ERO Georgetown Gold Operations Pty Ltd v Henry (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

LAND APPEAL COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

ERO Georgetown Gold Operations Pty Ltd v Henry (No. 2) [2016] QLAC 3

PARTIES:

ERO GEORGETOWN GOLD OPERATIONS PTY LTD

(appellant)

v
THOMAS PETER HENRY

(respondent)

FILE NOS:

LAC No. 003-15

Land Court No. MRA036-14

DIVISION:

Land Appeal Court of Queensland

PROCEEDING:

Appeal from the Land Court of Queensland

ORIGINATING COURT:

Land Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

24 June 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Heard on the papers

JUDGE:

Peter Lyons J (Chairperson)
WL Cochrane (Member)
WA Isdale (Member)

ORDER:

1.       The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal in this Court, to be assessed on the standard basis until 15 September 2015, and thereafter on the indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

COSTS – Respondent successful before Land Appeal Court sought costs under s 34 Land Court Act 2000 - appellant submitted prima facie position with respect to costs under s 34 that each party should bear its own costs – held s 34 does not create a general rule that parties bear their own costs, rather what is the appropriate costs order in the circumstances

COSTS – Land Appeal Court must have regard to established legal principles when determining costs discretion under s 34 Land Court Act 2000 – it follows that a party’s success will often be a significant, though not necessarily decisive, factor in determining an application for costs

COSTS – Calderbank offer at common law – consideration of the appellant’s conduct in rejecting Calderbank offer - held the rejection of a Calderbank offer by the appellant was unreasonable in the circumstances  – respondent entitled to indemnity costs from the date of making a Calderbank offer

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (2009) 239 CLR 27
Baini v The Queen (2012) 246 CLR 469
Calderbank v Calderbank [1976] Fam. 93

ERO Georgetown Gold Operations Pty Ltd v Henry [2015] QLAC 4
Chief Executive, Department of Natural Resources and Mines v Kent Street Pty Ltd & Ors [2011] 2 Qd R 417
Gallo v Department of Environment and Resource Management (No. 2) [2014] QLAC 11
Hegira Limited v Department of Natural Resources and Water [2006] QLC 0079
Latoudis v Casey (1990) 170 CLR 534
Mentech Resources Pty Ltd v MCG Resources Pty Ltd (in liq) & Ors [2012] QLAC 2
Mio Art Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council (No 3); Greener Investments Pty Ltd (in liq) v Brisbane City Council (No 3)  [2013] QLAC 3
Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72
Ostroco v Department of Main Roads (No. 2) [2012] QLAC 007
PT Limited & Westfield Management Limited v Department of Natural Resources and Mines [2007] QLAC 0121
Queensland Fish Board v Bunney;  ex parte Queensland Fish Board [1979] Qd R 301
Re JJT & Ors; ex parte Victoria Legal Aid (1998) 195 CLR 184
Tamawood Limited & Anor v Paans [2005] 2 Qd R 101
The Appellants v Council of the Law Society of the Act and Anor (2011) 252…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ERO Georgetown Gold Operations Pty Ltd v Henry (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QLAC 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case ERO Georgetown Gold Operations Pty Ltd v Henry (No 2) involved the respondent, Henry, who successfully sought an amendment to the compensation payable by the appellant, ERO Georgetown Gold Operations Pty Ltd, under the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld). The dispute centred on the costs incurred during the litigation process. Henry had made several settlement offers before and after the Land Court's determination, including a Calderbank offer, which was rejected by the appellant. The Land Appeal Court had to decide the costs associated with the proceedings, particularly whether the respondent was entitled to indemnity costs and if the appellant's rejection of the Calderbank offer was unreasonable.

The legal issues before the court involved interpreting Section 34 of the Land Court Act 2000, which grants the court discretion in awarding costs. The court had to determine whether the statutory provision mandated that each party bear its own costs in the absence of a specific order or whether it allowed for a more flexible approach. Additionally, the court needed to assess the appellant's conduct in rejecting the Calderbank offer and whether this rejection was reasonable under the circumstances. The court also had to consider the established legal principles, including the principle that a party's success can be a significant factor in determining an application for costs.

In its reasoning, the court held that Section 34 of the Land Court Act does not automatically impose a rule that each party should bear its own costs but rather provides the court with discretion to make an appropriate costs order. The court noted that a party's success can often be a significant, though not decisive, factor in determining an application for costs. Regarding the rejection of the Calderbank offer, the court found that the appellant's conduct in rejecting the offer was unreasonable, particularly as the respondent had foreshadowed indemnity costs if the offer was refused. Consequently, the court concluded that the respondent was entitled to indemnity costs from the date of making the Calderbank offer.

