Ervin Mahrer and Partners v Strathfield Municipal Council

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read
Reported Decision: 111 LGERA 308

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: Ervin Mahrer and Partners v Strathfield Municipal Council [2000] NSWLEC 245
PARTIES:

APPLICANT:
Ervin Mahrer and Partners

RESPONDENT:
Strathfield Municipal Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 10088 of 2000
CORAM: Bignold J
KEY ISSUES:

Costs :- Hearing of class 1 proceedings vacated on Motion of Council on account of Applicant’s conduct in the litigation. Whether Council entitled to an order for costs of the Motion and costs thrown away by virtue of the vacation of the hearing dates

LEGISLATION CITED:
CASES CITED: Litevale Pty Ltd v Lismore City Council (1997) 96 LGERA 91;
MacDonald v Mosman Municipal Council (No 2) (2000) 107 LGERA 211;
Tenstat Chullora No. 2 Trust v The Valuer General & Anor [2000] NSWLEC 212.
DATES OF HEARING: 12 July 2000
DATE OF JUDGMENT:
11/30/2000
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT:
Mr M Astill, Solicitor
SOLICITORS:
Blake Dawson Waldron

RESPONDENT:
Mr D Baird, Solicitor
SOLICITORS
Price Waterhouse Coopers


JUDGMENT:


IN THE LAND AND Matter No . 10088 of 2000


ENVIRONMENT COURT OF Coram : Bignold J.


NEW SOUTH WALES 30 November 2000

ERVIN MAHRER & PARTNERS

Applicant

v

STRATHFIELD MUNICIPAL COUNCIL

Respondent

JUDGMENT ON COSTS



Bignold J:

A. INTRODUCTION

1. On 12 July 2000, on the Notice of Motion filed 7 July 2000 by the Respondent (the Council), I vacated the hearing dates that had been fixed for the hearing on 12 to 19 July 2000 of the pending Class 1 proceedings involving an appeal pursuant to the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979, s 97 against the Council’s deemed refusal of the Applicant’s development application for a development that had been described as:

            Demolition of building at 73 Parramatta Rd (Old Strathfield Library). Part conversion of 55-57 Parramatta Rd (Homebush Theatre) to serviced apartments, erection of serviced apartments and commercial space at 59-67 and 71-78 Parramatta Rd and 14-26 Powell Street, Homebush.

2. The order vacating of the hearing dates had not been opposed by the Applicant for reasons that will become apparent.

3. However, the Applicant did oppose the Council’s application for an order that the Applicant pay the Council’s costs thrown away or the costs of the Motion.

4. On that occasion, I reserved the question of costs that had been keenly debated. This judgment deals only with that question of costs.

B. THE HISTORY OF THE LITIGATION

5. The proceedings were commenced on 3 February 2000.

6. On 31 March 2000 the Council filed its Statement of Issues in the proceedings raising 25 separate issues.

7. On 4 April 2000, the Council filed a Notice of Motion seeking the determination by a judge as a preliminary issue, of a point of law concerning the true characterisation of the proposed development. That Motion was settled between the parties upon the basis that it was agreed that the proposed development was for “residential flat buildings with a commercial component”, the Council consented to the Applicant’s amendment of the development…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ervin Mahrer and Partners v Strathfield Municipal Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWLEC 245
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ervin Mahrer and Partners (Applicant) appealed against the Strathfield Municipal Council (Council) for a deemed refusal of their development application. The application was for the demolition of the old Strathfield Library and the construction of serviced apartments and commercial spaces. The Council moved for the hearing dates to be vacated due to the Applicant's conduct in the litigation, which involved significant changes to the development proposal and the submission of revised plans. The Court vacated the hearing dates but did not grant the Council's request for costs thrown away or costs of the Motion. The Applicant opposed the Council's application for costs, leading to a judgment on the question of costs. The court found that the Council was entitled to an order for costs of the Motion, but the claim for costs thrown away was premature and could not be substantiated at that time. The court held that the proceedings remained on foot and the ultimate position of the Applicant in the litigation could not be anticipated.

The court found that the Council's solicitors and experts became aware of significant changes to the proposed development one week before the scheduled commencement of the hearing. The Council's solicitors immediately notified the Applicant's solicitors and sought to vacate the hearing dates on the ground that the revised plans were an attempt to modify the development proposal in an unpermissible manner and that the existence of the plans had prejudiced the Council's preparation of its case. The Applicant's solicitors consented to the vacating of the hearing dates but not to the costs orders claimed in the Notice of Motion. The court held that the Council was entitled to the costs of its Motion as heard initially by the Duty Judge and finally by the trial judge. However, the Council's claim to costs "thrown away" by vacating the hearing dates was rejected as premature because the proceedings remained on foot and the future course of the litigation could not be anticipated. The court held that an order for costs thrown away may be made in appropriate cases where it is not already known that costs have been thrown away but where it can be reasonably anticipated that costs will be thrown away. The present position did not support a finding that costs had already been thrown away or that that result could be reasonably anticipated. The court held that the Council could seek an order for costs thrown away at some stage in the future course of the present proceedings if it sought to assert such an entitlement.

The court ordered the Applicant to pay the Respondent's costs of the Notice of Motion in the sum agreed or failing agreement, as assessed. The exhibits were to be returned.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established