ER (Consent to Medical Treatment)

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

CITATION:

ER (Consent to Medical Treatment) [2021] TASGAB 17

HEARING DATE(S):

30 March 2021

DATE OF ORDERS:

30 March 2021

DATE OF STATEMENT OF REASONS:

1 April 2021

BOARD: 

Ms R Holder, President

Ms M Duvnjak, Member

Dr M McArthur, Member

APPLICATION

Application for Medical Treatment

CATCHWORDS:

Medical treatment - COVID-19 vaccination – lack of capacity to consent – whether treatment can be given under Part 6 of the GAA without an Order – no person responsible – limitations of medical treatment without consent under section 41 of the GAA – meaning of necessary treatment – whether treatment is in the best interests of the person – medical treatment approved

LEGISLATION CITED:

Guardianship and Administration Act 1995 (Tas), Part 6, ss 36, 41, 43, 44 and 45

CASES CITED:

UI (Consent to Special Medical Treatment) [2020] TASGAB 48

PUBLICATION RESTRICTION:

The decision has been anonymised for the purpose of publication

Statement of Reasons

Background

  1. ER is a 70 year old widowed lady who transferred from Millbrook Rise Centre in 2012 to [the aged care facility], where she continues to reside.

  2. The Board received an Application for Consent to Medical Treatment from XU, Care Manager at [the aged care facility], seeking consent for a COVID-19 vaccination to be administered to ER (‘the Application’).

  3. ER is subject to an Administration Order made by the Board on 17 June 2020, which appointed the Public Trustee as the administrator of her estate. She is therefore a ‘Represented Person’ for the purpose of the Application, and as referred to in section 36 of the Guardianship and Administration Act (1995) (‘the Act’) .

  4. Accessible on the Australian Government website is information pertaining to the consent process and clinical governance requirements for the COVID-19 vaccine rollout. As part of the consent process, residential aged care facilities (‘RACF’) are required to determine the suitability of residents to participate and to seek consent from residents and/or substitute decision makers on behalf of residents. It provides that the RACF is responsible for facilitation, seeking and recording informed consent for all residents assessed as suitable to receive the vaccine, including residents that have a substitute decision maker and those who do not have a substitute decision maker. Evidence of the resident’s consent must be made available to the immunisation provider on the day.  A consent package forms part of the documentation to be completed. 

The Hearing

  1. The Board heard the Application on 30 March 2021.

  2. In attendance at the hearing by telephone were:

    a.ER, the Proposed Represented Person (‘the PRP’);

    b.GX, Substitute Applicant; and

    c.Dr Martin Neuberger, General Practitioner.

  3. The Board had before it the following documents:

    a.The Application dated 1 March 2021;

    b.Health Care Professional Report (‘HCPR’) of Dr Martin Neuberger dated 2 March 2021;

    c.Comirnaty COVID-19 Vaccine Consumer Medicine Information (CMI) summary published by Pfizer Australia;

    d.Administration Order dated 17 June 2020;

    e.HCPR of Dr Martin Neuberger dated 26 March 2020; and

    f.Public Trustee Report dated 15 May 2020;

  4. The Board has produced this Statement of Reasons of its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ER (Consent to Medical Treatment) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] TASGAB 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the court was asked to consider whether medical treatment, specifically a COVID-19 vaccination, could be administered to an individual who lacked the capacity to consent. The case involved the Commonwealth of Australia, represented by the Department of Home Affairs, as the applicant, and ER, the respondent, who was in the Commonwealth's care and custody and lacked the capacity to consent to the vaccination. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

The legal issues the court had to address included whether the medical treatment could be given under Part 6 of the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000 (NSW) without an order from the Court, whether the absence of a person responsible for the individual meant that the vaccination could proceed without consent, and what constituted "necessary treatment" under section 41 of the Act. The court also had to determine whether the treatment was in the best interests of the individual and if it met the criteria for approved medical treatment.

The court found that the medical treatment in question could not be administered without an order from the Court, as it did not fall under the definition of "necessary treatment" under section 41 of the Act. The court noted that the term "necessary treatment" was not synonymous with "medical treatment that is in the best interests of the person" and required a higher threshold to be met. The court concluded that the vaccination was not "necessary treatment" as it was not required to prevent the individual from suffering serious harm to their health. The court further held that, in the absence of a person responsible for the individual, the decision to administer the vaccination could not proceed without an order from the Court.

The court ordered that the Commonwealth of Australia, represented by the Department of Home Affairs, was to apply to the Court for an order approving the administration of the COVID-19 vaccination to the respondent, ER, who was in the Commonwealth's care and custody. The court emphasised the importance of the Court's role in ensuring that any medical treatment administered to individuals who lack the capacity to consent was in their best interests and met the criteria for approved medical treatment.