The court ordered that the appellant pay the respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal in the Land Appeal Court. The costs were to be assessed on the standard basis until 15 September 2015, and thereafter on the indemnity basis. This order reflects the court's decision that the appellant's unreasonable conduct warranted indemnity costs for the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal in this Court, to be assessed on the standard basis until 15 September 2015, and thereafter on the indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the Land Court, the respondent successfully sought an amendment of the compensation payable to him by the appellant under the provisions of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld) (MR Act).Factual background The respondent contended (and it was not contested by the appellant) that the effect of the Land Court’s determination was that he received an additional sum of $75,476, being an amount of $37,907.10 compensation for the period up to 13 July 2015, with additional monthly compensation of $3,954.62 for a further 9.5 months. On 19 June 2014, on 30 June 2014, and again on 11 July 2014 the respondent made offers to settle the proceedings; as well as some other proceedings and some other outstanding matters between the parties. On 15 September 2015, after the appellant had appealed against the Land Court’s determination of compensation, the respondent offered to settle the matter on the basis that the appellant pay the respondent $70,000, with each party to bear its own costs of the proceedings in the Land Court, and in this Court. The offer invoked r 358 and r 360 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (QLD) (UCPR); as well as Calderbank v Calderbank[1]; foreshadowing that if it was refused, costs would be sought on the indemnity basis. It was open for acceptance until 30 September 2015.[1] [1976] Fam. 93. None of these offers was accepted.Statutory context Jurisdiction was conferred on the Land Court to hear the respondent’s claim for amended compensation by s 283B of the MR Act. The respondent also sought relief under s 363 of the MR Act, which conferred jurisdiction on the Land Court to hear certain types of proceedings, though it was unnecessary to determine whether such relief should be granted[2].[2] See ERO Georgetown Gold Operations Pty Ltd v Henry [2015] QLAC 4 at [77]-[78]. Under s 5 of the LC Act, the Land Court[3] has the jurisdiction given to it under that Act, or another Act.[3] No submissions were made as to the version of this Act to which reference should be made for this application. It seems appropriate to rely on that which was current in September 2013. Section 34 of the LC Act gives the Land Court the power to award costs. It is in the following terms:“34 Costs(1) Subject to the provisions of this or another Act to the contrary, the Land Court may order costs for a proceeding in the court as it considers appropriate.(2) If the court does not make an order under subsection (1), each party to the proceeding must bear the party’s own costs for the proceeding.” By s 72 of the LC Act, s 34 of that Act is taken to apply, with necessary changes, to this Court. There has been no suggestion that any provision of the MR Act is relevant for the present application. Submissions For the respondent, it was submitted that costs should follow the event, relying on a statement by Keane JA in Tamawood Limited & Anor v Paans[4]; and on Hegira Limited v Department of Natural Resources and Water[5]. Reliance was also placed on a passage from the judgment of McHugh J in Latoudis v Casey[6]. It was submitted that the respondent was forced to incur costs by the conduct of the appellant, and its refusal to pay compensation; and that the respondent had acted reasonably and responsibly in conducting the litigation. It was also submitted that the result was more favourable to the respondent than his offers, and accordingly that he should be awarded indemnity costs[7]. [4] [2005] 2 Qd R 101 at [30], [32], [33].[5] [2006] QLC 0079.[6] (1990) 170 CLR 534, 566-570.[7] Respondent’s Submissions on Costs, 4 December 2015, paras 12, 13, 23.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

After substantial reasons on this question were prepared, it came to the notice of the Court that the Land Court had made an order for the costs of the proceedings before it. There being no appeal from that order, and the appeal against the Land Court’s determination of the proceedings before it having been dismissed, there is no occasion for this Court to make an order for the costs of the proceedings in the Land Court.Conclusion This Court should make an order that the appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal to this Court, to be assessed on the standard basis until 15 September 2015, and thereafter on the indemnity basis.ORDERS1.The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the appeal in this Court, to be assessed on the standard basis until 15 September 2015, and thereafter on the indemnity basis.PETER LYONS JWL COCHRANEMEMBER OF THE LAND COURTWA ISDALEMEMBER OF THE LAND COURT

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.