Errol Frederick Lymbery v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read
CITATION: Errol Frederick Lymbery v Commonwealth of Australia [2007] NSWSC 183
HEARING DATE(S): 27,28, 29, 30 November 2006
1, 4, 5, 6, 7, December 2006
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

9 March 2007
JUDGMENT OF: Patten AJ at 1
DECISION: See paragraph 176
CASES CITED: Medlin v State Government Insurance Commission (1995) 69 ALJR 118
Malec v J C Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 64 ALJR 316
National Insurance Co of New Zealand v Espagne (1961) 105 CLR 569 at 598;
Thatcher v Charles (1961) 104 CLR 57
Victoria Stevedoring Pty Ltd v Farlow (1963) VR 594
Simonius Vischer & Co v Holt and Thompson [1979] 2 NSWLR 322
Bennett v Jones (1977) 2 NSWLR 355
PARTIES: Errol Frederick Lymbery
Commonwealth of Australia
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20824 of 2001
COUNSEL: Mr M.Williams SC with Mr A Gemmell - Plaintiff
Mr R. Burbidge QC with Mr D. Brogan - Defendant
SOLICITORS: Hollows Lawyers - Plaintiff
Australian Government Solicitor - Defendant

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION

Patten A J

9 March 2007

Errol Frederick Lymbery v Commonwealth of Australia
No: 20824 of 2001

JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION:

1 The Plaintiff was born on 10 November 1944 at Maleny in Queensland. He grew up in the Sunshine Coast area and was educated at Caboolture High School where, in his teens, he met the woman who subsequently became his wife.

2 About the end of 1961, he decided to make a career in the Navy. To that end, in January 1962, he passed various mental and physical examinations and on 9 February was accepted as a recruit. He was posted to HMAS Cerberus for training. Thereafter, his naval career progressed satisfactorily, as I will relate hereafter in greater detail. By February 1964, he was serving on the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne as a member of the arrestor gear party stationed on the flight deck. At that time he was classed as an Engineer Mechanic.

3 On the night of 10 February 1964, the Plaintiff was on board Melbourne, which was engaged with the Daring Class Destroyer HMAS Voyager in night flying exercises, some 21 miles east of Jervis Bay. About 9pm, there was a collision between Melbourne and Voyager, as a result of which some 82 sailors died and Voyager sank. I will, hereafter, simply refer to this terrible event as “the collision”.

4 In these proceedings, which were commenced on 10 October 2001, the Plaintiff claims damages for psychiatric injury and sequelae thereof suffered as a result of the collision. Master Harrison granted him an appropriate extension of time to bring action on 2 June 2005.

5 The Defendant, on the pleadings, admitted liability for the Plaintiff’s claim but denied that he suffered damage causally connected to the collision. The hearing before me largely concerned that issue. He was represented by Mr M Williams SC with Mr Gemmell, and the Defendant by Mr Burbidge QC with Mr Brogan.

THE PLAINTIFF’S EARLY LIFE:

6 The Plaintiff recounted a happy normal childhood and early…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Errol Frederick Lymbery v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWSC 183
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Errol Frederick Lymbery v Commonwealth of Australia, the plaintiff, Errol Frederick Lymbery, sought damages for psychiatric injury and sequelae resulting from his involvement in the collision between the HMAS Melbourne and HMAS Voyager in 1964. The defendant, the Commonwealth of Australia, admitted liability but denied that the plaintiff's injuries were causally connected to the collision. The case involved several legal issues, including the identification of the psychiatric injuries suffered by the plaintiff, the causal link between those injuries and the collision, and the extent of the plaintiff's diminished earning capacity. The court found that the plaintiff had established a causal link between the collision and his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which had persisted for more than 40 years. The court also found that the plaintiff's personality had changed significantly after the collision, and that he had experienced frequent "flashbacks" and a loss of confidence in his abilities when given high responsibility. The court awarded the plaintiff general damages for non-economic loss, past and future medical expenses, and compensation for diminished earning capacity. The court also awarded interest on the general damages and compensation for diminished earning capacity from 1 July 1972 to the date of judgment. The final orders included a verdict and judgment for the plaintiff in the amount of $241,391, with the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Errol Frederick Lymbery, born in 1944, grew up in Queensland and decided to make a career in the Navy. In January 1962, he passed various mental and physical examinations and was accepted as a recruit. He was posted to HMAS Cerberus for training and later served on the aircraft carrier HMAS Melbourne as a member of the arrestor gear party. On the night of 10 February 1964, Melbourne collided with HMAS Voyager, resulting in 82 sailors' deaths and the sinking of Voyager. Lymbery was on board Melbourne during the collision. He witnessed the aftermath and experienced horror and helplessness. He has no recollection of events between the collision and his return to Sydney. Lymbery claims damages for psychiatric injury and sequelae suffered as a result of the collision. He experienced nightmares, flashbacks, sleep disturbances, and loss of confidence in his abilities, which affected his career progression and personal life. The Defendant admitted liability for the claim but denied that Lymbery's injuries were causally connected to the collision.

The case was commenced on 10 October 2001. Master Harrison granted Lymbery an appropriate extension of time to bring the action on 2 June 2005. The matter was heard before Patten A J over several days in November and December 2006. The Plaintiff was represented by Mr M Williams SC with Mr Gemmell, and the Defendant by Mr Burbidge QC with Mr Brogan. The court considered the evidence presented by both parties and made a judgment on 9 March 2007.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Lymbery suffered psychiatric injury and sequelae as a result of the collision between HMAS Melbourne and HMAS Voyager.
2. Whether the psychiatric injury and sequelae were causally connected to the collision.
3. Whether Lymbery's decision to leave the Navy, Amoco, and BP were causally connected to the collision.
4. Whether Lymbery failed to mitigate his losses.

Held
1. The court held that Lymbery suffered psychiatric injury and sequelae as a result of the collision between HMAS Melbourne and HMAS Voyager.
2. The court held that the psychiatric injury and sequelae were causally connected to the collision.
3. The court held that Lymbery's decision to leave the Navy, Amoco, and BP were not causally connected to the collision.
4. The court held that Lymbery failed to mitigate his losses by not seeking timely psychological treatment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence provided by Lymbery and his witnesses to determine if Lymbery suffered psychiatric injury and sequelae from the collision. The court accepted that Lymbery suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which manifested in flashbacks, changed personality, gastric reflux, and loss of confidence. The court rejected the argument that Lymbery's increased smoking, alcohol consumption, and skin rashes were causally connected to the collision.

Regarding the causation of Lymbery's decisions to leave the Navy, Amoco, and BP, the court held that his decision to leave the Navy was reasonable as it was causally related to the collision. However, the court found that his decisions to leave Amoco and BP were predominantly for personal reasons and only remotely connected to the collision. Therefore, Lymbery could not claim compensation for diminished earning capacity related to those decisions.

The court also found that Lymbery failed to mitigate his losses by not seeking timely psychological treatment. The court reasoned that had Lymbery sought treatment soon after leaving the Navy, his degree of disability would likely have been reduced. The court deducted 10% from the general damages to account for this failure to mitigate.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that while a plaintiff may be entitled to compensation for psychiatric injury caused by a collision, they must also take reasonable steps to mitigate their losses, such as seeking timely psychological treatment. The court distinguished prior authority by holding that a plaintiff's decisions to leave employment may not be causally connected to the initial injury if those decisions were predominantly for personal reasons.