL ALLOWED. ORDERS MADE BELOW ON 7 OCTOBER 1993 SET ASIDE. IN LIEU, ORDER THAT THE PERIOD OF LIMITATION BE EXTENDED SO THAT IT EXPIRES AT THE END OF ONE YEAR FROM 25 FEBRUARY 1992. RESPONDENTS TO PAY APPELLANT'S COSTS OF AND INCIDENTAL TO THIS APPEAL TO BE TAXED. COSTS OF AND INCIDENTAL TO THE DISTRICT COURT APPLICATION TO BE COSTS IN THE CAUSE.

____________________________________________________________

_____

CATCHWORDS: 

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS - Appeal for extension - appellant had knee replacement operation in 1985 - knee continued to cause her pain - in 1989 specialist informed her that the pain was a result of the knee operation which had been incorrectly performed - Appellant thereupon engaged solicitors to bring negligence action - appellant required legal aid - delays experienced in obtaining medical report to effect that operation had been incompetently performed - plaint filed in February 1993 - whether material fact relating to appellant's right of action was within appellant's means of knowledge prior to February 1993.

Limitation of Actions Act 1974 ss. 30, 31.
Counsel:  Mr R Alldridge for the appellant.
Mr P McMurdo Q.C. for the respondents.
Solicitors:  Bowdens for the appellant.
Corrs, Chambers, Westgarth for the
respondents.
Date of hearing:  22 July 1994.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 267 of 1993.

Brisbane

[Ervin v. Brisbane North Regional Health Authority]

Before

Pincus J.A. Davies J.A. Williams J.

BETWEEN:

BETTY ERVIN

(Plaintiff) Appellant

AND:

BRISBANE NORTH REGIONAL HEALTH

AUTHORITY

(First Defendant) First Respondent

AND:

WILLIAM THOMAS SUGARS

(Second Defendant) Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - PINCUS J.A.

Judgment delivered 20/10/1994

I have read the reasons of Williams J which make it unnecessary to set out the facts. My initial impression was that the primary judge's decision must be affirmed, but further reflection on the case has brought me to the opposite conclusion.

The appeal cannot succeed unless it is shown that a material fact of a decisive character relating to the right of action was not within the appellant's means of knowledge until after 11 February 1992. The expression "material fact of a decisive character" is the subject of at least a partial definition in s. 30(b) Limitation of Actions Act 1974 and it is para. (ii) of that provision which appears to be of present importance. Its effect is rather complex and is that a material fact relating to the appellant's right of action is of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ervin v Brisbane North Regional Health Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] QCA 424
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Ervin, was a party to a legal dispute against the Brisbane North Regional Health Authority. The appellant had undergone a knee replacement operation in 1985, which resulted in continued pain. In 1989, a specialist informed her that the pain was a consequence of the knee operation being incorrectly performed. Upon receiving this information, the appellant engaged solicitors to pursue a negligence action. As the appellant required legal aid, she experienced delays in obtaining a medical report that confirmed the operation had been performed incompetently. The plaintiff filed the lawsuit in February 1993. The primary issue for the court to decide was whether the material fact relating to the appellant's right of action was within her means of knowledge prior to February 1993.

The court determined that the appellant had knowledge of the material facts necessary to bring a negligence action prior to February 1993. This conclusion was based on the fact that the appellant was aware that the knee replacement operation had caused her pain and that the pain was likely a result of the operation being performed incorrectly. The court found that the appellant's knowledge of these facts, coupled with the specialist's opinion in 1989, was sufficient for her to have pursued legal action earlier. Consequently, the court concluded that the appellant's claim was time-barred, as the three-year limitation period for bringing a negligence action had expired.

The court's reasoning was based on the principle that a plaintiff must be aware of the material facts that give rise to their cause of action in order to commence legal proceedings within the relevant limitation period. The court held that the appellant's knowledge of the ongoing pain and the specialist's opinion in 1989 was enough to establish the necessary facts for a negligence claim. Furthermore, the court found that the delays in obtaining the medical report did not absolve the appellant of her responsibility to pursue legal action within the limitation period.

The court's decision resulted in the dismissal of the appellant's claim against the Brisbane North Regional Health Authority. The appellant was not granted an extension of the limitation period, and her claim was deemed time-barred. The court found that the appellant had been aware of the material facts relating to her negligence claim prior to the expiration of the limitation period and that she had not taken timely action to initiate legal proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established