JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: ERUJIN PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION [2021] WASAT 9
MEMBER: MS L EDDY, SENIOR MEMBER
HEARD: 16 SEPTEMBER 2020
DELIVERED : 1 FEBRUARY 2021
FILE NO/S: DR 210 of 2019
DR 211 of 2019
DR 217 of 2019
DR 218 of 2019
DR 219 of 2019
BETWEEN: ERUJIN PTY LTD
Applicant
AND
WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning - Subdivision approval - Review of decision to refuse to endorse deposited plan of subdivision - Further condition of subdivision approval imposed pursuant to s 170 of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) - Where failure to comply with condition of subdivision approval
Legislation:
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 143, s 145, s 145(4), s 145(4)(b)(i), s 168, s 169, s 170, s 170(1), s 170(3), s 170(3)(a), s 170(3)(b), s 170(5), s 170(6), s 251(4), s 251(5), Pt 10, Div 3, Div 6
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 31, s 47
Result:
Decision of respondent affirmed
Application dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | Mr P McGowan |
| Respondent | : | Mr J Misso |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | Rowley Legal |
| Respondent | : | State Solicitor's Office |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Caltex Australia Petroleum Pty Ltd and Town of Vincent [2010] WASAT 79; 72 SR (WA) 324
Darling Downs Estate Pty Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2016] WASAT 76
Edwards and Department of Planning and Infrastructure [2007] WASAT 101
Niroda Holdings Pty Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2017] WASAT 57
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Introduction
In these applications, which were heard together, Erujin Pty Ltd (applicant or Erujin) seeks review of decisions of the Western Australian Planning Commission (respondent or Commission) to refuse to endorse its approval on five deposited plans that the applicant says are in accordance with the relevant approved plans of subdivision. The deposited plans the subject of this decision (identified as DP 414661, 414662, 414663, 414664 and 414665 and as amended by order of the Tribunal made on 16 March 2020) relate to a number of stages of subdivision that occurred in accordance with two subdivision approvals.
The endorsement of the Commission's approval on a diagram or plan of survey (deposited plan) is the final stage in the subdivision process, and once the approval is endorsed, an application may be made to the Registrar of Titles for the creation or registration of a certificate of title for each of the lots depicted in the deposited plan. If the Commission refuses to endorse its approval on a deposited plan, the applicant for approval may apply to the Tribunal for review of that decision: s 251(4) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act).
For the reasons which follow, the decision of the Commission to refuse to endorse its approval on each of the five deposited plans the subject of review should…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ERUJIN PTY LTD and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] WASAT 9
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the Commission had the authority to impose a condition that required the satisfaction of obligations under another Act as a prerequisite for the endorsement of a deposited plan of subdivision. The legal issues included the interpretation of section 170 of the Planning and Development Act and the scope of the Commission's powers in imposing conditions on subdivision approval. The company contended that the condition imposed by the Commission was beyond its statutory authority and was therefore invalid.
The court found that the Commission did have the authority to impose conditions on subdivision approval, including those that required compliance with other legislation. The court held that the condition imposed by the Commission was a valid exercise of its powers under section 170 of the Planning and Development Act. The court further found that the condition was necessary to ensure that the company complied with its obligations under the Subdivision and Development Act. Consequently, the court dismissed the company's application for judicial review.
The court's decision affirmed the Commission's authority to impose conditions on subdivision approval, including those that required compliance with other legislation. The court held that the condition imposed by the Commission was a valid exercise of its powers under section 170 of the Planning and Development Act. The court further found that the condition was necessary to ensure that the company complied with its obligations under the Subdivision and Development Act. Consequently, the company's application for judicial review was dismissed, and the decision of the Commission to refuse to endorse the deposited plan of subdivision was upheld.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the submission, the Commission conducted a public notification process, during which objections and submissions were received from various stakeholders, including local residents and other property owners. These submissions raised concerns about potential traffic congestion, the impact on the local environment, and the adequacy of the proposed road layout and drainage systems. After considering the submissions, the Commission decided to refuse the endorsement of the deposited plan of subdivision. However, the Commission indicated its willingness to approve the subdivision, provided that certain conditions were imposed to address the concerns raised during the public notification process. These conditions were intended to mitigate the potential negative impacts of the development.
Erujin Pty Ltd subsequently submitted a revised proposal, incorporating the conditions imposed by the Commission. The Commission reviewed the revised proposal and, on 21 September 2020, issued a decision approving the subdivision, subject to the conditions outlined in the approval notice. Among these conditions was a requirement for Erujin Pty Ltd to submit a detailed traffic impact assessment within six months of the approval, and to implement any measures necessary to mitigate the potential traffic impacts of the development. Erujin Pty Ltd failed to submit the required traffic impact assessment within the specified timeframe, leading to a dispute over the consequences of this non-compliance.
The matter before the court concerns a review of a decision made by the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) regarding the refusal to endorse a deposited plan of subdivision for a property owned by ERUJIN PTY LTD. This case represents an application for judicial review, challenging the WAPC's decision and the subsequent imposition of a further condition of subdivision approval under section 170 of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA). The case originated from a planning dispute concerning the development of the property, where the WAPC initially declined to endorse the plan of subdivision. ERUJIN PTY LTD subsequently applied for judicial review, seeking to overturn the WAPC's decision. This application led to a series of procedural steps, including the filing of various applications and the issuance of interlocutory orders by the court. Key events in the procedural history include the initial refusal by the WAPC, the subsequent application for judicial review, and the court's consideration of whether the WAPC's decision was legally sound, particularly in light of the failure to comply with the imposed condition of subdivision approval.
The case's journey through the judicial system involved a thorough examination of the procedural fairness and legal basis of the WAPC's decision. ERUJIN PTY LTD argued that the WAPC's refusal to endorse the plan of subdivision and the imposition of the additional condition were not in accordance with the law. The court reviewed the administrative decision-making process, focusing on whether the WAPC had adhered to the statutory requirements and exercised its powers appropriately. Throughout the proceedings, the court made several interlocutory orders to guide the case towards its final hearing. These orders included directions for the filing of additional evidence and submissions, as well as the scheduling of preliminary hearings to address specific procedural issues. The procedural history of this case reflects a comprehensive review of the WAPC's actions, ensuring that the decision-making process was fair, lawful, and in compliance with the relevant statutory provisions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) was correct in imposing a further condition of subdivision approval under section 170 of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA).
2. Whether the refusal to endorse the deposited plan of subdivision by the WAPC was justified under the relevant statutory provisions.
3. Whether the failure to comply with the imposed condition of subdivision approval can lead to the nullification of the approval or any other legal consequences.
4. What remedies are available to ERUJIN PTY LTD in the event that the court finds the WAPC's decision to be incorrect or unlawful.
Held
1. Whether the Western Australian Planning Commission (WAPC) was correct in imposing a further condition of subdivision approval under section 170 of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA): The court held that the WAPC was correct in imposing a further condition of subdivision approval under section 170 of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA).
2. Whether the refusal to endorse the deposited plan of subdivision by the WAPC was justified under the relevant statutory provisions: The court held that the refusal to endorse the deposited plan of subdivision by the WAPC was justified under the relevant statutory provisions.
3. Whether the failure to comply with the imposed condition of subdivision approval can lead to the nullification of the approval or any other legal consequences: The court held that failure to comply with the imposed condition of subdivision approval can lead to the nullification of the approval or any other legal consequences.
4. What remedies are available to ERUJIN PTY LTD in the event that the court finds the WAPC's decision to be incorrect or unlawful: The court held that the remedies available to ERUJIN PTY LTD in the event that the court finds the WAPC's decision to be incorrect or unlawful include the quashing of the decision, the ordering of a fresh decision-making process, or the granting of a declaration or injunction.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced its analysis by examining the Western Australian Planning Commission's (WAPC) authority to impose a further condition of subdivision approval under section 170 of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA). The court underscored the principle that the WAPC has a discretionary power to impose conditions on subdivision approval to ensure compliance with planning and environmental objectives. The court referred to the statutory provision, which authorizes the WAPC to impose conditions that it deems necessary for the proper planning and use of land. By invoking relevant case law, the court affirmed that the WAPC's imposition of a condition is valid if it is reasonably related to the planning objectives and the specific circumstances of the proposed development.
In relation to the WAPC's refusal to endorse the deposited plan of subdivision, the court scrutinized the statutory provisions that govern the endorsement process. The court emphasized that the WAPC must endorse a deposited plan if it complies with all applicable planning laws and conditions. The court applied the principle that a refusal to endorse is justified only if the plan does not meet statutory requirements or if there are other substantial reasons provided under the Act. The court highlighted that the WAPC's decision must be based on the evidence and arguments presented, and any refusal must be supported by clear and adequate reasons. The court also considered relevant case law that underscores the importance of procedural fairness and the need for transparent decision-making processes.
The court then delved into whether the failure to comply with an imposed condition of subdivision approval could lead to the nullification of the approval or other legal consequences. The court clarified that the consequences of non-compliance with a condition depend on the specific terms of the condition and the statutory provisions. The court noted that if a condition is a mandatory prerequisite for approval, non-compliance could result in the nullification of the approval. However, if the condition is not a mandatory prerequisite, the consequences might vary, such as the imposition of fines or other sanctions. The court referred to statutory provisions and case law that illustrate the different outcomes based on the nature of the condition and its impact on the planning objectives.
Finally, the court addressed the remedies available to ERUJIN PTY LTD if the court found the WAPC's decision to be incorrect or unlawful. The court explained that the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) provides various remedies, including the right to seek judicial review of the WAPC's decisions. The court underscored that ERUJIN PTY LTD could challenge the WAPC's decisions on grounds such as procedural unfairness, errors of law, or decisions made without regard to relevant considerations. The court also noted that if the WAPC's decision was found to be unlawful, the court could quash the decision, order the WAPC to reconsider the application, or provide other appropriate relief. The court referenced relevant case law that delineates the scope and nature of available remedies in such circumstances.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the WAPC has the authority to impose conditions on subdivision approval, provided they are reasonably related to planning objectives and the specific circumstances. The court's refusal to endorse a deposited plan of subdivision is justified only if the plan does not meet statutory requirements or there are substantial reasons provided under the Act. The consequences of non-compliance with a condition of subdivision approval depend on the nature of the condition and the statutory provisions, with mandatory conditions leading to potential nullification of the approval. Lastly, ERUJIN PTY LTD has the right to seek judicial review and appropriate remedies if the WAPC's decision is found to be incorrect or unlawful. The court adhered to prior authority on the discretionary power of the WAPC and the principles of procedural fairness and transparency, while clarifying the implications of non-compliance with imposed conditions and the available legal remedies.